General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About

Elana Vital
BBC News
comments

Comments by "Elana Vital" (@ElanaVital83) on "The Lovely Bones author Alice Sebold apologises to man cleared of her rape - BBC News" video.

@jasemalkhaleel7122 It just took her 8 days huh? She really seemed broken up about it 🙄
20
Well you know how it is #believewomen
13
@samuellp1146 I don't believe she's a victim.
10
@dominiquejones3805 Good idea! This poor guy seriously needs to sue
7
@jamesholdener7625 I don't care how old she was. She LIED.
6
She's lying about the whole thing.
6
I don't even really believe she's a victim of a heinous crime. I think she made up the whole thing.
5
Jo Pearson I'll say it: I don't believe she was attacked at all. Women can lie, you know. Especially women who write novels glamorizing the sexual assault and murder of a child and trying to market it as a cutesy YA romance ghost story. She's sick. Read her stuff.
5
@pookiesis1465 Men can't really share rape stories without being shamed, but it happens and men aren't allowed to complain. This dudes is melodramatic, bit it's true that the justice system is slanted against men.
5
@Leanne Nope. She's the one who made millions of dollars on a bogus story she embellished for drama's sake.
5
@samuellp1146 Yes. I believe she lied about that 100%.
5
@Leanne So she should be made and example of.
5
@noshimoshi How do we know she didn't lie about EVERYTHING?
4
@samuelgates5935 Women have lied, but not just white women. Remember the Lacrosse team that was lied about.
4
@barboralitvanova5111 I doubt everything she claims., too. Because she wrote a dramatized version of him just to sell her books, man. No trauma survivor wants to rehash the details, let alone EMBELLISH them just for drama's sake.
4
@barboralitvanova5111 People don't react to trauma by embellishing the details of the trauma for book sales. Doing that would be TRAUMATIC. And you're making excuses for a proven liar.
4
@barboralitvanova5111 She isn't a proven victim, or did you forget the "forensic evidence" has already been shown as unreliable? Stop trying to downplay what she did here by painting her as a victim. She sat and collected checks, and even exaggerated his life story to make it more dramatic. She LIED.
4
@angellee356 Agreed. She glamorized a murder into a YA supernatural romance. Weird stuff.
4
@Betelgeuse Nah, they're trying so hard to still paint her as a victim here. Check out the comments they're disgusting. "THE POLICE BRAINWASHED HER!! SHE'S NOT RESPONSIBLE!!" Meanwhile she's making millions off a story she knew was false.
4
@critique0767 People are allowed to doubt the word of someone who lied for 16 years. I'm flat out saying it. She glamorized story the r4pe and murder of a child into a cutesy YA romance. Munchausen is a real mental illness.
3
@critique0767 I don't believe her and I doubt it ever happened. Clutch your pearls all you want. I'll say it again: I AM CONVINCED SHE LIED ABOUT THE WHOLE THING. She sat on this for 16 years and quietly collected checks while fabricating a nonexistent criminal history for him because it would sell her books better. I believe she LIED ABOUT EVERYTHING. Cry about it.
3
@honeypeaches7736 I doubt she was telling the truth about her rape. She lied to write a book. She glamorized the rape of a minor and then exaggerated the same thing with the innocent man. She's a liar and a malingerer who would lie about it for sympathy.
3
Jo Pearson Honey, there are people who poison their own children for sympathy. And that report supposedly had Broadwater's DNA in it, and now it's disregarded. Yes, sick people are willing to self harm to get attention and sympathy. Yes, I believe that she is one of those people.
3
Jo Pearson What doesn't "make sense" is why you're trying so hard to allow her to shirk responsibility for her actions. Alice....is that you?
3
Women of color aren't safe either. Ever see Victoria Secret Karen? She assaulted a black woman,and both the cops and employees told the black woman she was in the wrong for "bothering" her.
3
@Leanne I have a vag. And calling this disgusting woman out for the horrible thing she's done IS NOT MISOGYNY. Sit down because you don't get to speak for all women.
3
@Leanne Women like you disgust me. Trying to use our sex and gender as a "get out of responsibility free" card. Go sit on a tack. You're part of the problem.
3
@samuellp1146 Innocent until proven guilty. That's how it works.
