Comments by "Phil Dobson" (@phildobson8705) on "'IS tried to recruit me for London attacks’ - BBC News" video.

  1. Amar Abidali Muhammad's previously married wife was his own daughter in law, she was also his cousin, so his son had been married to his aunt before his father married her. The girl promised to Muhammad at 6 years old and married at 9 years old was Asia
    1
  2. Amar Abidali Aisha Muhammad agreed terms with Abu Bakr for his 6 year old child who he married age 9. Abu Bakr became the first caliph immediately Muhammad died and his flowers are called Sunni Muslims.
    1
  3. Amar Abidali How do you make this stuff up? Aisha father Abu Bakr became 1st Caliph by agreeing her marriage to Muhammad when she was age 6 and the marriage was completed age 9. This caused the split in Islam because Shia Muslims rejected Abu Bakr, quite rightly under the circumstances
    1
  4. Amar Abidali you're obviously a Shia Muslim. You must know Sunni Muslims originated as followers of Abu Bakr and the split in Islam that began immediately after Muhammad's death because of it?
    1
  5. Amar Sunni Muslims would disagree about Muhammad's successor. "A group of Muslims followed Abu Bakr" (father of Muhammads 9-year-old wife Aisha) was 75% of Muslims, Sunni Muslims, ancestors of ones you want to ban in Saudi Arabia! Shia Muslins descended from Early agricultural communities such as Chogha Golan in Iran 12,000 years ago. At sites dating back 100,000 years, stone tools made by Neandertals have also been found.
    1
  6. Amar Abidali where is your link to your claim that Muhammad child bride, daughter of first caliph Abu Bakr, had a sister who claimed she was 17? Who, according to you, claimed such a sister made such a claim? Why would she, 1400 years ago what difference would it make? Are you telling us it's like when an older girl gets her younger sister into a nightclub by saying she is older than she is?
    1
  7. Amar Abidali that is an extremely long twisty was to calculate age 17. Aisha was 18 when Muhammad died, after she had been married for 9 years SUNAN NASA‘I … When Hadrat Aisha passed nine years of marriage life, the Holy Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) fell in mortal sickness… ‘A’isha was eighteen years of age at the time when the Holy Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) passed away and she remained a widow for forty-eight years till she died at the age of sixty-seven. She saw the rules of four Caliphs in her lifetime. She died on Ramadan 58 A.H. during the Caliphate of Hadrat Amir Mu‘awiya… (Sunan Nasa'i: English translation with Arabic Text, compiled by Imam Abu Abd-ur-Rahman Ahmad Nasa'i, rendered into English by Muhammad Iqbal Siddiqui [Kazi Publication, 121-Zulqarnain Chambers, Gampat Road, Lahore, Pakistan; first edition, 1994], Volume 1, p. 108) SUNAN IBN-I-MAJAH 1876. ‘A’isha (Allah be pleased with her) is reported to have said: Allah’s Messenger (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) contracted marriage with me while I was (yet) a six years [sic] old girl. Then we arrived at Medina and stayed with Banu Harith b. Khazraj. I fell victim to fever; then my hair (of the head fell off (and became scattered). Then they became plenty and hanged down upto [sic] the earlobes. My mother ‘Umm Ruman came to me while I was (playing) in a swing alongwith [sic] my play-mates. She (the mother) called me loudly. I went to her and I did not know what he [sic] wanted. She seized my hand and stopped me at the door of the house and I was hearing [sic] violently until the agitation of my heart was over. Then she took some water and wiped it over my face and head. Then she admitted me to the house when some woman [sic] of Ansar were present in the house. They said, "You have entered with blessings and good fortune." Then she (the mother) entrusted me to them. So they embellished me and nothing frightened me but Allah’s Messenger (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) (when he came there) in the morning and they (the women) entrusted me to him. On that day, I was a nine years [sic] old girl." 1877. Abdullah (Allah be pleased with him) is reported to have said, "The Holy Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) married ‘A’isha while she was a seven years [sic] old girl and took him [sic] to his house as a bride when she was nine years old and he parted with her (after his demise) when she was eighteen years old." According to Al-Zawa‘id its isnad is sahih in accordance with the condition prescribed by Bukhari, but munqatabecause Abu ‘Ubaida did not hear from his father. Shu‘ba Abu Hatim and Ibn Hibban mentioned him amongst the authentic and reliable authorities. Tirmidhi in al-Jami’ and al-Mazzi in al-Atraf (has expressed the same opinion). Nasa‘i has transmitted this hadith in al-Sughra from the hadith ‘A’isha (Allah be pleased with her). (Sunan Ibn-I-Majah, Imam Abdullah Muhammad B. Yazid Ibn-I-Maja Al-Qazwini, English version by Muhammad Tufail Ansari [Kazi Publications, 121-Zulqarnain Chambers, Gampat Road, Lahore Pakistan, first edition, 1995], volume III, pp. 133-134)
    1
  8. Amar Abidali with so many Direct accounts of Asia being age 6 and married at 9 including from herself I'm not at all convinced by your laborious mathematics. What is your motive for disagreeing with Aisha's own account of her age?
    1
  9. Amar Abidali The majority of hadith sources state that Aisha was married to Muhammad at the age of six or seven, but she stayed in her parent's home until the age of nine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aisha
    1
  10. Amar Abidali She must have been quite exceptional, writing so much in those days! Surely written 1400 years ago makes her hadith's unalterable Word of God?
    1