Comments by "Richard_N" (@richard_n) on "Rick Beato" channel.

  1. I respectfully understand why you put Oasis on the list, but top 22? I don't think so. Temple of the Dog doesn't really count in my book, it was a collaboration of two established bands that had played together for a long time. Finally your honorable mentions were literally better than 15 of your top 22. Especially The Black Crows, whose debut album is better than 95% of all bands greatest hits albums. Seriously, there is no way they shouldn't be in everyone's top 5 of all time.
    1
  2. I love Sammy Hager and the work he did with Van Halen, but the Roth music has held up WAY better over time than anything Van Hager did. I love Brian Johnson, but Bon Scott beats him in every category. Better voice, stage presence, writing ability, you name it. By the way, I do believe that Bon Scott wrote the majority of Back in Black before he died and that the rest of the band didn't want to share the royalties with his heirs. Alice in Chains has/had as much raw talent as any band that has ever existed.
    1
  3. Rick, I would say this was the greatest list of it's kind, EXCEPT you left off the very definition of your criteria: David Draiman of Disturbed. The only person on your list who can compete with him is Freddie Mercury. Huge fail not having him on the list. (The second huge fail was Springsteen. Seriously dude? You couldn't even include a clip of the guy he's so bad). ADD: Watching this a second time a few months later, you should have had Joan Jett instead of Alanis. Also, I love all the grunge bands, but how do you leave off Scott Weiland? Probably the best of that decade with the possible exception of Cornell.
    1
  4. Great? Jump is easily one of the worst songs Van Halen ever did.
    1
  5. Rick you had some fantastic picks on this list, especially Ten Years Gone, probably my favorite Zeppelin song of all time. However, you have such a glaring omission on this list that I simply have to give it a fail. How do you leave the greatest rhythm guitarist of all time, Malcolm Young, off the list??? You had a choice of great ones like Let There Be Rock, Dirty Deeds, Touch Too Much, and Walk All Over You.
    1
  6. Most famous riff of all time? You have to be kidding. I can name 10 Zeppelin riffs off the top of my head that are more famous.
    1
  7. How do you not have a Billie Gibbons solo? Slash, Kirk Hammett, Randy Rhodes, and SRV?
    1