Youtube comments of Lewis Smith (@lewissmith350).

  1. That was six hundred people laughing, Michael McIntyre would be happy with that.
    142
  2. Raquel Welch.
    46
  3. Riley Gaines is right to protect women's sports.
    36
  4. I don't think she had a choice on being room mates
    29
  5. He is not disgusted at them at all, he disagrees with certain agendas of the trans rights lobby, and accepts biological sex has massive consequences, so should affect laws and safeguarding rules to protect and defend womens rights and safeguarding, but he has compassion and understanding for them. .i would say his view is the moderate centrist sensible position, opposed to hatred and bullying and bigotry v trans people, supportive of gay rights, but also equally opposed to the fanatics who believe biological sex should not be classed as far more important than gender idealogy, and opposing the fantasies who deny the obvious glaring existence of recognition that biological women exist, as biological women rights matter. As does recognizing biological women exist, and this has consequences on safety and all that.
    28
  6. Richard Ayoade is a great speaker. 😊 Great host.
    13
  7. He is s hero.
    12
  8. Well done to Brazil for being a democracy, beautiful country, well done Lula, .
    10
  9. But surely it is better to believe rational true reasons for evil things occurring, then you can more easily defeat them. Like knowing witches don't exist, the cows died of a disease, so you defeat the disease, not allegations against alleged witches.
    9
  10. It's a terrible situation, all caused by a puritan zealotry by trans rights extremism.
    9
  11. The irony is they enter the women's events as well, gee I wonder why. 😂😂😂
    8
  12. My message to those veterans, T.Hanks.
    8
  13. Here are my examples, 1980s Spain, 1960s France, 1910s Canada, 1990s South Africa, 1950s Japan. And 1980s Brazil. Of divided lands that sustained stable democracies. Plus 1950s , west Germany, Luxembourg, and Belgium. And maybe 1970s Italy.
    8
  14. Wow, 😳, 😳😳😳😳😳😳😳, i have nothing to say, 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢, heretics is a courageous channel regarding this shocking issue. ..
    7
  15. I think Harris prayers haven been answered.
    7
  16. You miss spelt biologist.
    7
  17. Good health to him and all the Brazilian people.
    7
  18. Brazil is great, keep the peace.
    7
  19. ​ @jennifermorris833 surely if you stop having single sex spaces, that takes away a right of women. And to a extent at times men.
    7
  20. That's a shame, fined for saying a truth.
    7
  21. ​ @matthewoehler2472 five thousand men have ran faster than the womens hundred meters record, surely that proves the facts.
    6
  22. This won't be passed by the Senate, so put it in the budget reconciliation bill, so it does not need sixty votes.
    6
  23. Now he is funny
    6
  24. He does not give a F, about offending people's sacred cows, he says it like it is, like a tasty pear cider, that's he rolls,if you don't like that, well that's life.
    6
  25. I agree, that idea that any human with a IQ under 80, could function is daft, and that would be so for any neolithic or even mesolithic society. Some of the IQ tests claim Nepal has a IQ score, which is impossibly low. They claim scores in the fifties, for a country, with beautiful temples, beyond the design of the average person anywhere, and of whom, the great sherpas and gerkhas came from. How could sherpa tensing have climbed Mount Everest if he had a IQ of the fifties, he would have slipped to his death in no time with a IQ that low. How come so many gerkhas learned great English and were able to handle being great soldiers. The believers in racial IQs are fantasists. And hilariously most of them on this YouTube comments spell worse even than me. Even Bushmen and aborigine lifestyle need a IQ well over 80 to survive, what with their cultural stuff, if you watch how rich their cultures are, you realize they can not possibly have the IQs the racialists like to claim for them. I mean who invented the boomerang, or the pygmy cultures, that ray mears and the like see. There is no way iqs are all that different, that can't be explained for now by culture.
    6
  26. People like JK Rowling, are not saying trans women are not saying that trans women present a threat to women because they are trans, they are saying they have a fear , because they are biological males, and they feel that whether a biological meal identifies as a man or as a woman they still have the threat levels that a biological male has whatever they identify as.
    5
  27. Helen Joyce is a nice caring person.
    5
  28. Good for them, no to football thugs. Football hooligans are neanderthals, and I would run away from them. Most Celtic and rangers fans are great, brilliant people, but hooligans whether they support the gets, the bhoys, hibs, hearts, epl side or any spfl side, are just horrible.
    5
  29. In most situations we don't need to care, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤
    5
  30. Surely she does, explain your criticism.
    5
  31. ❤In most situations we don't need to care, and can be happy and inclusive, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins is also someone criticized for saying biological sex exists, but was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤ we should oppose bullying of trans people, but it is ok to sensible nuanced laws which accept sex exists.
    5
  32. Can you define anti trans. I agree bullying a trans person is anti trans, but sometimes activists claim, believing in biology sex to any extent, and even super minor questions regarding gender idea are anti trans. Which very unreasonable.
    5
  33. No way, as he still says out of Africa occurred, and to be honest I am happy the Neanderthals were not wiped out, it feels nicer that way. and we should not let politics get in the way.
    5
  34. He is siding with well mannered middle aged ladies, and oppressed female athletes,who could be his relatives, and he would care more about them than anybody, as biological males are evolutionry designed to want to protect women, after all they did so much for use they gave birth to us, they nurse in hospitals in wars, they would do the same for us. Helen Joyce is not a mean girl, she is a maths expert, who has kids, and talks clearly and rational ly,whereas extreme trans activists argue like Orwellian bullies. Ps can biological males who identify as women be classed as mean girls.
    5
  35. 2:32 it's American red cross
    5
  36. It is a new concept, to see biological males who identify as women, as a completely the same in every category group with biological women who identify as women.
    5
  37. 5000 men have beaten the womens hundred meters record, in your system, no woman would ever win any medals.
    5
  38. Plus David Blunket and Tony Blair have some agreement with him, and jk Rowling and Alex salamond. And Kate Forbes and Rosie Duffield, All left wingers.
    4
  39. Who is having the blissful ignorance here, in your view. Joyce is cool.
    4
  40. But here are huge nuances we should debate , women's safe spaces, and women's sports for example.
    4
  41. He may be saying it was not.
    4
  42. Yes, she is a hero, extremely brave for sticking to her completely reasonable totally uncontroversial vanilla beliefs, despite appalling attempts to silence, and utterly mis represent her statements. I honestly think she deserves a Nobel prize for standing her ground, when so many looked the other way. P.s, I am also proud Scottish civil society was so capable at criticising the new laws that jk opposed, some countries publics have just accepted what their elites wanted, but in Scotland their has been real debate and criticism of the law, not fawning obedience. If it had not been for that, I think Scotland would be seeing people being arrested for saying utterly trivial vanilla beliefs, but they have made the law now quite likely a unworkable laughing shops, by their campaign against it. And jk Rowling deserves most respect. Plus all the women and men who rightly condemned the most absurd elements of this new law, which organisations like s e x matters. highlighted so well. Plus to be fair the Scottish conservatives, who have a vote winner on this issue. Although there are minor parties like alba, who oppose aspects of the law as well.
    4
  43. Definitely, i love that thought.
    4
  44. I am sure Dawkins recognizes there were people who regarded themselves as trans in common parlance in centuries past, his view is more nuanced than you may imagine. He was friendly with Jan Morris. He does not hate trans people, and respects them.
    4
  45. Yes, what a petty man,
    4
  46. What did you do about it.
    4
  47. That's exactly the kind of toxic remark they are mentioning in the title here. Instead of reasonable debate you come along with this line. In reality we should see how we can be nice to trans people, and also understand the concerns of biological women. Just labelling people far right, for acknowledging something that 99.999% of people can observe just walking around on daily life, that biological sex exists, is not a argument that is going to encourage understanding and tolerance.
    4
  48. No she does not, who on earth would think that, can you tell the difference between a biological woman and a biological man, 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂, its the most obvious thing in the world, sorry if you really cant tell the difference, you mustt find the game guess who very difficult. Here is an easy one, can you tell the difference between Andre the giant and Kylie minogue, as if you can't thats nothing to be proud of. And can you tell the difference between coke and pepsi of butter and margarine. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.
    4
  49. In what way is he disrespectful. Explain.
    4
  50. ​ @JB-nz8ph but they have also have experiences as well, should you respect their knowledge and understanding of the ways of to he world. Is biology not Dawkins field.
    4
  51. JK Rowling deserves a Nobel peace prize.
    4
  52. She is standing up against a aggressive macho bullying orwellian agenda, that in a Alice in wonderland hare argumentation style ignores the glaring realities that biological women exists.
    4
  53. But biology still exists and has consequences.
    4
  54. What a ridiculous thing to say. She is not a N,azu, she is a good woman. Belief in biological sex existing and having consequences is not far right, and it is shameful and extremists for you to opine otherwise, shame on your hateful slander of Helen.
    4
  55. The questioner wire a blue suit like something from a roald Dahl character who picks blueberries, and carries blue balloons and sings about blue things, why wear a odd blue suit to meet the president, what next, pink, multi colored, nothing, this questioner was a disgrace. I hope mtg is going to correct his bad choice. While z is ok, he is a manly warrior, 🪖 so can wear what he likes.🎉
    4
  56. Probably ninety percent of those men are untrained Russian conscripts. Absolutely monstrous remark.
    4
  57. 5000 men have beat the women's hundred meters record.
    4
  58. ​​​​ @benstark5320 it is a fair comparison. You just said, most, and clearly biological differences in height and physical advantages from being male still carry on, it's not clever to deny those realities. If Lisa Leslie had been born a man, instead of being 6 5 , she would likely be bigger and 6 7, these are clear advantages. A 6 7 woman would be 6 9 and so on.its unfair to disadvantage these brilliant women v people born male. Being born male, is like being born with a performance enhancing feature,that all the biological women don't have. Which is unfair. I don't mind shaq I neal or Lauren Jackson being better at me at basketball, it's brilliant there are men and women so good at sports, but it's unfair to have people in women's sports, when they had the physical advantages from being born male. It's like a performance enhancing drug, women don't get. Course that is super duper unfair.
    4
  59. ​ @michellerussell49 I think we have had enough offensive jokes, they have just lost trump the election.
    4
  60. What a load of disgraceful things to say. SERENA WILLIAMS IS A WOMAN, how dare you compare biological males competing in women's sports to the greatest female tennis player in history. How dare you. Wash your mouth out, what a disgusting comparison to make. You should be ashamed of comparing the great biological female tennis player in history, a proud proud African American hero, to biological males competing women's sport. Being born male is a unfair advantage in women's sport, as none of the other competitors have that advantage, for what is called women's sport. It is sickening to see trans rights activists constantly emote racist tropes about Serena, in the cause of their macho impervious ideal if biological males in women's sport.
    4
  61. Nobody is saying your evil, they are saying biological sex exists, and has consequences, that's what is being stated.
    4
  62. I thought he is being attacked for stating the glaring obvious that biological sex exists.
    4
  63. Biological sex is not a Victorian concept. The Romans, the celts they all knew it existed. And everybody said it did till some kind of mass meme change in the 2010s, that came from nowhere. We all know it exists, we should love trans, but accept for good or ill, biological sex exists, and make the best of it.
    4
  64. But he has been banned from writing comedies, on mainstream media as of his opinion, even though most like his stuff, and his views have more support than those who opposed him.
    4
  65. Can you give a example of a comment he liked, that you classify as anti trans, give the user name, its got to be one easy to find, and say the exact words, not a representation of what was said, and then give your analysis on that remark. Its only fair, so your definition of anti trans can be displayed. Otherwise are you interpreting anti trans, as just not agreeing wholeheartedly with your particular view on this nuanced issue.
    4
  66. It is not right wing to believe biological sex exists. Robert Winston a d Richard Dawkins, jk Rowling and the main British communist party, plus blunkett, Regan and more believe it does.
    4
  67. We would like trans people to be happy, but also for if to be acknowledged that biological sex exists, and has consequences in sports, and safety,
    4
  68. But there was good news, in Aberdeen winning the Scottish Cup. So some good things happened. And a Palestinian scored one of their penalties.
    4
  69. All he is saying is biological sex exists, what's wrong with that.
    4
  70. She is not super nasty, she is just saying.
    4
  71. I believe in science.
    4
  72. ​ @deathmetalmusicals6759 they tried to ban her. Did you support them firing her for her opinions.
    4
  73. ​ @kovi1581 celery is healthy, it is good with cheese, or others dips, nobody should oppose celery, unless, they have a allergy to it. Though I prefer hamburgers.
    3
  74. But if that is so, why are so many trans rights extremists so macho, as in not feminine in the way they argue. Lots of stats on crimes and all sorts, indicate, biological males who identify as women, have closer average stats on propensity to certain acts, to biological males who identify as men, not to biological women. Also the gender criticals debate, like women, as in effete intellectuals mulling and humphing and aaaaashing, over a glass of wine, on theory and facts. While trans rights activists shout aggressive abuse, and have totalist banners, or say things like abusive term for gender critical person, like terf, followed by threat against gender critical person. They treat their gender critical opponents like the worst thing you could be, as beyond the pale, which is a very macho aggressive way of arguing. So no the evidence does not indicate that biological males who identify as women, are really men with women's brains.
    3
  75. She had this forced on her, and was told to keep quiet about it by orwellian big wigs, well done her for speaking up.
    3
  76. Many on the left agree, with Dawkins . like Tommy Sheridan, Harper of the green party, and the main British communist party. Even the highly controversial George Galloway.
    3
  77. 😊If biological sex does not exist, why am I able to tell which players at Wimbledon are men, and which are women, the only reason some dodgy over defensive pseudo scientists now in their journals, describe biological sex as "more complicated than youuuuuu! Think," in tone belying even they know their agenda is on shaky ground intellectually, is as if a tiny percentage of people on the edges who are intersex, who yes exist, but they want to talk about them to undermine the clear obvious existence of biological sex, so they can muddy the waters of the term, and then shoehorn biological males who identify as women into the category of women. It's just ridiculous. Thank God or the universe for Collin Wright.
    3
  78. Did you do anything about the Rochdale girls, what a cheek to complain about people who live nowhere near Rochdale, not doing anything about something they did not know was happening. There are plenty enough men in Rochdale of all races, who could have noticed these things going on, and done something about it, look at the facts, women who are fifty percent of society, were seen as less important than less than o.5 percent of men, in the trans bathroom and sports debate, if they are that powerless, and need to be this loud to be heard, and make this much clamour, how much would they have been ignored regarding Rochdale. And don't pretend they were afraid of being seen as racist, as there are plenty of men in Rochdale who don't care what anybody thinks about them, who like Jimmy carr, Nigel farage, pubs, alcohol, and trump, what did they do, nothing, don't blame middle class liberals for something that they could not have even known about,. Remember the things said by male police during the Yorkshire ripper, case, claiming certain women did not matter, laughing at their problems when they were victims. Dont you dare blame nice kind relatively powerless middle class women for the men and powerful of Rochdale failing in this situation. You did not do anything about it, Jack, and you are a man, why did you do nothing about the horrible events in Rochdale, and also you did not protect t women in the trans bathroom debate, and you did nothing about Jimmy Saville. Ps I am not blaming all Rochdale men, but what on earth were all these people doing, while it was going on, social services and the police dont have that much power, what were the locals doing. What was general society up to. Don't they have any morals, or social cohesion, and don't blame middle class women for that , as you can bet your bottom dollar Helen Joyce and sal Glover would have cared, it's the locals, who don't care what happens to people who were to blame, and that's people who are not concerned about the problems regarding extreme trans rights activists, and people who abuse Rochdale kids. I mean a society that puts the rights of tickle above sal, is one where we need men to act and protect women.
    3
  79. He will be pm to at least 2028.
    3
  80. It is not extreme trans phobia, what have they said that you regard as extreme. And in what way are they denying trans gender existance, Dawkins says they exist. He just disagrees that the term woman being used in a different way to what he regards as typical.
    3
  81. ​ @tracygeddes5867 it's perfectly ok of you to debate the rights and wrongs of trans rights here, but to claim they are denying their existence, is different to denying their existence as women, it's a massive difference, it's not a nuance, its a total mistaking of their position.
    3
  82. ​​​​ @tracygeddes5867 why does it matter either way, if it's only a word, and you concur that gender if it different from sex, does it matter that the word for biological women is separate from the word of trans women. Are you saying the essence of trans women has to be counted in the same category as biological women, if so, what's the reasoning. It would be nice to learn, I love to be informed. Or are you saying gender is something, but biological divides are not. I don't think it makes you any less of a person,whatever is decided, you are still yourself, just as everybody else is. I give up, I don't know what the aim of everything here is. Have a good day.
    3
  83. Its not bigoted to discuss biological sex, yes we can be tolerant to everybody and be kind to everybody, but part of that is to accept the nuance, that biological sex exists and has consequences in sports and safety. Its not reasonable to deny its reality.
    3
  84. But they should be more sensitive.
    3
  85. To tell him apart from blue suit idiots.
    3
  86. Jk Rowling is a sensible feminist liberal,
    3
  87. ​​ @WalterWhite-jz7ct but she does not hate trans people, where is your evidence for this claim, I thought she believes she is protecting women's rights, what you may call biological womens rights against biological males, the fact they identify as trans from her point of view is secondary.
    3
  88. ​​​​​ @ProfessorChaos1349 But would you agree that the term woman, was never a term that only a obscure trade knew, people would have had such a term since the times of homosapiens arrival in Europe. It's not some never heard of idea, it's a term we couldn't live without. Probably even Neanderthals had a term for men, and a term for women. Additionally 99 percent of the words in any scientific paper are common a garden words everybody uses, like and, or, today, Tuesday, the number one, or man or woman.dont muddy the waters and pretend man or women are unknown words. They have a definition, and everyone comprehends that is a common term, it's fairly reasonables.
    3
  89. ​ @ProfessorChaos1349 but the word woman in the way Dawkins is using it, is the definition that has existed since the dawn of human language, it's only a political belief , a terminological sleight of hand, that is desiring to change the definition, purely for the sake of what could be called trans rights. It's not science that desired to change the definition, but a political idealogy,that had a set aim, so to pretend he is being wrong on the science, as some politically inspired people, want the term to be changed to what they want, is wrong, he is just not obeying the beliefs of people such as yourself.
    3
  90. ​ @ProfessorChaos1349 totally agree, that in itself, it is not offensive, but changing the language, and concepts of terms, massively important terms that have been used since the dawn of time, for the sake of a political aim, and not thinking about the consequences and affects it has on all societies and such, is unreasonable, and to them claim anybody who does not unswervingly go along with it, even if they have sensible criticism of the politically motivated change, to claim that anybody who does not unquestioningly go along with this change, is being something to look down on, i feel thats unfair.
    3
  91. No, a tall biological woman, is a biological woman, that's the difference. It's unfair to have the opposite in women's sports.
    3
  92. The last part of your paragraph sums up the incomprehensible confusion of trans rights ideology, itls the case that trans rights extremism is like the conversation at the Disney Alice in wonderland hatters tea party, from the hare, impossible to be cogent. .
    3
  93. Evolution is not a right wing idea, it's just true. Also Dawkins is right that Hitler was terrible, that sexism and racism are wrong, that biological sex exists, that brexit was not great, and that education is good.
    3
  94. ​ @davidjames2910 and maybe David Attenborough about nature, and Sadiq Khan about multi cultural ism and it's benefits. Joyce would be a top guest.
    3
  95. Biological sex exists, I support linehan and Rowling, they are right to oppose biological males in women's sports, and right to oppose men in women's prisons, Rowling is a hero, and her critics, are ridiculous. If anybody opposes linehan or has no sympathy for him, as he does not support males using women's ra🤯pee centres is a disgrace and should look at the dangers that idealogy poses for women. This crazy loony position must be opposed, and anybody who supports it should be ashamed. Linehan is a gr at comedian. Great bloke
    3
  96. The only people I have met who can't tell the difference between men and women, are people I met when helping at a school with severely learning difficulties. Evolution made us able to see the difference, anybody who can't is not firing on all cylinders.
    3
  97. Are you going to try and take over bud lite.
    3
  98. ​​​​​ @themaestro3034 the thing that annoys me about trans rights activists is they are so rude, so desperate to insult, and overbearingly put people in their place. Of course it is legitimate to have points of disagreement on women's safe spaces, and women's sports, but all you come out with is insults. That's the thing that has pushed me away from the side I would naturally have supported on this issue, trans rights activists are just so abusive, overbearing and arrogant. I have no problem with trans people, most don't have any problem with them, they are just fellow citizens who deserve respect, but it's ok for people to debate the nuances of the issue, hopefully we will come to a reasonable answer, that loves everyone including trans people, but also biologicalwomen. So come on insult me and bully me for not agreeing totally with you, I wonder who that makes the bigot. Ps I would have no problem using trans pronouns that they want, and oppose people being bullied or sacked for being trans, but of course it's easy to just call me a bigot as I think women's sports should just be for those assigned at birth female. I say Dawkins, Moulton and Rowling are examples of people bullied just for expressing concerns that are perfectly reasonable.
    3
  99. ​ @CarsonDobos he is not targeting the most vulnerable minority. And what about the rights of vulnerable women, in safe spaces, who have been affected as of these Puritan zealous laws, of putting xy people in xx safe spaces. It's ok to discuss these issues, we should care about trans people, but also care about everyone. I mean in some situations trans people are vulnerable, like a school, where everyone bullies trans people, and we should protect them there. But sometimes trans people are not the most vulnerable, like there were three roman emperor's who were trans, it that MMA fight where a person who was trans brutally injured the woman..or when Riley Gaines was surrounded by trans activists and forced to hide in a cupboard, as of fear of what would happen to her. Sometimes trans are the most vulnerable and sometimes not, we should protect everyone, including trans people and others.
    3
  100. Norm was brilliant, still love his stuff.
    3
  101. And Tasmania horrificly wiped out all the natives, so they are not some left wing Nirvana.
    3
  102. Evolution made men and women exist....
    3
  103. She is not taking it out on trans people, she is just saying biological sex exists, nothing against trans people.
    3
  104. ​ @crowscoyote there is nothing bigoted about jk Rowling, she is a rational caring person,
    3
  105. ​​​ @crowscoyote you can't give a example, the truth is, she said,.dress how you like and all that, etc etc, be nice yada yada, but stated biological sex exists, and to make a example of her, trans rights extremists declared war, and lost. She is nice and caring, unlike the hateful bullies who insult her all the time. It's not hateful to be nice to trans people, but to accept biological sex exists, and has consequences
    3
  106. Yes, the best biological woman, should win women's sports, not the five hundreth best biological man.
    3
  107. But the other commenter just said expressing his opinions ruined his career. Is that wrong.
    3
  108. It's trans rights activists who made this a issue, everyone was just living their lives, and along cane this unwanted intrusion, and when people raise any objections, they are called horrible names, and get rubbish gaslighting arguments thrown at them, which laughinly deny the obvious reality that biological women exist.
    3
  109. ​​​ @madnezz1961 I don't want to put you out like that, don't waste your time on my YouTube remark, if you don't remember that's ok, please I hate to make people do work like that. I will accept you think it's transphobic, that's ok, you have better things to do, than watcha video just for my sake, and if I disagree with you, that would make it completely pointless for you. As it would just give you negative vibes, have a good day, Please don't I shall feel guilty. Good day to you. Thanks for your efforts. Nice of you. please please don't watch a video you don't like, just for me, 😭 it shall make me feel guilty. Thanks for the thought.
    3
  110. There is no way iqs are that genetic. Why are most people unable to become doctors, but doctors come from every country on the globe. Most people in the world in 1700 were living similar bronze age varient lifestyles, with a few exceptions. All you have to do is speak to people from different races, and you see there is a similar iq level. Listen to talk radio stations, or read comments sections, from the nations supposedly ranked highest, and you can see there is not any group that is super intelligent. Then soeakbto the doctors of every country and you see there are many clever folk everywhere.
    3
  111. Except when it offends something they are close to. People should be careful with a election coming up.
    3
  112. ​​​ @bencutting146 but in that case, if inequality and all this, are such big problems. Why are there people focusing on trying to put biological males in women's sports when they could be focusing on inequality and all the terrible things in the world. Like you you could have gone on a profile on YouTube comments and gone on about encouraging equality and encouraging socialism and encouraging,. Peace. There are 500000 homeless people in the USA, have you any time why have you got any time to write comments criticising those standing up for women's rights, and just stating the reality that biological sex exists it just does it's just a glaring reality, when you could have spent all that time arguing against homelessness in favour of better taxes on the rich for the poor. You could have been arguing for stronger links with Europe to increase our economy. Instead instead of something useful like that you're going on this comment section going on about a tiny unimportant issue that that affects hardly anybody, and all for the idealogical mantras that really few supports and fewer really believes in, wouldn't it be better if you just let people you know defeat the kind of trans extremist argument, and then just argue against homelessness and aren't you against war and argue against hate and argue against racism you know wouldn't it be better to do something more useful. And if you comment on this then I will realise that really your main interest is this issue, and really you're just interested in opposing gender critical beliefs such as belief that biological sex is important or belief that biological woman rights are important you know. Just don't comment on this just go on somewhere and argue against homelessness or are you against health inequality do that do something useful. Like in Scotland the Green party were elected on a manifesto of supporting the environment, and when the Scottish government said oh no we're not going to do this recycling bottle scheme, they said that's ok we'll stay in the government when really that was the thing they should have left the government about, but when it when the Scottish government said we're not going to have have puberty blockers in such a way anymore because of the cass report, they left the government not because of environmental issues not because of social issues not because of economic issues but because of something which really they had no idea about their not experts on puberty blockers they don't know anything about the subject they left the government over something that's nothing to do with the environment. Really the people that are unfair and jaded on this, are the trans rates extremists who are willing to leave government's lose elections,Ike happened to Kamala on this issue, but don't actually stand up for Peace don't stand up for a tax rates on the Ritz they don't stand up for social services they don't stand up for public services. They bully JK Rowling and they bully innocent women who are just saying they don't want biological males in women's sport. If the trans rights extremists who hate JK Rowling, and hate innocent biological female athletes who are just saying they don't want biological meals in women's sports had spent all that time focusing on on opposing homelessness, then they would have done something far more use. So hey I'm going to continue saying the truth the biological sex exists it does does it's a glaring reality and if anybody says otherwise I'm still going to disagree with them, I'm still going to say I think in reality women should be entitled to say you know there's such a thing as a man and such a thing as a woman because affects their safety and safeguarding, I am going to say trans people deserve respect, and nobody should bully them, or call them mean names, but also I'm going to argue for a socialism and equality and liberalism and freedom, but I don't think it's fair for you to claim that pretending biological woman and biological male don't exist is some kind of left wing idea because it isn't, what we should do if we should love trance people have part of our society they are as much part of our society as anybody else and I oppose any bullying against them but I do also believe that we should have a society where we accept biological woman and biological man exist and we should have laws that are new and accept that but we can also also have socialism and equality and freedom and liberalism.
