General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

PiN
Whatifalthist
comments

Comments by "PiN" (@pierren___) on "Whatifalthist" channel.

26:54 "since land is divided, land is too small to feed themselves, which leads them to sell their lands to the rich, which causes revolutions" That hit home
280
Outside of their economic decisions, your grandparents are based and you should ask them "what can i do that you will love me for ?"
158
@MrBones105 i know they have defaults, read my comments again. However, racism is not a problem, its a virtue
53
Whomen didnt want to vote first because they knew it would send them to work. Some feminists movements were against whomen vote
43
1: losing wars 2: too aristocratic 3: too conservative 4: too reformist 5: too apolinian
36
@That Guy racism is litterally the base of survival, its litteraly bravery, im a hero bruh
30
Because they have parlementarian systems, which are blocked by 2 parties. But they will disappear too.
29
He is a symptom of a leftist reaction against the boomerang comeback
26
We live in a Period
26
Hitler the Rousseauist
23
Thats their ideology
21
@Ryzeex. there is something called "marshall plan" and social democracy
18
Les Misérables is a book 🤦‍♂️
16
Iranians, kalash, some kazakh...
15
They know very well whats happening to men and are happy with the result
13
@Ryzeex. that doesnt mean life standards didnt raise in Europe.
12
@Ryzeex. European boomers have retirement funds paid by workers too
12
Whomen egoism is crazy
12
@basileusbasil4041 no
8
Bro has ZERO rizz 💀
8
@samschlossberg476 lol, like people from celtic or germanic have no brain. The whole iron work that the roman are known for comes from hellstat (austria) and the germans had gothic art and nobilities of ALL Europe that existed from prehistory To Xx century, or even today for some. There has been more technological and art progress during Ancient Regime than Antiquity
7
C'est faux, on était le pays le peuplé d'Europe et la marine était bonne mais moins nombreuse. La révolution a détourné le destin de la France. D'ailleurs la France est le seul pays où la bourgeoisie est arrivé au pouvoir AVANT la révolution industrielle.
6
Could you make a video of differences between French and German? In the ancient regime it wasnt si different
5
A lot, especially in Europe.
5
Nope they dont, they speak peasant french (patois du poitou) 💀
5
As a men, ONLY extend your interests. Focus on YOUR pleasure.
5
Soldiers can revolt too !
5
@JoaoCosta-ly1sw im genuinely virtous
5
Its all a cloud. Once you poked it, you cannot take the propaganda seriously.
4
@BasedRanger because a musical is always a parody lmao
4
The arrogance of the elites will lead us to our death.
4
Fuck The freemasons fuck the j fuck the left for what they did us. Seriously. From paradise to hell. All our answers are in the past. Eternal laws are in nature, we should have never escape her, Forgot her
4
@Воровайчик whats that meme
4
@mobilityproject3485 the rhine
4
France won the Spanish succession. The Bourbon still sits there. (This channel has much anti-France bias)
4
@Frenchylikeshikes not enough colons? No thats a mistake. 28 millions in the XVIII c. The kings really didnt foresee and wanted To focus on invading england and conquering europe by mariages and war
3
24:38 Its christianity that was Proven false, and thats for the better since scientific world view is more fitted for europeans. The ww1 is due To democratic etc idealists that wanted a europe of nations, which was proven false by the same existence of this war. Same for ww2 : thats not incompatible. moral is not a definition for civilization, greatness or survival. The problem here is that you see/value whites as a civilization.
3
@TheGreenKnight500 the risk is total liberalism, Somalia style
3
2:45 its actually the contrary : France gives energy (electricity, water, military) while germany has finance influence
3
@usernamesample8386 cope
3
The reasoned solution is to not have liberalism
3
@jynx3978 some principles are eternal
3
Its the extremists that start fighting, then mobilisation is settle in territories
3
@wdwuccnxcnh7022 so latin nations are just latin speaker ? Thats very arbitrary
3
Just tell her youre a feminist lmao
3
17:54 Here, he repeats (revolutionnaries) clichés about the fake expenditures and mindset of the nobles. In fact, France was the wealthiest of its time during the 18century. The country was not ruined. The French revolution was mostly based on lies.
3
+1. He also forgot legal discrimination and still today, Québec doesnt reconize the Canadian Constitution and is de facto, independant.
3
@lesdodoclips3915 the actual spanish king is a Bourbon, you know ?
3
2:00
3
@Arcaryon You country Can be proud of ww2. The suffferance of today are your enemies fault. Europe making money is not something To be proud of. Having numerous aryan babies is.
