General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Binkov's Battlegrounds
comments
Comments by "" (@tomk3732) on "Could the modern Polish military protect the 1939 Poland? (part 2 of the series)" video.
No Soviets would certainly not attack earlier as on 16th they signed a document with Polish allay Japan. As far as Polish navy, author forgot the naval port at Hel - which held out to October - i.e. Polish navy in this scenario would resupply there.
5
LOL, not Russia - Ukraine. Only conscripts Russia sent to the war were from former Ukraine. Few accidental cases like a cook or similar. But nothing more. Ukraine on the other hand send whole brigades with just weeks or even a week of training.
3
Poland in 2023 is much weaker than Poland in this video from 2020. About half strength. Poland in 2023 has far and wide fewer tanks than in 2020 as well as fewer aircraft and much weaker air defenses. Not to mention weaker artillery. Try Poland in 2030 when it is stronger.
1
@patryknajbor7990 LOL WHAT. Poland in 2020 had more tanks, more artillery, more aircraft than today. As per official data from Polish ministry of defense. I mean come on, Poland given Ukraine over 300 tanks. 100s of IFVs. 100s of artillery systems. Multiple aircraft and helicopters. Lots and Lots of ammo. 10s of 1000s of anti armor systems (total RPG is around 100k units (!!!)). Also multiple anti air systems. It will take years to rebuild Polish army to pre Ukraine war status.
1