    3
  113. It is not right wing to believe biological sex exists, it is rational and progressive, and understanding reason and truth.
    3
  114. What is nonsensical about gender critical beliefs, surely biological sex is important.
    3
  115. The people being horribly mean, are often the most extreme trans rights activists, like some who on their march on Sunday had banners with threats towards people of other political beliefs.
    3
  116. He was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were even born.
    3
  117. NoBut why do folk like Caitlyn Jenner, and Eddie izzard, who identified as trans but were born biological male, behave more like the stereotype of a quite macho man, specially before they transitioned, remember Caitlin jenner after transitioning threatening ben Shapiro in a debate, hardly a dainty feminine act. And Izzard was always running marathons, and dominating panel shows with a strong persona. Great person,, but what about their behaviour indicates they are more feminine than most men, which surely would occur, if there was such a thing as female brains. If men are from Mars and women from Venus as the book claims in a joke, what about them seems venusian. And both are still attracted to women, I mean can you tell me, in what ways they behave like a typical woman. And the typical extreme trans rights activist often is a biological male, arguing and debating like a aggressive domineering biological male debates, indeed often in a more mansplaining way, than most cis males. Please explain how that is so. Please inform me, as I love to learn. So as of that I think the gender critical idea makes sense, that biological sex exists, there is much variation in personality, sexuality etc in each gender, there are tougher men weaker men, homosexuals and heterosexuals and all sorts, and even biological males who identify as women, but that does not stop biological sex existing, and vice versa for women, females, and heterosexuals and homosexuals are as normal as eachother, but it does not stop sex existence.
    3
  118. ​​​the reasonable gender critical position should be adhered to , while being as tolerant as doable within that, to trans rights, but nobody should be called a bigot for saying biological sex exists as vitally important in the descisons.
    3
  119. Thar was sneaky of the East Germans, crazy thing of them to do.
    3
  120. But is it fair, to deny biological sex exists, and to label people bigots a d far right for saying in certain situations we can accept it exists and has consequences. Is the pain just being pushed around, with people being ostrichized just for saying biological sex exists,
    3
  121. I don't think Dawkins would have much of a problem with your kids choosing their choices in life. Best happiness to yo and them. I don't think he objects to over eighteens choosing changes in gender, he just has nuances over the word woman. Am I right. And he agrees with you on women's sports, I think we can all come together on this issue on love and happiness. 😊😊😊 He was even friends with Jan Morris, he has no problem with trans people. I think he agrees with you on Rowling. And agreed with you that trans people deserve respect, so you are more similar than you think. You are a good person, and so is Dawkins.
    3
  122. You know Putin invaded.
    3
  123. That's a horrible thing to say. Mengele killed people, Dawkins has never killed anybody and is one of the foremost Oxford academics of our era. You should be ashamed. When Dawkins sneezed, that snot in his hanky, has more knowledge of biology and reality as well, than most of his abusive nasty horrible critics.
    3
  124. ​​ @JB-nz8ph yes, but they both know what it's like to be a biological male, and have experiences a lifetime of such, of interacting with biological women, surely this issue is not confined to just members of the trans communities, it affects biological men and biological women, aswell, so its unenlightened and unfair to brush away their concerns on an issue that has major affects on all of us, and definitions and rights and all sorts.
    3
  125. ​ @denzellmovies Because he is taking about the effects on all society. Which we are all part of.
    3
  126. In what way, please explain and happiness to you.
    3
  127. And they break records, showing they have a advantage.
    3
  128. ​​​​​ @Maksie0 I thought they said he signed up to a dating website, dressed as a woman, to show anybody was allowed to, which he thought satirized the idea of everyone being allowed to do that, isn't that a bit different to what you are saying. I mean it was not to dox people was it. And are you really categorizing everything he did in a fair way. Could you say the way you are describing what he did in these things is kind of spun to condemn him. If you described them in a neutral way they would not sound so bad, if you described the hem in a positive way, even more so. Surely it's fair to criticize him, but say what these criteria are,rather than just labelling insults. Please go into more detail in all the cases you mentioned, from a neutral manner, and say why you feel they can be regarded as hateful things to say. And though I like Tennant, he can hardly criticize strong language after what he said about that politician. Al him referencing the naz, Is, well who don't, trans activists always use the term for even mainstream centre left opponents, I mean he should not, bug it's just normal aggressive anglosphere debating language, trump called Kamala a commie, Dems called trump hit, ler.
    3
  129. She cares about people, that's why she defended women prisoners, a ignored group, from having to accept intact biological males in their cells.
    3
  130. Biological srx exists
    3
  131. But why do so many biological males who identify as women,still have so many male traits in their personality. Like crime stats are similar for biological males who identify as women, and biological males who identify as men, but not as biological women who identify as women. Surely we can accept there are biological males who identify as women, but it does not change the fact we need some safeguarding rules for women, in this sphere, and nobody should ever click on links on YouTube comments, it could be fsb, cia or con artists.
    3
  132. I am a genius
    3
  133. Yes she did, of course she would condemn them, what a mean insult.
    3
  134. Yes, comedy genius
    3
  135. ​​​ @jakejones5736 I have no problem with with people of any race competing in women's sports, as long as they are women. I think it is quite racist to compare black biological women competing in women's sports, to biological males competing in women's sports. Why do trans activists always try and undermine the legitimatcy of black people in in sports, by comparing them being in women's sports, to biological males in women's sports. Why do they never say,well if we allow middle class white women in women's sports,surely we should allow biological males. I think it's as trans activists are not right, they don't understand that all biological women should be allowed in women's sports, regardless of race, but there is a reasonable debate to not allowing people born male, in women's sports. Ps we must never hate trans people, and they should have free happy lives, welcome in our society, but it is ok to say women's sports should just be for biological women, it's the whole reason we have women's sports.
    3
  136. ​ @L_Martin good point
    3
  137. There are no right wing people, there are no left wing people, there are only people.
    3
  138. Dawkins is the best.
    3
  139. Then why do some people argue gender should decide access to womens prisons and safe spaces over sex.
    3
  140. What makes you think animals know their sex , surely they just have biological urges, they don't have a gender identity. I don't have a gender identity, I just wake up in the morning and have my breakfast, then follow my urges, needs and responsibilities, i no more walk about thinking i am a man, than i walk about thinking i have a nose and 2 eyes, and a mouth, i just have them.
    3
  141. I think Kier stamer was right to say this judgement brought clarity, it has been an issue that has harmed the left across the Western world, on some issues the left have to accept that they are the servants of the people, and most people currently do not agree with the belief that a trans woman is as much in every way a woman as a biological woman. Maybe in a couple of decades if that is a popular belief among everybody, then it can be what this state has, but till then I think you have to recognise what most people think. Also I think we also have to acknowledge, at 100% yes in many situations the trans woman, is the most vulnerable person in a situation, but in some situations it is the other way around. A big strong individual who was born a biological male, will in certain situations, such as women's sports, and women's prison cells, be the least vulnerable person, surely a sensible nuance society, accepts the sense of the gender critical position, but also learns a kind of tolerance towards trans individuals, I certainly don't think it's fair, the castigate women who are doing something which is pretty normal, there are clearly situations where a biological woman will feel threatened when a biological male is present, and it is ok to have certain safeguarding rules to protect their rights, whether that biological woman is the richest the most powerful in our country, or the poorest female glaswegian shoplifter who's in a prison cell in some Scottish prison, their safeguarding still matters, and it was right the Scottish people stood up and spoke up when the Bryson case occurred. I mean nobody would call a biological woman a bigot, if she said she felt threatened walking down an alleyway with a biological male following 20 metres behind her, because it's a sensible innate fear for women to have about their own protection. So we should not be surprised that there are some biological women who are threatened, just as much even possibly more so, by the thought of there being biological males whether those biological males identify as men or identify as women in their safe spaces. I don't think it is fair to call women bigots as they have a quite nirnal evolutionary created fear of the opposite gender, in certain situations. It's not toxic to recognise that. We should be nice to trans people, And to understand the fears that those women have.
    3
  142. ​ @ArrozDiCidade23 A very successful comedian actually, as shown by his devastatingly witty remarks here. And if he is a clown not in a good way, he is in that he shall haunt Glenn's nightmares, in how witty he was.
    3
  143. ​ @DarthPoyner Kathy Griffin got fired for offending trump.
    3
  144. There was a case in a Vancouver rap@ centre, in 2023, where a person did exactly the sort of thing Helen Joyce, and jk rowling talked of. Where a biological male was allowed in, and did the unthinkable, the worst thing you could do in such a place, as of the decision to ignore the concerns of sensible gender critical views. We should love everyone, but remember that the concerns of women's rights activists should be listened to.
    3
  145. That is a typical toxic response from trans rights activists. Trying to frame what the other side said in the most extreme and offensive way you possibly can. All you do is push everybody away from you and push everybody away from you. How can we have some kind of common ground, if you try to frame everybody else who has even the mildest criticism of you as an extremist. Hellen Joyce did not say the things you said in the way you said it. What you have done is frame something she said, in the most extreme way you can, so you can paint her in the most extreme way you can. If you listen to what she says she is clearly a moderate on this issue, and all she said was that there could be problems in the future, in terms of the potential very high number of detransitioners, who would be people who would need long lasting support as of the very powerful chemicals that were used in the transition processes. She was not asking for some kind of genocide, but every trans rights activist deliberately misinterpret what she said, the problem with that misinterpretation, if you do not own every single Media organisation in the world, so it is very easy to see that she didn't say what you said in the way you're saying it. So all that happens there, is the few things you're able to say in the media, are obviously discounted a statements that a misinterpreting whatever people said, so people are pushed away from any level of support for the trans rights activist position. And the people who know Helen Joyce and Helen stanilan, know what they believe, and know what they say and read their books and understand they don't have those extremist beliefs that you claim they do, so all that happens, is your side give out messaging which is obviously as strong as a creampie, while the gender critical people argue with very intelligent statements about the reality of biological sex and all that. Which is way in many court cases and in many dinner parties your belief system, is destroyed because of it is just powder puff, Robert gender critical arguments have rigidity and strength and rational reason behind them. What Helen Joyce is obviously saying, is that the chemicals that did the transition process was so strong, and the surgery was so final, that if it is the case that this was are some people think now they may not be right they may be wrong, that this was a kind of a social contagion, then there will be a very high number of de transitioners, and these people will need medical care for the rest of their lives out of the chemicals and such used in the process of transition. Now she may be wrong she may be right, but obviously she was not calling for a genocide, she was talking of the potential risks, that if this was a social contagion, and some people argue that because of statistics they claim exist around Hollywood children, which may or may not be true then there will be problems to do with the transition and the healthcare cost of that in the future. She clearly was not calling for a genocide, every interview in speech to have made obviously indicates that fact that she was not calling for a genocide, but the trans rights activists argue that she was, the problem with their argument, if all you have to do is read a book or see a speech from heen Joyce and see she is not supporting any form of genocide whatsoever. In fact Helen staniland, is probably anything mildly to the left in terms of trans rights, in his support for much toleration and understanding and compassion and kindness, compared to the vast majority of the population of the whole, for whom the majority position at times borders on, just not being bothered about the issue or the people involved at all, like Americans about their massive homelessness of problem. Helen staniland actually wants good things to happen to these people who suffer from gender dysphoria, whereas most people are not really all that interested and are more concerned with their own concerns and lives so would be individualusts about this, uncaring Like American's about homeless people. The truth is the only people following this issue, know that Helen Joyce does not support a genocide, so when they hear translate activist claim through ridiculous mission interpretations of what she said, that that is what she supports, all you do is prove to those human beings who are reading about this, that the trans rights activist side, is toxic and not be taken literally, and that the other side is actually reasonable and something to listen to, all you do is give credence to the Hellen Joyce Helen staniland side, which is sensible as they are moderate decent centrist people. And in due course all moderate centrist decent liberals, will agree with their moderate sensible decent liberal positions, of opposing genocide, of being nice to trans people, but acknowledging that biological sex obvioudly exist and is very important when we have safeguarding rules for women. Really what it is, is that some people believe that biological sex is very important when looking at safeguarding rules between men and women, and who should be in women's sports and things like that. Some people believe that for the sake of ideological reasons, what some people called gender ideology, or trans rights activism, that we should ignore that. The problem with the trans rights activists, is that instead of understanding that there are two main political positions that you can look at and that we should come to some kind of intelligent compassionate compromise, not agreeing with their political position, memes that the person is evil beyond comprehension, so they desperately dream up all sorts of horrible terms names and beliefs and statements about, anybody who gives even the mildest criticism of their beliefs. Whether that is Richard Dawkins, the supreme Court judges, kemi badenoch, a world renowned children's author, Chapelle, etc, that is the problem you have when waiting into this debate from the rational gender critical side. That you will receive laughable toxic insults from very extreme out of touch with proper debating styles, extreme trans rights activists.
    3
  146. Well instead of commenti g on this issue campaign for those things, and tell those campaigning for biologicl males in women's sports, to stop campaigning on this issue, and to campaign for actual noble causes
    3
  147. That would be showing trump too much respect.
    3
  148. Are you saying biological sex does or does not exist.
    3
  149. ​​ @MarcosFMolina so does biological sex exist and have consequences.
    3
  150. But don't the statistics indicate, the biological men whatever they identify as, don't change in terms of their safeguarding threat levels, purely because of what they identify as.
    3
  151. But surely we are intelligent enough as humans to know when someone is trans, or short or tall, it's glaring fact.
    3
  152. He still does have compassion, but says biological sex exists.
    3
  153. Ukrainian and Russian Cossack dancing is great.
    3
  154. Cool we still have dragons in our stories, even in harry potter.and of course how to train your dragon.
    3
  155. Why does almost every racist comment have poor gramnar.
    3
  156. But is it fair to force this on the athletes, are their wishes to be utterly ignored.
    3
  157. What did he say, that you regard to be offensive crap.
    3
  158. Jk Rowling is a example, she is centre left, and sociallyi liberal, argued gender critical views from a feminist point of view, not biblical, so really a lot of so called social conservatives left, are out and out left wing gender critical left wingers, nor conservatives at all, indeed the insults v them, are they are radical feminists which is not conservative.
    3
  159. ❤In most situations we don't need to care, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins is also someone criticized for saying biological sex exists, but was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤ we should oppose bullying of trans people, but it is ok to sensible nuanced laws which accept sex exists.
    3
  160. 😢Listen well my kin, reality does not yield to wishes, nor does truth bend to the tides of opinion, biological sex exists, it is not a shadow not a fleeting Notion, but an enduring fact of life, male and female are not identities plucked from the air, they are the result of millenia of adapting written into a very being guiding the essence of Life itself. But now my brothers and sisters we see an alarming tale and folding. The words of women biological woman who speak with courage and clarity are being met not with dialogue but with venom they are called hateful for daring to speak the truth they are branded with vile names accused of cruelty when all they seek his fairness and protecting for themselves and their daughters so we stand by their voices are drowned out. What madness has gripped this land when the safety of women in space is meant for them their shelters their sports their private places is considered expendable in the name of a distorted ideology. Compassion does not mean ignoring reality kindness does not mean ignoring reality..to call this truth hateful if to deny reason itself even have saved us all yes but biology is not a trivial detail women's rights have been hard one fought with blood sweat and tears and we dishonor their struggles by turning away their concerns protecting the rates and dignity of women is not an attack on anyone it is an act of Justice. We must not be cowed by the search of those who demand complaints at the cost of reason to stand for truth is not cruelty to protect the rights of women is not hatred it is strength it is fairness and it is a very foundation of the society that values both reality and kindness we must support Richard Dawkins JK Rowling Graham Lincoln and all the others.😮
    3
  161. ​ @thewirah1 change the subject as you know on this issue extreme trans rights is intellectually untenable, which is why Dawkins a d Rowling win every time. We should love trans people as part of our society, like Dawkins was pals with Jan Morris, but also accept biological women exists.
    3
  162. It's not fascist to say biological sex exists, it's a clearly obvious glaring reality. It's just a reality, like being six foot or five foot,. Yes we should accept trans people, nobody should name call them, nobody should be fired or disliked for being trans, but it is not fascist to just accept biological sex exists,. Hope you have a good day, and hope trans people have good days as well. ❤
    3
  163. ​ @ScorpionSuerte what has that got to do with anything, that's not the subject
    3
  164. Read the books of Helen Joyce and you will have an understanding of the position of people from the gender critical side.
    3
  165. I think anybody who screams abuse at jk Rowling, and claims she is there arch enemy, probably has to look in the mirror and ask themselves some hard questions.
    3
  166. How dare he stand up to a orwellian orthodoxy,that hardly anyone truly believes in.
    3
  167. ​ @pipinpip as people fear defending him, if you speak up on this topic you are the victim of a hate campaign. Look at Kathleen stock fired from a university for stating sex exists and has consequences. Look at Helen Joyce Rosie duffield, Joanna cherry and ash Regan, victim of hate campaigns and cancelling for their views. Look at Richard Dawkins, Chapelle, Gervais and Rowling, huge attempts were made to cancel them for their view that biological sex exists. Plus Joe Rogan really had that against him. If you are too big, the campaign falls flat, as most people agree with them on this issue. But small fry like social workers or dance directors were fired for saying biological sex exists, till jk Rowling funded compensation cases for them. Linehan is in between neither big or small fry, which is why he has been cancelled by powerful pencil pushing high level managers, normally people I support, but not in this case, from his career of his choice, but revitalized as a standard bearer against this orwellian idealogy.
    3
  168. He did not wear a suit, so as to show he was nit part of the blue suit idiot convention, that must have ben there that day, as shoen bybtrymp, Vance, rubio abd questioner.
    3
  169. Pele is great
    3
  170. He got his suit from the bottom of a bin.
    3
  171. Because we don't have white people's toilets and black people's toilets, there is no point in having them in a post-racial society. Where as we do have women's toilets and we do have men's toilets, because most people see there's a good reason for having them out of them, is there a lot of men who are quite perverted. Ok site this wedding once there was this drunk man trying to get in the women's toilet all the time. And the woman were all telling him to f*** off, I mean he was a cis male, and well done the women, for stopping him, but that is a case in point, of why we have women's toilets and men's toilets. But the fact he was a threat was not because he was cis, it was because he was a biological male.
    3
  172. Yes, people should stop campaigning to put biological males in women's sports, and instead of that unpopular pointless aim, campaign to reduce poverty and homelessness. The independent newspaper should replace all its articles propagandizing that first world problem subject, and focus on poverty. Every person who thinks up a argument in favor of biological males competing in women's sports, should forget about it, and spend a bigger amount of time doing something to help freezing homeless people.
    3
  173. This is like people who claim the 2020 election was rigged, using dumb out of date stats. Like the ones who claimed there were less votes in the 2024 election, not bothering to find out that in some places it takes two weeks to count the votes. They need to be more detailed and nerdy. By teo weeks over 19 million more votes were counted
    3
  174. Me too
    3
  175. He has never ever ever said anything about supporting horrible things like murdering innocent people, he would never support the murder of a trans person. And how can you yell online in Twitter anyways. Stop being so angry. Calm down. Calm the language,stop the libelous hate. What a ridiculous thing to have written, what horrible horrible unfounded allegations. Why can't trans rights activists stop being so fanatical.its dreadful.
    3
  176. By being invaded by Putin.
    3
  177. ​ @SLAMBANGO 😂😂😂😂
    2
  178. So we should all be shrinking violets according to you huh.
    2
  179. ​​​​​​​ @davidshaw123451001 are you serious, with people like you around, people who assume pronouns without asking the person first, how terrible, and you still have not apologized, how can you do something so full of potential hatred and lack of compassion. Shame on you. 😭😭😭😭😭, why would you do something if such potential uncaring hate, what sort of person are you to do that. 😮Oh no, this is such a horrifying comment to have seen. Such uncompassion. It's terrifying anybody could even have written what you have here, so totally insensitive. Do you promise to change your comment to bare in mind proper pronouns use
    2
  180. Most of her support is left of centre labour voters, who acknowledge biological sex exists. They don't hate trans people, they oppose bullying v them, but just believe in safeguarding rules between men and women, and believe what someone identifies as does not in every field negate the need for safeguarding rules. We should be nice to trans people, acknowledge biological sex exists and accept it is not far right to to say so. Single sex spaces are a historical sensible idea.😊
    2
  181. Sharron Davis is a good person.
    2
  182. 😱
    2
  183. I think blaming Henry kissinger for all these actions, is pretending it was a anomoly, when actually this was what was happening in the war between the west and ussr all the time. Jfk, lbj, reagan, dulles, British governments, the ussr in Afghanistan, yes kissinger did bad stuff, but to put all the blame on him i think sounds a bit scapegoaty.
    2
  184. Would you say that if dankula was a Muslim.
    2
  185. ​ @cozy_2X I think if a Islamic extremist, made jokes about the British victims of Islamic fundamentalist terrorist attacks, they should be out on a watch list at the very least, and probably prosecuted for national security reasons. I also think the same about white nationalist extremists. The most dangerous at the moment are Islamic fundamentalists, for certain. Do you agree with me that if someone who is pro extreme Islamic fundamentalism is mocking the victims of Islamic fundamentalist terrorist attacks in Britain, that we should not have your wishy washy, namby pamby , anything goes attitude, we should be prepared to prosecute those supporting that kind of hate. Ps I also believe the people who bully gender critical people, a d who discriminate v them, should face prosecution. As jk rowling is right.
    2
  186. ​​​ @porphura4448 but there have been cases of abuse, and JK Rowling would say, 😊 a biological male who identifies as a woman, does not suddenly remove themselves from safeguarding concerns, biological meal is a biological male whether that biological male identifies as a woman or a man, identifying as a woman doesn't negate the safeguarding concerns. That is the JK Rowling View. Any more than saying you're from Swansea or Moscow or New Zealand would negate concerns. A biological male is still a biological male whatever they identify as. A a biological male is still a biological male, whether he identifies as a woman, whether he wears glasses, weather his favourite colour is green, Weber he enjoys folk music, he is still simply just a biological male.
    2
  187. It's maybe as UK comedy came from 1980s anti thatcher forces, so it is very hard to not be tribally left everywhere.
    2
  188. Intellectual wonder, is beyond class
    2
  189. Gulf of Mexico, not Gulf of America
    2
  190. There does seem to be a very uncaring attitude from trans rights activists, like that MMA fighter who seemed to be delighted at defeating what they called terfs, and broke ones skull. And also the trans rights activists in r😢pe centres in Scotland that called r😢pe victims, terfs as a dismissive insults about their desires.
    2
  191. She looks like Lauren Jackson, and nicole kidman, and cate blanchett the actress.
    2
  192. You don't understand
    2
  193. ​​ @jackspring7709 I have not said anything anti any men. I have bigged up Bronson, and Wayne, two role models for most men, and said men should protect women, which most would be proud to do. What did you do to protect the Rochdale victims other than blame a beautiful community minded Australian woman, who has likely never been there, and likely would support any society effort to root out the individuals who did those abuses. The fact you go on here and try and blame a stunningly beautiful Australian woman, of so little power, she was ordered to pay a fine for not adhering in every way to ultra woke values, shows you are hardly a well focused campaigner. I would guess you are just a malcontent firing abuse at random people over a issue you have not done much about. Correct me if I am wrong. Bring to my attention anything you have done it achieved in connection to the Rochdale abuses, give me evidence you achieved something in opposing that. Give me proof it was you personally who achieved those things. What did you do, to stop the abuses, all you seem to have done is blame a beautiful Australian woman, someone on the other side of the world. She has done something to beat silly ideas, in standing up to orwellian idealogy, what have you done in terms of Rochdale, if you don't give evidence I think we can assume nothing, except blaming a attractive Aussie, who nobody in their right mind would put in the top seven billion people, of people responsible for what happened in Rochdale. Sall is a hero. You have not given any evidence of being such. Please correct me if I am wrong, what have you done, to be seen as anything approaching her campaigning spirit, give evidence, she put her head above the parapet, what have you done,
    2
  194. So let's end women's sport you say, as 0.5 percent of biological men identify as women. interesting point of to ew. And to be honest most male golfers are big fellows, big shouldered power hitters, if they trained at rugby they would be the biggest scrum players, have you seen a South Afriican male scrum half stand by a smiling female scrum half, it's like land of the Giants meets a little gurl. For your golfing analogy there daley, faldo, and co would beat any women's team in the scrimmage. Poor example you gave there. Did you see the coed comp at the Olympics where the male swimmers towered over the women ones, or the sam we for the running events.
    2
  195. And of that tiny amount, one of them broke women's records, proving they have a unfair advantage.
    2
  196. They both pulled themselves up by their bootstraps.
    2
  197. ​ @zoeolsson5683 the amount of women who look really very much like men, is tiny. So it's just rude.
    2
  198. It won't be about societal expectations, even if a woman has short hair and wears men's clothes most people will not think they are biological meals. But if a biological meal walks into a toilet, with a big bushy beard, in certain instances this may be noted upon.
