Comments by "Limrasson" (@Limrasson) on "Stellar Blade Director Responds to the Backlash" video.

  1. "modeled after a real woman" in the context you are trying to use is like saying that Smaug is real because a real human was used in motion capture.
    2
  2. Wait, how tall is that table devman's wife uses? Or how small is she?
    1
  3.  @TheGreatKatulu  Either way, the point is that the goal wasn't realism or inclusion or any political agenda in the first place. It was to have a fun / cool game. I don't know when insecurity became "cool", but I see more and more of it being inserted into everywhere, inclusion used incorrectly too.
    1
  4.  @TheGreatKatulu  It's made to point out that just because a human is a starting point the end result could be whatever.
    1
  5.  @TheGreatKatulu  A stick figure also represents a human being. It is a very sensible argument, for the sake of correct arguments. Incorrect "you know what I mean" arguments are the place where original meaning and intent is lost. Quite frankly these internet dramas seem to devolve into two sides incoherently screetching at each other.
    1
  6.  @TheGreatKatulu  I mean what is the basis of you saying that the character's (not the IRL model's) proportions are not unrealistic or hyper proportioned?
    1
  7.  @TheGreatKatulu  but otherwise agree, the character looks valid.
    1
  8.  @TheGreatKatulu  Might be or you might missed the conversation, it doesn't matter much.
    1
  9.  @TheGreatKatulu  I made another comment a few days back, youj probably haven't seen it. I think it was you who said the character is objectively realistic and I've asked what you base that on. Since then I've looked at the character and subjectively it does look realistic.
    1
  10.  @TheGreatKatulu  I agree that it looks like such bodies exist irl, but to be 100% nitpicky, you would have to show that, and by showing I meant actual measurements, to be objective. You likely know this, but academia is funny like this. A morepractical argument would be that why would journalist disagree with the assesment of the character modell, on one side we have "actual actress was used to produce the model" and "eyeball measurement checks out" I haven't actually read any of the articles, but now I wonder if there is any basis of these claims (if they were made). For instance I would make the argument that perfect "anime" body, specifically the face, doesn't really fit the post apocalyptic theme, but this is a thematic choice to begin with. Utawarerumono is one of my favourites after all.
    1
  11.  @TheGreatKatulu  Yeah, well scrutiny should be applied to them as well so anyone talking out of their ass gets called as such. I don't really understand how they have any impact whatsoever. It's like if a doomsayer drug-addled hobo suddenly received office somewhere important.
    1