Comments by "Qing Zhou" (@qingzhou9983) on "Ian Bremmer: US u0026 China's Changing Status Quo on Taiwan | Quick Take | GZERO Media" video.

You have right to your view. But you can't change the Fact. There is a reason your "country" name is Republic of CHINA and it is not in UN. Like in any Civil War, one side could not decide the outcome Alone, None in the long history of Human. You better understand that, otherwise you will cause a disaster for both Taiwan and Mainland.
5
@Courage2006 First, the US didn't split China. Second, Taiwan has never been part of the People's Republic of China. => You are so ignorant of the history and current event. Without the US 7th fleet in Taiwan Strait 1950, Taiwan was already part of PRC. And PRC vs ROC are still in a unfinished Civil War.
3
He is already one of the most rational and reasonable voice on US side. War will not break out for Taiwan this year or early next year, but China is clearly preparing for it since all sides agree that the peaceful unification is dead. The best possible outcome is Taiwan gives up under PRC's overwhelming Military Pressure. The worse is a war between US and China.
3
@KashiARTW You miss the point. Taiwan's ROC and its Constitution (please read it) are proof that It is part of China, not an independent country. This is different from even Korea and German situations (they were created by occupying force)
2
@Courage2006 @Zack Wang That's like saying that Australia, Canada, and India are part of the British Empire. Or that Ireland is part of the UK. Or that California is part of Mexico. Or that Pakistan is part of India. => This is so funny. Do you know PRC and ROC are still in an unfinished Civil War? Please learn some history before you make your comment.
1
@Courage2006 You are so funny. You did not rebuttal my point at all and then claimed I was wrong. Before 7th Fleet came in at 1950, everyone knew CCP could defeat KMT again and retake Taiwan. Please address this Point. It was a Civil War then and still a Civil War now. Please address this point. These two facts make your argument Taiwan was never Part of PRC useless. Do you see that! By the way, when you claimed China Pays me to lie, please show your evidence. Otherwise you are Lying. I claimed you do not know history and I proved it by showing you the Key Historical Facts that you do not know. This is the difference between You and Me.
1
@Courage2006 Also exactly because the West humiliated China for the past almost 200 years including 1950 7th Fleet and 1996 again, the Chinese People are determined to defend its Honor in recovering Taiwan (lost to Japan first and then to US 7th Fleet). You under-estimate their resolve at your own peril.
1
@Courage2006 Show me an international law that forbids PRC to finish its civil war? You have no right to force Mainland Chinese to give up their rights for their country. And show me another decode old unfinished Civil War you claimed existed (Korea and German do not count since they were created by occupying force, not civil wars). Please don't just assert something without an existing example.
1
@Courage2006 You have to prove PRC is more like Nazi or Imperial Japan than PRC itself in Korean War and Vietnam War. I think the Taiwan situation is more like US Civil War and PRC will fight to the End. Just be aware, it will be worse for US if it involves than in Korean War since PRC is much more advanced now.
1
@Courage2006 1) A civil war is a civil war whether it was thousand years ago, hundred years ago or now. As long as one side does not give up the military option, it will be decided on battle ground. 2) You really need to learn the fact that in US military's own war game about Taiwan in past decade, US lost every time and got worse each year. 3) The only wars US lost on battle ground is Korean War. US better be careful not to repeat that experience, especially since PRC is much stronger now than in 1950.
1
@Courage2006 The US military disagrees with you. They lost in war game to China ten years ago and it got worse every year. I am pretty sure they know the US vs China military capability around Taiwan Straits much better than you. Since this is a war in China, there is no way US military could win it since they could not control the Mainland itself where the fighter jets and missiles based. The only question is whether China is willing to risk the economic sanction. Judging from CCP's history and similar situations for Russia, Iran etc, economic sanction would not stop PRC to unify China. For Korean War PRC drove US army from Chinese border to 38th line. This is a military defeat by Chinese Troop by any definition. You better learn the real history. By the way, I am still waiting for you to cite the international law you claimed that prevents PRC to finishes its Civil War.
1
@PavelZaitsev @Qing Zhou genocidal commie discourse => useless assertion. Please backup with facts and logic!
1
@PavelZaitsev @Zack Wang nah China is part of Taiwan. You got it wrong way CCP roaches don’t like people to know => Funny, when Taiwan considered Mainland part of ROC (President Ma's 8 years) there was Peaceful across Taiwan straits. I am sure you don't understand Why. So Please make sure the Current Taiwan Leadership agrees with Your Opinion.
1
@KashiARTW Dreaming is your right.
1
@PavelZaitsev Chinese haven’t gone democratic and now threatens its peoples and world with harm and genocide , it will fall in line => Then, please tell the hysterical US ruling elites to calm down on Chinese Threat, because it will fail soon right? I have heard this Fall of CCP for decades now.
1
@KashiARTW @Qing Zhou I'm Taiwanese. Taiwan Constitution (ROC Constitution) never refers any territory in detail. Taiwan is even more different from the two Koreas and the two Germanys, because Taiwan doesn't consider ourselves as Chinese. The vast majority of people in Taiwan think that we are NOT Chinese. => 1) Don't let other people laughs at you. Either you are saying ROC Constitution covers no territory (and this is really bad for ROC) or you need define what Territory it covers. One thing I am very sure is that It does not state Taiwan is an independent Country since when that Constitution was written Taiwan was not or ever was an independent Country. In any case, you have a problem to claim Taiwan Independent based on ROC's Constitution. 2) I have no problem with people on Taiwan do not consider themselves to be Chinese. That is their rights. However, the Chinese in China also have the right to claim Taiwan. That is their rights. This is an unfinished Civil War. That is simple a Fact. Like most Civil Wars it is likely to be decided on battle ground. I just sincerely hope that People in Taiwan takes this unusual opportunity to peacefully unite with Mainland. Otherwise it will be a war and a disaster for Taiwan, to a less extend a disaster for Mainland.
1
@KashiARTW Useless assertion without any evidence. No need to rebuttal you. Keep your dream of PRC's splitting. That is your right.
1