Comments by "Black Cat Dungeon Master\x27s Familiar" (@blackcatdungeonmastersfami5311) on "Donbas Positions Continue Falling - What Is The Goal u0026 Reality In Kursk? Ukraine Map u0026 News Update" video.

@grahamhireme9283 Great footage but that BBC series was full of errors, some of them were excusable back then but some were blatantly wrong even then.
3
@e-machine-ol1987 That seems to be the Halder version of what happens. The TIK channel analyses the whole Stalingrad battle over maybe fifty hours of video. Blaming AH doesn't seem to stand up.
2
@e-machine-ol1987 In general the German generals who survived liked to blame AH for all kinds of stuff including the Stalingrad debacle and Halder was especially notorious for this. Obviously AH made mistakes too, it's just a warning to be sceptical of the AH is to blame narrative. TIK really did an amazing job with the Stalingrad series. But it's not a casual watch.
1
@iivanforchune9666 Yeah the World at War series interviews were excellent. A lot of excellent historiography has come out over the past 25 years it's not all rubbish. This is normal, Our understanding of even the First World war is much better now than it was 25 years ago. There are all kinds of myths about both wars which have been demolished.
1