Comments by "Phil Dobson" (@phildobson8705) on "Padmaavat: Why this Bollywood film is so controversial - BBC News" video.

  1. I wonder what would happen if Pakistan made a film about Muhammad falling in love with Aisha age 6 arranging to marry her age 9? Her father Abu Bakr consequently became1st Caliph & leader of Sunni Muslims? Film ends with consequences of 1400 yr split in Islam because Shiite Muslims believed Muhammad's grandson should have been 1st Caliph?
    39
  2. Arzzier Pakistan came from India in 1948, that's why that's relevant.
    6
  3. Kyle Reed Area called Pakistan was India at the time movie is set in. Muslim stole land from Indians
    4
  4. Ali Khan Your mathematics is not fit for the world anymore than your religion. Sunni Muslims have been at war with Shiite Muslims for 1400 years & claim Ahmadiyya Muslims are not Muslims yet add them all up together and claim your all on the same side lol
    3
  5. Blue Pearl which of his wives was 18? His cousin Zainab? Aisha herself said she was 6 when Muhammad made arrangements with her father Abu Bakr and 9 when married. Which wife are you Trolling about?
    2
  6. Maham hafeez 202 Why don't you do the intelligent thing and learn about Hinduism just as we take the trouble to learn about your religion? Look it up in Wikipedia
    2
  7. Ali Khan It's South Asianized Arab religion Islam that's not fit for World, NOT "World not fit for Islam." Sane people start learning truth: Photosynthesis how plants use energy from sun, transfer energy to food, start there.
    1
  8. Maham hafeez 202 Hadith's state Aisha married Muhammad at age six, but stayed in her parents' home until age nine, according to Ibn Hisham, when the marriage was consummated with Muhammad, then 53, in Medina. Wikipedia
    1
  9. Anonymous 1514 wow that is heavy stuff the way that poor woman died horrific. I see why Iran and Saudi Arabia are such enemies with what looks like an iresolvable difference in their account of the past. But in Iran a woman recently disappeared after taking off her headscarf? It seems both do horrific things to woman so this common denominator could be the source of the solution. The men have both side should bow down in shame for what they've done to women and educate themselves about how life on Earth actually works starting from phytoplankton photosynthesising at the beginning of the food chain and eventually caring for their women properly as equals If the religion doesn't allow it, it's their man made religion that's wrong
    1