Comments by "" (@TheHuxleyAgnostic) on "US Income Inequality Surges to Highest in 50 Years" video.
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@Freakarmy Where does this copy paste bullshit come from?
Non-staples: electric bill, phone bill, internet bill, cable bill, toys, games, any entertainment with a cost, snacks and pop, and all kinds of things that would still affect poor people.
Some of those poor people are already collecting $1000+ in government assistance of a kind Yang doesn't have stack with UBI. Those people will get zero economic benefit from the UBI but will still have to pay the VAT. He should have UBI stack with SSI and have a half UBI for children.
That price sensitivity nonsense is bullshit under normal circumstances. Basically every business would have a VAT added. They would all be sitting in the exact same competitive position they were in pre-VAT. There would be no reason to lower their prices and start eating their profit margins. Add in that consumers are being handed $3t to go shopping, and price increases won't even reduce consumption.
Yang is bullshitting, when he claims a VAT will make corporations like Amazon "pay their fair share". They'll still pay nothing with a VAT. Businesses get credited back for their input VAT in a VAT system. So, if even 20% of that $3t is spent on retail, and Amazon owns 5% of retail, Yang's VAT/UBI scheme will only make them an extra $30b a year. That'd make Bezos an extra $3.6b a year. He'd have to blow over $36b a year on goods and services with a VAT to pay in more than he'll get out.
1