Comments by "115islands Compass" (@115islandscompass6) on "Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell" channel.

  1. 146
  2. 77
  3. The CIA website has a PDF file with the following name. “Memoranda for the President: Japanese Feelers” The following is an excerpt from that PDF: “12 May 1945 MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT: The following information, transmitted by the OSS representative in Bern,9 originates with a German source, an authority on the Far East who is considered anti-Nazi but pro-Japanese:10 The source, on 11 May, talked with Shunichi Kase, the Japanese Minister to Switzerland. He reports that Kase expressed a wish to help arrange for a cessation of hostilities between the Japanese and the Allies. Kase reportedly considers direct talks with the Americans and the British preferable to negotiations through the USSR,11 because the latter eventually would increase Soviet prestige so much that the whole Far East would become Communist. Kase allegedly believes that one of the few provisions the Japanese would insist upon would be the retention of the Emperor as the only safeguard against Japan's conversion to Communism. Kase feels that Under Secretary of State Grew, whom he considers the best US authority on Japan, shares this opinion. Added by hand: Should we pursue this? Donovan” This PDF file shows that the Government of Japan was asking the United States to talk the end of the war. And it was recorded that they admitted defeat and argued that maintaining the emperor system was the only condition for surrender, which was necessary to prevent Japan from becoming a communist nation. The draft of the Potsdam Declaration was supervised by Joseph Grew, a former ambassador to Japan. The draft contained a sentence that allowed the continuation of the emperor system. Because Grew was known the above information, knew well why Japan wanted the continuation of the Emperor System, and knew that Japan would surrender as soon as the Potsdam Declaration allowed the continuation of the Emperor System. This Grew’s effort is proven by the Truman memoir. It says: "Grew arrived at the end of May and suggested to make a declaration urging Japan to surrender. The declaration provided Japan with a guarantee that the United States would allow the Emperor to remain head of state." "I told him that I had already considered this issue and that (Grew's suggestion) seemed like a sound opinion." However, when Truman annouced the Potsdam Declaration, the sentence that allowed the continuation of the emperor system had removed from the declaration. It was because the atomic bomb was completed the day before the declaration.
    35
  4. 34
  5. 21
  6. 20
  7. 19
  8. 12
  9. 9
  10. 7
  11. 7
  12. 6
  13. 6
  14. The CIA website has a PDF file with the following name. “Memoranda for the President: Japanese Feelers” And, the following is an excerpt from that. “12 May 1945 MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT: The following information, transmitted by the OSS representative in Bern,9 originates with a German source, an authority on the Far East who is considered anti-Nazi but pro-Japanese:10 The source, on 11 May, talked with Shunichi Kase, the Japanese Minister to Switzerland. He reports that Kase expressed a wish to help arrange for a cessation of hostilities between the Japanese and the Allies. Kase reportedly considers direct talks with the Americans and the British preferable to negotiations through the USSR,11 because the latter eventually would increase Soviet prestige so much that the whole Far East would become Communist. Kase allegedly believes that one of the few provisions the Japanese would insist upon would be the retention of the Emperor as the only safeguard against Japan's conversion to Communism. Kase feels that Under Secretary of State Grew, whom he considers the best US authority on Japan, shares this opinion. Added by hand: Should we pursue this? Donovan” This PDF file shows that the Government of Japan was asking the United States to talk the end of the war. And it was recorded that they admitted defeat and argued that maintaining the emperor system was the only condition for surrender, which was necessary to prevent Japan from becoming a communist nation. The draft of the Potsdam Declaration was supervised by Joseph Grew, a former ambassador to Japan. The draft contained a sentence that allowed the continuation of the emperor system. Because Grew was known the above information, knew well why Japan wanted the continuation of the Emperor System, and knew that Japan would surrender as soon as the Potsdam Declaration allowed the continuation of the Emperor System. This Grew’s effort is proven by the Truman memoir. It says: "Grew arrived at the end of May and suggested to make a declaration urging Japan to surrender. The declaration provided Japan with a guarantee that the United States would allow the Emperor to remain head of state." "I told him that I had already considered this issue and that (Grew's suggestion) seemed like a sound opinion." From the fact above, we can see no landing operations or atomic bombs were needed for the early end of the war. However, when Truman annouced the Potsdam Declaration, the sentence that allowed the continuation of the emperor system had removed from the declaration. It was because the atomic bomb was completed the day before the declaration.