3
8:22 France is closer To Germany Europe than "latin, méditerranéen". Speaking a latin language doesnt mean having the same culture.
3
14:35 western art = picture Asian art = cyclical view
2
@Easy-Eight yes so? Does that contradicts anything i said
2
Our parents are a serious problems. I never saw a generation of stubborn like this
2
Another W for monarchs
2
doomslayer420 lol
2
The only way to defeat a superior enemy is to domesticate it
2
@permets2apollox453 someone who has To live with him, someone he has To live with, LOL
2
@usernamesample8386 the "gay" french language that founded english language, yes i see
2
@usernamesample8386 60% french aka neolatin
2
@usernamesample8386 your jokes are lame 🤦‍♂️
2
Just catch the bankers (🙃) lmao
2
We have To forbid student emigration and abolish Schengen.
2
Pour nous c'est pire, ils ont les retraites 💀
2
Therefore you might be a futurist, or a perfectionnist. Time doesnt exist
2
@djstona5284 boomer nonsense
2
@jynx3978 fidelity, honor, purity, hierarchy, beauty, strength
2
@jynx3978 but they always exist
2
@jynx3978 no, its eternal philosophy
2
@horouathos8199 this ladies and gentleman
2
Its fucking crazy all of that happens because we refused/were forced not / to listen To the austrian painter. He explained everything
2
25:33 that map is old lol
2
Because we founded the west.
2
He did it to save the national cohesion so its not treason
2
@CL Melonshark im not necessary talking about that. Also thé tribe mentality, the dunbar numbers... etc
2
@jackasslawyer France wasnt in Nato during 1960-2007, which makes it an alternative.
2
You Can be autoritarian and liberal and totalitarian not authoritarian
2
Its not about generations, but about ideologies and politics
2
Envy makes you progress towards your accomplishment, so its a good thing.
2
L M A O. European boomers are wealthiest than US boomers since they benefitted from social security and senior funds. We are still paying them
2
@Ryzeex. cope and seethe
2
Theres too much 🔲 people to be french
2
0:33 passing by Persia peacefully
2
I agree with your Spain comment.
2
France was the most populated country in Europe since the Fall of Rome.
2
South italy used To be industrialize no? If im true then it is a recent modification
2
Europeans are trapped with anti-people elites. Thats a huge problem.
2
I see your french influences here 😉
2
I must correct : Spanish war 1700 is a french Victory. Bourbon dinasty still established in Spain.
2
50:00 From Poitou and Alsace, mostly
2
@nobodyherepal3292 they were actually the respectors of the confederacy
2
@nobodyherepal3292 well, tells a lot about the constitution credibility
2
@datdar6583 your still answering; use that time to find an argumentation
2
9:00 protestants who are absolutists are called "monarchomachs"
2
Exactly
2
The Longed House society
2
@Euthenon i dont need you
2
They will soon embrace class struggle.
2
Consequences of individualism
2
@Nix91 that might be the key for independance
2
@Nix91 c'est debattable
2
52:32 the French Acadians were deported... very lacky
2
New feodal system based on ✡
2
Meritocracy is a myth invented by present elites to prevent opposants from rising
2
29:20 this mal is innacurate because reference =/= agreement
2
German heritage is the most disdain and undervaluated in western civilization. Germanity bringed us everything i think. Orders system was Perfect. Medieval were enlighten. Peace was possible due to germanic family link of nobles across Europe; So feodality was united with classes system and racial one
2
7:59 China success is not due To liberalism wtf
2
Missed You mean stopped by the British ?
2
We will have worst. Thats the video message.
2
We are Litterally too serious and rational
2
@woodenfloor3131 really?
1
@davidvasey5065 in this case they would have, the kings wouldnt drop it
1
@davidvasey5065 ok haha
1
@marcafterdark1003 How?
1
@marcafterdark1003 yeah, did he receive order ? How did they guerilla exactly?
1
@kolerick yes, plus they were nobles and castes that had specialised rights
1
15:41 yess
1
Could you make that video but for european countries ?
1
CatholicPagan liberalism and commercial tolerance values. It follows the j.
1
Impose PATRIARCHY
1
It means you dont understand what left wing economically means
1
Center vs fringes ? Minorties vs Majorties
1
The concept of "generation" is itself a fallacy. Ideology >>>>
1
@NixonsHead liberal boomers
1
C'est plutôt une chance pour les indiens de manger correctement 🙄
1
European Revolution / European Confederation
1
@LostPilgrim i wanna cry that young gentleman, on YouTube, has access to so much information he decided to be a better elite than the official rulers. And for free To us. Oh fool ! Rejoice O Lord! Acclaim
1
In the us yes. Thats not a state question, but an oligarchy one.
