Youtube comments of The Critical Drinker (@TheCriticalDrinker).

  1. 11000
  2. 7200
  3. 5700
  4. 5500
  5. 4100
  6. 4000
  7. 3800
  8. 3700
  9. 3500
  10. 2900
  11. 2700
  12. 2500
  13. 2300
  14. 2300
  15. 2200
  16. 2200
  17. 2100
  18. 2100
  19. 2100
  20. 2000
  21. 1900
  22. 1900
  23. 1900
  24. 1900
  25. 1900
  26. 1700
  27. 1700
  28. 1600
  29. 1500
  30. 1400
  31. 1400
  32. 1400
  33. 1400
  34. 1400
  35. 1300
  36. 1300
  37. 1300
  38. 1200
  39. 1200
  40. 1200
  41. 1200
  42. 1200
  43. 1100
  44. 1100
  45. 1100
  46. 1100
  47. 1100
  48. 1100
  49. 1100
  50. 1100
  51. 1000
  52. 1000
  53. 1000
  54. 1000
  55. 1000
  56. 1000
  57. 1000
  58. 1000
  59. 1000
  60. 1000
  61. 989
  62. 988
  63. 985
  64. 969
  65. 957
  66. 956
  67. 945
  68. 937
  69. 932
  70. 928
  71. 921
  72. 914
  73. 909
  74. 906
  75. 904
  76. 889
  77. 887
  78. 880
  79. 879
  80. 870
  81. 864
  82. 859
  83. 837
  84. 824
  85. 824
  86. 817
  87. 807
  88. 801
  89. 790
  90. 784
  91. 770
  92. 769
  93. 737
  94. 730
  95. 721
  96. 715
  97. 705
  98. 703
  99. 683
  100. 678
  101. 676
  102. 674
  103. 657
  104. 654
  105. 651
  106. 649
  107. 646
  108. 639
  109. 638
  110. 632
  111. 631
  112. 620
  113. 620
  114. 617
  115. 616
  116. 608
  117. 607
  118. 607
  119. 596
  120. 594
  121. 593
  122. 593
  123. 585
  124. 583
  125. 562
  126. 561
  127. 557
  128. 555
  129. 550
  130. 547
  131. 545
  132. 542
  133. 539
  134. 539
  135. 535
  136. 509
  137. 506
  138. 506
  139. 504
  140. 504
  141. 503
  142. 491
  143. 488
  144. 487
  145. 482
  146. 478
  147. 476
  148. 474
  149. 474
  150. 471
  151. 467
  152. 466
  153. 459
  154. 458
  155. 447
  156. 444
  157. 443
  158. 442
  159. 439
  160. 436
  161. 429
  162. 419
  163. 419
  164. 406
  165. 405
  166. 400
  167. 392
  168. 392
  169. 390
  170. 387
  171. 378
  172. 377
  173. 365
  174. 365
  175. 359
  176. 351
  177. 347
  178. 345
  179. 335
  180. 334
  181. 330
  182. 328
  183. 326
  184. 324
  185. 323
  186. 323
  187. 312
  188. 311
  189. 308
  190. 306
  191. 304
  192. 285
  193. 283
  194. 270
  195. 261
  196. 256
  197. 255
  198. 254
  199. 254
  200. 251
  201. 245
  202. 244
  203. 241
  204. 240
  205. 235
  206. 227
  207. 226
  208. 214
  209. 205
  210. 204
  211. 198
  212. 194
  213. 193
  214. 192
  215. 188
  216. 183
  217. 168
  218. 164
  219. 163
  220. 162
  221. 161
  222. 154
  223. 146
  224. 145
  225. 143
  226. 141
  227. 139
  228. 139
  229. 135
  230. 131
  231. 129
  232. 128
  233. 121
  234. 118
  235. 116
  236. 115
  237. 110
  238. 109
  239. 105
  240. 100
  241. 100
  242. 98
  243. 97
  244. 96
  245. 95
  246. 93
  247. 92
  248. 91
  249. 87
  250. 87
  251. 84
  252. 81
  253. 79
  254. 73
  255. 72
  256. 72
  257. 70
  258. 69
  259. 66
  260. 66
  261. 64
  262. 63
  263. 62
  264. 62
  265. 62
  266. 59
  267. 57
  268. 56
  269. 54
  270. 53
  271. 51
  272. 51
  273. 49
  274. 45
  275. 45
  276. 45
  277. 44
  278. 44
  279. 43
  280. 42
  281. 42
  282. 41
  283. 41
  284. 39
  285. 38
  286. 38
  287. 37
  288. 36
  289. 36
  290. 34
  291. 34
  292. 34
  293. 32
  294. 32
  295. 31
  296. 31
  297. 30
  298. 29
  299. 29
  300. 28
  301. 28
  302. 27
  303. 26
  304. 26
  305. 26
  306. 26
  307. 24
  308. 23
  309. 22
  310. 22
  311. 22
  312. 21
  313. 21
  314. 21
  315. 21
  316. 19
  317. 19
  318. 19
  319. 19
  320. 19
  321. 18
  322. 17
  323. 17
  324. 16
  325. 16
  326. 16
  327. 16
  328. 15
  329. 15
  330. 14
  331. 14
  332. 14
  333. 14
  334. 13
  335. 13
  336. 13
  337. 13
  338. 12
  339. 11
  340. 11
  341. 11
  342. 10
  343. 10
  344. 10
  345. 9
  346. 9
  347. 9
  348. 9
  349. 9
  350. 9
  351. 8
  352. 8
  353. 8
  354. 8
  355. 7
  356. 7
  357. 7
  358. 7
  359. 7
  360. 7
  361. 7
  362. 7
  363. 6
  364. 6
  365. 6
  366. 6
  367. 6
  368. 6
  369. 6
  370. 6
  371. 5
  372. 5
  373. 5
  374. 5
  375. 5
  376. 5
  377. 5
  378. 5
  379. 5
  380. 5
  381. 5
  382. 5
  383. 5
  384. 5
  385. 5
  386. 5
  387. 5
  388. 5
  389. 5