    5
  15. 5
  16. 4
  17. 3
  18. 3
  19. 2
  20. 2
  21. 1
  22. 1
  23. 1
  24. 1
  25. 1
  26. 1
  27. 1
  28. 1
  29. 1
  30. 1
  31. 1
  32.  @infidelheretic923  It was Chiang Kai-shek & Communist Party Allied Forces that started the war with Japan. Chiang Kai-shek had received funds and weapons from the Western Powers in the name of destroying the Communist Party. However, at one point, he was caught by the Communist Party(Xi'an Incident). He was threatened to "If you finish destroying the Communist Party, you will not be able to make money in the war. Instead of destroying the Communist Party, fight with Japan. Or..." He agreed. This was also supported by Europe and the United States, which were worried that Japan would gain China's interests due to the creation of Manchuria with the backing of Japan. Today, Manchuria is said to be a nation that Japan cut from China and colonized, but that is not true. Prior to the Manchurian Incident, Chinese warlords frequently attacked civilians, including Japanese civilians. They were like gangsters. Civilians who could not withstand the victims of robbery, rape, kidnapping and murder sought help from the Japanese Kwantung Army. The Kwantung Army was a security unit of the South Manchuria Railway that was ceded by Russia after the Russo-Japanese War. The Kwantung Army wiped out the warlords to restore security in Manchuria. This mopping operation is called the Manchurian Incident. It is true that Manchuria was founded with the backing of Japan's economy and military power, but it was a nation for the Manchurian people by Manchuria people. Japan made a huge investment, cultivated with the people of Manchuria, developed soybeans that grow even in cold regions, and transformed Manchuria into one of the world's leading soybean producing nations. It was clear that if Japan continued this on an ethnic basis, the West would lose their interests in China, that is, they would not be able to exploit China. In the Marco Polo Bridge Incident, the Chinese National Revolutionary Army fired at the Japanese army, but Japan, which was based on non-expansion, immediately started peace talks, and the negotiations were about to end within a month. However, at that time, about 200 non armed Japanese were slaughtered in Tongzhou, a Japanese settlement. These victims included infants, children, women and the elderly. All men were killed after being tortured, such as being tied up with ropes and dragged around, and all women were cruelty killed after being raped. The misery photos of Japanese women’s bodies can be seen in the photos stolen by the book:“Rape of Nanjing”. Shortly thereafter, an assassination of a Japanese officer took place in Shanghai. Both were terrorist attacks by the Chinese side, and negotiations failed. Many Japanese(about 20,000) in China had gathered in Shanghai to evacuate to Japan for fear of Chinese attacks. Chiang Kai-shek troops besieged Shanghai to attack these unarmed Japanese, and the Japanese troops responded. This was the China-incident, and the war began. In other words, it is taught all over the world that “Japan invaded China” or "Japan fought Chiang Kai-shek for the purpose of invading China," but that is not true.