1
@charptho not strange at all, social economy against ue helps moralize nationalism-soverinism-democracy direct
1
Because I will have children. Sane.
1
Liberalism would have been restricted To UK, French King would proclaim sovereignity of the Crown over franc-bourgeois and delete all privileges, feodalism would have been total and French monarchy would have annexed Europe by marriage.
1
Moral is an abstract in America, in order to preserve civil war
1
@starhalv2427 its time To admit scientific traditionalism is the best deal. And ban all short term politics. Go back To earth, on a superior plan
1
Yes.
1
A contrario, i think a new european empire on the exemple inspired by Rome, would have conquered the world, with a pyramid putting the French on top and europeans following.
1
As a Frenchman, id be happy to hear how tou think of yourselve as a Frenchman.
1
 @t.j.marian7338 nations dont exist. Only races does.
1
@stephennootens916 bruh 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
1
@NixonsHead yes 💀
1
Womens rights are a crime against society
1
20:34 that map clearly shows america and india would lost, and grow resentment like Germany in the 20s
1
Neither the bourbon encouraged it, the cast system you talked about doesnt exist...
1
C'est plutôt une parodie de cette époque.
1
Colbertism + secession of civilisation
1
@Bruzzh 2121 nice
1
Maybe liberty is the problem
1
@permets2apollox453 how so ? Liberalism is at the root of all those disconnections and anti-social mentality
1
@theempoweredman7353 not that much, wait 20 years
1
"France is its own thing" you can say that about every other european country
1
France kingdom economic and political system were one, like china today.
1
@luizmonad777 reaganomics ruined the US bro 💀
1
43:08
1
23:00 capitalism, science, military, technology, geography, expansion, conquest
1
Nobody cares about freedom, its a myth
1
What do you think will happen for Europe ?
1
@DestinedWalnut wait for a war and you see people will radicalised themselves
1
@donaldjgumpofficial5754 do you think Europe is an usa ennemy ?
1
@philipmcniel4908 you know countries change with time right ?
1
@donaldjgumpofficial5754 i believe civil war will soon happen in France, and revolution for Europe
1
@donaldjgumpofficial5754 protesting is natural, dont fall into clichés. I am talking about a real war
1
@philipmcniel4908 yeah, they are not radical minority then
1
@PeachDragon_ dying for thr boomers fetish 🤡
1
True, but islam will take the throne
1
Viholent takeover by men will delete de facto whomen high position in society. They will be henslaved. Unemployment will disappear
1
It basically rally minorties against majority aka democracy, thus perpetuating oligarchic domination
1
No
1
He is not fat
1
5:35 France has a preference for statism, maybe thats what you mean by communism
1
True, thats why american conservatism is nonsense.
1
@usernamesample8386 you still there ?
1
Boulainvillers too... the feudal system is a class analysis
1
Low iq religion
1
Accuse banks, not system.
1
Italians are not white
1
The money is too High value also. It doesnt correspond
1
@allliquid6320 my thought + I think the dollar is too high
1
@FayotSonic qui es-tu ? Lol
1
Atheists* yes
1
They still believe in meritocracy
1
@gabrielethier2046 yeah
1
@S.J.L its the same thing, one leads to the other
1
@Quickshot0 i can tell you are not European. Lmao
1
@Quickshot0 "High european taxes on billionaires" "wages are high" "unemployment is very low" is not something any european would ever say, ESPECIALLY under the EU.
1
@Quickshot0 the EU is not a country as the euro is not a unique money,; in the sense that the value of 1 euro variates in the EU. Therefore, to compare middle wages as being "higher" (than dollar?) Is a nonsense. Europe PRODUCES unemployment as its freemarket craze is eternally incompatible with typical national interests (which i prefer). Globally china and the usa will surpass Europe soon. Im French, and the middle class disappeared. The rich got 30× times richer while the general wealth shrinks. The number of billionaires and deleted taxes have never been so High (for the billionaires benefit). The EU is a liberal project, and for this reason, i will fight so it Can finally disappear.
1
@TJansonable how are they aligned ? Whats your point with China ?
1
@TJansonable thats not a good argument... the press i read is totally submitted to liberalism and therefore To germany, which defends freemarket. Im anti-liberal, And i prefer china To USA.