    2
  199. ​​ @alyssashady but also involves women's rights,why not interview a woman's rights activist as well. Like Riley gains. In what way does this impact LGBT rights.
    2
  200. Good luck Brazil, and well done Lula
    2
  201. No more photos of crab cats please, too scary.
    2
  202. But in society it's ok to mention the real concerns that people have. It's not a natural for a woman to be a bit worried about men in certain situations, and and for many of them it will be the fact that they are biological males. There have been events in occurrences which have underlined those fears, it's not terrible to notice those real concerns, and see if there is a tolerant and understanding way where we can understand the concerns of all members of our society including those who are worried about these laws that are being enacted. Whether a biological male identifies as a man or as a woman, at times is irrelevant to the concerns of some individuals related to these issues,
    2
  203. You miss spelt HERO
    2
  204. Lewis carol airport, would be even more confusing.
    2
  205. I would say, that we all suffer, and it is wrong to say we ignore the concerns on this topic out of some obsession to only think about trans rights. I mean think of everyone, you can be a lonely boy or lonely girl, a theilidamide sufferer, def, or disabled, or with no arms or legs, i mean we all matter, so lets not only think one group matters. Andrew gold has done good work there.
    2
  206. Why don't these people pushing for biological men in women's sport, stop that unimportant aim, and campaign against homelessness, or poverty, or something useful. Very few people want assigned at birth male, in women's sports, but helping the poor and needy would be a noble cause. Talk about a agenda, when we have poverty. I mean think about it, all these campaigners for biological males in women's sports, could spend their time, feeding the needy, clothing the poor,
    2
  207. Yes, I suppose they were not much different in some ways to Neanderthals. In that they were just another group in Europe.
    2
  208. Yes, it is a annoying issue,,
    2
  209. ​ @fromchomleystreet there is such a thing as nuance, the phrase trans women are women is just a phrase, I mean biological women still exist even if you change the definition of the word, as Shakespeare said a rose is still a rose even if by another name, the reality that xx people exist does not go away as you chant a mantra.😮
    2
  210. But science exists surely in the same world as rest of society, so surely there is some effect, science is not in another dimension. Every scientist inhabits society, and lives in it.
    2
  211. ​ @ProfessorChaos1349 but why should scientists use terms that general society does not, surely science is part of society, a integral and vital element of it's well being, not a separate unconnected thing.
    2
  212. When I say the term woman, I mean it in the sense that every tribe in history had such a word, and every language, and it is one of the most important words any language has, I am sure when homo etectus developed language it was one of the first thousand words, and it meant biological woman, as most people in society means by it, in every land today. Don't pretend a confused unclear idealogy that is trying to appropriate the word, is society, and if you think the word is unimportant, don't write loads of comments about it. Also if you think Dawkins does not know about intersex, you have a very unfair and rude lack of knowledge about him, watch his other videos and he mentions it, and says it's not a separate sex, he knows about it
    2
  213. ​​​​​ @ProfessorChaos1349 it's not misleading, intersex is not a sex, it's a perfectly normal, nothing to be ashamed about deviation from the regular wonder of the universe that is binary biological sex. Think how amazing it is that biological sex occurred from evolution, but as has been said multiple times, intersex in most cases it's just a deviation from the regular biologigy, and in a super small number of cases, harder to define, not that we have to, but it's not some brand new sex. I have nothing against you supporting trans rights, but the term woman, referred to biological women since the Neanderthals and before, the idea that a bunch of political activists can appropriate this term, is just not a goer, it's the most important terms in the lexicon in this field, whether youb are using the french, german or japanese equivalent, so in that way it is perfectly acceptable for a scientist to use it in the way he uses it, he does not have to tow a political line, of using language in the way a particular trans rights activist demands, more so as some even want to ban the term biological sex, and especially when so many sorts of things, on womens rights, and society would be affected if we just take the trans rights activist position, as paramount, and ignore every other aspect of society being affected by these issues. So no, Dawkins is right to use the words he uses, not obey the Orwellian newspeak of the more aggressive trans rights activists. He can use the term woman, in the way he intends. Ps you have the right to use the term woman in the way you wish, but don't have a right to impose your definition of the word on Dawkins, but feel free to use it in whatever way you wish. Why do trans rights activists feel it is their right to impose vast swathes of vocabulary and radically new definitions of extremely important words on society, I think they have a right to use words how they like, but it is obviously political and domineering to expect everybody else to accept new definitions of the word woman, or use terms like assigned at birth, when it's observed.
    2
  214. ​​​ @ProfessorChaos1349 nuanced, that's a word that's being misused here, in the sense that fox news or pro Highland clearances people start their sentences with the words, no it's more nuanced than you think, then proceed to say what they think, that expelling crofters was perfectly ok, or trump's mean remarks on a issue should be forgotten. It's the same here, you say it's nuanced, but just say the inaccurate idea that sex is not binary as of intersex, when intersex is clearly not a sex. Also to appropriate the term woman, a term that has existed since the Neanderthals, and to not massively caveat the consequences of this, is either deliberately spin doctor style wrong, or super naive, . The way you use the word nuanced, is like someone at a party saying to the twenty other guests, well may I in a more nuanced way have all the birthday cake for myself. Clearly the trans activist position is to claim biological sex is a impossible to understand muddied thing, that is meaningless, so the only definition we should use to define gender is self id, or a version of that, when on reality, biological sex clearly exists and for well over ninety nine percent of people is a prime detail of them, so to deny it's importance is extremist and naive. And what about when biological males have gender affirming care, to be more like biological women, a sex change operation, and such, all this proves the whole idea of a woman is based on the proven reality of biological sex existence, and to deny it's importance is just a denial of rational observations.
    2
  215. I think trans rights at its most extreme is nothing to do with feminism, in fact its quite the opposite, its people were assigned at birth male, expecting everybody to see them and their world view as what matters most, if anything its quite a pompous macho assertiveness. Also i think it actually descended off lgb rights activism, for 2 main reasons, what happened was, just like heterosexuals have various ways of being hetero, so do gay men, and some gay men see a varied gender spectrum element as important to their sexualities, so they see trans rights as integral to their sexuality, and identity, they are such a strong element of the lgb community, that this became a gay rights issue, then even though many gay men have a version of homosexuality, which is different, and sees the biological divides in sex as being fundemental to their, sexuality, these gays are ignored by what have become lgbt groups, then of course some lesbians care even more so seeing, the fundemental divides of biological sex as wholly important to them, then they were the free core of fighting intelectually against extreme trans rights in britain. They allied to a rump element of the right on this issue, and some free thinking figures on the intellectual left. The reason extreme trans rights did so well in the 2010s, was as gay rights was a massive left right political issue on the west till then, but then in the left wing Victory on gay marriage ,i believe the right surrendered, like iraqis to the Americans in the gulf war, or germans to the allies in 1945, and what had been a hard fought war of attrition became total abject absolute total surrender, so even right wing institutions surrendered totally on trans rights with no debate. The debate was picked up, and now even the centre left agree with much of the gender critical line, even after having voted aspects of trans rights through with no debate whatsoever. I mean we should have a world for all, that loves everyone, whoever they are, but most agree biological sex exists.
    2
  216. Also undestably a lot of males who are attracted to women, had gender dysphoria, and their disophoria was coated into the lgb rights panorama, which made lgb so LGBT rights more pro the trans agenda, than against, so it be same part of the LGBT ticket. Which many gender critical people could not understand as gay seems so different to trans. Also the big difference with gay rights is this impact so massively on non gay people, so instead of the live and live way being applicable, people say, how can I live in this, if I don't ask for some reasonable boundaries. I think that's why so many things became pro LGBT rights, that's my dispassionate analysis there.
    2
  217. It's called caring about other human beings.
    2
  218. ​​​​ @Lollero200q yes, let them be, but also have safeguarding for kids in terms of chemicals and surgeries, and for womens rights, have fair women's sports, where the best biological women win, let people be attracted to the sex they want, without condemnation, and have capacity for sex based women safe spaces. Let biological women and biological men be, as well, we all matter, not just some people. Love all. And you said on a manner of words you don't care if people ruin their lives, so don't pretend your on the caring side. A lot of trans activism is just people who don't care about the consequences, it's like dog eat dog capitalism. That kind of libertarian thinking is why the us has its fentanyl problem.
    2
  219. ​ @suzannehill9935 which is why jk rowling was concerned about biological males using women's safe spaces.
    2
  220. 😂 brilliante
    2
  221. Dankulas terrible act was training his dog to get excited and happy, when mentioning the gassing of victims of the Holocaust, a very unfunny and strange act. Nothing to be proud of, and anybody who condemned him for that was within their rights. Ps I think dankula should be forgiven for his stupid act, but don't act like what he did was done heroic act, I am sure he has done good stuff for people, and made good jokes in his life, but that stupid thing he did was dumb. Not that any of us are perfect, and to be honest dankulas friends should have told him it was dumb as well.
    2
  222. Evolutionary biology is a amazing topic, good questions. And sad as it may be we have to speak of this topic, well done for standing up to the Orwellian, Pythonesque, Kafkaesque, mad hatters tea party ideaology, that is gender idealogy. Dawkins and Jk Rowling are brilliant. Thanks the gods for their wisdom.
    2
  223. ​ @josephsimmons9241 the best women Athletes should be winning women's sports, it's completely unreasonable to have it any other way.
    2
  224. I don't agree with this theory that has been developed, as how come my ancestors from 30 generations ago looked more like me, than a random selection of people elsewhere to wherev they were, and they looking more like the people thirty gens beforehand .I mean they did not just come out of the ground in 1800. Though I am not critical of this guy, it's the experts who have not found out everything about DNA, they are missing something.
    2
  225. I thought it was illegal to abuse a police officer. Winston Churchill grandson once got hit by a new York policeman for saying his own name, which was the same as the former pm, the officer thought he was joking. And unlike the bizarre individuals who think insulting police is normal, he just laughed it off.
    2
  226. Nobody told z, that it was a idiot convention, and blue suits were needed for that.
    2
  227. No way, I think it is a shame she left Labour, as most of her principles are close to Labour voters and members, she certainly is not a Reform Party style person. Most of her believes are left of centre, and tie in with current Labour voters, IE those who got Labour into power.
    2
  228. It was just a cartoon, and most people would be proud for South Park to mock them, it's a badge of pride. Well I don't like them mocking vulnerable people, like the severely disabled or such, but mocking a big figure is ok.
    2
  229. Then why are mens nets higher, hmm.
    2
  230. Nobody cares about gamergate, but everybody cares about women. Well done linehan on this.
    2
  231. What is a trans issue,
    2
  232. I love your Russian accent,
    2
  233. ​​ @jeromemccollom936 it's a red herring really, 99.9 percent of people are one sex or the other, a tiny percentage are truly intersex, which is not a sex in itself, surely it's mostly binary, and with some rough edges, like every word, like cake and biscuit z or tree and bush. Or van and car. But it's really a unimportant red herring.ps some males or females have some intersex elements, but all are ok. There is nothing wrong with being intersex. Surely people say this, to make sex seem some impossible to understand topic, so then gender identity is regarded as more important, when really even that is based on sex.
    2
  234. Great article
    2
  235. Well done Dawkins and Gold, cool discussion again,
    2
  236. I remember when tories hated him for having a working class accent, they had some horrible snobs in those days,
    2
  237. But dying your hair blonde does not affect your sport ability.
    2
  238. What has he said to that you consider transphobic.
    2
  239. Trans rights, religon, Trumpism, oh the sacred cows are getting knocked down.
    2
  240. What a unpleasant rude thing to say. She does not look anything like she is trans, she looks like a pretty young blonde woman, and there is nothing wrong with that. And your horrendoys untrue remark is a nasty mean cruel and hurtful thing to say about a young biological woman. Shame on you for being nasty, or to be honest, if you can't tell the difference between a man and a woman, that's nothing to be proud about, at all. And quite something to be embarrassed about. I can tell, as I am a red blooded male. A real man. Any red blooded male can tell the difference between a man and a woman, full stop, evolution made us. Ps no offense to the trans person, but no way is it a sign of intelligence to not know someone was born a woman, it's not clever or righteous, it is simply a lack of acquired skills,.
    2
  241. So you accept there is something called a man, define it.
    2
  242. Very clever man, sure he does lovely conversations, but I disagree on his saying he is a monarchist, I mean he talks about people who were not monarchs, the leader of China and Singapore, surely north Korea is more of a monarchy than them, and mao who he opposed was more powerful than deng. Also he blames the Sauds partly for the Uighurs, and it is is a monarchy. Also he glories in Elizabeth the first, but she was not that different to the thing we condemn Cromwell for in Ireland, England was in severe depression when she finished her reign, and she had lots of Catholics killed, and loads of Baptist's died in her jails, due to ill-treatment, i mean i could not have done a good job as her if i was ruler at the time, but she is no great symbol of royalism, and look at henry viii he killed loafs of rebels, wives and advisors, and heading off to russia they had iva the terrible at the time, who was massacring whole cities, and had rebels killed by his army, so i think he needs to find something 😮better than monarchy. Look at Russia in the 1600s at fell in population by a third as of misrule.
    2
  243. The trans butcher case is a example. Look up Melrose.
    2
  244. Did not know you could do that
    2
  245. Are you saying he is super sexy. When you say provocative, I know all the ladies agree, but he can't help it. Don't be jealous.
    2
  246. I agree, you get more money in men's sports as also.
    2
  247. It's not arrogant to say what you honestly believe.
    2
  248. 😮Have you seen the Wikipedia article on gender critical feminism, it's just a Orwellian hit job, trying to link the centrist belief, with the far right. This is done by mentioning the words, conservative, far right, right wing, anti trans and terf, together over one hundred times in the article, like someone in a Orwellian 15 minutes of hate, but left wing and socialism, something most gender critical people are, is mentioned no times. Also i looked at Wikipedia article on Hitler, it mentions far right once, and in relation to where he is is in the photo, so Wikipedia is more nuanced on the most evil man in history, than on the moderate centrist belief of gender critical feminism. . I think gender idealogy believers are ironically the most far right Orwellian bigots , totally unprepared to listen to others.
    2
  249. Amen and agree.
    2
  250. Nothing,
    2
  251. And in wales, my town has names pf roads, to those places. The Oxford Street example is cool. 🎉 ,.
    2
  252. Nixon lost to Vietnam in a war, trump lost to Russia.
    2
  253. That's not very apt or explanation, I prefer Steinbeck to your writings. 😊just calling someone a meaningless insult is of no use to the conversation.
    2
  254. He is an advo cat
    2
  255. Jk Rowling is a great author.
    2
  256. No,
    2
  257. ​@KazHughesa rose is a rose even if by another name. Even if you appropriate a word, it does not stop biological females existence, and needing safe spaces, and women's sports.
    2
  258. Comedy is meant to be funny. Insults are meant to be offensive, I mean you can find both funny.
    2
  259. But surely the fact you use the term rant, is indicative that you are being bigoted in how you are unable to listen to her views, without resorting to belittling abuse. On no level are you tolerant of her actual reasnoble fears. You just throw some intolerant rage at her, with no understanding.
    2
  260. ​​​ @HowardNorris-gh1jw you put Views in quotation marks, what arrogance. It is this arrogant aggressive belittling of anybody who dates to not agree with every current gender idealogy belief, that is so unbecoming of certain strands of trans rights activism.
    2
  261. My advice to women, is keep the pronouns for your sex never let her slip away, and andrew gold is good.
    2
  262. 😢 yes it's disappointing
    2
  263. This daft extremism, of calling anybody who opposes biological males in women's sports, anti trans and bigots, just got trump elected, what a ridiculous thing for these out of touch orwellian idealogues to have done. Could they not they have solved homelessness or something instead. Love to everyone including trans, but lusten to the public i say, on issues that affect them.
    2
  264. People who argue for trans rights, seem to be very aggressive, and why do you talk about steel boots, I think aggressively arguing for biological men in women's sports, is actually very right wing, arguing for the strong to oppress the weaker. And why not put the biological males, including trans women in the men's team, you don't mind men and women being on the same teams, so surely you have no problem with that, ok that is sorted.
    2
  265. ❤ to Puerto Rico. Down with hate.
    2
  266. But what will happen to us alliances, and the Western alliance.
    2
  267. She is not a darling of the far right, lots of left wingers like jk Rowling and Richard Dawkins support her, gender critical beliefs are left wing, those who try to censor gender critical views, are Orwellian bullies.
    2
  268. The only guy insulting presidents was trump
    2
  269. ​​ @yellowhorsecj Helen Joyce would not support forced operations on intersex people, and neither would I. I say intersex people are not the same subject as trans, we should love both, but they are not the same category I would say. Helen Joyce is just saying biological sex exists, she does not say she supports forced operations on children,, like you mention, if anything she probably says she opposed such things. I think she is a loving woman.
    2
  270. This Wes streeting seems sensible on this issue. Like Rosie Duffield.
    2
  271. Is that a tip from your previous experience.
    2
  272. ​​​​​​​​​ @vasilysidorov9502 so in your own experience, is it is easier to beg with a dog, or without, and do you in your experience feel using a placard while sitting at train station, is better than not. You seem a expert on this begging, I want to know, have you begged much. If so, sorry, and I hope things get better for you. ❤ There is always hope, and many who can help you. A good hot soup kitchen is good. I have given money to the homeless, and support charity. Pus a effectual state, and good kind values. Chin up, keep positive. Sorry
    2
  273. ​​​ @JC-1405 but there are laws in this country where it's illegal to discriminate against people, for protected beliefs.and believing biological sex exists, is a protected belief. It would be wrong to fire people for voting labour, or Tory or lib Dem or green, or brexit, it is wrong to discriminate against people just as they expressed opinions that are perfectly legal, and the vast majority of all people, including Richard Dawkins, JK Rowling, Robert Winston and all our last four prime ministers, indeed possibly every pm we have ever had,have some level of agree with. These people for all I know may be full on believers in extreme gender idealogy, and hate him as they disagree with his point of views, but they had no right to ban one of the greatest comedy writers of a generation for him not falling in line with gender idealogy zealotry. Surely
    2
  274. ​​​​ @JC-1405 yes it is, if you speak up on this topic you are the victim of a hate campaign. Look at Kathleen stock fired from a university for stating sex exists and has consequences. Look at Helen Joyce Rosie duffield, Joanna cherry and ash Regan, victim of hate campaigns and cancelling for their views. Look at Richard Dawkins, Chapelle, Gervais and Rowling, huge attempts were made to cancel them for their view that biological sex ecists. Plus Joe Rogan really had that against him. If you are too big, the campaign falls flat, as most people agree with them on this issue. But small fry like social workers or dance directors were fired for saying biological sex exists, till jk Rowling funded compensation cases for them. Linehan is in between neither big or small fry, which is why he has been cancelled by powerful pencil pushing high level managers, normally people I support, but not in this case, from his career of his choice, but revitalized as a standard bearer against this orwellian idealogy.
    2
  275. He also appeals to most people in every country in the world, who agree biological sex exists,even Keir Stamer think biological males should not be in women's sports. As of gender gender critical campaigners like jk Rowling and Richard Dawkins and Rosie duffield and Robert Winston and Alex salmond and ash Regan and Joanna cherry, extreme trans rights ideology is not running rampant in Britain like it is in Canada and Australia. Most people agree biological sex exists, it is not a far right belief, it is a moderate sensible mainstream beliy,even Britain's main communist party agree with most gender critical beliefs.
    2
  276. The snp, leader John Swinney says there are only two genders. The Tory leader won their leadership election on this issue. Keir Stamer is vehemently against biological males in women's sports, his successor in 2028, wes streeting also, and even Nigel farage disagrees with gender idealogy, as to George Galloway and the main British communist party, and former ssp leader tommy Sheridan. Most people agree with linehan on most issues,
    2
  277. There have now been six first ministers of Wales, alun michael, rhodri morgan, carwyn jones, mark drakeford, and Vaughan Gething, and all were Labour, i wonder who the next shall be, obviously Labour, i am not sure if the next after that will be labour, plaid or conservative, as it will be a mid term of stamer election, i predict labour will win, but maybe plaid or the tories could sneak a win, so maybe the eighth first minister shall not be labour, or maybe they shall. 2026 is the date of the next Welsh election.
    2
  278. Father Ted is brilliant, I mean did you have your funny bone removed or something. 😮ps, whatever you say, he is entitled to believe only biological women should use women's toilets,
    2
  279. Visit Hereford, it is quite nice.
    2
  280. Biological women exist, there is no shame in admitting that glaring reality.
    2
  281. I went to Prague airport, it was not like this. But i bought a book by kafka in the house where hd wrote it, in Prague castle. Also had some goose.
    2
  282. Good zingers by Zelensky against the douchebag journalist, about wearing a better suit.
    2
  283. He did not want to make Europe strong for Europeans, he killed millions of slavs, and actually the Jews were European, just as much as Germans.
    2
  284. What has he said that you regard as transphobic, I thought hd seemed rational.
    2
  285. ​ @madnezz1961 whether I watched it or not, I shall only answer when you answer. so what was said in the interview,that you feel deserves the categorization you stated, I saw some comments said it was good, so give me the reasons for why you say this about it.
    2
  286. ​​ @madnezz1961 I did watch it, a d was waiting for you to say what you found transphobic, so I could find out what is regarded as transphobic, can you say what was said that you regard as transphobic. Just say, so, otherwise I will just assume it was not transphobic,what did I miss, please say what you regarded in the interview as transphobic, if you don't say anything I shall have to assume it is fair for people to say it was not transphobic as you have not stated what you say was transphobic about it. 😊✔️
    2
  287. ​ @madnezz1961 Thank you for your response, I just think, saying, so and so is transphobic, because they had someone on the show, who you regard as transphobic, does not cut it with me. Otherwise someone could say anyone is transphobic,without supplying a reason they regard them as so, and say therefore that means they are transphobic. I mean on that basis everybody on earth is transphobic, as you say Dawkins is transphobic as he had Joyce on his show, then don't explain what he as transphobic about him or Joyce, then does that mean the guy here is transphobic as he had Dawkins on his show, does that make you transphobic as you watched this YouTube video. I mean that does not cut it with me, I think transphobic behavior, is someone shouting abuse at a trans person, or banning them from being a secretary or something just for being trans, I don't think we should regard making clear unhateful comments about biological sex existing,which we all agree it does, and saying there should be limitations in terms of who competes in women's sports, and uses women's safe spaces, I do t think it's is fair to regard that a transphobic, as to be honest it's a reasonable debate, maybe we should go for the trans rights viewz or the gender critical view, but uts a ok debate, as long as you respect trans people as our fellow citizens deserving of happiness which Dawkins a pal of jan morris, and joyce a kind mother, do.
    2
  288. ​I am not going to address every point you make, my main annoyance is people being called transphobic for saying biological sex exists and matters, I don't think it's fair to call people hateful for expressing concerns about biological males in women's sports, or biological males in women's safe spaces, or for questioning other elements of what is occurring. When people like Dawkins were friends with Jan Morris before most of his haters were born. And we should not live on data alone. There is a old saying there are three kinds of lies, lies,damned lies and statistics. I believe that people's experiences are vital to our understanding of the world x and the letter he received is as much evidence as anything else. the stats can be moulded and manipulated to argue any cause, while a simple letter like that can show how people are actually experiencing life. Also the stats argument can say things like, well it was only one person, one life, one stat, whereas that letter listed to a real person and treated that person like a real life, so he was good to do that.
    2
  289. ​​​​ @madnezz1961 But that is the massive thing that we are talking about. What language should I use instead, please tell me, as I feel there is a legitimate argument against some of the alternative terms. What terms should I use instead. I think if I said trans woman, it would sound like I think trans women should not be in women's.sport as they are trans, which is not so, the reason people oppose trans women in women's sports, is nothing what so ever to do with them being trans it's the the fact biologicl sex exists. And it's utterly unfair for you to say I must use language which misinterprets the reason I am giving. It should not be classed as transphobic for someone to say biological sex when that's what they are talking about. It's utterly unfair and mean to demand I change my language to suit one point of view. It's like in newspeak when they tried to ban some words so it would be impossible to even think a different way to the ingsoc orthodoxy. It's so unfair for this to be your demand, and your calling transphobic for just saying something that biological sex exists, which everybody says even trans activists accept, its just so mean and unfair. We don't hate trans people, we just say biological sex exists and that is not hateful. I would never say anything mean to a trans person, I would try to make them feel comfortable, and accept them, even used their pronouns, but you are saying I can't use a term, you accept exists, how do you square that, I try to be a good person, and hate bullies, but why do you try to make me feel guilty for using a term that you accept is true, and we all know is true. How can that be offensive. Please tell me. I mean if we use the term biological sex it does not in any way change someones gender does it. A trans woman is still the gender they choose, all that is happening is we are highlighting the issue of interest, the biological sex issue, which we all accept exists. And when that is the issue at hand it matters, if it is not the issue at hand it does not matter. It's like it would be mean for a NBA player to call me short all day, but if I kept asking why I can't reach the net, it would be ok to say, it's as I'm shorter than most NBA giants, if it's the issue at hand it's ok, if it's not, it's not, but in this issue it is. I mean think of it this way, when people oppose trans women in women's sports they don't oppose non binary women footballers, they do also oppose cis men in women's sports, it's nothing to do with them being trans, that makes them opposed to them being in women's sports, so it is utterly unfair for you to demand we use a term, that is not what our beliefs are about,vwe don't oppose trans women in women's sports as they are trans, or as they identify as women, we just want women's sport to be kept for a particular group, that can only be phrased in a way, that you are unfairly labelling as unacceptable language,even though you accept that such a group exists, the initials are b w, and it's not a offensive term in the context of this debate, as it's what we are talking about.
