Comments by "Sim Ko" (@simko8665) on "Palestinians: If Israel left the West Bank and Gaza, would there be peace with Israel?" video.

@AbuBakr.Abdullah Leaving the Gaza strip in 2005 was a test case to see what will come out if Israel will live the West Bank. Now everyone can see it.
3
Because the older, which were almost gone by now, knew the truth.
3
@hmdbxl6737 In Europe the Jews were told to leave to Palestine.
3
Eti Bronx Don't tell me, tell it to the Muslims. They have an argue which says that the Zionists in Israel are not the real Jews.
3
@1979osmocote can you show me where it is written, please?
3
@atn362 1909
2
@AbuBakr.Abdullah .No, the good news are for the poor citizens there who are suffering of Hammas. They will go back to the times when tens of thousands of them worked in Israel and made a good living .
2
@AbuBakr.Abdullah They already done it in the 70th. There were about 12 of them . Prime Minister Sharon decided to evacuate them 15 years ago in order to get a peace settlement with the P.L.O. but instead the citizens of Israel is getting Rockets almost every day. That only shows what kind of peace Israel will get when they'll evacuate the settlements from the West bank.
2
They wouldn't know what to do with it.
2
@wolfgangjannsen That's right. Maybe the Muslims do not believe in their Allah? If not, why do they resist his will which was creating the state of Israel.
2
@max998-m3g Do you believe Jesus or Issa being Jewish and lived in that region? If positive, this is the connection of the Israelis to this region.
2
@dsk71 Well, you got your answer.
2
Why to show your ignorance in public? These are not the facts. It like saying that after WW2 about 1,000 ships from Europe landed at the shores of the so called Balestine and about 1,000,000 Jews came out of it, well equipped with tanks, canons and air plans and took over that land in no time. History is telling a completely another story. I suggest you to study that history and then you'll see that you shouldn't write the nonsense that you wrote.
2
and why didn't they say one word when Jordan took over the West Bank for 19 years? Nobody talked then about establishing a Palestinian country in that region. Further more. The PLO was established in 1964 not against Jordan but against Israel in the borders before 1967. What does it say?
2
I do not know. Can you tell us please? I saw some body who wrote that Israel killed till now Millions of them.
1
@m.s.6487 Ask Palestinians and they will say Millions. Ask Israelis and they will tell you few hundreds and also hundreds of Israeli citizens.
1
@m.s.6487 Never heard about 300 children dead. Terrorists yes, so many children no. Israel is always avoiding of innocents .
1
@m.s.6487 If there were funerals of 300 babies you could had also say it. All T.V. stations were busy only with that issue for a long time . Can you recall such events? I'm sure you cannot. Ho, sorry, my mistake, Amnesty said it.
1
@m.s.6487 Because the world is fed by the media and Journalism. Instead of inquiring the truth it's much easier to quote people with an interest. I know that Israeli pilots on their way to bomb Hamas targets were told to abort their mission and to return back home. And why? Because the pilots saw some civilians who were standing near it. Did you ever heard the words "knock on the roof"? If you did not, look for it in Google and you'll understand better what I'm trying to explain to you.
1
@wikalein This is your best respond?
1
@amrelemary338 I'm watching T.V. every day and I didn't saw the mess of hundreds of funerals. No babies, no nurses, and no Journalists. If it was, all T.V.'s around the world would have shown it. Newspapers would put it in the front page. Did you? When was it? Places, dates and names if you can please.
1
@amrelemary338 All the media around the world is keeping quite? All newspapers? You are the only one who know about it? Are you insane?
1
@amrelemary338 Bottom line: fake news. I do not claim that it didn't took place here and there but not on purpose and only very few cases. It's war after all.
1
@amrelemary338 So you are saying that there were 15,000 funerals and nobody payed attention to it? Not even El Jazeera? Other anti Israeli broadcasting companies and newspapers over the world? Think again and ask yourself if it makes sense. 15,000 funerals and nobody was talking about it?
1
@amrelemary338 Nice work Israel. Bombing people and managing to wound 15,000 of them with no one killed.
1
@amrelemary338 Nice work Israel. 15,000 wounded with no one killed. Does it make sense to you? I didn't get your video unless you are talking about the 50 minutes debate. If it is another one, please send it to me.
1
@Ayaan Aali Which means that you do not wants peace at all. All you have are excuses. Before the Israeli occupation in 1967 you had the all West Bank just for yourself. why didn't you ask king Hussein for freedom? Why are you demanding it from Israel? Well, everyone knows exactly why. You do not want only the occupied territories you want a state called Palestine from the Jordan river to the sea with no Israelis there. It won't happen and you'll remain in your measery.