  390. 5
  391. 4
  392. 4
  393. 4
  394. 4
  395. 4
  396. 4
  397. 4
  398. 4
  399. 4
  400. 4
  401. 4
  402. 4
  403. I think their assessment of Dany's character is entirely wrong in that they place far too much emphasis on her arc being only the focussed and determined pursuit of power. On many occasions she's committed acts born out of compassion and a desire to help others. The Breaker of Chains moniker wasn't just something she adopted to make her sound cool, she saw herself as a saviour both of the slaves of Mereen and the people of Westeros and genuinely thought she could make a positive difference to the world. She was always about breaking away from her dark Targaeryan heritage and being her own person, a better person than her predecessors had been, but in this episode she just seems to embrace it and say "Fuck it, I want to be queen and if people won't accept that, I'll just make sure there's no people". I think the article's ludicrous suggestion that a lot of fans thought the tolling of the bells themselves drove her insane is total strawman bullshit. Most sensible people recognise her decision to burn King's Landing was a calculated choice to rule through fear instead of love (whether it was a choice she made in advance or a spur of the moment thing is up for debate), but its still a monumentally stupid one for someone who should know better. Her own experiences up to this point should have taught her one very important lesson above all else - all Tyrants inevitably fall, whether through violent revolution or internal betrayal. Even if she sits on the throne (or what's left of it), she'll have inherited a devastated kingdom with a populace that hates and fears her, and will likely spend the rest of her life fighting and killing to secure her fruitless victory.
    3
  404. 3
  405. 3
  406. 3
  407. 3
  408. 3
  409. 3
  410. 3
  411. 3
  412. 3
  413. 3
  414. 3
  415. 3
  416. 3
  417. 3
  418. 3
  419. 3
  420. 3
  421. 3
  422. 3
  423. 3
  424. 3
  425. 3
  426. 3
  427. 3
  428. 3
  429. 3
  430. 3
  431. 3
  432. 3
  433. 3
  434. 3
  435. 3
  436. 3
  437. 3
  438. 3
  439. 3
  440. 3
  441. 3
  442. 3
  443. 3
  444. 3
  445. 3
  446. 3
  447. 2
  448. 2
  449. 2
  450. 2
  451. 2
  452. 2
  453. 2
  454. 2
  455. 2
  456. 2
  457. 2
  458. 2
  459. That's a very interesting perspective, and although I did bring this up in the video, I didn't go into all that much detail about the implications of Wakanda's non-interference policy. The issue I have with this, particularly the example you gave of Shuri calling Ross a coloniser, is that the movie never goes so far as to outright criticise any of it. It's glossed over and bypassed. Shuri for example never faces censure for her earlier comments. It's clear when she meets Ross that she has little respect for him, but it's not like anything happens to drastically change her opinion or force her to confront her own prejudice. If for example she'd been in some kind of trouble and Ross had saved her, thus proving he's a good man and forcing her to acknowledge this and respect him, then fair enough - I'd be fine with that. As it is, Shuri operates pretty much independently throughout the movie, never really getting into trouble or needing help from anyone, especially Ross. It sets up a flaw in what could be seen as an arrogant, conceited character, then kind of forgets that it even exists. Likewise, the attitude towards Wakanda by the end of the movie isn't "Oh my god, we've made such a mistake throughout our history. So much needless suffering, war and poverty that we could have helped prevent". Instead it's presented more like "Wakanda is awesome, and we've kept our awesomeness hidden for too long. Now it's time to show the world what we can really do." Nowhere is this more evident than at the end with the obligatory sneering diplomat asking "What can a primitive country like Wakanda offer the world?", followed by T'Challa's knowing smile.   