Comments by "" (@sharonefee1426) on "PragerU" channel.

  1. He was far evil
    15
  2. I admit I even learned a few things. Thank you for this video.
    12
  3.  @raymack8767  Even if you gave them 75 percent, it wouldn't be enough. The so called Palestines want 100 percent of the land
    5
  4. It's too cold there.
    5
  5. The real middle eastern problem is that everyone care about this as if all other counties live peavefully. Nothing in Syroa, Lebanon, Iran and Iran.
    4
  6. Cause there are so many of them? XD
    4
  7. My question for you: Were you Canda's prime minister? (Sorry, I have a damn idea about the leaders of Canada XD or many countries...) Now for real... The thing is lies are told over and over and people believe them. And some of the media prefer to show only a certain side of the conflict. Yeah, I can also say "A child and woman were killed white Gaza was attacked" without mentioning that they were killed because a missile which sent from Gaza (as they fire from their home, and something went wrong).
    4
  8. SO USA is fine because people didn't reazlie colonilism was bad and Israel is not because it happened later? And when the British came to USA or Austerlia or whatever there were zero British. Jews always continues to live there.
    3
  9. Good luck XD
    3
  10. There's a book called "palestina ex monumentis veteribus illustrata" (palestine illustrated from ancient monuments) by Adriaan Reland who described the Palestine at the very end of the 17th centrury (or maybe some of the beginning). It says there are hardly any people at all there, but the vast majority are Jews. Some are Christians. Some very rare occasions of muslims, mainly Bedouin (who are not Palestinian). So where where did the Arabs come from, and how did they become the majority? At a certain point, Jews from Europe started to come to Palestine. As a response, Arabs came and were brought by the Ottomans to Palestine. They were in the land less than 150 years.
    3
  11. You should. There are some nice views here. And beached full of sand. And people, but oh well.
    3
  12. Shouldn't it be the opposite?
    3
  13. I'm not sure what wasn't allowed in South Africa, but let's say it this way: The Arabs has full rights as Jews.
    2
  14. A weird organization indeed. And since when traditional family is wrong?
    2
  15. There are ethnic countries who want to preserve a certain ethnic group. Look at the 2nd generation of Muslim immigrants. They don't feel like living there as it is, and states want to preservw rheir culture rather than changing in 180 degrees (and yeah, not all Muslims)
    2
  16. Easy: Palestinians. He was a close friend with the Mufti, the leaders of the Arabs who lived in Palestine back then. Not hardgo guess.
    2
  17. rockets are sent from Gaza, not the other way around.
    2
  18. They were always there. Not million of them, but they had their cities. After WW2, many people decided to go to Israel because... they didn't' feel safe at the place they once called home.
    2
  19. It's not just a historical presence. There were always Jews there. Much before the British and the Otman. For example. Jesus was a jew and lived 2000 years ago. But since then (and before) there were Jews there. Yes, they were conquered million times in between, but there was always a Jewish population. That's the reason the British state they called Palestine was divided in to two: Israel and Arab country. Arabs never excepted to for Israel to be a country, a war begun... and from there it's not much different from any other war. You talked about the Indians? They were conquered too. Does the world say a word about it? No.
    2
  20. It didn't' start as one-sided one war. You think it's the first time two countries fought and one conquered lands from the others? And at 1948, they were equal. No occupation and not anything
    2
  21. s the torpedo boats approached, Liberty opened fire on them. McGonagle said that he felt sure the torpedo boat captains believed they were under fire from the Liberty. Ensign Lucas, testified that he gave permission for the firing of the 03 level machine gun after the torpedo boats began firing at Liberty. Later, when the gun was unmanned, heat from a nearby fire apparently caused machine gun rounds at the gun to explode. (Wikipedia) So... a ship came nearer, didn't attack... and... Bang a shot. So... whose fault is this?
    2
  22. That's just absurd! I mean, okay, voter fraud isn't new... but this tactics are... well... sophisticated... But if there were more voters than should be... why no one does anything?! Because in this case, it is an obvious cheating.
    2
  23.  @markaxworthy2508 I think you missed the part where the video said that it was decided that the Jews should accept the land as they are the natives, but still, they split it.
    2
  24. And if it was the other way around, it wouldn't be a daylight robbery? They got a nation from the UN, one was happy one wasn't. So the not happy side attacked. And now they cry.
