General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Hobbs
TIKhistory
comments
Comments by "Hobbs" (@hobbso8508) on ""TIK's definitions are wrong!" (about Socialism & Capitalism)" video.
@robertvolz4200 Considering TIK defines publicly traded companies as socialism, you may want to check on your definitions again.
1
"Worker ownership of the means of production" is not the same as saying "state control." For workers to have ownership they have to have control over the means of production, meaning state control is only possible is the workers control the state, usually via democracy. Workers can also own the means of production directly through worker cooperatives and avoid the state entirely. If workers have no control, then they have no ownership. First you say that "the state" is "society" to prove that socialism only requires state control, then you argue against this exact definition. "Democracy is a lie" Now he's just a fascist. TIK agrees that his own definition is false, but rather than agreeing, he doubles down and claims that socialism is a lie instead.
1