This is my issue with the movie. It might flirt with the idea that Wakanda and its ideology are deeply flawed, but it never comes to grips with this in the way it should. It's too preoccupied with glorifying the technological achievements and martial capabilities of its characters that its unwilling to properly address their flaws. I didn't express these things as clearly as I could in the video, which is a failing on my part. But I stand by my criticism that the plot is simplistic, T'Challa is a boring character without a well defined arc who also made terrible decisions, supporting characters like Shuri are annoying, Killmonger's plan for world domination was far beyond his ability to achieve even with Wakanda's technology behind him, the battle scenes were silly and overall the movie told a thoroughly underwhelming story that didn't deserve the praise it got. That's my opinion, but I appreciate how you took the time to outline yours.
    2
  460. 2
  461. 2
  462. 2
  463. 2
  464. 2
  465. 2
  466. 2
  467. 2
  468. 2
  469. 2
  470. 2
  471. 2
  472. 2
  473. 2
  474. 2
  475. 2
  476. 2
  477. 2
  478. 2
  479. 2
  480. 2
  481. 2
  482. 2
  483. 2
  484. 2
  485. 2
  486. 2
  487. 2
  488. 2
  489. 2
  490. 2
  491. 2
  492. 2
  493. 2
  494. 2
  495. 2
  496. 2
  497. 2
  498. 2
  499. 2
  500. 2
  501. 2
  502. 2
  503. 2
  504. 2
  505. 2
  506. 2
  507. 2
  508. 2
  509. 2
  510. 2
  511. 2
  512. 2
  513. 2
  514. 2
  515. 2
  516. 2
  517. 2
  518. 2
  519. 2
  520. 2
  521. 2
  522. 2
  523. 2
  524. 2
  525. 2
  526. 2
  527. 2
  528. 2
  529. 2
  530. 2
  531. 2
  532. 2
  533. 2
  534. 2
  535. 2
  536. 2
  537. 2
  538. 2
  539. 2
  540. 2
  541. 2
  542. 2
  543. 2
  544. 2
  545. 2
  546. 2
  547. 2
  548. 2
  549. 2
  550. 2
  551. 2
  552. 2
  553. 2
  554. 2
  555. 2
  556. 2
  557. 2
  558. 2
  559. 2
  560. 2
  561. 2
  562. 2
  563. 2
  564. 2
  565. 2
  566. 2
  567. 2
  568. 2
  569. 2
  570. 2
  571. 2
  572. 2
  573. 2
  574. 2
  575. 2
  576. 2
  577. 2
  578. 2
  579. 2
  580. 2
  581. 2
  582. 2
  583. "yeah, he does. He literally told jaime where to go to escape in the previous episode. Makes sense that he'd, you know, look there first? Idiot" Yup, and of course there's no doubt they would make it down there with the castle collapsing all around them, that they wouldn't be killed by falling rubble or roasted by dragonfire on the way, or that Jaime would even make it to Cersei to tell her about the escape route in the first place? Not to mention that Tyrion was even able to get down there himself and easily find their undamaged bodies because Jaime's hand was magically visible. Yup, totally believable that all those things aligned perfectly. "it's that character building that you cried about not existing at first. It's important to see tyrion's reaction to their deaths to cement his realization that he's made a horrible mistake to take dany's side and that its cost him dearly." You really think the apocalyptic destruction he'd already witnessed wasn't enough to convince him he'd been wrong to support Dany? How much of a moron do you think Tyrion is? "I guess you missed that scene in episode 4 where they state that they lost half the unsullied and dothraki. Not all of them, half." Sure didn't look like it in Episode 3. It looked like they'd been completely annihilated by the white walkers. But yeah, sure, one throwaway line is clearly enough to completely negate what we've seen with our own eyes. "tyrion explains this. Jon literally asks him if there's still a night's watch. Tyrion explains that yes, there is, and why, the very next line. Did you just go all "HURR DURR JON NIGHT'S WATCH AGAIN WHAT BULLSHIT WHY" and ignore all the dialogue that came after like some fucking simpleton?" Again, with your reliance on dumb, throwaway lines. Just because the writers insert a line saying "the night's watch are still needed" without any elaboration or explanation, doesn't make the scene any less ridiculous. It doesn't change the fact that the very purpose of the night's watch no longer exists. There's no need for them to guard the north, because there's literally nothing to guard against. Their purpose is entirely moot.