    2
  25.  @markaxworthy2508  If a terror rrgime counts for you respobsible...
    2
  26. Maybe it's an older map?
    1
  27. Jews lived there too. That's why it was decided to slip the land. But one side didn't feel like sharing.
    1
  28. I guess he means they went to make it in a legal way rather than conquering everything and zip.
    1
  29.  @TheRachaelLefler  There is a difference between critique and saying a country shouldn't exist no matter what. And that's what many say... or want to say.
    1
  30. There many biased videos siding the Palestines.
    1
  31. On 2005, parts of the Gaza stripped were Jews lived, were "cleaned" of those places and they moved somewhere else. You know what happened then? Hamas, who controls the Gaza strip, ruined everything instead of using the fields for their own good they destroyed everything! So... now ask yourself: whose fault is that they're in their little prison?
    1
  32. Israel doesn't control in Gaze. It's Hamas, organization of terrorist, who controls it. Want to blame someone for their poor state? To that they're so-called "protectors" who get money and don't' even bother to build the houses that were ruined (as this very organization sent missiles on poor citizens, and it already went out of control. A woman and her baby were killed at this time? You know why? Oops, they sent those missiles' from people home!
    1
  33. Many many conquers in between...
    1
  34. And what doesi t have to do with anything...?
    1
  35. Because they conquered this land...
    1
  36. It was just crying after losing
    1
  37. Though it's counted as occupied territory, they can do inside of it more or less what they want.
    1
  38.  @andrew480miller  You mean a lot of Jews were banished, the same those people who now call themselves Palestine were one banished from their home by the Otman empire.
    1
  39. There were some occasions when Israel did try... but... You need two for tango.
    1
  40. You compare between a country its all agenda was to rule the world with a country of people who just want to live in their own land? Great analogy...
    1
  41. One side attacked the other and lost And they still cry.
    1
  42.  @Jennianner  Prussia and Germany are the same country, but with different names. Did the borders change since? Yeah. Did the kind of regime changed? Yeah. But it's the same country, though it lost some of its territory. But Prussia was an empire, it conquered lands of other countries. One of them is Poland. The same way Austro Hungarian didn't stay as big. By the way, Turkey is the "successor" of the Ottoman Empire. You can't say the Ottoman Empire is gone, it just shrinked. The same with the Greek, the Romans and so many others in history (though the name sometimes remained)
    1
  43.  @phukyew14  I thought traditional families refered a family with both mom and dad
    1
  44. Lasha Chakhunashvili The British called this peace of land Pakestine. Just because they felt like it
    1
  45. The Arabs never really lived under a country as we know of today. I don't think they would mind making it all one big country. If the people of the West Bank and Gaza behaved , they wouldn't be in that position, But they really like their terror. They had their chance to be a part of Jordan. They ruined it with their own hands! (as a nation, unrelated to piece of land).
    1
  46. Don't make anything? Look how much you use Israeli products without even realizing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1VvxR-t4pkA
    1
  47. Next time, when there's a war and your name is asked, don't shoot. That can spare some problem later.
    1
  48. The war at 67 as Israel thought it was about to be attacked. If Israel was right or not, is another question. In 1948 and later wars Arabs countries helped them... or tried. The Palestines are the only to stay refugees even when they get citizenship and it goes does to the next generation, all thanks to the UN you complain about. No other refugees get this treatment.
    1
  49. What a loving person you are.
    1
  50. I doubt anyone will vote for this.
    1
  51. Iran also thinks we're the problem.
    1
  52. Last time I checked, even if New York was a red state, it's very rich, because it is a main city, which lowers the price. This happens in a every city with high prices of houses.
    1
  53. System .Machine Well, usually they are talked apart as much as I know, despite having the same title (god) but one was once a man and the other was not. The question if Jesus was a woman
    1
  54.  @R2023-NV  You are confuding occupiers with residents. When the occupiers were gone, so were most of those who came from those. It's true, some Chrisitans stayed. Hardly any Arabs, though. They only got back less than 150 before Israel was establlshed. Look for "palestina ex monumentis veteribus illustrata"
    1
  55. For years Jew didn't have an equal state like others... And these refugees continue to be refugees when they have another citizenship. I don't see all other refugees complaining 70 years after.