    1
  33. 1
  34. 1
  35. 1
  36. 1
  37. 1
  38. 1
  39. 1
  40. 1
  41. 1
  42. 1
  43. 1
  44. 1
  45.  @DevinMacGregor  First, It was to prevent the invasion to Japan from Russia / Soviet Union / Communist forces that fought the Russo-Japanese War, Japan annexed Korean empire, became the backing of Manchuria, and fought against Chiang Kai-shek & CCP Union. It was Chiang Kai-shek & Communist Party Allied Forces that started the war with Japan by repeatedly attacking Japanese people and troops. I mentioned the Tongzhou incident and the assassination of Shanghai, but even before the Manchurian Incident, there were frequent cases of harassment, looting and rape kidnapping etc. of Japanese by Chinese warlords. During the Boxer Rebellion, each country sent PKO troops to China to protect the lives and property of their people. However, due to the Spanish flu epidemic, troops from Western countries returned. The countries that returned the army at this time entrusted the Japanese army to protect the lives and property of their people. Thus, the Japanese army became the target of China's expulsion activities. Chiang Kai-shek had received funds and weapons from the Western Powers in the name of destroying the Communist Party. However, at one point, he was caught by the Communist Party(Xi'an Incident). He was threatened to “If you finish destroying the Communist Party, you will not be able to make money in the war. Instead of destroying the Communist Party, fight with Japan. Or..." He agreed and teamed up the communists party. This was also supported by Europe and the United States, which were worried about losing their property in China. Western countries had supported Chiang Kai-shek.
    1
  46.  @DevinMacGregor  You said Japan was aiming to expand into the Pacific Ocean. However, Japan moved south to the Pacific Ocean in order to break the Allied embargo siege. Please check the time series again. The Japanese army attacked the colonial forces of Southeast Asian countries on the same day as the attack on Pearl Harbor. Entry into Indochina was done with the permission of France. The purpose was to stop the supply from the West to Chiang Kai-shek & CCP Union. And the ultimate goal of this was to end the war in China. As MacArthur said in his Senate speech shortly after his return, the Japanese war was for security. Japan did not want the aggression to expand. Prior to the attack on Pearl Harbor, Japan conducted diplomatic negotiations with the United States to lift the embargo. Almost entirely at the request of the United States, including the withdrawal from China, the United States further requested the immediate withdrawal of Japanese troops from the continent, and there was no guarantee that Japan would lift the embargo. This is the same as giving Manchuria and the Korean Peninsula, which have made large investments, to Chiang Kai-shek & the Communist Party forces or the Soviet Union or the both. And that means that the lives and property of the Chinese, Manchus, Koreans, and Japanese people who were there will be deprived. If the Soviet Union acquires the Korean Peninsula, the Japanese archipelago is also in danger of aggression. The United States knew that Japan would never accept it and demanded it. Why do you think the United States made even more unacceptable demands without a guarantee to lift the embargo when Japan said it would gradually withdraw from China? Dexter Hull handed over Hull Note with the above contents to Japan and ended diplomatic negotiations. This note was a kind of declaration of war. Therefore, this Hull Note should have been scrutinized by Congress. But the Roosevelt administration did not. What do you think about it?
    1
  47. 1
  48. 1
  49. 1
  50. 1
  51. 1
  52. 1
  53. 1
  54. 1
  55. 1
  56. 1
  57. 1
  58.  @mephostopheles3752  The following is an excerpt from an article with the following title: "August 6, 1945 Hiroshima Atomic Bomb Drop President's Statement" "It was to spare the Japanese people from utter destruction that the ultimatum of July 26 was issued at Potsdam. Their leaders promptly rejected that ultimatum." Truman can read in this speech stating that the United States dropped the atomic bomb because the Japanese government rejected the Potsdam Declaration. However, Prime Minister Suzuki did not officially notify the Allies of the rejection of the Potsdam Declaration. According to the reporter's record interviewed shortly after the declaration, Prime Minister Suzuki said, "I don't think much importance to it," and etc. and ended the conference and tried to leave there. Because the situation was very sensitive, so he didn’t want to say any words that influence the situation. Reporters chased the leaving prime minister and sought what it meant to be "not important." At this time, Prime Minister Suzuki answered "no comment" and left there. In response, the Japanese newspapers that could not write "no comment" because the use of English was prohibited reported as follows. Yomiuri Shimbun and Mainichi Shimbun: "笑止"Shoushi Asahi Shimbun: "黙殺"Mokusatsu “Mokusatsu” means silently ignorance. So, the Alliance newspaper reported "ignore". And then Western newspapers reported it as "reject". But, the government of Japan did not any response to the declaration in official yet. The minutes of the Cabinet meeting on August 9th of the Government of Japan have a record of discussions on the approval of the Potsdam Declaration. In the morning, the Prime Minister Kantaro Suzuki started the conference with the statement, "I’m going to accept the Potsdam Declaration." And the atomic bomb was dropped on Nagasaki during this cabinet meeting.
