Comments by "Chompy the Beast" (@chompythebeast) on "Growing a Planned Economy: The Logic of Early Soviet Development" video.

  1. Love the emphasis on concrete, material figures. Seems like it bores or confounds the typical low-grade chuds as well, for the comment section here is quite academic. Definite sub, looking forward to going through your work here!
    5
  2.  @Xylos101  You're neither willing nor does it seem you are capable of having an intelligent conversation about this subject. It is astounding how those who refuse to do reading think they're cleverer by repeating lies from their masters
    3
  3. The fact that this is your response to a video about graphs proves that it is you who is ideologically tidal locked. This is nothing but baseless Red Scare scree and even you should realize that
    2
  4. 1) That is not rhe discussion here, and there are plenty of vids and texts rhat address the misconceptions and dalse digures you are repeating. You are not trting to have a conversation by hijacking the topic with ignorant claims when you could be having it in qny number of comment secrions on this site alone. Which leads to 2) That is a joke figure. Even the 100 million number is a joke, and you just threw on an uncited extra 50%. Please cite your figures for such an absurdly astronomical claim And while you're at it, why don't you take a look at how many are killed by preventable ailments such as diarrhea and starvation every year due to deliberately unequal exchange, let alone the costs of human life in settler-colonial capital enterprises, and let alone those slain by imperialist efforts. Those inflated figures against communists from the Black Book literally count German soldiers invading the USSR for God's sake Check out Hakim's vid about Socialism's Death Toll. Nobody "forgot" about these things, and it's frankly ridiculous that you'd even think that you had thought of something that just so happened to be the imperialist anti-communist line that somehow none of us had ever heard of. If you want to have an informed conversation, let's have it, but it requires information. If you just want repeat the same old anti-communist imperialist lines that have been responded to and debunked time and again, then you are not as informed or as early to the party as you think you are, and that would be mouthing but a waste of everyone's time
    1
  5. "You own nothing, not even your underwear." OK in literally no way is this true. How could you possibly even think this. You simply don't know what Socialism is, let alone the scientific definition of Private Property (it is not the same as "personal property" like your toothbrush, comrade)
    1