    1
  584. 1
  585. 1
  586. 1
  587. 1
  588. 1
  589. 1
  590. 1
  591. 1
  592. 1
  593. 1
  594. 1
  595. 1
  596. 1
  597. 1
  598. 1
  599. 1
  600. 1
  601. 1
  602. 1
  603. 1
  604. 1
  605. 1
  606. 1
  607. 1
  608. 1
  609. 1
  610. 1
  611. 1
  612. 1
  613. 1
  614. 1
  615. 1
  616. 1
  617. 1
  618. 1
  619. 1
  620. 1
  621. 1
  622. 1
  623. 1
  624. 1
  625. 1
  626. 1
  627. 1
  628. 1
  629. 1
  630. 1
  631. 1
  632. 1
  633. 1
  634. 1
  635. 1
  636. 1
  637. 1
  638. 1
  639. 1
  640. 1
  641. 1
  642. 1
  643. 1
  644. 1
  645. 1
  646. 1
  647. 1
  648. 1
  649. 1
  650. 1
  651. 1
  652. 1
  653. 1
  654. 1
  655. 1
  656. 1
  657. 1
  658. 1
  659. 1
  660. 1
  661. 1
  662. 1
  663. 1
  664. 1
  665. 1
  666. 1
  667. 1
  668. 1
  669. 1
  670. 1
  671. 1
  672. 1
  673. 1
  674. 1
  675. 1
  676. 1
  677. 1
  678. 1
  679. 1
  680. 1
  681. 1
  682. 1
  683. 1
  684. 1
  685. 1
  686. 1
  687. 1
  688. 1
  689. 1
  690. 1
  691. 1
  692. 1
  693. 1
  694. 1
  695. 1
  696. 1
  697. 1
  698. 1
  699. 1
  700. 1
  701. 1
  702. Actually I spent an entire video outlining my problems with it, but since you're apparently unaware of that, here's a quick summary: 1. The plot was overly simplistic and riddled with so many holes that it bordered on nonsensical. 2. Wakanda is a ridiculous wish fulfilment fantasy nation that people seem to idealize despite the fact its a selfish, technocratic black ethnostate. 3. T'Challa is a boring, bland personality-vacuum whose character arc makes no sense given the events he'd just been through in Civil War. 4. The movie is patronising and insulting to white people, treating its few white characters with absolute disdain. 5. Shuri is impossibly intelligent and accomplished given her age - again, another smug wish fulfilment character on the part of the writers. 6. Vibranium is used as a cure-all plot remedy to get the characters out of any situation and explain almost anything. 7. The people of Wakanda are the most technologically advanced nation on earth, yet they fight hand to hand with spears and melee weapons. 8. Armoured war rhinos. 9. Killmonger actually believes he can overthrow governments and defeat all of Earth's combined military forces by arming small bands of operatives and revolutionaries with laser guns. 10. T'Challa allows himself to be goaded into a death match against Killmonger when he had no reason or need to accept the challenge. 11. When Killmonger defeats T'Challa, everyone declares him king and swears loyalty to him, despite the fact he's an outsider and they know almost nothing about him. Is that enough or should I keep going?
    1
  703. 1
  704. 1
  705. 1
  706. 1
  707. 1
  708. 1
  709. 1
  710. 1
  711. 1
  712. 1
  713. 1
  714. 1
  715. 1
  716. 1
  717. 1
  718. 1
  719. 1
  720. 1
  721. 1
  722. 1
  723. 1
  724. 1
  725. 1
  726. 1
  727. 1
  728. 1
  729. 1
  730. 1
  731. 1
  732. 1
  733. 1
  734. 1
  735. 1
  736. 1
  737. 1
  738. 1
  739. 1
  740. 1
  741. 1
  742. 1
  743. 1
  744. 1
  745. 1
  746. 1
  747. 1
  748. 1
  749. 1
  750. 1
  751. 1
  752. 1
  753. 1
  754. 1
  755. 1
  756. 1
  757. 1
  758. 1
  759. 1
  760. 1
  761. 1
  762. 1
  763. 1