1
@TJansonable lmaoooo this motivate me To vote Zemmour Le Pen. We have everything to gain. But maybe you are not White.
1
@TJansonable if i listen to you, everything is fine in the best of the worlds... Fascism is when truth is spoken.
1
Naturalist
1
@houseofjax2806 Futurist*
1
@houseofjax2806 progressism is linked to humanism. Futurism is purely technological
1
@djstona5284 talked like a true boomer
1
@jynx3978 they can be found everywhere
1
@jynx3978 you need examples of beauty, strength ???
1
@jynx3978 beauty : fashion Strength : modern army
1
@Alexander-tu3iv lol. The problem is de are pushing for a life of work instead of a work of life. In the middle ages people were working 150 days and 3 jours a day. The problem is work mentality; which is slavery.
1
@marcobonesi6794 its a planet-scale thought, not a nation one. Think higher
1
@marcobonesi6794 debt is not unemployment. And unemployment is caused by worldwide openness and concurrency and Will be cured by national priority. However its true they dont realize their economy was artificial and are too individualistic.
1
@marcobonesi6794 no lol. It causes rise of taxes like you just said. However people still go To work. Unemployment is due To delocalization of serious jobs and lack of national priority in studies and job creation.
1
@marcobonesi6794 yeah in France too
1
@marcobonesi6794 a recent demography of migrants so its worst than being hungary for exemple. But yeah still good indigen demography true. 50% taxes in France to pay to reicive migrants 💀
1
@mllesamedi84 lol no, a random feminist that promotes masculine vision of women
1
@mllesamedi84 yes
1
It denied its alliance because the king was dead, contrary.
1
15:18 this. I was shocked as a teen To see women in a dissonance cognitive.
1
And nature path is devaluate for work.
1
Nice, but the best would be to link everyone revenue on inflation.
1
16:27 there was a race. One race.
1
@adamnesico at 16:27
1
Rhone Valley is the New Silicon Valley
1
 @connorperrett9559 you think we are gonna live famines and all in Europe ?
1
Agreed
1
No germans were hurt globally, when it happened (1934) it was to save the nation from purged
1
Fascism takeover against capitalism
1
9:44 weak absolutism (central delegation)
1
He never Said that France will stay in the line of US influence. Actually, he explains the contrary.
1
Tell that to the jooz lmao
1
Due to individualist nuclear family structure easily dismantling, we'll see soon Quebec becoming independant or creating a new Canada.
1
Feminism + individualism + open society + hypergamy + conformism + advertisement + high expectations (too much movies) + telereality
1
I noticed science confirm differences
1
Center left, center right
1
12:51 Québec isnt latin wtf
1
Civil war is the only to purge elites to develop a stronger country
1
@anakinthemannequin69 lmao keep dreaming, democracy is based on conformity, Augustus was stronger than the republic
1
@thekraken1173 same situation in France & Paris
1
@vorynrosethorn903 theres always is weaklings and chads
1
@kenshin891 thats a myth. Actual problems are due to oestrogen in food and water. Chads emerge naturally. I do believe society can also chadize humans, partly.
1
??? Who tf said that
1
It seems that Hitler was incapable to think the Cold War concept
1
@constantinethecataphract5949 all countries in Europe received plan marshall
1
Confederation*
1
I see you have a thing for french historians ;)
1
What hamiltonian moment?
1
Those tensions were organised through the CIA & masonry. Those fashists were usedul idiots for the cia
1
 @SisckoImper Great Leaders are not popular usually
1
@christopherhardy8808 make Louisiana Great again.
1
@Raadpensionaris France got industrialized (colbert), famine is not his fault (climate), conquest of franche comté and alsace, highest demography in Europe (20 millions) with 8 children, wars were costly for nobles though
1
@Raadpensionaris he conquered the north, the East, the south (provence), he assured supplies during famines and created a court culture to be imitated by all Europe. Yes, he is at peak.
1
@Raadpensionaris what is modest here ? Also colonies expanded
1
Agreed but economy does exist
1
Ra6e, sacrifice, embetterment.
1
16:19 this Will end so bad.
1
Agreed
1
@MeanBeanComedy eye for an eye, teeth for teeth
1
A confederation.
1
Because the cost of life is so high that the caracteristics of high life themselves are lower
1
Hispanics =/= mexicans. Hispanics are Europeans and totally different from indigenous.
1
It is kinda stucked in between. I think authoritarian should take over this structure, so that the family is ruled politically
1
Because iits the people that want this, not right wing parties.