    1
  59.  @mephostopheles3752  Furthermore, the United States knew that Japan had admitted defeat and was about to surrender. the CIA website has a PDF file with the following name. “Memoranda for the President: Japanese Feelers” And, the following is an excerpt from that. “12 May 1945 MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT: The following information, transmitted by the OSS representative in Bern,9 originates with a German source, an authority on the Far East who is considered anti-Nazi but pro-Japanese:10 The source, on 11 May, talked with Shunichi Kase, the Japanese Minister to Switzerland. He reports that Kase expressed a wish to help arrange for a cessation of hostilities between the Japanese and the Allies. Kase reportedly considers direct talks with the Americans and the British preferable to negotiations through the USSR,11 because the latter eventually would increase Soviet prestige so much that the whole Far East would become Communist. Kase allegedly believes that one of the few provisions the Japanese would insist upon would be the retention of the Emperor as the only safeguard against Japan's conversion to Communism. Kase feels that Under Secretary of State Grew, whom he considers the best US authority on Japan, shares this opinion. Added by hand: Should we pursue this? Donovan” This PDF file shows that the Government of Japan was asking the United States to talk the end of the war. And it was recorded that they admitted defeat and argued that maintaining the emperor system was the only condition for surrender, which was necessary to prevent Japan from becoming a communist nation. The draft of the Potsdam Declaration was supervised by Joseph Grew, a former ambassador to Japan. The draft contained a sentence that allowed the continuation of the emperor system. Because Grew knew well why Japan wanted the continuation of the Emperor System, and knew that Japan would surrender as soon as the Potsdam Declaration allowed the continuation of the Emperor System. This Grew’s effort is proven by the Truman memoir. It says: "Grew arrived at the end of May and said,'Why don't you make a declaration urging Japan to surrender?' The declaration provided Japan with a guarantee that the United States would allow the Emperor to remain head of state. I told him that I had already considered this issue and that (Glue's suggestion) seemed like a sound opinion." However, when Truman annouced the Potsdam Declaration, the sentence that allowed the continuation of the emperor system had removed from the declaration. It was because the atomic bomb was completed the day before the declaration.
    1
  60. 1
  61. 1
  62. 1
  63. 1
  64. The CIA website has a PDF file with the following name. “Memoranda for the President: Japanese Feelers” And, the following is an excerpt from that. “12 May 1945 MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT: The following information, transmitted by the OSS representative in Bern,9 originates with a German source, an authority on the Far East who is considered anti-Nazi but pro-Japanese:10 The source, on 11 May, talked with Shunichi Kase, the Japanese Minister to Switzerland. He reports that Kase expressed a wish to help arrange for a cessation of hostilities between the Japanese and the Allies. Kase reportedly considers direct talks with the Americans and the British preferable to negotiations through the USSR,11 because the latter eventually would increase Soviet prestige so much that the whole Far East would become Communist. Kase allegedly believes that one of the few provisions the Japanese would insist upon would be the retention of the Emperor as the only safeguard against Japan's conversion to Communism. Kase feels that Under Secretary of State Grew, whom he considers the best US authority on Japan, shares this opinion. Added by hand: Should we pursue this? Donovan” This PDF file shows that the Government of Japan was asking the United States to talk the end of the war. And it was recorded that they admitted defeat and argued that maintaining the emperor system was the only condition for surrender, which was necessary to prevent Japan from becoming a communist nation. The draft of the Potsdam Declaration was supervised by Joseph Grew, a former ambassador to Japan. The draft contained a sentence that allowed the continuation of the emperor system. Because Grew knew well why Japan wanted the continuation of the Emperor System, and knew that Japan would surrender as soon as the Potsdam