General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Ivancho
Zeihan on Geopolitics
comments
Comments by "Ivancho" (@ivancho5854) on "Ask Peter: Why Scottish Independence Will NEVER Happen!" video.
@quinkana1 The Independence questions has absolutely nothing to do with the monarchy. These are two totally separate issues.
13
I really hope that you're correct. 🤞
12
How much aid did Slovakia get from the EU? Because Scotland won't get a single Euro.
9
Wow, that's harsh, but maybe a true assessment. Long live the UK. 🤞
6
@manmonkee Being Scottish and having spoken to many pro-independence people over the years I am constantly dismayed by how little logic plays a part in their stance. Nationalism is one of the easiest forms of politics - it's easy to convince people that everything wrong is your big neighbour's fault.
6
@shelleyscloud3651 I am talking about a post independence scenario, not whilst we were a part of the EU. Again, but clearer I hope: In the future Scotland will not get a single Euro from the EU IF it becomes independent, until it joins the EU. And even then it is not guaranteed. The Eastern Block countries which joined the EU received aid from the EU to improve their physical, governmental and judicial infrastructure and not to fund economies which had structural issues. Scotland already has a sound political, judicial and physical infrastructure so would not qualify. There was also a huge political consensus for security reasons to help Eastern Europe, which again does not apply to Scotland.
6
I'm so glad to hear a fellow Scot who can see through the lies of power hungry politicians and make a sound decision.
6
@kjubone26 I meant is Slovakia a net contributor to the EU or a net beneficiary.
3
@curiositycloset2359 Agreed 100%.
3
@thomasherrin6798 You are talking about a game, recreation, sport, pastime, etc.
2
Very true and very sad. 😢
2
@quinkana1 Gotcha. 👍
2
The Spanish have said that Scotland is never getting in.
2
Honestly I think that the Welsh are smarter than my fellow delusional Scots.
1
@secretname4190 Are you Russian?
1
The EU is not interested in having Scotland on the basis of security. That's NATO's job. Turkey is similar. A bridge or tunnel is a fantasy. It would cost WAY too much. We wouldn't be allowed into the EU, much less the Euro. Instead we would be strung along like Turkey forever. The EU doesn't want us, they just want to break up the UK as revenge for Brexit.
1
@sprocket5526 All very true. 👍
1
@stuartmcnaughton1495 Unfortunately every pro-independence person I have ever spoken to fails to admit or address this fact. 😢
1
@TwelfthClover Spain pressured? By whom exactly? No one in the EU wants Scotland to join, they just want to break up the UK out of revenge for Brexit!
1
@TwelfthClover The EU will encourage Scotland to leave the UK and then string it along over joining just like they did with Turkey.
1
@PseudonymousBrit I doubt it. They will see Scotland utterly fail and thank their lucky stars that they are part of the UK.
1
@ajc5479 Yes, you're right in many ways they are, but financially € count.
1
@rob6927 Because it was in Western Europe's interest to have Eastern Europe stable and it provided a mobile workforce and The West was prepared to pay for that. None of that applies to Scotland.
1
@secretname4190 You're not Spain. Spain is guaranteed to enforce a veto.
1
@charmainelamont2020 If you believe that then I have a bridge to sell you. 🤣
1
@elektrotehnik94 No, the EU would NOT accept Scotland as we don't meet the entry requirements for the EU, let alone the Euro. Politically the EU absolutely will not accept another poor nation which will be a net drain on the EU for many decades to come with nothing to benefit the EU like increased stability. The only reason that the EU hasn't ever come out and said this is that they absolutely hate the UK for leaving the EU and want the UK to fail. Get real.
1
@chollyappleseed1969 History paints a less optimistic picture. 😢
1
As a Scot it has been incredibly stressful to not know if my country is going to self-destruct for so long. 😢
1
@PortilloMoment I don't believe them. The EU wants to break up the UK. They will string Scotland along just like Turkey because they don't want Scotland for the reasons Peter said.
1