General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
David Himmelsbach
War Academy
comments
Comments by "David Himmelsbach" (@davidhimmelsbach557) on "What was the Greatest Allied Mistake during World War II? Military and Sociological Analysis" video.
Market-Garden was the error. Because of V-2s hitting London, Winston phoned Monty, Monty plead with Ike, and M-G was born. Because of M-G, the Red Ball Express was terminated -- Monty needed its GMC 2.5 ton trucks. This caused M-G to be delayed by three-days -- all by itself. Because Bradley and Patton lost their trucks, gasoline piled up back around Cherbourg; 1st & 3rd Armies were frozen in place. German morale turned on a dime with a full-week's rest. See: A Bridge Too Far -- the film. THAT'S what caused the war to last another six-months. The Krauts were dropping rifles all over France until the Red Ball stopped. Aachen was actually ready to be given over to 1st US Army as an open city. When it stopped advancing, everything changed. If Aachen had been accepted -- a few jeeps would do -- the US Army would've been over the Rhine PDQ. War over. Yup. This sequence is so painful to relate that historians DON'T bring it up. The links are (deliberately) not made.
1