Comments by "Вячеслав Скопюк" (@user-yj8vj3sq6j) on "MANNERHEIM | History and his Line" video.

  1. Describing the breakthrough of the Mannerheim Line, Trotter brings everything to the human wave that sweeps the defending Finns. I doubt that this happened at least once during the war. The lessons of the First World War were learned a long time ago. "Mow down hundreds of man " - a typical clishe. About "Mannerheim decided not to take part in the siege of Leningrad" - it wasn't so. Mannerheim decided not to help the Germans to attack Leningrad
    4
  2. +Kastor Hallavainio >just the amount of mostly Ukrainian bodies how they check nationality of the body? >the amount of deaths both Finland AND USSR reported pretty much back this "Mowing down hundreds of men". Can you be more precise? As far as i know, there were no such thing as "mowed down hundred of man". In particularly unfortunate cases, these were several dozen at a time. >About Leningrad: Finns did not try to intercept supplies to Leningrad over the lake ladoga which is the definition of "Siege" they simply could not do anything about supplies on Ladoga lake. But they(and Germans) tried to close the ring of encirclement on the Svir >neither did the Finns strike at Leningrad with aircraft or artillery And how exactly could they do this? Without the presence of long-range artillery and bomber aircraft in sufficient numbers? They had some things to do in the north, remember? >Next you're probably going to tell us that the shelling of Mainila really happened with Finnish artillery shooting way past their maximum range. I wonder why you remembered Mainila in the discussion about breakthrough of the Mannerheim Line and siege of Leningrad?
    4
  3. +Great Jamie Mannerheim didn't used nothing. He was supreme commander. He was way above any tactics. Tactics was the responsibility of officers of a lower level. And skiers didn't attacked tanks, lol - at night or otherwise.
    2
  4. +Great Jamie He distinguished himself as a politician, not as a general
    1
  5. +Great Jamie what 'brilliant tactics' do you mean?
    1
  6.  @jounisuninen  oh, stop that nonsense with "Finland army stopped on the old border"
    1
  7. +Michael McCabe >Those who have actually lived under communism will all attest to that. Finnish 'reds' weren't communist, nor bolshevik's
    1
  8. +Michael McCabe >The reds always considered themselves to be socialists and communists nope, lol. >You're effectively calling them liars. nope, i calling you a liar. We didn't talk about communists. We were talking about 'reds'
    1