Comments by "Lewis Smith" (@lewissmith350) on "MEN IN DRESSES Now Have Extra Rights! - Ella Whelan (4K) | heretics. 55" video.

  1. I think trans rights at its most extreme is nothing to do with feminism, in fact its quite the opposite, its people were assigned at birth male, expecting everybody to see them and their world view as what matters most, if anything its quite a pompous macho assertiveness. Also i think it actually descended off lgb rights activism, for 2 main reasons, what happened was, just like heterosexuals have various ways of being hetero, so do gay men, and some gay men see a varied gender spectrum element as important to their sexualities, so they see trans rights as integral to their sexuality, and identity, they are such a strong element of the lgb community, that this became a gay rights issue, then even though many gay men have a version of homosexuality, which is different, and sees the biological divides in sex as being fundemental to their, sexuality, these gays are ignored by what have become lgbt groups, then of course some lesbians care even more so seeing, the fundemental divides of biological sex as wholly important to them, then they were the free core of fighting intelectually against extreme trans rights in britain. They allied to a rump element of the right on this issue, and some free thinking figures on the intellectual left. The reason extreme trans rights did so well in the 2010s, was as gay rights was a massive left right political issue on the west till then, but then in the left wing Victory on gay marriage ,i believe the right surrendered, like iraqis to the Americans in the gulf war, or germans to the allies in 1945, and what had been a hard fought war of attrition became total abject absolute total surrender, so even right wing institutions surrendered totally on trans rights with no debate. The debate was picked up, and now even the centre left agree with much of the gender critical line, even after having voted aspects of trans rights through with no debate whatsoever. I mean we should have a world for all, that loves everyone, whoever they are, but most agree biological sex exists.
    2
  2. Also undestably a lot of males who are attracted to women, had gender dysphoria, and their disophoria was coated into the lgb rights panorama, which made lgb so LGBT rights more pro the trans agenda, than against, so it be same part of the LGBT ticket. Which many gender critical people could not understand as gay seems so different to trans. Also the big difference with gay rights is this impact so massively on non gay people, so instead of the live and live way being applicable, people say, how can I live in this, if I don't ask for some reasonable boundaries. I think that's why so many things became pro LGBT rights, that's my dispassionate analysis there.
    2