Comments by "PiN" (@pierren___) on "Ryan Chapman" channel.

  1. In France we call rule-by-law "raison d'état", state-reason. The state survival is more important than to comply to law.
    94
  2. China has "reason of state", while America have "state of right". That means that China focuses on state obedience power, while America focuses on individual rights.
    16
  3.  @lindeng3035  i understand because the state is linked to the people, therefore to protect the people is = to protect the state.
    9
  4. 9:45 Land reform - divide the land - small groups 10:26 Light manifacturing with raw materials 10:49 heavy industry + 11:03 subsidies in exchange of export + Protectionnism + interest rate nationalised
    8
  5.  @lindeng3035  i never said the contrary. I agree mostly
    5
  6.  @freddiepatterson1045  its the longest republic ever, so we did a pretty good job.
    5
  7. Liberalism is way more scary
    4
  8.  @rap3208  thats my whole poitn
    4
  9. Demagogy =/= populism A lot of centrists are demagogs
    3
  10. You might also read "the doctrine of fascism" Mussolini
    3
  11. You missed ww2 in the beginning which reevaluated everything lol
    3
  12. I agree. Abstract définitions deletes responsabilities. Only rights are talken about, not duties. In China, society is made out of duties.
    3
  13.  @freddiepatterson1045  It's not a good thing to have a fixed constitution. Btw the venice republic switched domination, wasnt always independant
    3
  14. Fascism is also defined by politics, and China on this matter is less fascist
    3
  15. Excellent. The state was a tool to make the nation immortal, and for this it must teach invincibility.
    2
  16.  @lindeng3035  i would say china is reason of state
    2
  17. 9:51 National Consciousness
    2
  18. Centralisation iis thhe conséquence of decentralisation. Nothing can be done with everyone fighting for his little interest.
    2
  19. 14:30 i think that this work culture is due to the excessive demography, rather than volontary.
    2
  20. What is rule-by-law therefore ? To me, its seems CCP is a tool To defend the chinese people by Chinese identity. It has an tacit meaning, an image described in the constitution.
    2
  21. Fascism original goal is to make a new man, a Perfect man, and fascism goal is to create the culture for it.
    2
  22. Direct mandatory democracy vs indirect representative democracy, in a nutshell.
    2
  23.  @robto  i think he meant ' Cultural model " of han chinese
    2
  24.  @thomaharadja5307  under the 5th, the state is always above the law since it has the legislative power
    2
  25. Btw, Venice is nowhere closed to the Salic law of the french Monarchy
    2
  26. Political communism - economic capitalism
    2
  27. Rousseau was right
    1
  28. Yes it did. The word nation meant tribe at first, then a community. It wasnt linked to the state. Same for race
    1
  29. ​ @McCarthy1776 yes, a nation state is a nation. With a state. The jooz state is Israël. You dont define terms you know ?
    1
  30. Thanks. Can you make a video on Economic Plans ? I dont even know what it looks like
    1
  31. All humanism spreads from that moment, including UNO chart etc
    1
  32. You dont understand monarchy. Its about the race they incarnate and perpetuate, not the individual.
    1
  33.  @SusCalvin  yeah so ?
    1
  34.  @SusCalvin  very vague
    1
  35.  @SusCalvin  its a cycle, phases
    1
  36.  @SusCalvin  nope, national feeling is greater than the crown tho. Class is also a big feeling, but rasse is the best
    1
  37. It means people.
    1
  38. Americans puts the constitution as the basis of their nation, which makes their identity very weak.
    1
  39. Na zism is of course a Fasc ism, but it is wrong to equal them. Fas cism Is an heroism, while na zism is a rassial one
    1
  40. We are in an ideology : extreme liberalism aka neoliberalism aka libertarianism
    1
  41. Being born equal in nature =/= born with equal rights
    1
  42.  @travishylton6976  thats why i said
    1
  43.  @oliviamaynard9372  no, that was legit.
    1
  44. The constitution is only a piece of judicial process. But identity resides in society. It is time to give a national identity, that would not be based only on legislation, but on the organization of citzenry, and on the role of the state. Its time to surpass the constitution without disrespecting it.
    1
  45. We need to give the constitution a new understanding in order to protect it
    1
  46. The conditions of the 21st century are too different for the constitution to be applied in the same manner that it used to be
    1
  47. Its time to give America a new national identity. A new man. A new heart, made for a new love.
    1
  48. The CCP is like a school
    1
  49. They should develop different characteristics from one point then
    1
  50. Nice. What is the fifference ? I still dont understand
    1
  51. Excellent. Is China still marxist in this sense ?
    1
  52. Nationalism is litterally a leftist idea. Right-wingers defend racial casts.
    1
  53. 17:20 I think by the state, facsists means "the laws" which for them are the natural constraint of the world.
    1
  54. 15:39 This principle show that state is sovereign over private property.
    1
  55. 16:10 interpréter
    1
  56. Thats a great argument against democracy
    1
  57. It is purely political and contextual. Nothing to see with "taiwanese" identity, which doesnt exist anymore
    1
  58. Its temporary so idc
    1
  59. Btw its still a majoritarian democracy so it has a counter power. The soviet central commitee shouldnt have existed tho
    1
  60. 7:05 gradualist. Shock = plunder = ruin
    1
  61. How many time of montage ?
    1
  62. Unfortunately most people dont know there are rules.... I know a good book about logic
    1
  63. 46:45 socialism as a people
    1
  64. 7:25 Gradualist approach Implement reforms in some cities Verify their results
    1
  65. 20:36 capitalism is a flow of money between persons.
    1
  66. 6:56 Thats something i understand to be false now
    1
  67. 40:14 Fascism is a political ideology whose mythic core - in its various permutations - is a palingenetic form of populist ultra-nationalism.
    1
  68. Tocqueville*
    1
  69. For us, not for others.
    1
  70. Thats the why the government should institute mandatory corporations and direct the economy
    1
  71. Nice, i'm not a socialist but i'm certainly not a capitalist 💁‍♂️ see you
    1
  72. Most governments destroyed their communities to achieve a nation-state. Guorilla is more effective than voting
    1
  73. Bab- huff not "bab-ouf"
    1
  74. 14:17 there is a préambule, in the Chinese constitution, that explains why the CCP must govern: because they defend the Chinese people. Thats the sacred law, principle.
    1
  75.  @not_a_human_being  what you describe is "synarchism" aka corporatocracy. American People confuse it with coporatism (guildism) because the word has another sense in American history. But its always public in fact
    1
  76.  @teery203  sure
    1
  77.  @oxvendivil442  tell me more about ROC and what chinese people think of it
    1
  78. 35:45 on s'engage et on voit
    1