Comments by "Withnail1969" (@Withnail1969) on "laowhy86" channel.

@CornG4397 Taiwan is part of China. That will be clearly demonstrated in, say, 10 years or so.
4
@Country Of Taiwan! Taiwan is a province of China.
3
@pygmalioninvenus6057 I'm a CCP operative and we don't control youtube yet. there's a lot of anti China content here.
2
Taiwan is a province of China.
2
More anti China propaganda. I'm using Chinese made and designed products here in the UK and the quality is excellent.
2
Millions of people are employed in a full time job posting comments on behalf of the Chinese government? Any evidence for this claim?
1
allowing what? nobody is stopping this guy making videos on youtube. he claims people are mass reporting his videos, but provides no proof for his claims.
1
@BBarNavi China is number one and there is only one China.
1
@DonSolaris Of course it's bullshit.
1
@bobs_toys of course Taiwan is de facto independent. nobody disputes that.
1
@bobs_toys widespread recognition, perhaps a UN General Assembly Resolution.
1
@bobs_toys not sure where you get your information but it's all about recognition, preferably by the UN. I couldn't see any other viable path for Taiwan.
1
@bobs_toys the UN is the recognised authority these days.
1
@bobs_toys it was all about the UN and the UN Security Council when I studied international law. there isn't really any such thing as international legislation.
1
@bobs_toys the UN Charter is considered important. States sign up to that when they join. there is no international 'legislation' and never has been, states were and are sovereign.
1
@bobs_toys countries are generally considered countries through the mechanism of recognition both by states and by the UN, i thought i'd clarified that.
1
@bobs_toys there really are no hard and fast definitions or legislation. it's not even clear that international law really exists.
1
@bobs_toys ultimately the rules mean nothing. they can always be bent and usually are. using Crimea as an example, there was nothing particularly illegal about Crimea joining Russia, but the fact that most states refuse to recognise it as valid means the consensus is it was illegitimate and Crimea did not become part of Russia.
1
@bobs_toys Taiwan is a province of China. If China wanted to take it back by force, it could do so. But China is a nation of peace and would not do this. China is now the world's largest economy and is making huge progress in all fields. these are just facts.
1
@bobs_toys its historically a province of China, this isnt disputed by anyone. and i believe, one way or another, it will be again.
1
@bobs_toys recognition and history.
1
@bobs_toys ive given you the answers to your question.
1
@bobs_toys there are no laws. but the custom is that recognition or non recognition is what decides the matter.
1
@bobs_toys there are no laws, what dont you understand about that part?
1
@bobs_toys there are laws in society but there are no laws that apply to states because states are sovereign. the closest thing we have to anything like laws that govern states is the UN and the UN Charter. as to Taiwan, whether you like it or not, it is part of China, just like Hong Kong.
1
@bobs_toys only states can be members of the UN. a territory that has been denied UN membership is not a state.
1
@bobs_toys dude its axiomatic that only states can be in the UN. you should probably stay out of topics you dont know anything about until you've researched them.
1
@bobs_toys i didnt say you had to be in the UN to be a state but if you have applied to join the UN as a state and been rejected, you're not a state.
1
@bobs_toys The source is me, I'm an expert.
1
stay out of Chinese affairs.
1
Good riddance. Unfortunately not banned from youtube yet.
1