    1
  56. There are moral stiff there, some of them nice for children. Some you totally think twice before teaching. Okay, no doubt, David and Goliath is a nice story for children. But, what about the rest? I didn't learn that until 12th grade, and still, things were censored, by the way. About Cain and Abel, no one thinks killing is good, and let's pretend Cain didn't give the best of his animals. So, if one children has less ability than the other, should he be treated differently. Both of your children come from the kindergarden One comes with a lovely drawing and the other won't succeed as much. So you will be happy about one picture and not the other? That's a bad parantnship.
    1
  57. msalgadosp Did you click the bell?
    1
  58. To be honest, he made it a new thing, so does it matter, really?
    1
  59. Even if I wanted to consider myself white privellage, that's kinda hard when Jews are both whilte and non-white. White, black, pink....who cares? (Okay, maybe pink may worry some peoople...)
    1
  60. Leticia Francisco The poor guy... may he rest in piece
    1
  61. I am not sure how much of a socialist he was. But as weird as it may sound, a party can be leaning both left and right (for example: security vs financical)
    1
  62. The first book is totally idiotic. Even if you want to talk about it, it's totally not the age. And abour the second where it was more luke A is for Applce, B for banana and C for carrots (or somerhing like this).
    1
  63. Why there should be a Jewish state... Do we want to repeat again history? Cause let's be real it didn't start at WW2 and it didn't end there. There are enough people who would throw up to the sea just because... no good reason really.
    1
  64. From what you say, some think of the bilogical meaning rather than the political 😅I was also surprised when I read the first word. But with the rest of the sentence it was clear.
    1
  65. Mario Bros. Isn't it only because males can't give birth?
    1
  66. Too said that they are too quick to come with treatmeant just for those girls (or boys, for that matter), they don't are fond of the change.
    1
  67. martin baker II There's somwthing about it. People don't say to say "when someone comes ro a jov interview, he/she should try to come on time and he/she needs to wear outfit thar will give a good impression" In Hebrew its worse
    1
  68. Well, yeah, the Arab empire (whcih is the called the Muslim empire for some unknown reason) did rule the land at the time. But it was kicked out at 1099 by the crusaders. Arabs weren't back in the land until the 18th century. I mean, with your logic, half of the world owns Israel.
    1
  69. Are they real with the swing doors? But let's be real... non of the things you mentioned make sense...
    1
  70. But no one cares about that... Miracles still happen to this very day.
    1
  71. Well, you can't really compare taxes to this. The most reasobable offer would be for all to pay the same amount, or, in worst case, 12% for each. But when it comes to taxes.. if one barely ends the month, how can you ask him to pay the same? And then what will he have? On the other hand, if the rich also pays 0 taxes, there just won't be any taxes Someone who has no money, unfotunstely will give up the idea of paying so much to begin with
    1
  72. For the same reason, there are Arabs states. Jew is also a nation, not just a religion.
    1
  73. And east Germany, who was in good terms with the rebellers, were also in good term with Lub, and Lubian made terror attacks. I wasn't really alive at that time, but both USA and Europe supported this. So what's the difference?
    1
  74.  @markaxworthy2508  acnestor don't go back 150 years. That's all the time they were in this land.
    1
  75. Israel was once the Jewish country many many years ago. It was occupied again and again and again. But Jews remained there. Many were banished, but always some stayed there. One of the occupants of Israel was Otman Empire who took Arabs from one country and moved it to the state of Israel. Another was the British who decided to call this piece of land Palestine.
    1
  76. In general I agree, but you said something not too definitive "White guys are arrested more than black." (or something like this). It can be intepted to ways: the percent of white poeople arrested because there's really no different or for the reason they are majority. I don't know which is true, but it can be interpeted in two ways
    1
  77. The Roman empire once ruled what we call today... do we really need to count them all? It didn't stop those countries being themselves after the Roman Empire "died". The barbarians of the Roman Empire later because of the Holy Empire (and some countries). So... German is actually a part of Italy? Or Maybe Italy is part of German as they were conquered by the Holy Empire. As none of it really matters. So... same here.
    1
  78. The same offer was made in 1947. Looks where we are today.
    1
  79. What is this "claiming to be Jews" so are you claiming you're an Arab\Muslim?
    1
  80. Remember the Jewish were after WW2. They don't need to be again in the mercy of others.
    1
  81. Many other Islamic countries were also under the British Mandate, or the French, for that matter, Jordan also was a part of the British Mandate.
