Comments by "Megalo Don" (@megalodon3655) on "Understanding Islamic Civilization" video.

@WhatifAltHist I watched your video it has some serious mistakes when you say Islam shunned science in all that you are saying based on many orientalists like Joseph Massad a US based Palestinian Christian and he said this In his book “Islam and the orientalist world system”The term Islamic golden age is very euro centric as said by a Pakistani academic named ProfessorDr Jamal Malik who said in this in his book “Islam in South Asia” pages 4-5 where he points that orientalists had this perception or view that the golden age of Islam ended in 1258 and was in barbarism and a dark age while Europe went through the enlightenment the Muslim world in 1750 was in “barbarism” which is the same mistake you are making. meanwhile there are example that Muslims were still in the golden age even after Baghdad’s destruction some references Elias Muhanna’s book on medieval and and early modern Islamic history which was released in 2017 called “the world in a book” some academics who talked more about the subject are George salvia and Robert wisnovsky who mentions that we can’t tell when is the classical post Islamic golden age because there were too many manuscripts unstudied another academic Muzaffer Iqbal wrote in his book “the making of Islamic sciences” page 144-146 that there were 1000 Muslim scientists who worked between the 8th and 18th centuries and 200k manuscripts in Iran alone. You mentioned that Muslims still stone g#y people and are stuck in the stone ages and oppress “minorities” Muslims have always have had these harsh punishments for people who commit homosexuality and adultery and fornicateors and it was in our laws since the time of Muhammad Pbuh the rashidun and ummayad and Abbasid caliphate had these hats punishments And how do you define oppression of minorities? Do your mean non muslims because their culture and religion and way of life is preserved under Muslim rule meanwhile in the west due to secularism and liberalism being shoved down our throats Christianity is dying even in Muslim families who live inn the west their children or grand children liberalize and their way of life is not preserved. Also this is hypocritical of you talking about stoning G#s and “oppressing minorities” when your own Bible allowed it and until the enlightenment Christians also used to “oppress minorities” and punish people for sexual deviancy. And if you say but Christians change but you still can’t say it’s inherently wrong as your God allowed it in the old and New Testament And you mention women not being able to drive have you been under a rock Saudi Arabia has removed that law and other Muslim countries don’t have that law. And you mentioned the Mutilizah being free thinkers that made me laugh if you look into the life of Ahmed ibn hanbal and Abbisad caliph Al Mamun the first Mutilizah caliph you will find out that they weren’t free thinkers in fact they convinced Al Mamun to persecute anyone who didn’t agree with their view on religion like the Quran being created which is a blasphemy in Sunni Islam and at the time as well Muslims were persecuted if they didn’t follow the view of the Mutilizah Ahmed ibn hanbal debated these guys and essentially won but they still persecuted him so you need to look into the life of Ahmed ibn Hanbal and Al Mamun through authentic Muslim sources because secular sources will make heavy mistakes or get something wrong. The Sunni Shia divide happend because the Muslims were debating on if Ali should have been the first caliph or Abu bakr the prophets friend. Those were your mistakes your video was educational still I would request that at the 10 minute mark when you showed the virgin Jesus vs chad Muhammad either remove that or never show that again because it was very disrespectful to me as a Muslims because as Muslims we love and revere Jesus pbuh not as a God but as a might prophet and messenger of God and respect him and Muhammad and all the other prophets greatly and two you should have covered their faces with a veil of light as it’s disrespectful in Islam to show the faces of God’s prophets and messengers and two according to the Christian and Muslim views Jesus will return a second time and he will not be all loving he will be a warlord essentially and fight and k!11 the anti christ and his enemies. So both Muhammad Pbuh and Jesus pbuh are warriors. If you want the biblical references ask me and I will give it to you. In the picture for your video you forgot to include Bosina and hergovizna and Albani and Kosovo as Muslim majority countries on your map.Also what is the name of the books you used and two please br8ng back alternate history I miss alternate history. And one last thing you mentioned God being a humanized being and “rational” will God being human is what destroyed Christianity , Federich Niche in his book “the gay science” section 125 mentions how people murd##ed God and in section 343 he says that God is dead based on”that the belief in the Christian God has become unbelievable” and he was right you can look up some pew research articles on the decline of Christianity and between now and 2050 Christianity will lose some 66-106 million followers and will be 2nd largest religion behind Islam.
6
@fat4eyes thx for the advice sir.
2
@donovanjamesiii what?
1
@namaan123 thx for the summarization I was trying to give references while writing my comment.
1
@velumadhavsanthanam6354 you just confirmed that Christians have abandoned or spelled out their beliefs stop calling it “progressive” and call it for what it is which is abandoning their beliefs and selling out you want the references the Bible’s harsh punishment for homosexuality I can give it Just say it and I can give it. As for the gender fluidity read the book “the search for eve’s rib searching for the biological roots of the sex differences” and be debunks gender fluidity and shows that the gender characteristics are fluid but not the genders and that even in chines and Native American societies there still was gender roles.
1