Declaration allowed the continuation of the Emperor System. This Grew’s effort is proven by the Truman memoir. It says: "Grew arrives at the end of May and says,'Why don't you make a declaration urging Japan to surrender?' The declaration provided Japan with a guarantee that the United States would allow the Emperor to remain head of state." "I told him that I had already considered this issue and that (Grew’s suggestion) seemed like a sound opinion." However, when Truman annouced the Potsdam Declaration, the sentence that allowed the continuation of the emperor system had removed from the declaration. It was because the atomic bomb was completed the day before the declaration. As we can see, no landing operations or atomic bombs were needed for the early end of the war. So why is it still taught around the world that "the atomic bomb was dropped to end the war early or to avoid landing operations to save many lives"? Because it were examinations The US’s purposes of dropping the atomic bomb in Japan: 1. Experiments on how the atomic bomb destroys and kills living cities and people 2. Experiments on contamination by radioactivity and its effects on the human body 3. Demonstration to the Soviet Union After the end of the war, the United States established the Atomic Bomb Casualty Commission (ABCC) in Hiroshima and Nagasaki and began investigating the effects of radioactivity. ABCC put people who were harmed by atomic bombs in their facility saying they would treat those pacients. But no treatment was given. Never. They took blood from survivors, photographed wounds and keloids, recorded their condition, took organs when they died. They sent those organs and etc. to the United States as samples with various investigations and records. On the other hand, the treatment of Japanese doctors was banned. Their medical records were taken away and the request for medicine to the Red Cross was stopped. In addition, it was not allowed to report all of this. It’s clear that what we are taught was written to hide what the United States actually had done.
    1
  65. 1
  66. 1
  67. The CIA website has a PDF file with the following name. “Memoranda for the President: Japanese Feelers” And, the following is an excerpt from that file: “12 May 1945 MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT: The following information, transmitted by the OSS representative in Bern,9 originates with a German source, an authority on the Far East who is considered anti-Nazi but pro-Japanese:10 The source, on 11 May, talked with Shunichi Kase, the Japanese Minister to Switzerland. He reports that Kase expressed a wish to help arrange for a cessation of hostilities between the Japanese and the Allies. Kase reportedly considers direct talks with the Americans and the British preferable to negotiations through the USSR,11 because the latter eventually would increase Soviet prestige so much that the whole Far East would become Communist. Kase allegedly believes that one of the few provisions the Japanese would insist upon would be the retention of the Emperor as the only safeguard against Japan's conversion to Communism. Kase feels that Under Secretary of State Grew, whom he considers the best US authority on Japan, shares this opinion. Added by hand: Should we pursue this? Donovan” This PDF file shows that the Government of Japan is asking the United States to talk the end of the war. And it is recorded that they admitted defeat and argued that maintaining the emperor system was the only condition for surrender, which was necessary to prevent Japan from becoming a communist nation. The draft of the Potsdam Declaration was supervised by Joseph Grew, a former ambassador to Japan. The draft contained a sentence that allowed the continuation of the emperor system. Because Grew knew well why Japan wanted the continuation of the Emperor System, and knew that Japan would surrender as soon as the Potsdam Declaration allowed the continuation of the Emperor System. The Truman memoir says: "Glue arrives at the end of May and says,'Why don't you make a declaration urging Japan to surrender?' The declaration provided Japan with a guarantee that the United States would allow the Emperor to remain head of state." "I told him that I had already considered this issue and that (Glue's suggestion) seemed like a sound opinion." However, when Truman annouced the Potsdam Declaration, the sentence that allowed the continuation of the emperor system had removed from the declaration.
    1