1
@annelid4728 You are very mistaken. Jews lived in that region through all the centuries. In Jerusalem, Hebron, Sefad, Tiberias, Gaza and other smaller places. For instance, according the Ottomans, at the end of the 19th century, most of tens of thousands citizens of Jerusalem, 50% were Jews. 50% of the so called Palestinians arrive in that region during the 19th century. Now they claim living there for ages. If you really have an interest in the history of that region, I suggest you to read a good history book of the last 200 years of it.
1
@yxndn6914 chiko chikoku, is it you??
1
Nobody asked France to consider it.
1
Were do they live now?
1
Maybe in two generations.
1
@chikochikoku5900 Get yourself a good history book of that region for the last 200 years and you'll understand that it is not black and white as you think it is. After you read it you'll have the right to express your opinion in public, not before that.
1
@chikochikoku5900 Fine. What issue would you like to discuss? Where did most of the Palestine arrive from? Since when did Jewish citizens live at this region? Christians? Cherkesians? Bosnians? Druze? Egyptians? Syrians? How many Jews lived then in Jerusalem and how many Muslims and Christians? Jewish first settlements (I live in what was a settlement established 1878)? Other issues for your choice? Were do you live? Please.
1
@chikochikoku5900 I forget to ask you what happen in 1882? And how do you know that I'm a man, not a woman?
1
@chikochikoku5900 Sorry, I do not know why. I'll write to you again but only on Sunday. I'm an Orthodox Jew and as one we do not use Electric device from today evening till tomorrow evening and I have to do now some preparations for it. As for 1882. I'll tell you also about it, but one comment: There were earlier settlements before it. My town was established at 1878 and also one more. The founders were seven Jews from Jerusalem. Now it is a town of 270,000. Please let me know if you got this one properly. You do not have to tell me where you live if you do not want to do it. I wish you Shabbat Shalom.
1
@chikochikoku5900 Can you read some of it? I wrote to you two answers.
1
@chikochikoku5900 I don't know what is going on. After sending you my two answers today I checked and it was here properly. Telling me that you didn't see it just as it was last week, make me think that somebody erased it deliberately. Now I don't know how to send it to you. Any suggestions?
1
@chikochikoku5900 E-mail is fine, but do you want it to be public? It won't be safe and too risky. What do you say? Shall we let it go? That would be a shame.
1
@chikochikoku5900 I'll try to do it by small portions. please let me know if you got it. My answer to No. 1- if Jews has the right on Palestine after Jews were wiped away by the romans. Well, Yes, they do. Generally, this is the way of history. Lands were taken by wars all over history. After the Romans there were Byzants, Arabs, Selejuks, Mamelukes, Crusaders, Mongols, Ottomans, British and now Israel. All the above-mentioned conquerors had no connection to this land and no one remained there since. Only the Jews did during all the ages, till today. This land was given to Israel by God. Even the Quran says it and you cannot deny it unless you do not believe in Muhammed and the Quran. The Persian ruled in Judea after defeating Babylon and taking their lands include Israel. They were kind to the Jews by letting them return to Judea and re-built the Temple and Jerusalem. There were three revolts against the Romans. The Main one was at 66 A.D. and Jerusalem and the Temple were ruined. At 161 year revolt, Bar Kokhba put the final nail in the Coffin of Jewish hopes for freedom. Caesar Hadrian got tired of the Jews and decided to erase the name of Judea from the Google Map and called it Palestina. This name derived from the Plishtim who arrived from Crete in the ancient times till king David kicked them out in about 1000 B.C. After that the Jews and the Jewish center with their leaders moved to the upper Galilee area and to Tiberias since Hadrian didn't allow them to return to Jerusalem. You can find today many ruins of ancient big and gorgeous Synagogues in Judea, Galillee, The Golan Heights and even in Gaza. They were in use till the 7 Century when the Arab invaders arrived, and all of it were ruined by them. Many Arab cities and villages names are still called today with their original Jewish names.
1
@chikochikoku5900 Continuing with my previous answer: My answer to question No. 2 – after the Arabs took over that region there were just Muslims and Christians and no Jews. You are wrong. Jews lived in that land Continuously all these years since 1250 B.C. The Muslims rulerד and Christians rulers forced them in certain times to convert and to pay high taxes. They had hard times. There were ups and downs of their population but they managed to exist till today in that land. The Arabs have no advantage over the Jews at that point. Yes, In the 19th century Arabs were the Majority in that region but Jews were the majority in Jerusalem, according to Ottoman sources. You'll find more in my next answer to your question No.3., if you let me know receiving this second answer.
1
I rather destroy another's house rather him destroy mine.
1
Tell it to the Muslims. The Jews know it already.
1