    1
  82.  @raymack8767  So it's all political for him...?
    1
  83. Here somebody had a gun and is judged for shooting for self protect. So what did we do? And gracious, how many armed robbries are there? The problem with everyone having a gun is that more psychos have a chance to have them
    1
  84. If the next step is about killinhg the subject if speech, just cause hate them, than it should be cencored. Cause the next can ve an actual killing. It hapoened, you know
    1
  85. I admit I didn't even understand all the mockings... But of those I did... they were so lame. And people, stop comparing every people you don't like to Hilter or Nazis. Get over it. Though the one who talked about his mom...It's not really a news channel, so in a way, he's right. You don't really cover news, so it's only natural she won't be updated by that. So not sure what he meant to begin with.
    1
  86. Rather than carrying if someone is rich or poor, seems like he cared about justice and brotherhood
    1
  87. I think it's better to do "ractess characters" at then, anyone can fit in. So okay, after the cast is decided you can act some stuff to make it fit, but I wouldn't recommand on having character by race (unless there's a super speciel reason). If you do... inform "we look for ___ actor\actress", and don't make people waste their time.
    1
  88. I don't live in USA, so never heard of any of this (no RBG and not the second one or any other case). That's very weird.
    1
  89. Very funny...
    1
  90. Yeah, in today's standard it's real, but in the past, each piece of land end every race had its own gods
    1
  91. No one ever said there should be a problem with a religious country for any kind. The problem starts when the main agenda of this religion is "let's kill people just because they don't suit my taste". (I don't say all Muslims are like that, but there are far too many. But they're not the only one, I must say). Arabs aren't responsible for the Holocaust, but they are responsible for the forced departure from their countries just because they didn't' agree with the existence of Israel. My grandparents didn't line Iraq just because they wanted to, they had no much choice as they were afraid for their lives. To this day, Jews leave Europe as they are afraid of antisemitism. There are religious people in Israel who believe in having the whole country, but many others support this idea because they worry about what will happen if a Palestine country will be established. Netanyahu just says what he thinks fit at the same moments. There were times when he talked about two countries solution. Zionism by definition talks about the longing to live once again in Israel. As Israel wasn't established at the time, it referred to the old old old Israel. It doesn't have anything to do with hating all the rest. Arabs do live inside of Israel. In fact, 20% of Israel's citizens are Arabs. How many counties have such a big population of Arab as a minority? In France, the non-Muslim European country with most Arabs (6 million), has 10% of Arabs in there. More than Israel (2 million), but France's population is 7 times bigger to begin with. Is the situation perfect? No. But these Arabs have the same rights as any Israeli, as they are, Israelis (Or, as they are called, Israeli Arabs). Some of them don't accept this title, but you can't blame Israel for that too,
    1
  92. That's the ending goal, but you first want to see if you have a connection, cause you don't want to stuck with a rich man you stand. And though one can marry withou love, it has higher chances of divorce
    1
  93. Ilay harel There were a lot? (No offense or anything, I really have no idea.)
    1
  94. I heard they have problem with another group and I doubt they look for troubles...
    1
  95. daveypooh Yeah... he couldn't say my other mother, did he?
    1
  96. And since then, Palestines were all sacred and did nothing wrong at all to anyone... Ah, wait, totally forgot about the progroms before 1948 and the terrorist attacks after it. Oops.
    1
  97. Why should it be legal?
    1
  98. I don't need a reason to hate you, I just do.
    1
  99. As long as someone's not encouraging hurting people (which isn't part of free speech, as it hurts the right of being safe), you can disagree, argue and even protest, but cancelling one's opinion is... quite idiotic. You can't force everyone to have the same opinion
    1
  100. I never heard anyone talking about using batteries alone. They are comfortable for mobile stuff (cellphone, MP4), but not for things like TV
    1
  101. ​ @samuelmoskovitz5031  Actually, the Americans don't have those, so they pay the whole prize by themselves when they are hospitalized. And gracious, the prices they have.
    1
  102. But at the end of the day he was a human garbage
    1
  103.  @paul329869  Isn't weird for a prayer to encourage lying?
