General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
asynchronicity
Corey Gil-Shuster
comments
Comments by "asynchronicity" (@asynchronicity) on "Palestinian refugees: What do you know about the villages you come from?" video.
@sandrad9695 Well, Jordan and Egypt won’t take them. There are a huge number that have actually been born in refugee camps, aren’t there?
2
@mirabrown2271 So you are saying they have now been conquered by Israelis and have to leave?
1
@mirabrown2271 Well, you have to admit that most Israelis ultimately see West Bank territory as Judea and Samaria, and therefore part of “historical Israel.” Even Gaza is seen by many in the same way. What is left?
1
@mirabrown2271 Yes, if you look at the 1947 proposal the Arabs seem to have really missed an opportunity for a relatively sweet deal. However, given that it included Judea and Samaria would they really have been able to expect that they would ultimately be allowed to keep that part of historical Israel?
1
@sandrad9695 Where are they from then?
1
@sandrad9695 Where are they from in general though? (As refugees it is hard to say isn't it?)
1