1
Also ww2 comeback is a french Victory. First army in austria etc
1
 @Canario_27 lmao thats a reverse cope. Still today, decentralisation is destroying spain like Catalonia brexit.
1
 @Canario_27 of south americans think spain is bad , its because most of sa is non spanish. Thus its rassial, not ideological.
1
Were heading there so clearly
1
Male loneliness = revolution.
1
@ileutur6863 in Europe too
1
23:55 that explains why germanics country are federal
1
17:01 🙂
1
26:41 honor, faith
1
I knew it wasnt senseless that classics path are empty or unachievable. We are abandonned and torture.
1
A contrario, i think a new european empire on the exemple inspired of rome would have conquêtes the world, with a pyramid putting the French on top and europeans following.
1
@datdar6583 no, we are talking about xviii century Bourbon of France: they had a goal, conquer the world by annexing by weddings system europe first
1
@datdar6583 its not delusional To marry with all the royal european countries. Look at the vidéo about the greatest european royal families: the most powerful was french one. Remember i didnt the say europe would be conquer, there would still be kings and costums: I Say europeans conquer the world with France leading the diplomacy outside europe, due To its familial nodes
1
@datdar6583 such a better argument
1
@datdar6583 no certainly not, it was on its way until the French revolution
1
@datdar6583 you dont decide whats delusional or not haha
1
He also misclassified 2 i would say
1
The problem is also that Americans dont consider themselves Europeans anymore.
1
The French nobility was mostly poor, the rest is a cliché. Wars dispenses + colonial defeats + bourgeoisie without industry = revolution
1
National-socialism.
1
6:59 im a traditionnal one
1
It was rohm plotting against hitlerr
1
21:27 So true. We dont have access to foreign news.
1
They did Well attacking but should have won by retreating until trenches reached. Then start push back and win like in 1918
1
@vardekpetrovic9716 he should have let slav armies and give them the Oural russia. Then he should have reduce collaboration in France and implement a natsoc state with german authorities.
1
@Nix91 definitely you are or a leftist, or not québécois.
1
@Nix91 le japon aussi pourtant il survit. Il faut un Front Canadien contre l'immigration
1
@axcel9128 he will not, he is a christian normie
1
@Scratchhh why are you raging ? Its beautiful
1
Ever heard about the third position ?
1
36:55 on voit bien ici que la France domine ses voisins pour des raisons géographiques
1
13:40 very bad exemple. London urbanized in the 17th century, and industrialized sooner for this reason
1
France is more north than south
1
@aspen1606 i agree
1
Its false since there was as much strife in Uk/usa
1
So whats gonna happen to Europe ?
1
Thanks for abording the hardest subjects.
1
We need nationalist revolution to be sure no one is ever capable of thinking otherwise
1
Eternal Struggle of the Peoples.
1
Capitalism doesnnt define whats left wing or not. Capitalism is "accumulation of money by person" which can be given by an authoritarian governement. Fascism is based on right wing values like order, race, religion, patriarchy, purity
1
 @jellyrcw12 you were a fetus once
1
Good
1
17:54 Here, he repeats (revolutionnaries) clichés about the fake expenditures and mindset of the nobles. In fact, France was the wealthiest of its time during the 18century. The country was not ruined. The revolution was mostly based on lies.
1
Are you trying to revolt, slave?
1
False
1
3: thats pretty bad example. France is based on the Frank people (not social construct) and their servants (the French), not a social construct
1
9:57 chinese superstitions
1
Its a cliché
1
I hope we will become a confederation I wrote a constitution for it. It has 4 articles
1
Americas a giant mall
1
24:34 final point : alternative countries - property tolerance France, Russia, China, Indonesia & Saudi Arabia
1
No, its their entitlement to freedom that makes them despicable
1
Its America thats gonna have a religious renaissance, not others.
1
France ancien regime.
1
@walterusalbus oui
1
@MMGAMERMG not really, no
1
@ale-xsantos1078 how so ? Its not even a Orléans on the throne, its the Sun King sons (Bourbon) who STILL are on the throne. How many have France lost ?
1
Nope.
1
@ivangutierrez3540 monarchy restored
1
@ivangutierrez3540 yeah. He evicted the royalists who controlled the directory and were negotiating a restauration with louis XVIII. Napoleon said to louis XVIII : if you come back To France, you will have to walk on bodies.
1
All the West was founded by France. Good and bad.
1
The French revolution was extremely patriarchal & the rights of Women were wrote by a random philosopher sho got killed lmao
1
@peterwindhorst5775 the better sex 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 is the masculine one
1