    2
  290. ​​​​​​​​​ @madnezz1961 I mean like this, if someone says they object to trans women in women's sports z and some says why, isn't it ok, how do they say it in clear English. How can that be said in a way you tolerate as acceptable. Surely the only way you can say it is to mention biological sex, which you accept exists, just like it's sometimes ok to say someone is tall, or short, but not to say it all the time, like when you are ordering food at a MacDonalds etc. how can we debate these topics if done the language being used, essential to one sides argument is banned, when it's not in itself offensive. It's not a gratuitous thing to mention, when it's the whole nature of what one side is saying. It's completely unreasonable for you to demand we use your language when that language distorts what we are saying. You may be right, you may be wrong, maybe trans women should be in women's.sport and safe spaces either wholly or partially, but it's unfair to take away the language we use which explains what we believe, when even you agree those factors are true, I mean that's unreasonable. I say we should love trans people, but it's ok to debate the nuances of laws and how they Impa ct everyone, in a participating democracy I would not minid if friend or relative or the pm or anynody was trans, or even a royal, or the two guys here, all I am saying is its ok to sensibly debate the nuances.of this issue, and it not hateful to do so. Love to you, and great happiness to you. And happiness to trans people as well.
    2
  291. Purely hateful. They are quite mad campaigners.
    2
  292. You can tell pretty much all the time if someone is male or female. That's nothing to be ashamed of. We can as of millions of years of evolution. And the whole idea that women exists is as biology of billions of years created men and women, in actual fact, a rose is a rose, biological women exists and the whole concept of womenhood comes from biological women existing. If a rose went by any other names it would still be a rose, if we don't have the term women, women still exist, as they just do, as of biological reality from evolution.
    2
  293. Japan and UK have similar per capita. Tokyo is even more dominant by far.
    2
  294. ​​ @ScorpionSuerte yet another innacuracy, it's actually 2369 comments, get your facts straight, and I ain't your bro, I ain't your bro, or buddy, or mate, and would not ever want to be, and that's a fact, sorry should I say thabs a fact.
    2
  295. Did you Miss spell biologist.
    2
  296. Listen well my kin, reality does not yield to wishes, nor does proof bend to the tides of opinion, biological sex exists, it is not a shadow not a fleeting Notion, but an enduring fact of life, male and female are not identities plucked from the air, they are the result of millenia of adapting written into a very being guiding the essence of Life itself. But now my brothers and sisters we see an alarming tale and folding. The words of women biological woman who speak with courage and clarity are being met not with dialogue but with venom they are called hateful for daring to speak the truth they are branded with vile names accused of cruelty when all they seek his fairness and protecting for themselves and their daughters so we stand by their voices are drowned out. What madness has gripped this land when the safety of women in space is meant for them their shelters their sports their private places is considered expendable in the name of a distorted ideology. Compassion does not mean ignoring reality kindness does not mean ignoring reality..to call this truth hateful if to deny reason itself even have saved us all yes but biology is not a trivial detail women's rights have been hard one fought with blood sweat and tears and we dishonor their struggles by turning away their concerns protecting the rates and dignity of women is not an attack on anyone it is an act of Justice. We must not be cowed by the search of those who demand complaints at the cost of reason to stand for truth is not cruelty to protect the rights of women is not hatred it is strength it is fairness and it is a very foundation of the society that values both reality and kindness we must support Richard Dawkins JK Rowling Graham Lincoln and all the others.😮
    2
  297. He was great friends with Jan Morris before most of you were born , he understands this issue perfectly.
    2
  298. It was as disgraceful this lecturer was fired for expressing a perfectly reasonable and dependable position. If anything the people who fired her should be prosecuted as Orwellianism bigots. Their idealogy is alice in wonderland dogs breakfast, completely indefensible in reality, which us why jk Rowling a d Richard Dawkins dont agree with them. I mean we should love everyone, but its not reasonable to say biological sex has no consequences.
    2
  299. So if a neuron in piers Morgan s brain,says he is the most handsome man in the world, does that mean he is.
    2
  300. Interesting
    2
  301. I would say, to all those who speak up for gender critical beliefs, thank you for being a friend, andrew gold is great.
    2
  302. No he is just saying biological sex exists, and it's ok to say that, as it does, a s most left wingers know that.
    2
  303. ​​​ @madnezz1961  it are you repeating right wing talking points, and hating on persecuted trans people, by saying biological sex exists, no, and neither is Dawkins. We can accept trans people but also except biological sex exists, and remember it's important nuances.
    2
  304. What is gender, please define what it is, surely it only means anything if you have to some a extent a belief biological sex exists. Or is there a other interpretation, what is gender if we say biological sex does not in any sense exist. Please explain, I love to learn, can you tell me, what gender is, in your way of thinking.
    2
  305. ​​​​ @denzellmovies so you are using fancy words, neurological, to say, if someone feels they are a gender, that means they are. So that's what gender is based on ok. Well I feel we have to remember biological sex is important, and should not be ignored in policy. And surely everything happening in the brain is happening in a component of your biology, it's not separate from biology. Sure that is a fact, as my neurology came up with that fact.
    2
  306. ​​​ @denzellmovies so are you saying if you call yourself he, and wear mens clothes, that's what gender is, surely that is less important than biological sex, or is gender more complicated than that or are you saying the quiet bit out loud.. what about maoist China, they all wore the same there. But there were still men and women.
    2
  307. ​ @denzellmovies but is it fair for you to take the terms men, and women, which have existed since the times of the Neanderthals to your belief system. What do you say to those who believe in the time immemorial definition of men and women, purely by biological sex, and not by gender,what are your thoughts on that.
    2
  308. I love this channel, its like Richatd Dawkins and darwin thought it up.
    2
  309. Down with orwellian trans rights bullies, up with jk Rowling.
    2
  310. Anyway, thats all from me, good happiness to every person.
    2
  311. That is a dreadful thing to say. This is the aggressive tactic of trans rights activists to say the most horrible things they can about JK Rowling, the problem for your activist, is everybody knows what she said. She has never said the people of colour don't look female enough, she was referring to some specific athletes, where there has been controversy about. She was not saying it because of their colour or their race and that is obviously the case. As look at the fact she has been willing to criticise athletes, of all backgrounds, and ethnicities, on the biological women's sports issue. She has supported Riley Gaines over Lia Thomas. And many women of colour agree with the JK Rowling position, for instance wnba great Lisa Leslie, has expressed concern over the inclusion of biological males in women's sports. Rowling also criticized The White Italian paralompian who competed in the women's events. The way you have described us very unfair and offensive, and incredibly rude. She also has defended the greatest woman tennis player, Serena Williams from racist haters. Everybody who understands this topic knows that is not what she meant. So all that has to happen is reasonable people look at this topic and see how extreme and hysterical and unreasonable your side are, and they just can't listen to your arguments. And she does not engage in Holocaust denial. That is an atrocious thing to say. You are not helping your side by being so aggressive and unpleasant towards anybody who speaks out against aspect of your beliefs. You must learn to be more understanding. I know that is not possible, so this is why this announcement by the supreme Court, was not treated with the horror that you may have expected from a liberal middle class society, it is because your side have been so unreasonable to people who have made even the slightest objections to any element of your beliefs.
    2
  312. ​​​ @rosieo5875 give the quotations that prove what your mean spirited claims. And would you like it if people claimed you had said those things, would you like it if people claim that you said those terrible things about the Holocaust and people of colour, that you claim she said, if you had not. In reality many trans rights activists, launch misinformation and hate campaigns against any famous left wing person who criticises the claim trans women are women. Give the quotations to prove your terrible offensive libellous claims about JK Rowling. Where are they come on come on give them.
    2
  313. ​​​ @rosieo5875 you haven't reported anything that she has said. You have said a vial and horrible thing about her, I'm not giving it any credibility. This is the epitome of the pathetic childishness of extreme trans rights activism which I hope you should ditch. Anybody with any sense knows that she would never deny the Holocaust. The only reason why people are claiming that is because they hate her so much because she doesn't agree with their intellectually weak specific view on trans rights. So in their typical orwellian / childish manner, they think of the most horrible things you could say about somebody on the left, when clearly the things they are saying are utter rubbish, and if you searched hard you could make up rubbish about anybody if just because you disagree with them. And to be honest that is traditionally a far-right and centre right trick not a trick of the left. Because the left are about people coming together, not about hate and demonising. Please can these hateful nasty unpleasant people stop their horrible lies about JK Rowling.
    2
  314. Statement from J.K. Rowling, 14th March 2024 While I’m used to the gross distraction techniques used by the more extreme faction of trans activism, the claim that I am a holocaust denier is baseless and disgusting.
    2
  315. ​​​​​ @Tamos40000 You tell me, I have not written anything about fever dreams. Please elaborate. All that has happened, is there are a lot of people who don't like the fact, that she comes from a position, that states biological males and biological females remain that whatever they identify as. So as of that a lot of people want to get at her, as an example, they want to make that an opinion that is not allowed to be believed or stated. That's all that happened. And there will be people who will keep on grinding at her and grinding at her, but it doesn't stop the reality, more and more and more people have come to state the same thing, so it has been impossible to suppress the opinion she was being condemned for, no matter what horrible things people say about her. Why can't you just accept she has a different opinion to you, somebody having a different opinion to you does not make them beyond the pale. If anything you're doing a Barbra Streisand effect on her. When it would have been far more sensible to have said, you're entitled to your position, and I am entitled to my position, but we can still be friends.
    2
  316. ​​​​​​​​​​ @Tamos40000 I have just looked it up, and as far as I am aware, JK Rowling has never supported the burning of books. In fact if anything, it was the anti JK Rowling activists, who wanted to ban her books, and cancel her video game, even though it had a trans character. It has been the people against gender critical beliefs, who have been trying to ban and cancel, trying to ban Kathleen stock from speaking at Oxford, all sorts of things like that. I remember there was one book seller at Waterstons, who said that all a US female authors gender critical books should be burned, and they tried to cancel Chapelle, and get Rosie duffield expelled from labour. It certainly is not the JK Rowling side, that have been trying to censor and ban cancel. Remember that SnP, member of Parliament, Joanna cherry, she was banned from speaking at a comedy club because she had gender critical pro JK Rowling opinions,, it was not the gender critical people who have been the censors, it has been the trans activists who have been trying to ban people all along. It's like this, I may not agree with every tenet of communism, of of every one of its thinkers, but it does not mean I support burning their books like the Nazis did to communist books. I don't support every element of anti gender critical idealogy, but I don't support burning the books of anti gender critical authors. The comparison by your side is I feel a extreme and bitter campaign against gender critical people and their works, and you know, not capable of understanding that there's an alternative position to the anti gender critical side. It has pushed everybody away from you. In 2016 your side had popular support, but the constant kind of hyperbole from your side has pushed everybody away, so something that would never have been possible in 2016, the supreme court judgement has made a huge decision and there has been no popular opposition to it. This toxicity of this debate is awful. Why can't we just be nice to trans people, but acknowledge the position that biological sex exists is acceptable. Also there was a dance company founder, who was fired from the company she founded, for expressing mildly gender critical beliefs. There was a guy in the music industry, who experienced the same stuff, he was fired because of a campaign to get him fired for making vanilla remarks on puberty blockers, which to some extent of been supported by the cass report, a a Newcastle United fan, who happened to be a lesbian, was banned from the club, ironically owned by the famously not pro gay, kingdom of Saudi Arabia, as she made mildly vanilla gender critical remarks. Thete was an attempt to jail a woman in Norway, for not accepting preferred pronouns dependent on self identity. And the jailing of a teacher in Ireland for not adhering in every way to the new ideology. In fact your ideology is so extreme, that on some considerations you're not even allowed to mention biological woman, in a mild vanilla debate on trans rights,which is so largely new speak it's ridiculous.
    2
  317. ​​ @Tamos40000 I don't think she has denied that books were burned. To me the comment she is making, is it criticising a political position, is completely ok, and is not the same as burning the books of those people who have those beliefs. I don't agree with every Marxist philosopher in history, some people interpret a marxist leninist, as different to a maoist, I myself am more a traditional social democrat, who admires certain egalitarian beliefs of the left. But that does not mean I would ever support burning das capital, or the Little red book. I can disagree with somebody's political beliefs, but it does not automatically mean I support somebody burning their books. But the extreme trans right position, seems to believe that if you don't agree with every aspect of their beliefs, then that makes you exactly the same as somebody who is burning their books, which is completely unreasonable to think. I am sure they would have burned George Galloway's books, I would condemn that, I don't agree with everything he believes, but here somebody who disagrees with elements of trans rights fundamentalism. If a Nazi burned one of George Galloway's books, the fact that a trans rights activist, disagrees with the position of George Galloway on this issue, does not make that trans rights actiivist, a Holocaust denier. The same goes here, the fact I don't agree with every aspect of trans rights ideology, does not mean I support burning the books of people who do support it, and it is absolutely the case, disagreeing with aspects of trans rights idealogy, does not make someone a Holocaust denier. Your form of shoehorning in that claim, is is literally beyond belief.
    2
  318. ​​ @Tamos40000 your sides orwellian campaign to cancel and ban people, and misinterpret them on a horrendous scale for expressing gender critical views, is the epitome of toxic.
    2
  319. ​ @Tamos40000 but your claim seems to be saying, that if you don't agree with someone's political beliefs, that that is exactly the same as burning their books. Therefore if you don't agree with them, then your denying the Holocaust, but only in the insultingly litoral sense, that Holocaust, means fire. No I disagree with your political beliefs, but I don't support burning the books of your political opinions, and in the context of the Holocaust, the Holocaust refers to the murder of 6 million Jews and many other minorities. As someone of sonne gypsy heritage myself, I feel it is quite sick and quite disturbing to pretend that burning a book equates to the same as killing a human being. I don't support burning books but burning books is not the same as murdering millions of people. It's absolutely disgraceful to put them in the same pedestal. I condemn the burning of books, as I would assume jk Rowling does, but that is a whole different level to the Holocaust killing people. JK Rowling should be suing these people, and actually the anti-defamation organisation should be suing them as well for comparing the burning of books to The killing of millions of Jews. JK Rowling should sue them for claiming she supports burning books, and the anti defamation league should be suing them for equating burning books, to killing people. And the biggest irony of all, is it is the trans rights actiivists who have been doing the cancelling and some of even talked about burning the books of gender critical people.
    2
  320. ​​​​​​​​​​ @Tamos40000 the truth is extreme trans rights activists don't like JK Rowling, because she doesn't agree with the idea of declaring biological woman, a subset of woman, and renaming them chest feeders, or some other unpleasant dehumanising term like that. As shown by the fact, Graham Linehan is banned from British comedy for his gender critical stance, but jimmy carr, made a joke which many said glorified the murder of gypsies in the Holocaust, but he gets to present shows, with the same comedians who refuse to work with Graham Linehan just for saying biological sex exists. And PS I would not want to be friends with somebody as unpleasant, desperate to find reasons to dislike someone, and rude at you anyway. But gender critical people and people of all stripes, should still try and be friends and friendly with, people who happen to be trans etc. but we should be nice to trans people and also accept biological sex exist. And I don't agree with discriminating against people for being trans, nobody should be fired for being trans or harassed for being trans. But I do understand that there are complex debates and nuances which recognise clearly biological sex exists, it is a glaringly obvious fact, and it is not bigoted for biological woman to to haveam safeguarding rules about biological males, and in many cases that is about their sex not their gender identity, as it is the sex the biological sex which is the thing that creates the concern. So it is a reasonable debate, and we should lower the toxicity, and accept there are concerns which biological women women have which we should listen to and understand clearly. 😊
    2
  321. ​​​​​​​​ @Tamos40000 she's not denying they burning of the bookd, she is denying that criticising elements of trans rights ideology, is the same as burning books on trans rights idealogy. And even if she had denied the burning of those books, it would not be the the same as denying the killing of 6 million Jews or, gypsies, and as . myself , as somebody with gypsy heritage, I myself see the difference between burning groups of people like myself, and burning a book which is just made of paper, as completely different things, and I am offended that you are comparing burning books to killing human beings. Please apologise to me, for comparing burning pieces of paper, to the Holocaust , which was about killing people of my ethnicity. And unlike those trans activists about GC books, she does not support the burning of books. You should admit that your claims are monsterous, and the insult to the 6 million Jews who died in the Holocaust, and the 250,000 gypsies off my ethnicity, who were murdered by the Nazis. You should be ashamed of your disgusting miss interpretations, and it shows how the dreadfully toxic your campaigns are. And anybody who knows anything about the subject of what she said and what your claiming, knows that what you are doing is disgraceful. Shame on you for trying to equate not agreeing with every tenet of trans rights positions ideology, with the murder of 6 million Jews, shame on you, you should be very ashamed.
    2
  322. ​​​​ @Tamos40000 you did not provide proof, you provided proof that she were shocked, that somebody would claim that criticising elements of trans rights idealogy, is the same as burning books on the subject. And they are not the same. Then you claimed that if she had done that it would be effectively Holocaust denial, and I as a person who has a member of an ethnicity that was killed in the Holocaust, find it incredibly offensive for you to compare burning a piece of paper to killing human beings. This just shows that trans rights extremism, is a hateful idealogy, that tries to think of the most hurtful and hateful things it can about people who disagree with it. It is an extremist ideology, as it represents anybody who disagrees with it as beyond the pale. That is not true about gender critical people, Isaiah prepared to debate with their opponents on the issues, rather than dehumanize the people who are putting forward the opposing political views. Your brand of trans rights activism is clearly a unpleasant aggressive attacking viewpoint, that is not compatible with democratic debate of understanding of other people's views and beliefs. You have chosen to dismiss other people, and think of the most offensive things you can about people of different opinions. This is more like a kind of a Russian nationalist tactic of attacking with hate filled extremism anybody who disagrees with you. You haven't provided any real evidence of your claim, and you should be ashamed of your disgraceful attacking of a person who hasn't said what you claim they say, as far as the evidence you indicate. And considering all the evil people that are in the world who you could malign and condemn, all the dictators and kings of dictatorships. It speaks volumes about you that you have decided to attack a beloved children's author, and horribly misrepresent a tweet that you have seen. And the fact you haven't apologised to me a person of Gypsy ethnicity, for your claims, also speaks volumes. Shame on you.
    2
  323. ​​​ @Tamos40000 thinking about it again, even though I don't agree that she was denying that specific books were burned during the Nazi regime.I don't think that most people consider the burning of any book, as really a car part of the Holocaust, the Holocaust describes The killing of 6 million Jews, 250000 gypsies and many other minorities, when people talk about the horrors of the Holocaust they are not talking about the Nazi book burnings. It's not a technicality, a human life is more significant even than the most valuable book in history. So for you to be calling her a Holocaust denier, over the burning of a book, a claim about her you haven't provided evidence for in my view, is just a symbol of the hatefulness of a lot of trans rights campaigners, of wanting to think of the most horrible hateful thing they can think of about people who disagree with their opinions. The Nazi book burnings were a Nazi book burning, that is a different thing to killing lots of human beings, you should be able to recognise the difference between the Nazis killing a human being which was a horrible horrible horrible thing for them to have done, and the Nazis burning books which was terrible, but not comparible to killing people, that's not a technicality, the Nazis killing a person is different to the Nazis the burning a book. You should be able to see the difference.
    2
  324. ​​​​​​ @Tamos40000 you have not provided clear evidence that she did deny that. And even if she did say that, which you have not provided evidence for, that is not what your side claims. Your side claimed that she has a Holocaust denier, I have seen that stated on Wikipedia articles from around the world. When she clearly is not a Holocaust denier. Your side are making horrible horrible horrible ghastly claims about her, because you can't defeat her on the main point, but she doesn't agree with your categorisation that biological males who identify as women get classed with biological woman. So because she doesn't agree with that, trans rights activists say the most horrible horrible horrible things about her, and then absurdly don't see these horrible things, about people with power like Putin, or kings of Arab countries, who are doing fireworks things to LGBT people. Shame on your people's terrible lies about her. You have also used weasel words, to not deny, the ghastly horrible vial claims about her. You have not denied those vile claims about her, which is typical of trans rights extremism, which all too often is a woman hating macho uncaring offensive ideology, that attacks it's critics in the most horrendous cowardly ways they can think of. You should be ashamed that you have not condemned the vial criticisms of her, you have pushed all decent thinking people away from your agenda, and USA and Britain are right, to look away from your activism. And I don't think any sensible person, regards every single thing the Nazis did as the Holocaust. The Holocaust was a specific and horrific event, find it undermines it's status if JK Rowling, you put burning a pile of books, in with the horrific murder of millions of people including my ethnicity, shame on you.
    2
  325. I saw the crown jewels
    2
  326. Yes, Colin wright, could be called Colin is right.
    2
  327. ​ @victortorres1585 thanks you have placated my tears, thank the heavens for your kindness,
    2
  328. The people are rising up against this heroically and powerfully..
    2
  329. Yes, aspects are kind of extra legal,
    2
  330. He defended people then, brought great laughter,band is still defending women's rights, like jk Rowling a hero. Down with extreme trans activists who hate graham linehan for saying biological women, and biological sex exists.
    2
  331. ​​​​​​​​​ @denzellmovies good correction, it was someone called Zoey tur, who made that threat to shapiro. i am not saying running a marathon is masculine, but running 50 of them, to great acclaim, is not a famously effeminate activity. The whole idea of the word feminine is based on the idea biological women exist, and things they do are classed as feminine, things biological men do are classed as masculine, if a biological male behaves very masculine, and macho, but his brain waves are similar to a woman's usual brain waves, and maybe some of these such folk believe they are women, and some believe they are men, what should society do. I say we still accept biological sex exists, and is very important, and it's ok to accept it's important in policy making.the problem with your argument is that plenty of biological males who identify as women, who are actually as macho as most other biological males, so whats the big deal about the brain waves, why does that mean anything. Are you agreeing that if a biological male identifies as a woman, and his brain waves and patterns are similar to a woman's, then it certainly does not mean that he will be more inclined to statistically feminine traits in personality, of on average being much less aggressive, and certainly won't be the case he shall automatically a kind of shrinking violet, dainty feminine jane austen character lady, stuck in a biological males body. I am not being mean there, but if you look a trans rights campaigners and their aggressiveness, it's often far more macho than feminine, correct me if i am wrong. I mean I like izzard who is a great comedian, and labourite, but I remember one of izzards shows had a bit, where izzard was rightly proud of fighting back some thugs who made some homophobic bullying remarks towards said izzard,, while look at Riley gaines, when she had some aggressive bullies surrounding and intimidate her she did a normal feminine thing of seeking safety. I mean look at all these let women speak events where a bunch of middle aged female professors stand at a street corner just making a speech, and then tra activists make threats and come looking for a physical fight,, and have banners making terrible threats about what they dismissively and macho and dehumanisingly call terfs. Surely the brain waves or pattern thing does not change the reality, that biological sex exists.
    2
  332. ​ @denzellmovies well so that's your view then, that's great, I have no problem with you thinking this way. All I say is biological sex exists, and nobody should be called a bigot for saying it exists, and should matter on state policy. In my experience biological men are on average much more aggressive than biological women, but that's ok. Ps Serena Williams is a great woman, and the fact she is good at sport is great.
    2
  333. ​ @racheljames7 he has not destroyed anybody's life.
    2
  334. I find it really annoying there seems to be so many people who seem to find donkey's so called s joke, funny it was not funny It's not funny to Mock victims of the Holocaust, I would find it a bad if anybody mocked victims of stalins horrendous crimes, I would find it bad if anybody mocked the victims of Pol Potts horrible crimes, I saw a video on Pol Potts horrible crimes and was physically shaken by it,it was not funny. It was also not funny when that poor grandfather who all he was arrested for I believe was holding up a pathetic sign, about the new world order and lots of crazy conspiracy theory stuff, if that's all he was arrested for that seems very unfair and it was very sad when he died. It's not funny when he died he died of a heart attack and that wasn't funny that was unfair and unhappy. People should not mock victims of the Holocaust it's horrible to do that, it's not funny It's not funny to mock the victims of stalin crimes, it's not funny to mock anybody being killed whether they're right wing or left wing or centrist or anything.
    2
  335. I would also oppose Islamic fundamentalists who mock british victims of Islamic fundamentalist terrorist attacks, I think that would be a big red flag, the security services should not ignore.
    2
  336. Surely it is ok to not find genocide funny.
    2
  337. ​ @TheWeb-is-a-Lie just accept it, rubbish racist jokes are pointless.
    2
  338. Riley Gaines is a freedom fighter.
    2
  339. Yes many times
    2
  340. He's just saying his view.
    2
  341. What did she say that is anti trans.
    2
  342. Yes, people should stop campaigning for biological males in women's sports, and fight against homelessness.
    2
  343. And today which activists talk about burning books, and banning people for beleving biological sex exists, the ones who hate gender critical ideas.
    2
  344. What has he said that you term transphobic
    2
  345. But what about when that affects others, it's all fair and well talking of identity, but what about biological sex and it's consequences on how we are, and interact with others, and the totally legitimate safety and other concerns that even tony Blair and Keir staner accept are thorny issues, we must analyse.
    2
  346. He did aot, he stood up for left wing ideals, comprehensive education, strong ,NHS etc etc.
    2
  347. Good point.
    2
  348. From a guy dressed like a blue m and m guy.
    2
  349. Three interesting people.
    2
  350. Keeping fit, is very useful.
    2
  351. ​​​​ @WoodTech9 who called him a Nazi, was it the judge, give a example. I thought that people just thought it was a insensitive remark, please give a example of someone who called him a Nazi, was it someone important, or just someone who nobody listens to. I did not like the joke as it made me think of horrible uncaring bullies, who say the worst things they can about people. I mean I know those people don't matter, but for someone to act like saying the most horrible thing you can about someone is some noble act is just monstrous. Couldn't he just have apologized for any hurt caused, and got on with his life, instead of acting like being the most offensive you can be is some freedom loving act. I think it's interesting the same people defending him for this joke, range from liberal free speech extremists, but also to far right people. I mean there is a guy on this comment section, and I have seen his comments on this subject before, who says wrongly, we fought on the wrong side in world war two. It happened when Jimmy carr made his horrible joke glorifying the Holocaust of gypsies, there were loads of people in the comments section, claiming it was all just a joke and being ironic, but just as many were horrible far right people, stating horrible things about gypsies, and seemingly agreeing with what supposedly was an ironic joke. To be honest, I think we can forgive dankula for his horrible joke, but it was not anything to be proud of. We all do silly things, I mean I have to stop swearing at the asda till machine, when it stops working, but I apologize. As I should. I think Peterson was a hero on the trans issue, but here I think he is being a ivory tower liberal. As you would expect of course none of these far-right pro free speech people ever get in a big huff if somebody is fired for criticising Trump, or the queen or Putin, which is what free speech is supposed to be for. Which shows their grand great hypocrisy. Did they get annoyed when trump sues people for saying stuff about him.
