Comments by "D. von N." (@D.von.N) on "Middle East Eye" channel.

 @ilanklinger2573 don't try to pretend the conflict started out of nothing on Oct 7th.
35
@ilanklinger2573 And, according to Jewish scholars, Judaism prohibits creation of Jewish state. Judaism is a religion, not a nationality. Nobody stopped Jews living in the land and if they wished to move in, they could purchase land if others having it wanted to sell it. They were not supposed to shoot entire Arab families and villages dead. Besides, you not so elegantly avoided my question. Let me repeat it: "if somebody who claims having a thousands years old religious right for a land was forcing you of YOUR home and land, on which generations of your family lived in peace, would you just give a way or would you fight back?"
16
@ilanklinger2573 Yotube seems to have filtered my answer again, so let me try once more: by your logic we should revive mammoths and return the land to them? Palestine was there and was comprised by 90% Arabs. Although laws weren't as fair back then as they are now, British govt wanted to maintain its influence in the region and so it pushed for Israel, no law in the world allowed natives to be killed in thousands and thousands to make space for Jews moving in. Palestine was a broadly recognised region, old maps prove it, and just because it didn't have the same political status of a solid state, that doesn't mean it never existed or that those who inhabited it and were mostly in peace with each other, including Jews comprising some 8% population there then, that they (Arabs) were lesser humans not deserving deserve respect and right for their homes and land that fed them for generations.
15
Indeed. The veil has been torn off. The plain truth is coming to the view.
14
@ilanklinger2573 Yes, I do have a question: if somebody who claims having a thousands years old religious right for a land was forcing you of YOUR home and land, on which generations of your family lived in peace, would you just give a way or would you fight back?
14
@ilanklinger2573 "By the way when Israel was established only 8% of the land was under Arab property." not sure about that figure, but if it was true, it was because the large numbers of them were killed. You seem to be OK with that. If they didn't want to move, they were killed. Some weren't even asked. Whatever you say from this point, only shows what kind of being you are. No nationality is above a human life.
8
@ilanklinger2573 and still didn't answer my question. I can see why...
5
Common sense isn't that common. Just a similar effect to the DunningKruger.
5
Kudos to Piers for speaking sense, for once. And Isr.aelis will eventually have to agree to equal treatment.They are in a process to mentally get there. It takes time.
3
True words spoken, just forgetting Israel is not in it alone. Western powers created Israel, it is their project and they don't seem keen to give up on it. And now Haaretz is bein censored... what's next? Assassination of journalists? Foreign journalists already paid the highest price for covering the situation in occupied camps. Shireen was shot almost face to face. They knew who she was and they didn't want her there.
2
He is dellusional. I see RuSSian propagandists saying that nonsense to the all Western world in their propaganda channel. Nuking Britain, nuking Germany... while they couldn't take Avdiivka since 2014 and also Bakhmut just recently, and that only at a massive cost of lives and pull out of the defenders that value their lives. The same crap in just blue-white. Theater for the viewers mostly.
2
Britain needs a new party, quick. Neither Tories, nor Labour under Starmer's 'leadership' are fit to govern a democratic and human country. I don't expect the Greens to win and Lib Dems are 50/50.
2
Scott Ritter is not reliable. He might tell truth from time to time, like broken clock shows a correct time 2x a day. His adhesion to Kremlin's propaganda exposed him. This might be part of it, as Kremlin only welcomed distraction from the front in Ukraine. Slava Ukraini, peace to Palestinians.
1
Excellently put. What I am missing though is to bring to the light the vested Western interest for their ally in the region. For that reason I have a suspicion the West isn't not paying attention. They try ignoring it, perhaps to the point they cannot anymore, because of the domestic turn against the officials. We have a saying: a shirt is closer to the body than a coat. That's the reason for all those protests. And even the AIPAC can then go get stuffed. Americans have spent too much of their tax money for the aggresor to have a universal healthcare while they go bankrupt from medical bills and see no end to it.
1
Yahweh's intervention? He cannot watch this injustice.
1
@Dee78584 Have you heard about the wipeouts of entire Arab villages in Palestine by militant z.i.o.n.i.s.t.s back in 1920s? They were supported by the west by the modern weapons. Ha.mas is a response to the century old injustice in the region. I am not condoning what they did, just explaining that it has a background many people don't know or don't want to know.
1
@quoc28mytube it is easy to present oneself as top tech when getting $bns every year as a present, even having a universal healthcare, while those paying for this circus go bankrupt from medical bills or die because they cannot afford insulin costing them arm and leg, literally.
1
@segs3394 you mean those 300 miles of tunnels so 2 million people could get their supplies under decades of occupation? If you were sent packing from your home and your trees that fed your family for generations were uprooted to make room for illegal settlers, would you just bow and reverse into oblivion?
1
@marklawrence6958 elaborate on what exactly? Regardles, nobody displaced from anywhere for whatever reason has no right do displace anyone else. You don't get justice by keeping the wheel of injustice spinning. Any other questions?
1
@marklawrence6958 "gonna have to elaborate lad. Are we talking about Jews being displaced from Qatar, Saudi, Iran, pakistan, or Syria?" no mentioning on what nation, or what exactly I was supposed to elaborate on, me posting a few comments here, so no idea what you were referring to.
1
Piers is as stupid as it gets. Is.rael needs to look like the good guy, to keep getting $billions every year, no conditions, no questions asked. Little by little they are following their genocidal goal. They could do it all at once, but they don't want to and cannot afford to if they want to keep looking like the good guy.
1
Miscalculation of Israel was its entire agenda from the beginning, that it would succeed in its ultimate goal and get away with it.
1