Comments by "" (@davidulanovsky8943) on "Monsieur Z" channel.

  1. A is O now I may be wrong, but I’m pretty sure the commune was before any of that. Anarchists have never had much sway over those organisations either.
    2
  2. A is O yeah, I just don’t think the revolutions in the 20s or after ww2 would have been as popular without vanguard socialism.
    2
  3. Green man the Finns didn’t win
    2
  4. A is O no revolutions
    1
  5. A is O only lenin inspired the masses. Anarchism has always been too radical.
    1
  6. A is O the Paris commune would have always failed. It sprang up before Marx could publish his books setting the standard for an international revolution. The best that could have happened was a socialist France for a few years.
    1
  7. A is O because he and lenin established the theory of international revolution and a huge successful revolution respectively. The commune was formed before Marx wrote his books.
    1
  8. A is O if you mean the international Workers Association that was formed in 1922. If you mean the international Workingmen’s Association that was still only founded in 1864 just a few years before the commune.
    1
  9. Eliot Brookes anarchism?
    1
  10. A is O the countries you mentioned were hardly anarchist, they just were more libertarian.
    1
  11. A is O but the socialists in Spain and Mexico were still Leninist and even more so in America.
    1
  12. A is O the IWW and CNT are still Leninist. The zapistas are more communalist and nativist than outright anarchist.
    1
  13. A is O Catalonian and Spanish groups were all supported by stalin.
    1
  14. A is O stalin sent aid to all left front groups.
    1
  15. A is O don’t know about Trotskyists (of which I am one) were supported but the CNT received aid.
    1
  16. A is O yeah, sure and I like a lot of your views, but I just don’t know if it could have been a world revolution, something that is quite possibly with more of a state.
    1
  17. A is O excluding social democrats, centrists and capitalist apologists.
    1