    2
  352. ​​​​​ @GAIS414 ok so if nobody got hurt, why are so many people whining about poor little baby dankula, as if he is the Christ child, maybe stop whining for dankula, and get on with your lives, he has gotten over it, as he is a proper bloke, why can't his fan boys get over it. They are still sobbing about it ten years later, as if he was thieir pet dog, or something, 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😞😞😞😞, why is that, what is the reason for that. There are Holocaust victims who got over the Holocaust more easily, than dankula fan boys have over his act of pure political theatre.
    2
  353. ​​most people who got thalidomide poisoning coped it with it, better than dankulas fan did about his self enforced jailing. Which was all political theatre. Get over it.
    2
  354. If that were true, then there would be loads of female NBA players earning 100 times what they do in WNBA.
    2
  355. ​ @MeatloafProductionz Richard Dawkins and Robert Winston agree with GC views.
    2
  356. ​ @Maksie0 what do you consider hateful about what he said. Please list what you see as fair to call his remarks hateful. Dear commenter.
    2
  357. 🤠
    2
  358. ​ @dreamcatcher77- truly unpleasant fellow
    2
  359. ​​ @Kemily91 making straw man videos about someone, is not the same as debating someone, it is the case no extreme trans rights activist would debate Joyce, as she would dominate a fair debate, destroying the incoherent basis of the most extreme aspects of their orwellian idealogy.
    2
  360. Why not rebuild it.
    2
  361. Losers, what sort of horrible bullying term is that. It's so Trumpian, so final, so dismissive, so lacking in humanity, it's better to be called a loser by a bully, than to give in toca bully. Let him be. Calling someone a loser, as they devote themselves to a greater cause, was Gandhi a losers,were his supporters losers, were the abolitionists losers, were the resistance losers, was Winston smith a loser, get maybe to you they were, maybe we should not care, maybe we should ignore problems, leave everything to special interest groups and oligarchs, yeah lets just give in, to the powerful, and not care, nah, lets not, you may not like that there are people who say no, but there are, so to all the obriens from 1984 who call the resistance losers, i seay to, you, let freedom roarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr. 🦁 Glory to freedom, glory to democracy glory to the resistance. We will never surrender, you will never have victory. We will have our own sensible liberal moderate kind thoughts, love, and be free, no to hate, yes to knowledge, truth, we don't have to surrender to orwellian demands. Biological sex exists, two plus two is four,
    2
  362. So true, very true. True indeed .
    2
  363. Yes, agreed.
    2
  364. Trans rights activists are the most macho impervious manly arrogant, unfeminine campaigners there are, proving JK rowling right.
    2
  365. 😂
    2
  366. But surely when he made the documentary, about the event where trans activists had been trying to get into a woman's only camp, it would be very factual to mention the fact one of the activists, Dana Rivers had murdered camp inhabitants. Surely we need to mention that extreme trans activists, such as the Nashville shooter, are a severe threat. And he is wrong to ignore that.
    2
  367. ​ @Etcher he should add a extra bit
    2
  368. ​ @rudynathan8852 i thought there is some belief they had some of these things, the academics are debating.
    2
  369. Yes, but also within proper safeguarding, all societies know men can be a threat to women, it does not change just as someone identifies as the other sex.
    2
  370. It is not right wing, to say women's sports should be for biological women. Richard Dawkins believes that, and is not right wing. We should love trans as part of our society, but we have women's sports,vas of biological women exists, not as of gender.
    2
  371. No, it was as he criticized trans rights,
    2
  372. I don't think Dawkins thinks being trans is a idealogy, and I am sure he and gold would abhor any bullying v you for being trans, but the idealogy that demands we deny in totality the existence of biological sex for any purpose, as of the concerns of trans rights, , does have a idealogical sway, which is what a lot of reasnoble people, who have no hate for trans people, whatsoever are concerned about. I believe there is a middle way, and it is probably the Dawkins be nice to trans people, but biological women exist way.
    2
  373. ​​ @ThaliaIvy-j6t I believe almost everyone, even right wing, even far right people, never mind centre and left wing don't care if anybody calls themselves or dresses the way they like. But to have biological males in women's sports and safe spaces is where there is a debate, now who wins this debate let's see, but it's not fair to call all gc opinions and people bigots, as Dawkins and the like have nothing but acceptance of trans people but within nuances of utterly accepting certain things involving biological sex have a relevance in the debate. Good to see we agree on lots, and even on what we disagree with, cordially, yes that is what is needed in this debate genuine sensible common ground, not a faux common ground but a real one, have a good day.
    2
  374. So what if i am a weak and insecure man, if thats what i am, i am and I love being so, coz i am cool. But that does not stop jk Rowling and Riley gaines being right that there are important issues in this debate. I what you arrogantly labelI as a weak insecure man, whatever to hat is, can see why a woman would be upset at about biological males using their toilets, sports and r😖pe centres, and am sure most uncaring heartless big strong powerful.men are not affected by it, so dont care about the vulnerable biological women hurt by this crazy idealogy. How dare you see it as a sign of strengh to not care about women. Ps funny how you can now ignore the mad pronoun idea of refusing to accept the reality that men and women exist, when you want to throw typical pathetic trans rights extremists abuse at people. Laughably even your hateful abuse about gender critical activists, contradicts the mad Alice in wonderland mad hare mad hatters tea party idealogy that trans rights extremists boast about. Gender critical ideology is left wing, as it defends the vulnerable.
    2
  375. Too right, Dawkins is clever.
    2
  376. Yes, lets hope for peace as soon as, it's a frustrating and very distressing,.
    2
  377. ​ @3ndw but this is a real woman's issue. Just imagine you were a woman who had to sharea cell with that intact biological male, there was the fuss about, well she defended those women, some of the most marginalized in society from a danger, so she does defend women in danger.
    2
  378. In heaven, for lowering poverty.
    2
  379. Yes, that would show who is boss.
    2
  380. That's nice to know
    2
  381. No way all the things. To be honest if you think about ut, the issues are totally different. I cant think of a single tjhing that connects the two, can you tell me a example.
    2
  382. Thank Jupiter
    2
  383. Woke Martian phraseology. 😂im only joking.
    2
  384. Nobody says they did not exist before, we are saying that taking the word woman away from just biological women,visiting a giant step, especially done in the Orwellian aggressive way it has been done to a word that must have existed in some form in the way Dawkins uses it since the Neanderthals.
    2
  385. ​​​​​ @Cardinal_Hordriss it is Orwellian, as everybody who had any even mild criticism, to your slogans and laws was the victim of Orwellian campaigns to silence them, even jk Rowling, chapelle and Dawkins. It did not succeed for them, but people lower down, were sacked just for saying biological sex exists And we totally accept there are people who are trans, there is just a debate about women's safe spaces and sports, and the right of people to be attracted to the biological sex they choose, without condemnation by trans activists. Look at the Wikipedia page on gender critical feminism, it is just a Orwellian hit job, ninety percent coffee which is about trying to link it with the right and far right. No attempt to understand that some people believe biological sex exists, that we should treat trans with respect, but also biological sex exists, has consequences, and the law should be partly be moulded about that fact, not just Orwellian slogans of believers in gender idealogy. I mean even Dawkins video has been demonetised, on this channel, can you think of any gender idealogy videos demonetised, for saying their beliefs on n the subject.
    2
  386. I don't think linehan is stopping over eighteens who want to change gender, he has no power on the issue. Most gc people say adults can do what they like. It's only kids we think there should be safeguarding rules about.
    2
  387. But don't we then get statements like the Bryson case, where she r@ped her with her p@nis, surely there are times we must be nice to everybody, including trans people, but also acknowledge the reality that biological sex exists. Just like they might be cases where you have to admit someone is too short to go on the roller coaster or reach the bookshelf. It's a fact that make annoy some shorter people in some cases to mention, but as long as you keep it to the right places, then we can be a nice tolerant society. But it must be legal to acknowledge the reality that biological sex exist. And surely if you are discussing national policy, it is completely unreasonable, to ignore such loudly important concern in the matter. Yes let's be tolerant, reality that biological sex exists, indeed it's a major matter for both sides of the argument in some senses.
    2
  388. I don't think you understand the judgement.
    2
  389. Its a shame she felt she had to leave, as Stamer got elected with a big majority, but she is a very decent person who stands up for her convictions, which themselves are very in with current Labour voters, (Not ones who voted Reform, but actual current Labourites) so it is a shame for Labour, they need people like this. I think Stamer will last, as people are never ousted just after a election, and he is very moderate on most issues, so I dont think there is appetite in the party to replace him, I think they are grateful he won the election.
    2
  390. You worship money.
    2
  391. Not just in the middle aged did they believe that sex and gender are the same, but in the neanderthal era, and upto 2010 just about everybody, every other era and most people do today. Whatever any Orwellian idealougues try and force us to believe.
    2
  392. Compare z wife, she is a babe.
    2
  393. Yes, Russia should withdraw.
    2
  394. Writer of the european greatest sitcom of the past thirty years.
    2
  395. ​@KazHughesfather Ted was great, sorry you don't find it funny. 😢😢😢, you are missing out.
    2
  396. To be fair, the people obsessing over this the most are people who want to bring in what they call trans rights by stealth, the likes of jk Rowling and Helen Joyce and Richard Dawkins who are not at all right wing, are just reacting to very radical attempts at change, which otherwise would have been brought in by stealth, such as biological males in womens sports, convicted r@pists in womens prisons, and the astonishing fact that children under ten across the western world, out of nowhere are being taught tbat biological sex is a unimportant element of gender, when in reality its the whole reason we acknowledge its existance. We should love everyone, including trans, but to deny biological sex is important, when we are talking about gende is not a sensible view really, and it is right that people stood up and said the truth that there are serious and reasonable concerns mostly to do with womens rightds and safety, that we must acknowledge on this issue, and no amount of Orwellian newspeak, furious Orwellian bluster, and powder flam mantras can gloss over that. So we'll done Helen for mentioning these issues, and shame in anybody who says we should just let idealogy win over the needs of people who are affected by this issue. Biological sex exists and we just need to realise that and live life in a way and have rules that acknowledge the effect ts that causes on society. Jk Rowling is a good female rights campaigner. And think of all the homosexuals who agree with Helen, here is a list, arty, Andrew Doyle, Joanna Cherry, Martina Navaratalola, Douglas Murray, the list is very long, Elaine Miller and James Dreyfuss, and and the list goes on, and most of those are left wing. Why are you disagreeing with them, can you tolerate their views. This is a reasonable debate to have and if we did not have it, we would have biological males winning women's sport event, and in women's safe spaces. And really left wing views should be based on reality and facts, biological sex still exists, the fact has not changed, so we should have a society, that in a loving caring way realises that. It's not right wing to accept biological truth.
    2
  397. Good point
    2
  398. ​ @Golfphantom the BBC have nothing to do with who works in us comedy.
    2
  399. It happened in one, and the person broke a lady's skull.
    2
  400. He is a rational man.
    2
  401. Jk Rowling is a hero,she is why intact biological men who have comitted s,x crimes are not being allowed to share cells with women in britain, she is a heroine, fighting Orwellian idealogy, for the sake of humanity.
    2
  402. I like both, Jesus said some groovy things.
    2
  403. Never surrender to Orwellian oppression.
    2
  404. She looks like a beautiful Hollywood actress, like Ryan Reynolds wife.
    2
  405. What has he said that you say is bigoted,
    2
  406. ​ @assses-3216 but surely we have the term masculine, because there are biological males, it is not a term that cropped out of thin air. And the statistics indicate that biological males are more aggressive whatever they identify as. As shown by the trans debate, where the trans rights side is much more about labeling opponents dehumanizing terms like bigot, or terf, and the gender critical side is more about talking.
    2
  407. It is not far right to acknowledge biological sex exists, and based in real material reality, caused by billions of years of time and evolution.
    2
  408. Against the usa
    2
  409. Leicester, everton, barca, spurs legend, will miss his quips.
    2
  410. I don't think he was ever a mp, Simon Hughes beat him in the election.
    2
  411. He seems darn clever on this issue.
    2
  412. This won't be passed by the Senate, so put it in the budget reconciliation bill, so it does not need sixty votes.
    2
  413. No, it's as some people see there being issues such as women's sport, and safe spaces, it's not for no reason.
    2
  414. Yes nobody would stop them being in the section for biological males.
    2
  415. If instead of being born a pretty, biological women, as she is, if she had been born a biological male then that could have given her advantages over the other biological women in the sport, . That would be one way of having a unfair advantage.
    2
  416. It is actually, they all start from this same start line, and cross the same finish line
    2
  417. The same politicians who failed to fund free education, are the same who prioritized putting biological males in women's sports, over homelessness and health.
    2
  418. ​ @TheBlackDogChronicles everyone in the world is different, and has something unusual about them, everyone has hurt, but that does not stop biological sex existing. We should have nuanced laws that are inclusive of trans people and the reality that biological sex exists.
    2
  419. We all know Vance and trump will have nice blue suits for Putin. Gimp suits, o😅😅😅😅, I jest. 😅😅😅
    2
  420. ​​​​​ @thatonellamawhoissoobsesse8138 who thinks women aren't capable fighters, who is talking about fighting. I know some are very intimidating and capable fighters, what are you referring to. Look at boudica and wonderwoman, two amazing biological women. I would disagree with anyone who says that no women are capable fighters.
    2
  421. He will wear a better suit than you will, when the war is over.
    2
  422. ​ @shemdig what was Riley gaines upset about.
    2
  423. Journalists are good, she is a whistleblower like those journalists who caught Nixon. And being great at maths shows you are clever and rational.
    2
  424. ​ @garrett7101 she has absolutely no hatred, clearly,
    2
  425. ​ @garrett7101 the only hatred I see, is coming from intolerant extreme trans rights activists, who say the most horrible belittling names about people, just for daring to express the most vanilla criticisms of elements of what they believe.
    2
  426. Its perfectly OK to believe what you want, but a book seller should remember Fahrenheit 451, its what the Michael Moore movie Fahrrenheit 9 11 was in title based on, and not support burning books, as they oppose the beliefs of the person, she is perfectly entitled to believe what she likes, but not to support burning books of pretty typical mainstream beliefs, I could understand if it was some far out hateful extremism, but even then its not for her to burn books, but gender critical beliefs are quite normal and mainstream. She should really be apologising. We are all guilty of hyperbole, but that would have been a better thing. Book sellers are for selling books, not for burning books, thats not their job. Its simple. A book seller should love books, and love reading all sorts of opinions, to support, or even pull them apart, burning books is not the move of intellectuals. Firstly she should apologise.
    2
  427. I love Caspian Report, geopolitics is fascinating.
    2
  428. ❤🎉If biological sex does not exist, why am I able to tell which players at Wimbledon are men, and which are women, the only reason some dodgy over defensive pseudo scientists now in their journals, describe biological sex as "more complicated than youuuuuu! Think," in tone belying even they know their agenda is on shaky ground intellectually, is as if a tiny percentage of people on the edges who are intersex, who yes exist, but they want to talk about them to undermine the clear obvious existence of biological sex, so they can muddy the waters of the term, and then shoehorn biological males who identify as women into the category of women. It's just ridiculous. Thank God or the universe for Collin Wright.
    2
  429. And the losers cry into their beer, 😂😂😂
    2
  430. But we are human, not others species . And the one percent of babies who are intersex, are mainly very one or the other sex, it's very rare to be truly intersex, not that they should be ashamed, but it's just biological sex exists.
    2
  431. Eels
    2
  432. I am sure starving children in shanty towns shall be watching this feeling sorry for us, i mean get real, wevare not third world, we have a obesity problem, and our main problem as a society is drugs and alcohol, not poverty.
    2
  433. You could be a alpha male, even if you are a short guy, look at Bernie Ecclestone and Napoleon Bonaparte. But biologicl sex, exists whatever.
    2
  434. Well Ronson is great, and has done some fine stuff, fab fellow. But he kind of on this issue, some people critisise him for making a documentary on this issue, where the trans right activists were painted as all sweetness and light, and the concerns of the gender critical women, were not really given equal weight, it was kind of all, hey lets all come together on the angle the trans rights activists want. Which was quite typical of the current debate and way laws are enacted by centrist and centre left and even centre right parrties at the moment, (well untill the right and in Britain the left, realised its a vote winner, as GC ideas have credance and are right). And bizarely this was a place where there had been a murder by a extreme very untypical trans rights activist of a gender critical campaigner. I think it was the Dana Rivers case, it would be like doing a video on the troubles in Northern Ireland, and acting ;like only side had people who comnitted violence oir unfair acts, and that the othger side is all sweetness and light, which even many Sinn Fein or DUP supporters would kind of be a bit perplexed about. I mean I wish some kind of compromoise could be made, that accepts everybody, including gc requests, but I think even Ronson feels he has to apologise a bit, for missing the Rivers case from his documentary, so its understandable people are perplxed he made such a untypical Ronsson video, and probably media should be told, hey hang on here whats all this about when it misses major things. It would be like doing a documentary on World War Two, and painting the Americans as pure baddies, by just ignoring Pearl Harbour, and saying America declared war on Japan for no reason what so ever. Or a documentary on JFK visit to Dallas, that utterly ignores the assassination. The same here, I mean GC people have some concerns and certain people totally ignore their reasonings and act like they are just horrible bigots and even call them Nazis and bigots just for querying anything to do with this issue.
    2
  435. Good one,
    2
  436. Pre school, isn't that a bit early. Are you serious.
    2
  437. He is right,
    2
  438. You just want to misunderstand him, so you can insult him, that's bullying. Trans rights activists are mean dismissive disrespectful bullies, who want to overbearingly belittle people,..
    2
  439. ​​​ @operationgoldfish8331 I don't need to watch it again, I have a photographic memory, I don't think it is Fair that trans rights activists are so hate filled and belittling towards any disagreement. You have to be joking if you are literally assuming he does not know about the existence of intersex conditions, the guy knows a lot, it's safe to assume he knows they exist, even your big standard YouTube commenter on this issue knows they exist, now come off it, stop all the pretending to be superior attitude,when really he knows a huge amount on this subject, if you watch it again, you will realise that. I dont beef to watch it again as of my photographic style memory. I mean calling him dodgy, is horrible bullying.
    2
  440. ​​​ @operationgoldfish8331 I remember, as of my photographic memory, in a interview with gb news, Andrew Doyle, he mentioned intersex, he knows of the term, dont imagine you know better than him on such simple basics of the subject. The man has a IQ way above average so won't not know of that. Stop bullying and misunderstanding people. It's unpleasant and cruel. Why do trans rights activists have to insult and bully people just for saying stuff they disagree with, it's rarely arguing on the actual issue, as they have so little to support them, they just lob horrible hate filled cruel hurtful remarks at those who dont fall in line, just mean fanatics.
    2
  441. ​ @operationgoldfish8331 I am sorry I have a photographic memory, and assume everyone does, I am sorry you missed the points he has made, that's ok, but I would advise you to watch the video again, and you may realize and understand the points he is making, and see he is right. Yes you can bully and name call him all you like, just as many trans rights activists do in their overbearing arrogant ways about people who don't agree with them, but he is still right, whatever abuse you have. Watch the video and his others,like on other channels you will see what I mean.
    2
  442. ​​​ @operationgoldfish8331 insult insult, misinterpret and from there Insult, insult and defame, and insult insult and insult anybody who does not join in your bullying, that's what you have as someone has the temerity to not agree with you, watch his videos and try to understand what he is saying, don't bully him, don't name call him for disagreeing with you, stop hating people just for not agreeing with you. Let's hear what abuse and insults you have, any more bullying remarks about him , come on let's hear it,n to reveal once and for all if after all this, you are just a bully. What insults you got come on let's here it, got any more bullying remarks as someone disagrees with you. Gender critical views, are loving, and defensible, we do not hate trans people, we just acknowledge the obvious glaring in your face reality than biological sex exists, that is true, and sensible left wingers accept that reality, as left wing beliefs are based on reality, like biological sex exists.
    2
  443. ​​​​​ @operationgoldfish8331 You are usingndismissive terms like calling him or people who agree with him as maga or right wing, and such to delegitmise alternative views, . You misinterpreted his view on intersex, and then call him dodgy, I think really that counts as bullying. I am not going to look up what you advised, as you have proven yourself to be intolerant of alternative views, and clearly I don't think that having a gender ideology comisar on every and all discussions on this issue is at all democratic. I think trans rights activists hectoring bullying attitude towards those who disagree with them is just a sign they are Orwellian bullies. Trans rights extremists are just bullies, insulting anybody who dares to not agree with their beliefs. And I see you getting the insults on me now, as I called out your bullying, 👏👏👏👏👋 , let's be honest, if someone says something even mildly disagreeing with trans rights extremism,they will be called all sorts of horrible names, so no surprise there. Keep showing up that bullies dominate tra extremism.
    2
  444. ​​​​​​​​ @operationgoldfish8331  I am disappointed in you, you have not stated any more bullying dismissive insults yet, surely you have more in you than that, come on, got any more cruel take downs, thats the typical way, I'm all ears. Yes apparently anybody who opposes people who bully, is a passive aggressive, thanks,. 😂😂😂😂, I suppose if a thug comes and beats me up, and I say please don't beat me up, that makes me a passive aggressive, pull the other one, stop insulting people. Stop name calling, stop labeling, stop calling people nasty names. To me that counts as bullying, so stop bullying people. Why are trans rights activists so full of insults, and so uncaring about people they disagree with. It's just amazing how unpleasant and rude they are about people who disagree with them. Just rude and hurtful activists.
    2
  445. ​Do whatever you like pal, just stop the mean names. Totally agree no more contact between us is fine by me, but please don't call people nasty names just as they disagree with you
    2
  446. Andrew gold considers himself centrist and mainstream. He does not call himself right wing. You claimed wright is a paid influencer of the right, , you put in doubt his credentials, claim.ing he lacks mentions of intersex, even though if you watch his video, with Stephen knight, he talks about intersex the whole time. He knows this subject very well, and is honestly putting forwsrd a intelligent clear cut persuasive case. It is a very common thing for trans rights activists to try and bully and undermine people who criticize gender ideology beliefs, by claiming the person dies not know about intersex , when the person,whether it is Colin wright or Richard Dawkins knows more about intersex than the commenter does. I would definitely believe that trying to undermine someone by pretending they a expert on the field, don't know about something they do know about, is demeaning and bullying behavior. It is absolutely the case that trans rights activists do always try to undermine those who criticize gender ideology, by calling them far right, right wing or some such term, and they often try to undermine critics of gender idealogy, by lying about what they believe or calling I to question their credentials, often by lies about what the, the Richard Dawkins has never heard of intersex, is a common trans rights extremists lie, so sorry I have a antenna for knowing that a trans rights activist trope. All I am saying is don't bully, don't name call, just as people dont agree with you. He knows his stuff, and does not deserve bullying attempts to demean him. We all know trans rights activists often bully women who don't fall into line, saying the most atrocious sexist vile rubbish about them, sickening shameful stuff. This guy may wear glasses, but that don't make him a wimp, just like jk Rowling, he will stand up to orwellian bullies. Ps I am not saying trans people are bullies, I am saying that most trans activists and their supporters do bully, and that is proven, they try to drive out alternative options, and pile on guff, claiming anybody who does not agree with gender idealogy is a evil right winger,who should be quarantined as of they are terrible far right people. The jaw dropping reality, is gender critical people are treated by some media worse than actual far right people. Look at Wikipedia it bans the mention of biological sex, and it's definition of gender critical feminism is a hit job, filled with multiple mentions of the words, far right, right wing, hate, terf and all such. But it's arrticke on the most evil man in history, a h, of 1930s Germany mention s far right just once in reference to where he is in a photo. Shockingly it gives far right and racist views more freedom, than gender critical views. It disgracefully has a article on the n word, it describes far right peoples views in their own language, having quotations from a h, in the articles. It gives both sides of the view on the highland clearances, the proper view and the far right pro clearance view. But for gender critical feminism, it refuses to accept the language feminists use. So making their views unheard and utterly censored. The BBC and CNN allow extremists language, like assigned male at birth, as if it's some wild guess from a doctor what sex you are. If you search Google for biological sex, it lists condescending confused articles based on extreme gender idealogy, of denying the firmness of their being sex. There are even high up articles like titled myth of biological sex. You are wrong to ignore the arrogance of this orwellian idealogy, that denies glaring realitirs, all for the sake of a puritan style zealotry of the unthinking mantra of trans women are women, which is ok fir you to believe, but not fir you to have as the national slogan and devotion, the idealogical Puritanicalness of this neo quasi religious movement should be opposed like any other orwellian rubbish. Truth to power
    2
  447. In terms of sports, it's the other way round, there was a mma fighter who identified as a woman, but was born a man, and broke skull of a biological woman, and calls people terfs. Joe Rogan mentions it a lot. Also in terms of the first one, well in USA prisons there have been those things occurring, which could not even have remotely occurred if the policy did not allow biological males in women's prisons. For the Mma Fallon fox was the name, and the individual boasted about beating up terfs, which was horrible and indicative of the dangers from tra. The statistics indicate, the biological males whatever they identify as are still a threat to women.
    2
  448. ​ @judithellen the Chinese, the Arabs, and the scots.