3
@Leanne She didn't "clearly misidentify" his fictional criminal history. Nice try though. She BLATANTLY FABRICATED IT to make him seems more like a villain....to sell her books
3
@ChicaMaria61 How are we better? Easy. We didn't falsely accuse anyone and ruin their lives for 40 years. That's how we're better.
3
@noshimoshi You act as if lying about rape is impossible.
2
@critique0767 Nope. That's not how justice even as a philosophy works, and if you were on the receiving end of a false accusation, you would want to be innocent until PROVEN GUILTY. FFS this hurts real victims so much! Women like her make it scary for real victims to tell their stories.
2
@Melissa-hd3jr I doubt the entire story. Especially since the "rape kit" was proven to be inaccurate.
2
@ChicaMaria61 I don't care of what you're tired of. You're making excuses for this woman who profited off of maligning an innocent man by fabricating a criminal history for dramatic effect to sell books. Trauma survivors wouldn't do that. I don't believe she was actually raped, but that she glamorizes the idea of it (as shown in her books).
2
@ChicaMaria61 Women who suffer from Munchausen syndrome do lie about sexual assault and fabricate stories of how victimized they were for sympathy. I believe she is one of these women. Why else would she be trying to make so much money off of a supposed trauma, meanwhile inventing ways to make it more dramatic? She wanted money and attention.
2
@ChicaMaria61 How do you know it "was a fact" when even the supposed forensic evidence is now no longer reliable? How do you know it "was a fact" when previously she stated "it was a fact" that he was her attacker? It doesn't add up at all.
2
@CyanideSunshines You're only making excuses for her because she's white.
2
@CyanideSunshines "Not everything is about color!" said the white woman who benefits from being a protected class in society. If you cry crocodile tears and point a finger of blame at anyone, they're bound to rot for 16 years, too. You know it. You LOVE IT. I see right through you, Gemma. Of course you want Sebold to dodge responsibility. You're her same demographic.
2
@miguelbermudez5426 Nope. She wont be held accountable because she's a white woman.
2
Women who suffer from Munchausen syndrome do lie about sexual assault and fabricate stories of how victimized they were for sympathy. I believe she is one of these women. Why else would she be trying to make so much money off of a supposed trauma, meanwhile inventing ways to make her "villain" sound more evil by creating a fictional past, just to make it more dramatic? She wanted money and attention. She knew on one would think twice of convicting a black man. She called the book "Lucky". She was lucky everyone bought it.
2
I agree. She seems to think violence against women is glamorous. She made it up.
2
@creatyve What Real Things is trying to do is use jargon as a smokescreen to deflect Alice Sebold's responsibility in this. This is called "narcissistic word salad" and is a common tactic for abusive people like her to shift blame.
2
@Leanne You're trying so hard to deflect Alice's responsibility.
2
@realthings5821 Your feeble attempt to deflect her responsibility only makes people happy to see her pay for what she did.
2
Don't forget, SHE'S the victim!
2
@cat_Connoisseur You want to take responsibility off her shoulders? Why? Because she's white?
2
@realthings5821 Hello, gaslighter. I see what you are doing
2
@realthings5821 I don't need to read her mind, I can look at her 16 year deceptive track record. You act as if people are incapable of lying about a crime. People murder people and lie about it.
2
@realthings5821 She invented a criminal history for her book to be more dramatic. Tell me how that's remotely something a trauma survivor would want to do.
2
@cat_Connoisseur "Waaah she was brainwashed!!" Stop it.
2
@princerose233 I don't think she was raped either. Not when she's writing nonexistent criminal histories to add drama to sell books. Trauma survivors wouldn't do that.
2
@Leanne Her motivation was to become a famous millionaire off her "brave story"...Not rocket science. She knew accusing a white man would lead to a deeper investigation. So she picked a black man because she knew no one would care.
2
@Angelina He Share a percentage? He deserves the entirety of her books sales from "Lucky". And she sat on this for 40 years collecting checks.
2
@J4MESOX4D People like Paula thrive on misrepresentation
2
@Leanne There are plenty of shades of gray between good and evil. It's a spectrum and she is pretty far away from the good side. Putting an innocent man in prison and fabricating lies about him to sell books is pretty evil. Defending such a person is pretty evil, too.
2
I do question it, but everyone else is too scared to!
1
@critique0767 Look up Lacey Spears. Gypsy Rose Lee.
1
@mariannehavisham8323 What evidence? I looked and looked and found little to nothing.
