Comments by "" (@ronjon7942) on "CaspianReport"
channel.
-
4
-
4
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
First off, wow, what a great report! I really enjoyed listening to your perspective. The UN, to me, was an important institution that is involved in important issues, but I really never took the time to learn much about it.
I’m a fan of the UN in glossy principle, but yes - it seems its model seems outdated, and doesn’t look to have been developed to be flexibly modified. Maybe it should be scrapped and replaced, but would anything new be any different than what we have? Perhaps a new United Democracies…
Major reforms seem unlikely to happen what with Security Council members being considered enemies of each other. Maybe just get rid of the Security Council? Or change the permanent member criteria to ‘need to be a democratic society, with a capitalist economy, and place a high value on human rights?
It would seem difficult to squeeze China out as a permanent member, but in my opinion, Russia forfeited itself after the Soviet Union collapsed. Germany looks to be more appropriate than Russia, and Japan more than China.
Regardless of what critics of the United States might think (even American critics), if the US pulled out of the UN, the UN would cease; any reform or replacement would require permanent American involvement.
Maybe we have what we have, and the multinational General Assembly for dialogue, advocacy, and advisement is the best the UN can ever be, along with Economic and Social Council and the International Court of Justice.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
If only other navies could re-register their capital ships to the Ukraine…
Seriously, though, this video seems overly optimistic in favor of Ukraine. All the downstream strategies (ie, successful drone strikes on the Russian Navy, using US Army ATCMs to destroy Russian assets) have too many dependencies on previous operations working flawlessly. This is my first video from this channel, and while I did learn a lot, the steps to retake Crimea suggested appear to me too simplistic. I don’t know, maybe he’s 100% correct, but this video feels more like a wishlist rather than an assessment with recommendations by an analyst.
Edit - I did appreciate Caspian’s summary, where he brought up counterpoints to liberalization, like the Russians in Crimea, and international points of view. I subscribed, I’ll give the channel a chance. Hopefully it’ll be an objective source and not a cheerleader site.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Maybe not humiliation as experienced by the biden administration, but the military and the citizens (including me) are VERY humiliated by our administration's withdrawal. Biden left them to the wolves and he knew it. Yeah, we were fatigued, yeah it was expensive. But in his rush to get out, 13 Americans died needlessly, thousands of Afghans were likely immediately killed, untold thousands, if not tens of thousands, have their fates sealed. Women's rights are gone, children are being raised as terrorists, the government gutted, infrastructure....
20 years and $2.7 trillion gone and wasted...for what? So biden could announce he ended the war and brought our troops home, all so he could claim points for his upcoming reelection bs.
It's humiliating because how he did it was wrong, and I'm so very ashamed of our leadership. Of all the wrong ways to withdraw, our idiot president picked the very worst. Irritatingly, he's so self centered, he's already forgotten about the misery he's caused.
Don't get me wrong, Afghanistan should have done more to shore up their government and military; they had plenty of time and assistance, and they failed. But this culture does NOT seem conducive to democracy, and we tried forcing a concept upon them they have no experience or intuition for. They likely had adjusted to being 'ruled' by a military power, and in that regard they'll likely fall in line with the Taliban. Unfortunately, the taliban isn't much different than hamas, regardless of their attempts at giving the illusion of international legitimacy.
1
-
1