    2
  449. The British communists accept gc ideas, as do Stamer and streeting. Plus even snp leader Swinney. And.regan, Sheridan, duffield, Rowling, Dawkins, rfk jr, Seth Moulton, the US green party vp candidate, Joanna cherry, Alex salmond, Robert Winston, Katie Forbes david blunket, macron, the German conservative left party, loads of left wingers are gc. Ps lots of gay people are gc as well. And some gay people, are as right wing as any other right wingers, look at David Starkey. And there are folk like him in every country. Gays are ok.
    2
  450. Good point.
    2
  451. Yes, it caused trump to beat Kamala.
    2
  452. Of course not, that would be ridiculous, er em, oh yeah.
    2
  453. ​​ @katelynnblatt9614 well thank you for your answers, very interesting points. I don't agree with your conclusions, but certainly a lot of knowledge there, thank you for the information. Now I don't believe it's relevant to mention race in this discussion, as I am from a generation where we dont discuss race, I am not sure about the kilinefelter stuff, but interesting. Well I think if Mr Gold had you on his show, you would need to slow down a bit, and keep to the general issues he is discussing. So good day to you, and if you ever get on this show, it shall be interesting to watch, but best to slow down a bit first, so a reasonable discussion can be had. Otherwise it will be impossible for specific points to be answered, without a muddying of the waters. I think biologic sex exists, but maybe we have nuanced disagreements. Thank you for your answers. Sorry that's all from me, but good day to you, and may peace break out between the gender critical and the anti gender critical. It would be great if you could be on this show, or a debate with a other podcaster, not putting any pressure on gold. So maybe better if you were on a other show, like someone less famous, as a start off, and if that's popular, he should have on his show.
    2
  454. Biological sex exists
    2
  455. You just got on the nerves of the etc. people
    2
  456. Back in school, I did some as a cossack dancer in fiddler on the roof. So I am a expert on such things.
    2
  457. ​ @kovi1581 well done, I hope these great traditions survive well, they are cool. I would struggle to do them now.
    2
  458. He upped NHS funding.
    2
  459. But I dont think it was just that, I mean Ronson is great, and has done some fine stuff, fab fellow. But he kind of on this issue, some people critisise him for making a documentary on this issue, where the trans right activists were painted as all sweetness and light, and the concerns of the gender critical women, were not really given equal weight, it was kind of all, hey lets all come together on the angle the trans rights activists want. Which was quite typical of the current debate and way laws are enacted by centrist and centre left and even centre right parrties at the moment, (well untill the right and in Britain the left, realised its a vote winner, as GC ideas have credance and are right). And bizarely this was a place where there had been a murder by a extreme very untypical trans rights activist of a gender critical campaigner. I think it was the Dana Rivers case, it would be like doing a video on the troubles in Northern Ireland, and acting ;like only side had people who comnitted violence oir unfair acts, and that the othger side is all sweetness and light, which even many Sinn Fein or DUP supporters would kind of be a bit perplexed about. I mean I wish some kind of compromoise could be made, that accepts everybody, including gc requests, but I think even Ronson feels he has to apologise a bit, for missing the Rivers case from his documentary, so its understandable people are perplxed he made such a untypical Ronsson video, and probably media should be told, hey hang on here whats all this about when it misses major things. It would be like doing a documentary on World War Two, and painting the Americans as pure baddies, by just ignoring Pearl Harbour, and saying America declared war on Japan for no reason what so ever. Or a documentary on JFK visit to Dallas, that utterly ignores the assassination. The same here, I mean GC people have some concerns and certain people totally ignore their reasonings and act like they are just horrible bigots and even call them Nazis and bigots just for querying anything to do with this issue.
    2
  460. I mean ignoring the murder, that's like something from a Mitchell and Webb sketch, it's beyond satire, but I still think Robson is great , and his other showsv are brilliant
    2
  461. Biological women who play volleyball are some of the prettiest ladies around.
    2
  462. Hello, Dankulas act was training his dog to get excited and happy, when mentioning the gassing of victims of the Holocaust, a very unfunny and strange act. Nothing to be proud of, and anybody who condemned him for that was within their rights. Ps I think dankula should be forgiven for his stupid act, but don't act like what he did was done heroic act, I am sure he has done good stuff for people, and made good jokes in his life, but that stupid thing he did was dumb. Not that any of us are perfect, and to be honest dankulas friends should have told him it was dumb as well. Biological sex exists whether dankula fans or extreme trans activists and far right activists accept it or not. Linehan has a right to criticize rubbish jokes, but it is not fair to cancel him for saying biological women exists, or two plus two is four. And he did not try to cancel Dankula, the guy was not famous before, his poor taste joke, so cancel is a strong word. And people must have the right to say they don't like a joke or statement it's part of free speech.
    2
  463. They mention scots
    2
  464. That is a unpleasant mean thing to say...
    2
  465. Me too, and Richard herring and Adam Buxton.
    2
  466. ❤If biological sex does not exist, why am I able to tell which players at Wimbledon are men, and which are women, the only reason some dodgy over defensive pseudo scientists now in their journals, describe biological sex as "more complicated than youuuuuu! Think," in tone belying even they know their agenda is on shaky ground intellectually, is as if a tiny percentage of people on the edges who are intersex, who yes exist, but they want to talk about them to undermine the clear obvious existence of biological sex, so they can muddy the waters of the term, and then shoehorn biological males who identify as women into the category of women. It's just ridiculous. Thank God or the universe for Collin Wright.
    2
  467. Great author.
    2
  468. So should heavy weights fight feather weights.
    2
  469. In what way,
    2
  470. Are periods transphobic, as only biological women can have them.
    2
  471. Well done Lula,
    2
  472. In most situations we don't need to care, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins is also someone criticized for saying biological sex exists, but was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤ we should oppose bullying of trans people, but it is ok to sensible nuanced laws which accept sex exists.
    2
  473. Well how come I have a pretty much 100% accuracy, level, able to identify which tennis player is in the women's event and which is in the men's event.
    2
  474. ​​ @MeatloafProductionz s You are ignoring the main point. The idealogy of self id, believed that gender identity is so important, that it is hateful, far right, bigoted, transphobic, uncompassionate, conservative, n🤐zi, f@asiust and cruel to not put intact biological males convicted of r🤐pes who identify as women, in women's prison cells. Luckily jk Rowling heroically stopped that, kudos to her. Now maybe you have a non empathetic, gender identity ism, view, which ignores the lives of people over a idealogical desire to support gender identity, but thankfully the people in charge don't agree with such a uncaring view. Well done Keir Stamer and the conservative for accepting sense....
    2
  475. But he does not mind that, except when it touches on others lives, women's sports,vans safe spaces etc.
    2
  476. 😮Have you seen the Wikipedia article on gender critical feminism, it's just a Orwellian hit job, trying to link the centrist belief, with the far right. This is done by mentioning the words, conservative, far right, right wing, anti trans and terf, together over one hundred times in the article, like someone in a Orwellian 15 minutes of hate, but left wing and socialism, something most gender critical people are, is mentioned no times. Also i looked at Wikipedia article on Hitler, it mentions far right once, and in relation to where he is is in the photo, so Wikipedia is more nuanced on the most evil man in history, than on the moderate centrist belief of gender critical feminism. . I think gender idealogy believers are ironically the most far right Orwellian bigots , totally unprepared to listen to others.
    2
  477. That is just the kind of toxic comment that is not needed. If you are arguing for trans rights. You should learn to argue in a more understanding and tolerant way of other people's opinions, just saying these things about anybody who doesn't agree with you doesn't bring people along with you, it pushes people away. I say we should be nice to trans people, but also accept the worries and concerns that many biological woman have about these situations, I'm not in a patronising mansplaining way, what's an understanding way that accepts their fears and concerns.
    2
  478. ​ @peekaboots01 yes, she is not being level headed,
    2
  479. Would you support dankula and his jokes about the Holocaust, if he was Muslim. I see you don't have an answer.
    2
  480. He does not condemn transgenders, he was friends with Jan Morris a pioneering trans person. Where does he condemn them, please be more tolerant and understandong of what he believes, he does not condemn trans people at all.
    2
  481. ​​​ @7king8debs79 that's not exactly what he said, surely you call anybody anti trans, if you twist how they said what they said. Isn't what you are saying, just as reductive, if what he said is. Am I right, yeah I think so.
    2
  482. ​ @7king8debs79 you prove my point.
    2
  483. ​ @7king8debs79 typically nuanced and friendly reply from those who opposes GC ideas. It's this kind of charm, that makes people like jk so enammared with the people who try to ban her
    2
  484. ​​ @7king8debs79 in what way are they harmful. Have any nuance on this issue, is he just wrong, have you no capacity to see where he may have a point, what major things do you dosagree with him on, and surely its ok he has his view, and you yours, then we debate from there.
    2
  485. ​​ @7king8debs79 it is not, as we live in a world where aspects of this idealogy are being imposed, with no thought of the consequences or explanation, and only the gender critical campaigns, have averted the silliness. Jk Rowling has been framed as a bigot, when she clearly stated she no problem with trans people, she just believe biological woman exist. And how could you bring up p the legit fears many have around this issue, without being called a bigot. It's impossible. He mentions some have abused the sillier aspects of the new laws, and gets called a bigot for doing so. Should we pretend these things are not happening, treat the victims like statistics, to ignore, and then we won't be called bigots, but also won't help those suffering from the daft and horrible parts of this in thought out radical change from above. Debate was needed, with reasonable safeguarding rules, but also a loving acceptance of trans, while accepting biological sex exists z has consequences, and needs to be attended to in laws.
    2
  486. ​@schweiztony5728so are you claiming trans people are like city ports, or something. That sounds transphobic if you ask me, what a bigoted thing to say. There is no place for the kind of hateful comparing of trans people with city ports. I say we should listen to the balanced moderate tolerant view of Richard Dawkins instead.
    2
  487. Cool
    2
  488. Yes, the average biological man who identifies as a woman, has the manner and persona of a biological man, like some of them have the persona of viking kings, not delicate flowers.
    2
  489. ​​​ @brettjohnson536 what crime did he accuse him.of,.was it not just bluster, has Tennant, great as he is, done exactly the same bluster, which most passionate politically interested people are guilty of at some point in their lives, specially if they are open and express their feelings and wear their hearts on their sleeves. I think you exaggerating, in exactly the same exaxtlry to be honest.
    2
  490. ​​ @ScorpionSuerte promise you won't ever become a air traffic controller, otherwise there would be loads of accidents as of your lack of ability to be accurate and notice your errors, like how you did with spelling that, thab, which is spelt t h a t, for your information. Promise for the good of man kind you shall never apply for such a post.
    2
  491. Good points
    2
  492. You spell White House without capitals, you show no respect, Benedict Arnold, especially by supporting Putin.
    2
  493. Gary Lineker has some good quips, so it is a shame. Has become a good personality for BBC, wonder if sky will take him.
    2
  494. Yes, good for her.
    2
  495. That's not true, she is a pretty, young blonde, pride of her state. And if someone can't tell which was born a woman, and which was born a man, that says more about their lack of observation abilities, than anybody else. 😂😂😂😂😂. A red blooded male can tell the difference. A true American can.
    2
  496. That's good.
    2
  497. ​ @theunknownatheist3815 yes, surely it was not Dawkins who created the universe, even I as a agnostic know that much.
    2
  498. Great joke, well achieve
    2
  499. ​What has she said that means she can wrongly be called nasty, say what, as surely she is nice, say honestly what proves your offensive point ​ @garrett7101 and it's good we have journalists, like the ones who caught Nixon at Watergate.
    2
  500. Even if he went back to Argentina, to meet him ? Then again, probably not, he would think it was a plot to capture him, and take him to Israel for his trial.
    2
  501. Good fact about us Neanderthal S there, the last if the proper ones had a modern human wife.
    2
  502. But if you agree with most of what he has to say, surely it's ok to just accept that you're going to disagree on some things, and not be in agreeance on everything, entirely with you on every point, and then claim that you have a right to be disappointed and that they don't know what they're talking about is incredibly unreasonable. Unless really you do disagree with what he's saying and then just accept directly some people disagree with you and some belief, nobody has a right to be disappointed that somebody else disagrees of them in some way. Does he have a right to be disappointed with you for having a slight disagreement with him that we don't really know, what to disagree with him about this. Has he arrived to be disappointed with you because you don't agree with him on everything. Does everybody else in the world have a right to be disappointed with you because you don't agree with them on everything. What is it you're claiming you know more about than about this issue than he does.
    2
  503. ​ @Rumpleforeskin77 what a surprise, there are loads of comments on this vid, worshipping a guy who mocked victims of the Holocaust, and one of the comments reveals some of these guys think we thought on the wrong side in the war, ps it's not a surprise at all. Bet these people who glorify this rubbish joke, would not glorify it if dankula was Muslim, or if his joke mocked victims of their group, I mean they get in a fit about dankula being fined, and not paying a fine, bug then laugh at Anne Frank and the like being gassed. The joke was rubbish.
    2
  504. Kick trump out of the white House.
    2
  505. Boxing is not about people dying, don't be so heartless.
    2
  506. ​ @mrvenom88 sounds like something Ivan drago would say. Appalling.
    2
  507. ​ @mrvenom88 no, I am saying it is callous to brush off any danger of deaths occurring. And for effect, I am saying Ivan drago was callous about a death in boxing, which was a attempt by the writers to say he was the baddie in the movie.
    2
  508. ​​ @mrvenom88 yes, that's kind of like the quote in Rocky, by the Russian guy about Rocky's mentor. And Rocky is sad.
    2
  509. ​ @candidbowyer4625 I did hear about it, it reminds me of the boxing death we saw on television, when we were young, which was terrible. People talk a lot about compassion in this debate, please be compassionate about everybody, we should care about trans people and we should care about non trans people, including women boxers, please be truly compassionate, rather the letting ideology be more important than safety concerns. Too often the trans rights campaigners talk a lot about compassion, but completely ignore it in safeguarding.
    2
  510. ​ @candidbowyer4625 yes I did hear about it, do you have any compassion for that boxer or women boxers, most of us think it is terrible if a tragedy like that occurs in boxing.
    2
  511. ​​ @candidbowyer4625 what happened to the compassion the celebs who claim they support your side say they have. Show compassion to the boxers. Their lives also matter. Think of the pain and hurt caused by these deaths, you should have compassion for everybody, and clearly the hatefulness and individualism of trans right activism, is a turn off.
    2
  512. Biological sex still exists, we are not all androgens, why am I able to tell the difference between male and female tennis players.
    2
  513. Nah,
    2
  514. Yes, or that blue suited guy who looks like he is at a blue man club themed party.
    2
  515. ​ @alexy8520 In most situations we don't need to care, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤
    2
  516. ​​ @N6TH9N John Oliver explained English football by claiming the fourth division is amateur, despite it being way above the average wage, although he is a witty cool guy, on some issues he can not be bothered presenting the case of both sides, clearly his show ion this issue is just a party political broadcast for one position, he has not really understood the position of those who have the view of common sense. Sadly.
    2
  517. ​But he clearly presents a angle, and just proceeds to put all the things, and views which support his view. Then he presens the alternative view from some daft perspective, often interviewing someone representing that side, who is not a expert. Criticising sone beside the point comments they make, and acting like his conclusion is the Moses on the mountain moment. Yes it's ok to do that on stuff I agree with him on, but it gives you a new perspective when you know he is wrong, and on this issue he is clearly wrong. I love these top us comic shows, but in reality, we should not act like they are unbiased investigate reports, they are comics pushing a view from one side. It's fun when I agree, like Colbert mocking trump, but when you realise they are wrong, like on this issue, , it's bad.. ​ @N6TH9N 
    2
  518. ​ @N6TH9N also I don't like it how he pretend to be a wimp for comic effect, when he is not.
    2
  519. ​ @N6TH9N it's a pop up, simplified view of the subject from one angle. That's ok, but it's annoying when he does it for the view you don't support. He is a great comic though, and has interesting stuff, though one sided.
    2
  520. ​​ @N6TH9N It certainly is not compassionate to call opponents bigots, and hateful, to malign and label them and try to cancel those as trans rights activists do about those who speak up on this subject. It was not compassionate to ignore the concerns of female athletes, to have their medals and records taken by people who it was perfectly fair to question the legitimacy of were taking part. There were even threats to expel female athletes from college for criticising the idea that biological males, who already have a richer more watched sport, competing in women's sports. Clearly he gave just a one sided orwellian view of the argument. Watch interviews with Riley Gaines and you will see what she had to deal with. When some female athletes in US college system, stated that they did not make the idea of intact biological males and dressing in their, dressing rooms, instead of thinking about the logic of this, realising that this could be intimidating to a large number of women, the ridiculous college elite decided that they should be seeking counseling, there was no attempt to compassion and decency towards these women, indeed just like happened to JK Rowling Catherine stock and Helen Joyce, these women were treated like the unimportant proles, underlined by how when Riley games finished an equal position with Leah Thomas in time, they gave the award to Leah Thomas, just like how the second Caitlyn Jenner announced they were a woman, they were given the award of women of the year, as if there were no biological woman who had done anything that year. And the arrogant macho nature of trans rights activists, calling people the most horrible names, dismissing them in dehumanising manners, as underlined by the one-sided nature of the John Oliver show. In Britain we have a show called The One show, his soul could be called the one-sided show.
    2
  521. But they were dark haired.
    2
  522. Linehan was not the judge, and also dankula went to jail as he refused to pay a small fine. Stop acting like what dankula did, which was a poor taste joke, was some gandhi or mandela like act. Much worse things happen to people than happened to dankula, even on school busses and playgrounds every day, stop remembering an unimportant slight from over 2 and a half centuries ago, and live your life. There are people begging on the streets, and your still wailing about something linehan had no power over, and does not even believe any more. Even the guy Dankula does not care and forgave him, good grief. And it gave dankula a career. Why do you pick on linehan about this, what's that about. I mean under your mentality nobody should ever forgive anybody for even the mildest thing, that's a recipe for chaos. Linehan was not the judge.
    2
  523. What has she ever said that is hateful or bigoted. Surely she is just saying biological sex exists. It's not fair to call people bigots for saying biological sex exists and has consequences. Dawkins has total respect for trans people like Jan Morris, but he does not have to ditch his understanding of his evolution created men and ladies.
    2
  524. ​​ @michellejean11 lol, so ok none of us can find anything she said that is hateful,. It's not hateful to say biological women and biological men exist on the subject of gender affirming care, I don't know,
    2
  525. If biological sex does not exist, why am I able to tell which players at Wimbledon are men, and which are women, the only reason some dodgy over defensive pseudo scientists now in their journals, describe biological sex as "more complicated than youuuuuu! Think," in tone belying even they know their agenda is on shaky ground intellectually, is as if a tiny percentage of people on the edges who are intersex, who yes exist, but they want to talk about them to undermine the clear obvious existence of biological sex, so they can muddy the waters of the term, and then shoehorn biological males who identify as women into the category of women. It's just ridiculous. Thank God or the universe for Collin Wright.
    2
  526. Who was it wanted some more boxes of votes found in Georgia, as they had lost.
    2
  527. But it's the other way around actually, it's actually trans activists who say liking blue makes you a boy, when gender critical people say you can like blue or pink but stills you is a boy, if it's your biological sex. And of course trans people exist, it's just a debate on how we use the word woman, but we should all respect each other. Love to you.
    2
  528. Good idea, you have succeeded in life.
    1
  529. Maybi ask tou, do other Pacific islands have ferry service.
    1
  530. Who is celery
    1
  531. And there are more dinosaurs than humans.
    1
  532. He has never said anything of the sort
    1
  533. It is illiberal
    1
  534. Interesting
    1
  535. He remembers quotes like amazing.
    1
  536. Fascinating, i suppose Rogan is doing a thing i would wish i could do.
    1
  537. Human biology exists, spooky scary skeletons, human private parts and all sorts they proove it exists, and biological sex, and well done andrew gold for this work.
    1
  538. This is what I had looked for on Google the week before, surprised a ship registered abroad was British. So Liberians don't own many ships, just registered, well that makes sense really.
    1
  539. Judd trump
    1
  540. Well trump now is evicting them all to Jordan.
    1
  541. ​ @Aeson-np8tr this is very difficult to read ,
    1
  542. Under the equality act a biological woman is a woman.
    1
  543. But trump says he supports Medicare.
    1
  544. You said, he, without asking his pronouns, shameful.
    1
  545. ​ @davidshaw123451001 😢you used the word him, without asking pronouns, what are you doing this for, are you trying to aggravate people.
    1
  546. ​​ @davidshaw123451001 Ive found temu graham linehan, someone refusing to use proper preferred pronouns behavior.
    1
  547. Yes
    1
  548. It's not right wing or hateful to say biological women exists, and j Edgar Hoover, and three roman emperors, and some Tory mps, were trans or interested in cross dressing, so don't act like being trans is some radical superior expression. Some like that kind of thing, that's ok, be what you want to be, but it does not stop biological sex existing.
    1
  549. Agreed
    1
  550. The vogue commercial, was to get support.
    1
  551. No, it's as old as time itself. Look at animals, males and females often live differently.
    1
  552. ​ @mrhobsonschoice she is not backed by Putin, dont be ridiculous. She is a beloved children's author, who has won polls across the world on her popularity. Edinburgh and London for the past couple of decades have revealed in the cash she brings their tourist industry. Both Keir stamer and kemi badenoch refuse to criticize her. Her views are that of a left leaning sensible social democrat. The only thing she digressed from late 2010s political thought on, was the trans issue, and for that, she was smeared on mass by a orwellian hate campaign. If she had been a nobody, it would have worked. But people knew who she is, and knew she is not far right. So if anything the bullying attempts to cancel her, just gave her strength, like a star trek creature, growing from the Lazer beans the enterprise fired at it. JK Rowling is a passionate defender of women's rights, and the ludicrous attempt to frame her as anything other than that has failed.
    1
  553. Amazing, that's why they let me walk at them, unobstructed.
    1
  554. Good stuff.
    1
  555. Yes it is good he is objeciing to orwellian idealogues.
    1
  556. Nah, I think comedians have to veca little understanding of their situation, like everyone. I mean we let them say more, but they should use their brains as well.
    1
  557. I read the book about him by merle miller, so am biased in favor of him. Interesting to hear a non left wing, slash centrist, but still fair minded, view of the guy.
    1
  558. Feminity is based on the observed reality that biological women exist, a d comes from that fact. It's not something cropped out of thin air.
    1
  559. ❤❤In most situations we don't need to care, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins is also someone criticized for saying biological sex exists, but was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤ we should oppose bullying of trans people, but it is ok to sensible nuanced laws which accept sex exists. Ps linehan was always a feminist to be fair, as to jk Rowling, look at her condenning the crushing of Iranian protesters, don't pretend that opposing racism, is not something that can't be believed in alongside protecting women's sports. Also many gay people, oppose extreme trans rights beliefs. Look at arty Morty, Andrew Doyle, David Starkey, the actor James Dreyfuss, Joanna cherry, Elaine miller, they are not homophobic. It's not good to be so blinkered on the nuances of this issue.
    1
  560. ​​ @someonesomeone25 in most respects we live in a post-racial society, not many people I know would like there to be white people's things and black people things. Whereas we still as a society believe in women's safeguarding , and that makes a whole lot of sense, when you think about the fact of the relations between men and women. So the two things are completely different.
    1
  561. I think some like the occipital bin do, but it's all at low dispersed rates.
    1
  562. ​ @johnkocev3369 but should you be criticized as they were in the same country as you. Does that make you guilty by association.
    1
  563. I think he would be more just surrendering.
    1
  564. I am sorry, but if you think a pretty, biological woman is anything other than a woman, that's more something for you to be embarrassed about than anything else, don't admit that you lack the ability everyone else has. Tell me can you tell Jennifer Lawrence is a woman, and tom cruise is a man, or is this a big problem you need to learn about.😊
    1
  565. We went there
    1
  566. 😂
    1
  567. Trump dodged the draft
    1
  568. Why was the situation kept secret.
    1
  569. Russia was the one that invaded.
    1
  570. He single handedly won world war two, and the cold war, and defeated the attempt to bring in gender idealogy to Britain, he nade British stronger.
    1
  571. But why make a documentary on that feminist camp, and ignore the Dana Rivers case, if you are not bothered about the issue. He is a great fellow, but should only make documentaries on subjects he is willing to research properly, and be prepared to give weight to facts that don't agree with the position you like.
    1
  572. Good show, proper professional stuff. And rational.
    1
  573. I know the feeling, i was thinking oh no, at the Florida resiult
    1
  574. ​​​ @cozy_2X but surely that kind of ignoring red flags for the sake of political correctness is just malign negligence. What all for the sake of ivory tower political correctness. That is the kind of wishy washy ideals that allowed grooming gangs, racists and terrorists to do what they like. The only people who believe in your politically correct to ltra free speech, live in gated communities, in ivory towers, away from the real world.
    1
  575. Can you give a example of someone he has hunted down, surely if that were so, it would be well known, the person would have revealed it, are you exaggerating his actions.
    1
  576. There's a pretty, biological woman.
    1
  577. Here is one, under him poverty went down. And homelessness went down. And unemployment went down.
    1
  578. No, he is right. He is not half way to being wrong, he is just right. The problem with the sapolsky idea. Is that even if you believe that a biological male who identifies as a woman, identifies as a woman because they're brain tells them they are a woman. Maybe because their neurons are the same as a woman's neurons. Even then, the reality is, biological sex still exists. So in all sorts of statistics, biological males who identify as women offer the same risks as biological males who identify as males. So, yes a biological male may believe that he is a woman, but because of his instincts and so many things about him, then he has the same level of threat towards women as other biological males. Look at crime stats, trans women are closer to cis males, at many important crimes, per population. Whether it is certain violent crimes, or s🤒x offences, I I am not saying they are more of a threat. They are not more of a threat. Also in sports they have those advantages as well, and the rest of the population can see they have those advantages and certain personality traits, that biological males, who identify as men also have. Look at the debate here. Gender critical women debate like, by writing eight thousand page tomes, and sit at tables speaking like a jane Austin character, about why they want trans people to be respected, but biological sex exists, and has consequences on biological women and biological men, so biological women exist, while trans rights campaigners have Hamas style slogans, with threats against their opponents on banners, which also use dismissive terms about what they call the terfs we ho they are threatening. Then they try and ban people from having gender critical views, and label them in a dismissive macho way, like only really powerful aggressive biological males can do. Surely the reality is gender disphoria exists, but it does not stop biological sex and it's instincts existence.