1
@ChicaMaria61 You're making excuses for her by using emotionally manipulative speech to paint her as a victim: "I know she did a bad thing but *SHE WAS A YOUNG IMPRESSIONABLE WOMAN!!*" Stop it. She wrote a book and profited off of a fabricated criminal history about him to sell her book better. She INVENTED a criminal past that never existed! Explain that.
1
@dmitrywinter2781 I disagree. A liar getting high on their own narcissistic supply would be full of themselves enough to draw attention that could incriminate their lies. Look at Amber Heard.
1
@-redacted2554 I have doubts she was raped as well, and it most certainly is my right to believe whatever I want.
1
@CyanideSunshines You have a vested interest as a white woman to ensure that no white women are ever held to an equal standard as the rest of society.
1
Jo Pearson Which proves she was never a victim in the first place IMO
1
@CyanideSunshines As a sexual assault survivor, I'm not going to "give up" because you and your fellow Karens think surviving r4p3 is somehow glamorous enough to write a melodrama about to make millions while an innocent "muse" rots away in a prison cell. Kiss my Puerto Rican chocolate starfish, Gemma. SHE INVENTED HIS CRIMINAL HISTORY. SHE FABRICATED HIS LIFE STORY. TRAUMA SURVIVORS DON'T DO THAT.
1
@steffennielsen5942 LOL you're funny. You don't get to speak on behalf of all men. Heck, you're hardly one yourself
1
@lh68 Nah. He's less of one because he's himself. What do you care? That's his problem
1
@lh68 I don't care what you think of my logic, honey. You're nobody important.
1
@terrencemchatten4804 Yet she waited for 16 years to say anything? BS
1
@Frank L Screw Gemma and her pathetic, racist lying self, defending this horrible lying woman because she IS a horrible lying woman.
1
@Frank L I'm outraged because she dares to defend a woman who falsely accused an innocent man of rape. He spent 40 years on the sex offender registry because some racist Karen needed dramatics for her books to sell. How can anyone make excuses for this monster? If you're really a man, I truly hope you can see how scary it is. Just one woman has to cry and point a finger at you and your life is over. Especially if she's white. I'm unhinged because women who do this anger me. I've been lied to and believed people were evil just so some histrionic b%$$# can make her life into a soap opera.
1
@Frank L All Gemma has to offer is "Well, it's not her fault because she's a young impressionable victim and she shouldn't see any consequences because men generally abuse women all the time, *blah blah blah feminist buzzword blah blah blah*." I told her "Sit down, Karen" and she immediately tried to twist it that I'm "ableist" for telling her to sit down because"disabled people can't sit" or whatever. Yes, I'm angry. People who play victim games like that p*$$ me off to no end.
1
@Frank L The real victims of the world are victimized by manipulative pieces of refuse who try to use emotionalism to browbeat everyone into obedience.
1
@Frank L Amber Heard's another one. White Karen points her finger and cries and the innocent person she accused gets destroyed.
1
@Frank L Speaking up and calling them out for their BS.
1
@Frank L I literally have no idea what you're saying. People who lie have one weakness: The truth. Speaking the truth is the only way to combat liars. So I'm going to speak the truth. That's it.
1
@Frank L The real truth: Factual verified evidence, not the word of some entitled narcissistic Karen who wants attention or revenge. Factual, verifiable evidence.
1
You're trying to downplay how people of color are treated.
1
@pookiesis1465 It's true
1
@CyanideSunshines I don't believe she was r4ped. She glamorized the r4pe and murder of a girl in her books for the melodrama. She glamorizes victimhood in her twisted brain
1
@CyanideSunshines You're a piece of work, white lady. I survived sexual assault and child abuse, and even I can clearly see she lied about everything for ATTENTION AND DRAMA. Or do you want to pretend Munchausen syndrome doesn't exist? Sit down, Karen.
1
@CyanideSunshines She waited 16 years and only spoke up because the producer saw through her BS. Sit. Down.
1
@CyanideSunshines LOL You are just like her, that's the only reason why you want to defend her. USING progressivism to paint yourself a victim so you can malign anyone you want! Saying "sit down" is ableist is a tell of how you wish to abuse progressive ideals. SIT DOWN, KAREN. You're just mad that your demographic as an entitled white woman with the ability to cry crocodile tears and toss around false accusations is done. SIT DOWN, KAREN.