    1
  104. Why the UK and New Zealand doesn't have it? But the reason is because there's inner conflict of relgion's part in the country.
    1
  105. Luckily, the USA has no other problems. But let's be real now, if Israel didn't exist, many things you enjoy today... wouldn't exist.
    1
  106. I remember the kneeling phenomena, never understood it. Competitions of all kinds should be apolitical. Even the Eurovision taught me something, it's not always the case (some countries vote to their neighbours). But the little difference is.... this is between countries, not between groups in the same country. People are weird
    1
  107. To be clear: by unwed we talk about none married women (including widows or divorced), or just those who never married is any point of their life? And also, how many of those kids are unwanted? This is also a question.
    1
  108. The thing about anything related to health is that people aren't scientists, so they have to rely on others. But goverment, as a source of information, should do its research.
    1
  109. Paul Ashley Kevin Bryer May I ask what you are talking about? (interest, not judging, as I really have no idea what you meant)
    1
  110. But no one talked about them going off their land, so how is it even relevant?
    1
  111. The question is: Hitler didn't establish the Nazi Party. So he came with the social part was in the name. Did he intend to keep it that way? To be honest, never bothered to see his financial agenda. Race is not a right\left wing value, but the moment think your race is superior of others... that's right wing. It doesn't mean ALL right wingers are racist, only the very radical. Just like not everyone on the left winger is a woke. But really? Who cares what he was. Neither answers should make him worthy of appreciation.
    1
  112. No one gives the bankers their salary, and this is why people are upset when they have an absolutely ridiculous salary. And free market is still not the solution for that.
    1
  113. So you're saying the crazy woke are even closer to him when they think... And they think the opposite...
    1
  114. Inner racism isn't a new thing. Look at the US. Is Israel perfect? No. But so are many other countries.
    1
  115. I really don't understand how or why this story happened.... And the funny part is that the Arab state could be connexted to Jordan. They really wouldn't have cared.
    1
  116. He said getting the monedy back by buying and collobrations.
    1
  117. I don't know who that is, but it's not truth about gender, it's truth about sex. The gender is irrelevant.
    1
  118. Let me tell you a secret: there are people who aren't born as any specific sex. They're called inter-sexual
    1
  119. Kaiser Wilhelm II One little difference Goliath was the one who said come and attack me, and David excepted the challange for his people. Today, Palestinian attack and the Israeli deffence themselves. So the only differrnce is who is bigger now
    1
  120. You could easily find about it Wikipedia.
    1
  121.  @awildweeb4376  You know that up until the early 20th century everything you gained was yours. Defensive or not.
    1
  122. It was nice if she explained what black card is. I only find a credit card by the same name...
    1
  123. The naiveness of people...
    1
  124. I think it's just a short.
    1
  125. No... but why not blame Israel for all the rest if people can? Israel was blamed for a damn tsunami.
    1
  126. Okay, the things that happened there aren't optional. If Arabs hadn't start a war. there was no need for all this occupation. And if Israel has less luck... there was no Israel. That's fine with you, I guess?
    1
  127. Both sides could get their share of the land. But the Arabs didn't feel like having another state in places they don't sit in anyway (Not 100%, but in general, only a minority was left in both sides). The Arabs didn't feel like excepting this. And the rest is history.
    1
  128. Day Reldorito I think they mean in his way of thinking, rather than a physical appearance
    1
  129. The opposite videos are offensive to all soldiers killed in wat between the two and those who died from the terror attacks.
    1
  130. You said Nixon approved implemented the Affirmative Action, which republic consider bad, and that's why he's not racist? It doesn't make any sense. About the voted ID: unless they are illegal or there just for work, they should have an ID. Why should a temporary worker vote? Why illegal immigrant should vote? And of course, not every parent would make the right choice, but it's unrelated to colour or race. And... Maybe not all, but for the Ragen and Nixon, here's the reason why (Maybe more Ragen, less Nixon, but still) https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/07/ronald-reagans-racist-conversation-richard-nixon/595102/
    1
  131. No people would hurt... a good joke.
    1
  132. Why women are the only one's mentioned here...? Guys aren't innocent at that. My father has a magic shop, something quite rare where I live, and people come to his store, as him to show how to use the magic and say they want to buy it on eBay. That's irritating. (and by the way, they are not women). I never go to a store without intending to buy. Maybe not at that very moment, but I may know I will come later to buy the product. Sure, I don't always find something for my liking, but that's not a sin on its own.