    1
  579. The truth is he is right, we should be friendly and accepting of trans people, but accept their are nuances in the issue, that laws and safeguarding should observe. The screaming ninnies claiming anybody who accepts biological women exist, is far right and evil, are just wrong, as are people who call trans people, horrible mean names. He holds the sensible middle ground in this issue. Have a nice day.
    1
  580. But what about this
    1
  581. He is the master of zingers, v douchebag journalists,even Russians laugh at his witty remarks.
    1
  582. 😮When the gender recognition act was proposed, all the media outlets said, it was just about making it easier for people to change sex, it sounded like it was just about on their passports. There was no announcement it was about regarding biological men who identify as women in every case. Very few people truly believe that is so. Sadly the courts will certainly choose the extreme trans activists position that biological males who identify as women are women in every case. Well if you give in to thus demand without any thought about it , its like failing at level one of 1984 the computer game, so say what ever you like law, biological sex still exists. Two plus two is four. Even if the law says it is five, if anything we should wear our rejection of this orwellian descison as a proud badge of pride.
    1
  583. Some of them are, there was a big protest in a school in southern England, which went back to having women's and men's toilets. As there were some cases where bad things happened. So no, women do protest against that plus linehan.
    1
  584. How dare zelensy be so disrespectful to trump, why what if stormy Daniels had walked in with a newspaper at that ecaxt time, preparing to administer it to trump, how offended would she have been to see trump clothed.
    1
  585. Instead of campaigning for this unpopular cause, why not campaign against homelessness, or inequality, or against dictatorships, why waste your time on this unimportant issue, stop caring about this unimportant issue, care about the million homeless instead,
    1
  586. I don't pay much credence to the John Oliver side, as he is still one sided on this topic. He wants cleaned the puberty blockers can be reversed, which sounds like how on Earth could that possibly be true and it's a complicated thing is puberty. And in terms of sports, biological males have records better than the biological woman.
    1
  587. So modern humans could speak better. Good questions by the interviewer, amazing stuff from the prof.
    1
  588. ​ @porphura4448 why are you wasting energy on it and thinking about it if it is so not important.
    1
  589. Yes, they are the most awful activists. Yes I have had arguments with far right people, but at least they have a sense of humour, the trans rights extremists are like some steroid induced bodybuilder screaming abuse at people, and sitting down to sob, you think its safe, then they are back to the screaming.
    1
  590. Who cares, why should a intellectual be bothered about anything other than intellectual pressures. Lots of working class people agree with him, it does not matter if some dont, as facts matter, not class, race or politics. Evolutionry biology is nothing to do with class, he should focus on the beautiful facts he knows, like on gender, and let clever working class people listen, the gin Alley dunces lot can keep with their gin and fighting. Ps loads of working class people agree with him, yes some don't, but those people dont matter more.
    1
  591. In your dreams,
    1
  592. ​​​ @venga3 but surely linehan as king of the justice system of Scotland, who decides everything apparently, also got dankula his interviews on the piers Morgan show, and as the supreme judge of Scotland, also made sure that dankula was released, so surely he should be thanking him for that. Also we'll done linehan for using the sas to put down that prison riot in the 1980s in Scotland, as surely he is in charge of all Scottish justice matters apparently. Well done him for that. And linehan must have made sure Scotland has had no gun massacres since dunblane, as of his supreme galactic power over all Scottish legal matters, well done linehan,
    1
  593. Some people like biological females, sone like biological males, hey that's ok with me.
    1
  594. Trans rights activists talk about compassion, but are the least so you could imagine.
    1
  595. ​​​​​​​​​ @jackspring7709 oh you campaigned, wouldn't it be great in a western movie if Charles Bronson when hearing about there being baddies stealing land has written a letter of complaint to a newspaper, or if a John wayne character had written a sternly worded comment on a video about a land buying in Chicago real estate, saying, well it's terrible some baddies did something in dodge city. That would have sorted all the problems out,vans if had blamed middle class ladies in New York for all the crime, in dodge city, the John Wayne character could have had a shorter movie, yes but actually done anything about it, but he could have felt proud he wrote so e YouTube comments. Let's be honest, you did very little, and called on other people, big strong men, to sort it out. I have nothing against men, good men are great, but we should protect women where we can and support them where we can, as women protect us men where they can. The same people who caused Rochdale, uncaring people, also did but care about women in the trans debate. And they included as many right wing populists as imaginary liberals. Where were you when the abuse happened, did you try and stop it, did you do anything other than send emails and blame powerless beautiful intelligent courageous driven middle class women, who are so powerless they lose court cases to people like who sal Glover lost her case to. Trans rights extremism, Jimmy Saville and the Rochdale abuse cases were caused by the mentality you are showing here, making excuses for the unfair things occurring, and saying it does not matter, you should be ashamed, that the mentality you are showing, allowed those terrible things to occur, shame on people who have the mentality you are showing here.
    1
  596. Human beings are not frogs. Sorry
    1
  597. ​ @FightXScience-wh6kx but lots of left wingers agree with him on biological sex exists.
    1
  598. ​What's that got to with anything.
    1
  599. ​ @barrywhite1770 no, it is so so rare, if anything it just underlines the existence of biological sex. Yes some humans have six fingers but it's fair to say humans have five fingers on each hand. Even though that's more common than what you talk about.
    1
  600. It's a woman.
    1
  601. Russia beat trumps America in Ukraine,
    1
  602. He should have said, hey why you wearing the same suits, i did nit know we are at a idiot convention.
    1
  603. His view was changed as of public pressure.
    1
  604. ​ @guyfieri7189 the most misogynistic people are often biological males campaigning against what they call terfs. The things they say about them, are terrible.
    1
  605. Without suit, didn't had suits, didn't picked up, your grammar, so disrespectful.
    1
  606. Poverty fell under him.
    1
  607. ​ @steveclark2887 most of the immigrants were good people.
    1
  608. They claim Nepal has a IQ in the fifties, which is absolutely impossible. The society would have collapsed in that case.
    1
  609. ​​​​​ @aliendroneservices6621 well how did sherpa tensing climb Everest then, if his IQ was that low, he would have not known what a rope is for. This shows racism is nonsense. How does nepal have such beautiful buildings. Despite never being colonised. Could you have the intelligence to be the first person to climb Everest, what it your greatest personal achievement compared with Sherpa Tensing. Tell me what have you done in your life that compares favourably to Sherpa Tensing.
    1
  610. ​​ @aliendroneservices6621 if that were true Hilary would have fallen to his death with Sherpa, as the climb would have been like something out of the three stooges, with unattached ropes on tensings end. This belief that nepalis have such a low IQ, is utterly laughable, and what's worse is the people making the claim, are not man enough to climb the highest mountain in the world, on a uncharted route. So what loons these racists are. For anybody to believe nepalis have such a low IQ, the person would have to have such a low IQ themselves to be so gullible.
    1
  611. ​ @aliendroneservices6621 he was just the child of random Nepal yak herders, and did something that needed intellectual ability well above the racism,ist keyboard warriors malining entire races here. He a normal Nepali climbed Everest first, or second, could you guys have done that. I did not think so.
    1
  612. ​ @bevs9995 I accept there are clever people in every country, and there are stupid people in every country, so are stupid people in China, as well as Europe and everywhere else who believe in stupid racist beliefs, but that does not make stupid racist beliefs right. I wonder if the Chinese racists can't spell, like the European racists, can't spell.
    1
  613. But how many Russian places want to break away, surely it's abnormal to take other states land by force.
    1
  614. Biological sex.
    1
  615. Yes, Moira is a good woman.
    1
  616. Richard Dawkins, jk rowling and Krause agree with her. It's not far right to believe biological sex exists.
    1
  617. It is not far right to believe biological women exist, look at Dawkins and Rowling.
    1
  618. I think he is too famous for that, like jk Rowling, chapelle, and Gervais.
    1
  619. The Gulf of Mexico is the name, facts is facts.
    1
  620. It is not, the IQ differences are tiny at best.
    1
  621. ​ @anotherfreediver3639 it is for sure though, that people of higher iqs support internationalism, look at Oppenheimer, he was very left wing, while people of lower iqs are often very ignorant racists, ,
    1
  622. I have not seen any evidence of him being a Marxismt, he is a musician, and sensible Marxism support linehan.
    1
  623. But they don't mind working with Jimmy carr, who made the horrible remark about gypsies and the Holocaust, or many other people who have said worse jokes than that. Some of them even defended Carrs joke on that issue. They all love to work for the sun, or telegraph if it offers them a role, or be interviewed by them for their glossy magazines. It's hypocrisy, anybody who speaks out on this subject, with normal mainstream views like Dawkins, Chapelle or Kathleen stock is the victim of a hate campaign, from activists, and to some extent quarantined by mainstream media, who should know better, and they should be tolerated for their normal mainstream beliefs, just like we do in a democracy, they should not be shunned, in a bullying manner, or sent to Coventry for quite mainstream beliefs. As they are often right.
    1
  624. How dare he stand up to a orwellian orthodoxy,that hardly anyone truly believes in.
    1
  625. Some are like Helen Joyce, but not all.
    1
  626. Well done Sharron. Brilliant stuff she is a heroine. ,,
    1
  627. Well done Riley for standing up to this Kafkaesque Orwellian Alice on Wonderland, Pythonesque nonsense.
    1
  628. But what about the rights of biological women,
    1
  629. 😂
    1
  630. Andrew Doyle and Joanne cherry oppose the extremism as well. And are LGBT.
    1
  631. And Lionel Messi is 5 foot 6, the greatest sports star of our generation, so don't make excuses
    1
  632. Well if so, stop trying to impose it on a country that just doesn't want it, why don't you argue against homelessness or against poverty or war, why on earth, are you on this comment section arguing in favour of something which nobody can really defend, which is totally unpopular everywhere, why not just agree that it's a silly thing to have and just concentrate on important things. Ditch this silly Orwellian belief, and get on with useful stuff.
    1
  633. 5000 men have beaten the women's hundred meters record, any study that denied biologicl sx exists, is a silly study.
    1
  634. Rubbish
    1
  635. Yes, it's such a a first world problem, the fact newspapers and politicians are campaigning for biological males in women's sports, when there are homeless people freezing on streets, and wars around the world, when nobody supports it, is just terrible. I say keep oppoising this orwellian nonsense.
    1
  636. Surely we should be more tolerant of her fears you know, if a woman felt threatened by me, I would feel awful I would feel unhappy, I wouldn't call her a bigot, I would try to understand why she feels my behaviour or the way I am threatens her. That's right one of the things I do, is I never walk down an alleyway after a woman has gone down it. There is loads of behaviour we as men do, so we don't make women feel uncomfortable. Part of tolerance is also respecting, the fears and rights of women in our society, it's not bigoted to understand those fears, we should be nice to trans people, just because he has a perfectly understandable fear of men, because I've seen many situations where there was proved to be quite a sensible fear. Like a few days ago I saw these biological males in their thirties saying rude things about women on the train, and I saw one of the women just moved to another carriage, she was a being her instinct which was to be quite fearful of those biological males, and by the look on her face, it was quite a strong fear. And in reality she was the best person to protect herself her fear and her instinct, was the best form of protection. With it never call women bigots, for listening to their instincts, because in reality of biological males, just these guys showed, don't have the same spidey senses that the average biological woman has.
    1
  637. ​ @assses-3216 give a example of where she behaved as you say. My interpretation was that she was chosen as an example, so that everybody would feel threatened, to be afraid of agreeing with her opinions. In reality the attempt to cancel her, was a terrible choice and interesting emboldened herself and people who agreed with her. Can you give me an example of where the acted in the way you say, and also why should JK Rowling not block anybody she feels like, she can block whoever she wants, just like you can say I'm not going to talk to this person or that person. She was the one being misrepresented, I remember countless times people would say what did she say that was so terrible, and nobody would be able to give a quotation of what she actually said.
    1
  638. But why not just not have the unpopular pointless idea of having trans women in women's sports. Why not love trans people, build houses for everyone, and not campaign for the pointless unpopular idea of having a few trans people in women's sports. Why lose a election on such a completeliy unimportant issue. That no person who has thought about it for more than a few seconds, support.
    1
  639. Keep up the good work Bill Maher.
    1
  640. In most situations we don't need to care, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins is also someone criticized for saying biological sex exists, but was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤ we should oppose bullying of trans people, but it is ok to sensible nuanced laws which accept sex exists.
    1
  641. Dankulas terrible act was training his dog to get excited and happy, when mentioning the gassing of victims of the Holocaust, a very unfunny and strange act. Nothing to be proud of, and anybody who condemned him for that was within their rights. Ps I think dankula should be forgiven for his stupid act, but don't act like what he did was done heroic act, I am sure he has done good stuff for people, and made good jokes in his life, but that stupid thing he did was dumb. Not that any of us are perfect, and to be honest dankulas friends should have told him it was dumb as well. Biological sex exists whether dankula fans or extreme trans activists and far right activists accept it or not.
    1
  642. Is trump derangement syndrome when you support trump.
    1
  643. Yep, christians and atheists can agree on this. Personal god confusion, sounds like personal Jesus, from Depeche mode.
    1
  644. Russia and USA have corruption.
    1
  645. They are not regarded as a actual third sex. And it would not make it right even if they did say that. You can't just say, other country believes this, therefore it is right. You have to give reasons.
    1
  646. ​​ @hend1n1 but it is wrong to see native Americans as sons otherworldly spirit beings, they are part of the human race, and in this rational world are subject to the same biological realities as everybody else. Sometimes people do fantasy utopianism views of Celts, or Saxons, or some groups, but facts is facts, and mystical beliefs are interesting, but just beside the point on a lot.
    1
  647. People speak in different ways, down accent snobbery, what is this, posh bullies bully the middle class.
    1
  648. And on much they are really socially liberal, except on gender critical views, on which they are still gender critical as they are feminist like jk Rowling.
    1
  649. I can believe that,
    1
  650. Actually the American accent sounds exactly like Canadian and scotch Irish, and it comes from Scotland.
    1
  651. What , lose all its allies.
    1
  652. ​ @LoreEclectic are you saying there are females and male brains, that makes no sense.
    1
  653. Who wouldn't, yes amazing.
    1
  654. Dankula won like last place in a election in Scotland.
    1
  655. That is a very mean spirited attitude towards Brooke, trans rights activists claim to be the only ones who are compassionate in this debate. In reality they seem to be full of so much full of so much aggression and mean spiritedness. The lady Brook is just saying some reasonable concerns which never seem to have reasonable arguments put back. All she gets is a kind of angry full aggression like the kind of mean spiritedness I see in this comment. Stop the Orwellian meanness towards those who dissent.
    1
  656. He just opposed the crazyness,
    1
  657. Aren't a lot of the conservative left parties, really gender critical socially liberals. Like the Scottish alba party have been called socially liberal, but are gc views are a form of feminism. So still liberals, nit conservatives. Dawkins and Rowling argue gc views from a liberal mindet, nit biblical.
    1
  658. == Alba are Socially liberal, They are not that socially conservative, they are pro choice on abortion, support the Human Rights act, support same sex-marriage, they support penalties against hate speech, support refugees, support a allowance of Women to serve in combat roles, oppose Capital punishment, oppose national service, support limiting misinformation, oppose the House of Lords, encourage diversity training, oppose flag burning laws, the only thing they dont support is parts of the Gender reform acts, so they are really a Gender Critical Socialy Liberal party. :But you choose the sources and surely a objective look, would say they are very much the same as the SNP on most things, and really they are just a party of people out of favour with the SNP leadership, they are not conservative on anything, Salmond was thrown out of the SNP in the 80s for being too left wing, and Tommy Sheridan, a Militant anti poll tax socialist, is in it, and the Proclaimers, supported them. They have ex-SNP MPs like Ash Regan, surely its a Socially Liberal Gender Critical Party, of mainstream Centre Left economics, led by people who fell out of favour with the then SNP leadership.:A basic look at what they believe in, and understanding of what constitutes centre left and socially liberal, can you give me a list of socially conservative things they believe in, not to do with Gender Critical policies. Can you give a few examples of socially conservative policies they have, outside of GC views.
    1
  659. Nice to see people can debate this issue without bluster.
    1
  660. Funny for a racist rally.
    1
  661. Fascinating and inspiring story.
    1
  662. He is being bombed
    1
  663. Its like loch ness
    1
  664. The fasc something its,
    1
  665. How dare he stand up to a orwellian orthodoxy, that does not stand up to scrutiny.
    1
  666. ​​​ @bl00m1mgt0n thanks for the lovely thoughts, oh so sweet,😂😂😂😂😂, such charm and friendlyness.
    1
  667. ​​​ @bl00m1mgt0n I am not angry, I think trans people should be treated nicely, but also think we should accept biological sex exists, if we lose the debate, and we all have to accept the position, that some activists want, of biological men in women's sports, etc, well we will just have to get on with it and accept it. I am not angry at all. Good day to you. Nothing to be angry about..ps just insulting people all the time is not good for you. Have a good day. Joy to the world.
    1
  668. ​ @bl00m1mgt0n ps, I wish great joy and happiness for you,
    1
  669. Actually yes even the audience did not laugh.
    1
  670. I agree, the people who have been trying to force biological males into women's sports we're just so disgraceful. It's like the Green party in Scotland where there was a so-called left-wing party elected to office, so when the Scottish government said it was not going to have a recycling bottle scheme the Green party said oh we're going to stay in the government we're not bothered about that. When really any respectable Green party would have left the government purely that. But then a month later the official British government report stated that puberty blockers were not that good for young people so stated they should be a moratorium. Bizarre the Green party took it upon themselves to claim they were some kind of experts on this issue which had nothing to do with green issues and decided to leave the government over that. And Kamala Harris probably lost a trump because of it, so because of this issue, so because of that Ukraine will lose funding, Canada Panama and Greenland are losing their sovereignty, welfare will be cut, the environment will suffer, taxes on the rich will be cut, and all because there's some people who seem to believe that biological males in women's sports is a more important issue than anything else in the world. Wouldn't it be better to just say let's accept what people want which is they don't want biological males and woman sports and for perfectly good reasons and let's just let it be like that.
    1
  671. There is nothing wrong with having advantages, the problem is being born a biological male in women's sports. Being born a biological male in women's sport is an unfair advantage. Being born taller or faster or stronger is not an unfair advantage in sport if that's what you are. But it is an unfair advantage to be born biologically male in women's sports. As we already have spots for biological males. Clearly you know that 5000 men have been in the women's 100 m record, the USA women's team lost to the wrexham retirees team, Andy under 15 men's Dallas team, what more evident do you need.
    1
  672. Dawkins is not a communist, and the ussr never had this stuff.
    1
  673. Father Ted is super funny, watch it , it will make you laugh,
    1
  674. His father is Welsh, and he has lived in Wales most of his life. And look his very Welsh name.
    1
  675. That's scary, hope that is not the case 😂😂😂
    1
  676. ​ @MrMeatballMasterMort no, with a woman. Don't talk rubbish.
    1
  677. 😂
    1
  678. ​ @janetshemaryahu5529 nah
    1
  679. ​ @DarthChrisJ the famous news night interview where he was treated like a war criminal for critcicisng the now condemned Tavistock.
    1
  680. Dankulas terrible act was training his dog to get excited and happy, when mentioning the gassing of victims of the Holocaust, a very unfunny and strange act. Nothing to be proud of, and anybody who condemned him for that was within their rights. Ps I think dankula should be forgiven for his stupid act, but don't act like what he did was done heroic act, I am sure he has done good stuff for people, and made good jokes in his life, but that stupid thing he did was dumb. Not that any of us are perfect, and to be honest dankulas friends should have told him it was dumb as well. Biological sex exists whether dankula fans or extreme trans activists and far right activists accept it or not.
    1
  681. ​​ @bunkaaa8726 he can say what he likes. His joke mocked Hitler, dankulas joke mocked Holocaust victims,bits the total opposite. Why do you drone on about dankula, when what he did was rubbish, and should be forgotten about, but condemn linehan, is it as he thinks biological males who committed raped, and have a intact male organ, should not be allowed to share women's prison cells,even if they identify as women.
    1
  682. ​​​​​ @bunkaaa8726 are you one of those extreme liberals who defend Islamic extremists when they drive through Jewish neighborhoods making threats to the women, as you defend pranks and so called free speech. I say dankulas act was rubbish, and nobody should mock the victims of the Holocaust like that, sorry, but if you care about free speech, accept I have a right to say that, just like you have a right to criticize those of us who condemn Nazis and Islamic extremists. You have a right to defend Islamic extremists, but I have a right to criticize religious extremists and the far right as well.its called freedom, get used to it.
    1
  683. Is it legal to say man, without asking their pronouns,
    1
  684. He knows more about it than you. In reality his knowledge has just increased,
    1
  685. ​​​​ @TheRover2010 all you do is insult others, I am not a bigot a out anything, you are clearly the hateful arrogant individual who just shouts abused at others, supplying no worth to the debate. Supplying no evidence for your claims. I would say the snot in Dawkins hanky has more knowledge about biology than the ignorant hateful bigots who insult him. And it could probably write a comment with more evidence.
    1
  686. ​ @TheRover2010 all you do is insult, that's a far right tactic, left wingers are nice and deal in facts, which is why people like Dawkins saying stuff. Stop being full of hate. Gender critical ideals are truth and reality, the one truth.
    1
  687. ​ @TheRover2010 ok, ok, you insult him again and giv no evidence. It's been a waste of my time as ever.
    1
  688. His baby universes remark proves that remark utterly indefensible, amazing insight by him.
    1
  689. ❤❤In most situations we don't need to care, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins is also someone criticized for saying biological sex exists, but was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤ we should oppose bullying of trans people, but it is ok to sensible nuanced laws which accept sex exists.
    1
  690. Ps your horrible disgusting remarks about fumes and suicide and such shows how many trans rights activists are the most hateful spiteful nasty forces. It says more about how hateful your side are than anything. Love to all. but it shows he is fighting the good fight
    1
  691. Riley Gaines is a beautiful young woman, and good.
    1
  692. 😮Have you seen the Wikipedia article on gender critical feminism, it's just a Orwellian hit job, trying to link the centrist belief, with the far right. This is done by mentioning the words, conservative, far right, right wing, anti trans and terf, together over one hundred times in the article, like someone in a Orwellian 15 minutes of hate, but left wing and socialism, something most gender critical people are, is mentioned no times. Also i looked at Wikipedia article on Hitler, it mentions far right once, and in relation to where he is is in the photo, so Wikipedia is more nuanced on the most evil man in history, than on the moderate centrist belief of gender critical feminism. . I think gender idealogy believers are ironically the most far right Orwellian bigots , totally unprepared to listen to others.
    1
  693. Why do you get bold writing, but not me,
    1
  694. If you speak against biological males in women's sports, there is always a Orwellian Hate campaign against you, I hope you oppose that
    1
  695. CCool discussion, Joe Rogan has topics I am interested in, so much, and Richard Dawkins very clever. Yes it's interesting how successful Mormonism is, though I don't like criticising people's deeply felt beliefs, but great to hear others views on religons. Though I agree some nice people believe in all sorts of things. Amazing. I believe Mormonism was actually part of the late 19th century religious revival. It was surprisingly popular among Welsh emigrants, which was experiencing a boom in Methodist beliefs at the time. Indeed mitt Romney's wife was part Welsh.
    1
  696. Which country did they create
    1
  697. No to nuclear submarines in my town, 😅😅😅😅😅
    1
  698. Yes, other than some non binary biological women.
    1
  699. What a clever man, he had a answer for everything, amazing. Shame to hear the yew trees factoid is a myth. And the green man, its hard to keep up with it all.
    1
  700. ​ @nevilleconnolly8938 but he was still good in it
    1
  701. Who
    1
  702. If that's ok, why not just have the biological male who identifies as a woman in the men's competition, if they don't have a problem with you, they sure won't have a problem with a biological male, who identify as a woman, that's the obvious need.
    1
  703. No left wing people support testosterone decline.
    1
  704. In your dreams,
    1
  705. Ghosts
    1
  706. But at the moment the technology is not here,
    1
  707. Very interesting, 😎 tell me more, blah blah rhubarb
    1
  708. Absolutely
    1
  709. And Stormy Daniels, how's she.
    1
  710. Nah
    1
  711. But lots of Jews died in the wtc so no, such as Joshua Reiss.
    1
  712. Anybody who speaks up on this is bullied in a hate campaign by orwellian bullies, I hope you are not part of that.
    1
  713. But biological males have a unfair advantage, as biological males are on average, bigger, and tougher, it's like it would be unfair if I finished fiftieth in a race instead of 49th, as someone in 40th took steroids.
    1
  714. ​ @TheRover2010 He doesn't bully trans people, give a example where he does, or accept he does not.
    1
  715. ​ @TheRover2010 not from now on, as your just full of abuse and wasting everybody's time. 😮😖
    1
  716. Amen to that.
    1
  717. ​@Russianngineer_bmstu which he was also wooden and rubbish in.
    1
  718. What nonsense. Nobody is saying that being better at sports makes you superior. Look at fdr the greatest leader in history, he could not walk, and was terrible at tennis. Also it's glaringly obvious the best men do better than the best women. So it's unfair to merge the categories. I mean a Dallas boys team beat the USA women's team at soccer.
    1
  719. No, let's face it, biological males, are on average bigger, and stronger, and more robust, remember that trans MMA fighter who crushed a cis women's skull, and boasted about beating up terfs.