1
@CyanideSunshines SIT
1
@CyanideSunshines DOWN
1
@BBWahoo I don't believe it ever happened.
1
@CyanideSunshines You lived in a vacuum where anyone you as a white woman choose point a finger at goes to prison without evidence and you're just salty people are getting wise, Karen. Sit down.
1
Karens never take accountability
1
@adamarzo559 sorry dude. Meant to @ Gemma
1
@B-Killin That's why women like Gemma adore her. They like being able to emotionally manipulate everyone.
1
@CyanideSunshines You love having the the ability to play victim, point and malign others, don't you? And no one is ever allowed to question you because you are a white woman. Like every Karen who cries to cops because a person of color got your order wrong in the drive through. You defend Alice because you're just like her. Sit down, Karen.
1
@realthings5821 In another thread you tried to justify her fabrication of his "criminal history" and accused me of being jealous that I wasn't able to do what she did to get rich. You're disgusting.
1
She's not THAT sorry 😅
1
@samuelgates5935 Bravo!!
1
She enjoyed the attention far too much for me to believe she's a victim. Especially since she tried to make him look more evil by creating a fake criminal past for him in her fake story.
1
@realthings5821 Why is it insane to be upset that someone lied? You sound like a sociopath
1
@realthings5821 I don't give a rats behind what your impression is, she INVENTED A NONEXISTENT CRIMINAL HISTORY FOR DRAMATIC EFFECT BECAUSE IT SOLD HER BOOK BETTER. TRAUMA SURVIVORS DON'T DO THAT.
1
I survived sexual assault twice. Alice Sebold is some kind of psychopath who thinks being a victim is glamorous, and romanticizes the sexual assault and murder for teenybopper ghost stories, and fabricated a nonexistent criminal history for this innocent black man she decided to frame as a rapist
1
@realthings5821 Because she was lying about an innocent man to do so, Moot. SHE KNEW IT WASN'T HIM AND COLLECTED CHECKS MALIGNING HIS PAST ANYWAY
1
@realthings5821 Because she said so in this stupid "apology", where she claims she was originally trying to say it was someone else. There she was admitting she didn't think it was him. Her lies have holes in them. Amd she presented the story of "Lucky" as her own, so it was him she was speaking of.
1
@realthings5821 I don't believe the crime ever happened. I believe she glamorizes trauma for her books to sell and for attention. She lied so everyone would pat her head and tell her how brave she is on the way to the bank. She specifically knew no one would look into the details if the man she accused was black. And the only reason why any of this came out was because a producer wanted to cover their a55 and found out her lies.
1
@realthings5821 Women who suffer from Munchausen syndrome do lie about sexual assault and fabricate stories of how victimized they were for sympathy. I believe she is one of these women. Why else would she be trying to make so much money off of a supposed trauma, meanwhile inventing ways to make it more dramatic? She wanted money and attention.
1
@realthings5821 What kind of envy? What would I be jealous of exactly?
1
@realthings5821 I'm ANGRY. Angry that someone would do such a horrible thing to make money and get attention. Horrified that for 16 years someone else had to suffer merely because she knew they would assume he was guilty because he's a black man. And you have the audacity to say I'm just jealous of her riches? I don't rail against Stephanie Meyer or even E.L. James. They didn't ruin anyone's life. They earned their millions and more power to them. She DID.
1
@realthings5821 If I were just jealous, why wouldn't I be going hard on other rich folks? I'm angry at HER because she hurt someone. On purpose.
1
@cat_Connoisseur Bringing to light trauma?? SHE LIED ABOUT TRAUMA, YOU MOOT
1
@maccy3966 Just one?
1
@Leanne She deserves to go to prison. She's a liar. I believe she lied about the assault because she glamorized rape in her books.
1
@kurtj.9656 I live how women like Paula assume you're desperate to bed a woman and threatens "NO SEX FOR YOU!" for doubting her narrative.
1
@animelytical8354 BS. She picked him out of the street and sat on it for 40 years
1
@Leanne Leanne you say you feel bad but try to water down the severity of what she did. That makes no sense
1
@Leanne I don't have to change your mind. It's just the truth.
1
@realthings5821 You're all over this video telling lies. And I'm all over it calling you out.
1
@realthings5821 Then I'll gladly continue. Better to be thought of as a fool for speaking the truth than to be a disgusting person like you who defends dishonesty with false narratives.
1