Comments by "Вячеслав Скопюк" (@user-yj8vj3sq6j) on "It's NOT acceptable to DENY History | TIK Q&A 2.5" video.

  1. >I personally don't think the germans were different from the british or the americans or the soviets , it was war treating non-combatants(not mentioning Jews) in German manner was something new and fresh. All those fancy orders about hanging and shooting
    7
  2. "there is a qualitative moral difference between open and specific racism and exterminationist antisemitism on the one hand and a form of philosophical materialism which deprioritises human sentiment and the individual resulting in policies which waste lives through negligence and callousness" - well said
    7
  3. TIK Just for you to know - hypothesis about deliberate nature of 1932-1933 Famine originates in "theory" that 1932-1933 Famine was targeted against Ukrainians. Oleh Wolowyna says directly, that Ukrainians were targets, despite their place of living. To me, it looks like he had answer long before the research. You can't just go and trust a man, even if he has a prefix "Dr." in front of the name. To fill the picture, we should see the criticism of his works
    5
  4. jeffrey dahmere >non-combatants whats exactly that I think, wikipedia has quite extensive definition of the term >if you gave housing , food or passed a intelligence or do propaganda from the those who are fighting , you are part of the war I'm sure you would gladly help lieutenant Calley boys shoot Vietnamese babies.They were part of the war, after all. >besides that the soviets didn't sight up the geneva conventions thats why you have "All those fancy orders about hanging and shooting" AFAIR, Geneva conventions before war say nothing about civilians. So, what do you mean by "that's why"? >there was many cases of misconduct on both sides not only german but on most cases it was punished we are not talking about misconduct. Because on the German side it was quite opposite - soldiers, who executed orders to shoot hostages, did the good thing.
    3
  5. Redfox161616 >Stalin killed close to 40-50 million close to 40-50 trillions. The latest research show that
    2
  6. >I repeat the idea of mass industrialization was first purposed by Trotsky,Stalin himself did not invent it. I think, idea of mass industrialization of Russia belongs to some man in Russian Empire in the early 1900-s. Or earlier. It isn't rocket science. >Stalin purged people in his own party because of just his paranoia how do you know that? >he signed a non aggresion pact with Hitler thinking he will be the first one to strike again - how do you know his thoughts? >If not a criminal he was definetly a idiot to say the least. idiot aren't capable of making his country a world superpower >With Trotsky in power USSR would have not even fight a war with Hitler,as Germany would've been USSRs ally long before 1940s. LOL. Hitler's Germany? With Lebensraum ? You are a mighty wishful thinker, dear sir :D
    2
  7. jeffrey dahmere >but on all of those cases that I mentioned above they were breaking those agreement how do you checked that? Read materials of field investigations? Remind me, what form of warfare conducted inhabitants of Oradour-sur-Glane? >hostages that were hiding and protecting partisan nope. Just hostages. >if you don't want to get involved it was simple don't help those terrorists/partisans/resistance save me from this bullshit, please. Nobody checked, who was helping partisans, and who not.
    1
  8. jeffrey dahmere >I can see that scene so, we are agree, that Germans killed civilians on principles of collective responsibility? Then, what the point of you talking about 'they killed only partisan supporters', when you denying your own words >thats right Oradour-sur-Glane they were hiding weapons and helping the resistance ,thats why the germans retaliated "collective responsibility" > thats what the germans did yep. Indiscriminately killed civilians, on the official orders. So, why are you talked about cases of misconduct on both sides? In the German case, misconduct - it's when German soldier refuses to execute civilian hostage
    1
  9. as the matter of fact, 316th rifle division consisted mostly of russians.
    1
  10. Almighty42 'idea' cost nothing without embodiment >Stalin was a criminal and nothing more then that. you know many criminals that create superpower from their country?
    1
  11. Yep. fiction books as the source
    1
  12. why GULAG shouldn't have existed?
    1
  13. that could be said about many things in USSR during 1920-1950. Those were tough times
    1
  14. Thing with Israel is that, that their opponents weren't peaceful neighbors and were(and are) quite determined to completely destroy Israel
    1
  15. AFAIR, Israel recognizes Palestine. Yep, Israel have some occupied lands, as a winner
    1
  16. >there wasn't even a drop of anti-semitism here why Lithuanians started killing Jews from first days of occupation, then? >many people turned against jewish people because of propaganda and just to get some bread https://ru.delfi.lt/news/live/professor-obyasnil-pochemu-v-litve-nacistam-ne-potrebovalis-gazovye-kamery.d?id=77102635 it's may be interesting to you
    1