    1
  133.  @markaxworthy2508  I guess you didn't listen too careful in your history class, so let me help: The gehtto was one of the many ways to make the life of the Jews miserable . But it wasn't what they were afrer. They wanted to have 0 Jews in the world. They didn't achieve that but it did get rid of 1/3 of the Jewish population at the time. The Jewish people still didn't get bacl to those numbers 80 years later. In the case of Gaza and the West Bank, the only reason they occupied Gaza or the West Bank is a war that started, among others, the countries who conquered them after Israel's indepent war (Jordan and Egypt). Israel never annexed those terrotories, so fornally, they are not part of Israel. We can argue if the Jews should or shouldn't have settles in those places, but the facts stil remain: terror emerged from both terrirotories, even if not in the same point in time. Israel left the Gaza stip not leaving a single Jew there. The way for an idependent country never was shorter. But it all changed when a terror regime took over the Gaza strip, giving a clear message it is inly interesed in the annihilation of Israel. So Israel decided to block all the entrance. But they have one more border, with Egypt. They also closed it. Your comparison is irrielvant as the Nazis did it to anhiliate the Jews, the Israeli did it to protect themselves. The Nazis were never threatened by the Jews, Israel is threatened by the Palestinians even before it was established formally.
    1
  134.  @CaptainSarky  I guess it's sarcastic or you are that your have a hole instead of knowledge of anything related to the subject?
    1
  135. I admit I am not very familiar with all energy stuff and its effects, but you can use rules, like factories which send their sewage to the river should pay a high fine. And if people think it is so helpful, why no one tries to promote it? I mean, at large scales, like the green.... something.
    1
  136. So you prefer, the second mother, the sob, and the holy spirit?
    1
  137. I was... and I don't say all Arabs are bad or something, but... rockets on your country times and again... That's not a life.
    1
  138. As much as I know, Israel attacked because they thought they are going to be attacked anyway. The Egyptians may think otherwise.
    1
  139. I understand transgenders feel like they belong to the other sex, but their body developed in a certain way. It doesn't matter if they grew breasts or changed their genitals, they still have automatic advantages. They should compete with men or with other transgenders (who did the same change and the other way around, cause letting women who become men to compete with men who changed to women will cause the same problem addressed here). And for those who say "women brought it upon themselves." Women have variety just like men, so even if some were for the idea, some were against it. I don't think she was for this idea. And also, there's a difference between saying a woman can be a good worker and she isn't necessarily stupider than a man than saying a woman's body has the same abilities as men. It's not a women's problem men don't want to see a woman in a power position.
    1
  140. Good to know other people don"t have temper tantrum
    1
  141. Gauls...? As in... French?
    1
  142. Do better and recycle them. :)
    1
  143. The average people in Gaza don't support Hamas? Then who's celebrating now their "victory"?
    1
  144. So... All America countries are ilegtimate too. Go to them first. And by the way, Jews were also there. Ask all those who conqueted this place
    1
  145. I don't think what was done to the Native American was really fare. They really left hardly anything from them.
    1
  146. That's truth, even though it may sadden you.
    1
  147. Israel was excepted as a country by the United Nations. Palestine was nothing but a name given to this area.
    1
  148.  @HVACSoldier  Are you sure? Jordan was never a Jewish territory. Ot most of the time (when it existed) anyway... And where did the plan to throw all the Arabs?
    1
  149. Not sure about eat bang, but in Gaza... not good at all. All the money they get if used for terror.. But Israel doesn't really control there. And there are no Jews there anyway (not that it means they aren't important, but Israel has no control there)
    1
  150. 711 Hardcandy That's a atupid argument? What's next? Tsunsmi?
    1
  151. When someone is looking at phones rather than you is always annoying. I will be as annoyed as he looked at his phone.
    1
  152. But they decided to sepearate, didn't they?
    1
  153. Feminism is classical liberalism applying to gender (and has nothing to do with race). What you described is EXTREME feminism. It's true anti-feminist may mean someone who is against extreme feminism, but it can also mean someone who is just shoving. You should have made it clear.
    1
  154. Firestar493 In Hebrew, there's not an "it", so a table is also "he"
    1