    1
  720. But Australia famously has a chip on its shoulder about British people. Surely Aussies should agree that race science is wrong, as if 19th century race science was true, then Australia would have the IQs of the convicts sent there. Surely Australia was like the opposite of sending your best and brightest to a space colony. It had the poorest, and criminals sent there, but still as of democracy and culture, and resources, is super wealthy, with many of the best sports people, and minds in the anglosphere. Surely if race science is right, it should be a bedraggled cesspit, of poverty. The same goes for the USA, which also had many of the poorest sent there, but also did very well.
    1
  721. I think we can forgive dankula, but there is a huge difference between someone being cancelled for saying biological sex exists, ie telling a brutal truth. And someone, Dankula being condemned rightly, for the terrible act of training his dog to get excited at the mention of gassing victims of the Holocaust. We should forgive dankula, but what he did deserved condemning, while what linehan did in saying biological sex exists, deserves praise.
    1
  722. Turning the computer on.
    1
  723. The united States of North Gulf of Mexico, is a cool country, my third favorite in North Gulf of Mexico land.
    1
  724. ​ @No_real_democracy if you describe people as rats, you have no reasonable right to call others, narrow minded.
    1
  725. ​​​​ @ScorpionSuerte because Scottish people prefer monopoly. Also I can't take that statement seriously as you spell that, thab, so your remarks are not truly attentive to accuracy, sorry all your remarks are to be ignored. I hope you are not a air traffic controller, with such poor accuracy levels.
    1
  726. ​ @ScorpionSuerte nope, I posted the most comments, so win, and corrected your poor spelling, which was right at the end of a comment, like someone making a speech, and putting a bowler hat on their head, which to their surprise was filled with custard, I get the points, for noticing the mistake. You lost as you did the error, I win as I pointed it out, like the story of the emperor's new dress.
    1
  727. ​ @ScorpionSuerte I'm not the one spouting big headed racial supremacy theories, thab is a thing thab you do, and thab is why it is funny to mock your hilarious errors. Look in the mirror for faults, not at others.
    1
  728. ​ @ScorpionSuerte you are the one who is doing that, clear as day. Vile racists. ...
    1
  729. Lefties like Oppenheimer and Einstein have higher iqs
    1
  730. How can we the West keep losing all these wars, it's not a good sign to surrender.
    1
  731. ​Women's volleyball should be won by the best biological female athletes,
    1
  732. ​​​ @josephsimmons9241 well why do we have women's sports then, if they are all the same level. Have you ever seen the difference between men and women's sports, look at football, a men's under fifteen team, beat the USA women's team. Why are you ignoring the reality, we have women's sports, so they can also get medals. And us men's football is poor, and women's is the best on earth. Ps to say women HAVE to compete against those born men, is very unfair, it's like bullying. It's like a jock bullying a nerd, or even a pe teacher, bullying a kid as he can't climb ropes well enough. It's simply abuse.
    1
  733. 5000 men have ran faster than the the 100 meters record
    1
  734. ​ @Alice-May no, he accepts that Brooke is affected by this.
    1
  735. Nah, it's a separate issues.
    1
  736. I like volleyball, it's great, and tennis, I have been to women's sports and men's sports. The people imposing this are the people who do not care about women's sports.
    1
  737. Well why are the glaciers melting then.
    1
  738. Britain is not third world, even most drug takers begging on the streets have enough to eat, we have a lot of problems, but most of them are not third world, its first world probs, like obesity, and drugs, and some daft policy misadeventures.
    1
  739. When did he talk About homosexuality.
    1
  740. ​I think they were just asking, I don't think they had a agenda. ​ @robertlabonte3118 
    1
  741. I don't see whats woke about it, its just daft and arty. It does not seem eoke to me. Maybe some of the models look a bit masculine, but we don't bother about that, it is nothing compared to the bud light advert, its not pushing a idealogy.
    1
  742. She is a pretty looking lady, typical Volleyball type.
    1
  743. They are funny, but should be more sensitive to him.
    1
  744. I was a cossack in fiddler on the roof, and a Jewish villager.
    1
  745. Yes, don't even try.
    1
  746. But surely he means ancestors like the evolutionary biological meaning, like I don't know if any of the neanderthal remains we have in museums, reproduced in their lifetime, but as they have relatives for sure who did, they are our ancestors in that sense.
    1
  747. Lower testosterone men just won't compete, we want to see the fastest men on earth and the fastest women, not the fastest men and fastest men who identify as women.
    1
  748. What, surrendering millions of people to genocide.
    1
  749. But he gave the right answers.
    1
  750. ​ @thatadamlad it needs heavyweights brains to be there.
    1
  751. I wrote biological women, on the BBC comments page, as said it was Orwellian to ban people from being able to convey their beliefs, and what people believe that biological srx exists, so the Orwellian editors have put restrictions on my account, I am proud, as my view is she should be allowed to convey her remarks, as she is clearly scientifically right, if any thing it's the reverse view that biological s,x does not exist, that is strange, and would be more deserving of banning, not that it should be. I enjoy this debate, as it makes me feel clever, and intelligent, able to throw the insults at those trying to restrict my view, that I am like Winston smith, and they are like o brien, and unlike the end of 1984, i shall not say i love big brother,bi shall not give on, as there is a spirit in man that will always accept the truth.
    1
  752. He never tried to assassinate anybody. He is a blameless man. Your statement and claim is appalling he has never tried to assassinate anybody, the man is a comedian.
    1
  753. ​​ @leonardcomani not trump and Vance for sure, or every other American I have ever seen big bellies. .
    1
  754. So why did he not mention the trans rights activist, who was a murderer, who murdered some gender critical people, in his documentary on the feminist camp, that was awful.
    1
  755. But I dont think it was just that, I mean Ronson is great, and has done some fine stuff, fab fellow. But he kind of on this issue, some people critisise him for making a documentary on this issue, where the trans right activists were painted as all sweetness and light, and the concerns of the gender critical women, were not really given equal weight, it was kind of all, hey lets all come together on the angle the trans rights activists want. Which was quite typical of the current debate and way laws are enacted by centrist and centre left and even centre right parrties at the moment, (well untill the right and in Britain the left, realised its a vote winner, as GC ideas have credance and are right). And bizarely this was a place where there had been a murder by a extreme very untypical trans rights activist of a gender critical campaigner. I think it was the Dana Rivers case, it would be like doing a video on the troubles in Northern Ireland, and acting ;like only side had people who comnitted violence oir unfair acts, and that the othger side is all sweetness and light, which even many Sinn Fein or DUP supporters would kind of be a bit perplexed about. I mean I wish some kind of compromoise could be made, that accepts everybody, including gc requests, but I think even Ronson feels he has to apologise a bit, for missing the Rivers case from his documentary, so its understandable people are perplxed he made such a untypical Ronsson video, and probably media should be told, hey hang on here whats all this about when it misses major things. It would be like doing a documentary on World War Two, and painting the Americans as pure baddies, by just ignoring Pearl Harbour, and saying America declared war on Japan for no reason what so ever. Or a documentary on JFK visit to Dallas, that utterly ignores the assassination. The same here, I mean GC people have some concerns and certain people totally ignore their reasonings and act like they are just horrible bigots and even call them Nazis and bigots just for querying anything to do with this issue.
    1
  756. If guys like him are not, trans rights extremists bring in their Orwellianism at full pace, well done e jk Rowling, and co for standing up to this stuff. If you don't stand up to this, it's like failing at a 1984 computer game, before level one, I mean if you can't stand up to this, what would you stand up to.
    1
  757. He did not steal money, you selfish person.
    1
  758. No tcp in the shops, as of brexit
    1
  759. Personal attacks, all trains rights campaigners have is personal attacks on anybody who criticises their Orwellianism and beliefs.
    1
  760. Brilliant article, absolutely right.
    1
  761. And the thing is they do have a advantage. If it were not for them being male, they would have less strength.
    1
  762. Hamburger eating surrender monkeys.
    1
  763. He understands everything.
    1
  764. I thought he came in to offer people blueberries, from planet blue, did not think he was a journalist.
    1
  765. Nope
    1
  766. I think it was rubbish what dankula did, it was not heroic, it was like pooing in the town square, why can't we have more decorum, why do people think this anything goes , do anything you w Want liberalism of say anything you want, do anything what you want, identifies whatever, is right. Surely we need a more decorum society, we need national service for the thugs and the arrogant.
    1
  767. But it's just so low, the lowest form of jokes.
    1
  768. I am crying, please stop being mean.
    1
  769. ​​​​ @stevel9914 he killed millions, caused a war that killed 40 million, I mean come off it. I oppose crazy ridiculous extreme trans rights ideas, but it's not as bad as AH. Ah regime did murderous experiments on live twins, and killed children as of their race. It was a million times worse than even gender idealogy. They put opposing nations soldiers in camps, and slave labour, of which many died, they bombed cities from Guernica to Coventry. They invaded over a dozen countries in Europe in just a few years. They fired Jewish people from their jobs to such a crazy extent, that some of those Jews were genius level people who sided Oppenheimer. And are you now saying ah was pro christian, I thought most feel he was a typical mid Century agnostic. The swastika was a kind of pre Christian symbol, they were not Christians. Also in the end the wars ah caused saw russia run riot over Germany. So it was not even a good thing for his ideas. I mean as of ah crazy ideas, and foolish decision to invade Russia, by a few years Germans were brutally expelled from lands where they had lived for centuries. All because of ah macho dream of lebensraum. His wat loving, imperialist ideas were appalling. And weirdly ironically some of ah people actually did forced experiments on people against their will, even worse than the worst of gender idealogy. And going on about porn, well he was not that great a figure in terms of Christian sexual norms. He had a affair with a relative of his, geli raubal, has sex before marriage, and three of his lovers killed themselves. I mean that's hardly normal. Also what's your view on ah friend rohm. Here is a weird fact, the ussr banned homosexuality in 1933 as they associated it with German millitarism, what a weird fact. Anyway, I don't think banning gay porn, is a good excuse for the nazis. Also mainstream anti trump GOP guys like Kemp have cut down gender idealogy. And ps there were lots of Germans on the good side on the war, fighting with the US army, like Eisenhower.
    1
  770. Clown show is the blue suit brigade.
    1
  771. I don't think many people would feel threatened by the vast majority, if they look like the famous ones I remember.
    1
  772. Glinner is not a communist, except on a use of the term that regards the vast majority of people as communists. He is actually very middle of the road.
    1
  773. He did not throw him under any bus
    1
  774. Biological males can just play with biological males, most of them did most of their lives.
    1
  775. Zielinski suit remark, was comedy genius
    1
  776. ​ @ScorpionSuerte you spell than, thab, your accuracy levels, and so everything you write can be ignored.
    1
  777. ​ @ScorpionSuerte you ain't no buddy of mine, another innacuracy,
    1
  778. I will have the duck please, followed by chocolate pie
    1
  779. ​​ @IncubusBroth but it can take time to develop the maturity to have opinions on things like this. Maybe she just accepted what authorities decided like most of us do, then thought about it differently as time went on. And surely being born biological male, makes you on average taller, and bigger, something not even most drugs can do, surely there is argument it is a unfair advantage against the non transgender women athletes.
    1
  780. No, that was birds.
    1
  781. But surely the two terms you use mean the same thing, I mean you could use both, and it would not be a lie. Surely that is a problem with a idealogy, if just using a slightly different term in itself, harms it's intellectual validity. Spin doctor language does not change the logic of a situation, if you already understand that occurrence.
    1
  782. Trump has been corrected by 3 leaders n a row
    1
  783. ​​ @Druku1977 yes, he tells it is, like a 100 percent pear cider, he gives it to you straight, like pear cider, made from delicious real pears.
    1
  784. ​ @sarbantz what on earth is a mis gender, what are you talking about,
    1
  785. They were begging people to buy his cars yesterday.
    1
  786. Put biological males in men's teams.
    1
  787. Mark steels visiting towns show was great, Inverness, Stockport, all sorts of places.
    1
  788. Most men as of evolution are attracted to biological women.
    1
  789. Fallon Fox.
    1
  790. Dawkins was friendly with Jan Morris, but also accepts biological sex exists, there is no room for abuse.
    1
  791. ​ @jasonchrist2172 Dawkins is a super high IQ, very rational person, he knows all about this stuff,band is a lefty.
    1
  792. What, well women can do anything they want with their photos, your argument is like the baddy in a movie, who says if a woman is more than friendly with one man, he must therefore have to be friends with him, what has happened to people to think what you have just said, it's disgraceful.
    1
  793. But clever fellow.
    1
  794. And surely Hitler was elected as the people were persuaded to oppose democracy. So Germany after the war realised democracy was right after all peeps. And look at all the severly inbred Pharaoh's, kings and queens who ruled withe the likes of Rasputin, or Japan warlords, monarchy failed big time, look at world war one, slavery and the Japanese empires.
    1
  795. No, he should also present panel shows.
    1
  796. Your kind of unforgiving rightists view is so woke.
    1
  797. ​​​ @sacredgeometry I think linehan is lucky not to be friends anymore with the so called lefty celebs who sold him down the river, as they were not real friends, unlike j Ross and the like, I think he should be willing to be friends with left and right wing people, but he should also think himself lucky to not be friends with right wingers who can't forgive him, they are people who are should be kept away from as well. I have learned in life to keep away from both those needy controlling types. I like good left wingers like Jonathan Ross, and good right wingers like well, Andrew Doyle.
    1
  798. Example would be the horrible event in Melrose last year when a little girl was kidnapped and abused by such a situation, it brought Nicola sturgeon down.
    1
  799. Dawkins is the best, his detractors are reality denying fantasists who believe that men can be women.
    1
  800. What is uneducated about him, all he is doing is saying biological sex exists and has consequences.
    1
  801. So why do some people think that the two separate categories should be merged socially, like biological males in women's prisons, or ​trans women in biology women sports.  @MrZeroFaith 
    1
  802. ​ @offthedeepend3996 is trump derangement syndrome, people who support him, or oppose him.
    1
  803. 😂, keep going, the world is amazing.
    1
  804. It's ok to be a Winston smith.
    1
  805. Yes, as he does acceptance biological sex exists.
    1
  806. ​ @denzellmovies but if you call yourself Ernie the ostrich, you have a name, and out special bells on your ostrich costume tail, they are ostriched clothes, does that mean ostrich is now your 👑 identity.
    1
  807. ​​​​but what if somebody believes it is their identity, and has a affinity with ostriches, like in the jungle book. I mean who are you to say what's acceptable or unacceptable, I'm not saying you don't have that right, ,but what makes it so, you can judge them on this issue. What's the big picture here, on the ostrich question, the right or the wrong. And who are you to say it is cartoonish. What if somebody believes they are a ostrich, surely that is possible, it must be, as people have done much more unusual things than that. And what about the perfectly well respected idea of native American spirit animals, like eagles or bears, isn't that identity.
    1
  808. ​​​​​​​​​​​​ @denzellmovies well then it makes the comparison not offensive, some people were offended when Dawkins compared a biological man. identifying as a woman, to identifying as a dog, but are you saying these people are being reasonable or unreasonable,if its ok to identify as a ostrich. Are you saying it's ok, to say they are a hateful ignorant out of date, bigot, to be compared with n,azis and racists and homophobes, if they don't accept the person is absolutely a ostrich. Like what most trans rights campaigners say about gender critical critics of the gender idealougues. To be honest, I don't think identifying as a ostrich makes you a ostrich,band I think mild gender critical views are pretty much a sensible way forward. We should be tolerant to trans, welcome them into society, but also accept biological sex exists, and we must decry those who bully gender critical believers. Muitos apolgencia, if I sound a little hot headed there. I mean no offence. Have a great time.
    1
  809. ​​​​​​​​​​​​​​ @denzellmovies 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢?ernie the ostrich, 😊? ?well maybe i have talked too long. That's where I leave this thread. Other than this, you are absolutely correct to have found out that some people believe gender, is a term that refers to identity and self expression, and some people believe it is more correct to define it by the same way we define sex. This truly is a interesting place for varied opinions. Well done you for looking at this subject, and deciding that you believe it refers to identity. What is your view though of those whose belief that gender as a word, refers to sex as well. Surely it's ok for them to choose that as the definition, just as some people who believe in gender idealogy, think the term women, should also include what they refer to a trans women. Do words matter here, can people use the terms dependent on their interpretation. Good week to yourself. Ps I am not saying anybody is lying about anything, so don't put words on my mouth there as i know one tool trans activists have, is to higher the temperature of the debate, by making allegations, about those on the gender critical side, to make it sound like they are just hateful and should be ignored, when in reality, all that has happened, is sometimes gender crirical people they are not Always agreeing with their opponents very rigid one dimensional terms, or interpretations.
    1
  810. It's based on when wolves raise humans.
    1
  811. Because trans rights activists certainly can't beat him in a debate.
    1
  812. Does that mean you lost your credibility by commenting.
    1
  813. Good points
    1
  814. Wales life expectancy has gained on England since 1999, and for the first time since the 14th century overtook north east England last year.
    1
  815. I Agree
    1
  816. It is ok to ban people from a university as they beat people up for being gay, but disgraceful to ban people for saying the reality that biological women exist as a different category from bio men who identify as ladies.
    1
  817. You have every right to vote for whichever party you want to, best of luck to you, dem, rep, green or libertarian,
    1
  818. ​ @josephsimmons9241 there is nothing more annoying than someone imposing something most people don't agree with on society,then claiming we are the obsessives, for not agreeing with it. Just stop imposing something that most people oppose, and listen to why most people oppose it. Yes let's end homelessness as well, but if the people trying to impose extreme trans rights, spent their time, ending homelessness, rather than this, they would do better. Stop trying to impose this unwanted belief, do something more useful.bso please don't comment again, instead of arguing for biological males in women's sports, go and build houses for the needy.
    1
  819. ​ @josephsimmons9241 who are the marginalized group, biological women's sports stars, who earn nothing.
    1
  820. ​​​ @josephsimmons9241 I don't hate trans people, but why do you need to have people who were born male, competing in women's sports, it is unreasonable to campaign for that. Surely we can have trans people in society, without having people who were born Male, competing in women's sports. What's wrong with them competing in the men's sports, can you tell why you think that would be wrong. If anything nebs sports gets more money and interest,vso if they are a marginalized group,why not put them in the richer more celebrated half of Spirit,rather than the already poorer, less celebrated, less roles part. Why take roles from one marginalized group, women in sports, why not take the roles of the least marginalized group, rich sportsmen. Ps why don't you campaign to end homelessness instead of chanting for people born male, to be taking people born women's, sporting places.
    1
  821. Dawkins is the king, he knows his stuff,
    1
  822. He is standing up against a daft orwellian idealogy, to not to, is like failing at 1984 the computer game level one.
    1
  823. The richest part of the globe
    1
  824. ​ @kylec1411 Canada has a higher life expectancy than USA or saudi
    1
  825. ​ @kylec1411 Canada has a higher life expectancy than USA, Saudi or Iran.
    1
  826. Z won,
    1
  827. Trump does as well, in fact he supports expelling the population, so you see the man who supports expelling the population, and you have no criticism of him, says what you really are, and that you don't care about Ukrainians, or Palestinians.
    1
  828. You would know.
    1
  829. Yes she is great.
    1
  830. She had this forced on her
    1
  831. It's suits, not shorts.
    1
  832. Good points
    1
  833. It's just the kind of pathetic abuse trans rights extremists say,c s their arguments are so weak.
    1
  834. ​ @lindamacleod1686 who did he ever victimize. Please tell.
    1
  835. You have no evidence for that. Things like this happen every so often, look at the 1947 Texas city disaster, you can't blame everything on dei.
    1
  836. Don't we all
    1
  837. Because it means the invader , the aggressor has won, against even the USA, it means evil can win, which is a sobering reality, it's like superman flying away to leave earth to general zod. 😢
    1
  838. Why use right wing nasty terms like snowflake.
    1
  839. Look at Ludlow or Harrogate, do these places look like shanty towns, get real.
    1
  840. He tours the front line, he said no to a us evacuation of him,
    1
  841. They were still crushed by him. .
    1
  842. Surely its not a dictatorship, is tbit a but like asian Switzerland with third way political beliefs.
    1
  843. I don't think he denies that gender disphoria exists.
    1
  844. But why wear a blue suit, was he picking blueberries, with roald Dahl characters, so disrespectful.
    1
  845. ​ @FluffyBunnyFeet how dare people stand up to orwellian orthodoxy, yes all morality plays like the crucible and such, tell us when something is occurring, we should all keep our heads down, and let it happen, not expressing any opinions on it. Lest anything bad happens to us,. Ps I am being ironic there.
    1
  846. He could have said to the questioner, which bin did you find your suit in.
    1
  847. The two things don't go together, it's like saying why don't NASA astronauts walk around with alasatians all day,
    1
  848. ​ @Mallarkey but surely this issue is being forced down our throats enough.
    1
  849. Vacuities is a new word on me, it means empty space thoughts.
    1
  850. And trans critics is offensive, as GC beliefs are about biology, not identity,
    1
  851. That was quite shocking.
    1
  852. Dankulas terrible act was training his dog to get excited and happy, when mentioning the gassing of victims of the Holocaust, a very unfunny and strange act. Nothing to be proud of, and anybody who condemned him for that was within their rights. Ps I think dankula should be forgiven for his stupid act, but don't act like what he did was done heroic act, I am sure he has done good stuff for people, and made good jokes in his life, but that stupid thing he did was dumb. Not that any of us are perfect, and to be honest dankulas friends should have told him it was dumb as well.
    1
  853. ​​​​​​ @Rhyds86 the chief rabbi of the Simon wisenthal institute advised he be taken to meet concentration camp victims, to see why mocking the victims of the Holocaust is not a good thing, so not everyone thought it was a heroic brave act. Would you be ok dude, if a islamist trained his dog to do that, I would be a bit worried if that occurred, and recommend a look at it by the authorities, but are you one of those extreme liberals who would say the police should not mind and we should tolerate islamist extremists doing things like that, I don't think so. I also oppose people pooing on war memorials, are you one of those extreme liberals who support desicration of our war graves for a laugh, I hope not. We need more decorum in our society, lock up the thugs and the louts, put young thugs and drunks in national service, teach you some manners ,some respect, good morals, less of this laughing at the weakest in society, teach you some respect, ps the judge was just having a laugh at his expense, he was just having a joke, so that makes it ok what he did on your book, huh, just a joke ha ha. Knew it would rile up, lolz. Lol
    1
  854. ​​​​​ @Rhyds86 Funny you think it's ok to mock victims of the Holocaust, but whine away dourly for dankula all day long, I ain't saying dankula deserved to go to jail, for the wokesters joke, but do you defend the wokesters for their prank joke, of locking dankula up, do you defend the wokesters for that prank. I am sure not. You defend pranks against Holocaust victims, but not pranks against comedians who mock Holocaust victims, hypocrisy.why do you oppose the pranks of wokesters, but not of non wokesters, and ps, linehan as far as I am aware, and correct me if I am wrong, is not a judge a d has no legal authority in Scotland, or any other country, as far as I am aware and correct me if I am wrong, he is not Scotlands judge dread, deciding all arrests and sentences, his words are not laws, and he does not decide who gets jobs, otherwise you should be thanking linehan for dankula being interviewed by pears morgan, and getting a job as a ukp Candidate, as obviously in your view linehan has total control over all the words hiring practices, of every country and person on the globe😭😭😭😭, ps I am being super ironic.
    1
  855. When he got the copy of black book of Carmarthen, its a suprise they did not think it was that channel 4 sitcom, the s4c version. Black books.
    1
  856. Volleyball is amazing, Gamova, Gabrielle Reece, zhou ruirrui, it is the true sport of kings
    1
  857. But look at every comment page, it's full of personal hate and criticism of him, just as of his beliefs. And nobody ever debates his beliefs, as his opponents arguments are often so weak.
    1
  858. They concern them as much as anybody else,
    1
  859. I did not think it was funny.
    1
  860. But there was no real debate on the issue, and the people who argue in favor of it, normally run a km from debating it.
    1
  861. What, completely unrelated people, wrongly spelt
    1
  862. Bad luck rangers, Celtic two penalty shoot out wins in a row, in two years, plus the hearts one, maybe maybe they lose if next time, I imagine hibs could do it.
    1
  863. Cool place
    1
  864. It's about defending yourself v attacks,
    1
  865. I don't support trump. I think we should accept trans people in our society, and I myself would have no problem working with someone who was trans, just the way Dawkins was friendly with Jan Morris, I would even be happy to use people's pronouns. What I find reprehensible is the aggressive overbearing nature of trans rights activists on certain nuanced issues. Let'sook at women's safe spaces, we should not call women, or the men who support those women bigots just for arguing that there are some points in favor of biologicl males, or trans women, using women's safe spaces. It's a legitimate debate. The same goes for women's sports. If we have women's sports, surely it is not because of cultural differences between men and women, surely it is as of differences in biology. And just calling someone a bigot, as they disagree with you, is so unreasonable. I think arguing for trans rights is a perfectly legit thing to do in a democracy, but why are so many trans rights activists, so aggressive and abusive, virtually every time they comment, they have some abusive remark aimed at who they speak to. All they do is shout bigot, which is not a argument, it just pushes people away from your side, antagonizes them. Most people today could not care less if a biological male wears women clothes and identifies as a woman, do what you like, but trans rights activists online, are just rude, and abusive. I mean come on, if course some people are going to debate these issues, don't just call them bigots, well good day to you, and what insult have you got for me next, love to you, love to trans people, love to all people, but hey come on what abusive remark have got for me, ps I don't like bullying or rude people., have you got any respect for others, or are you just going to insulte​ @themaestro3034 
    1
  866. I don't agree, i mean if you take away the richest part of the uk, Britain is much poorer yes, but thats true of most places. I don't think non London is third world, in fact those bits outside of it are often more rich looking. I don't think its remotely third world.
    1
  867. He jolted in shock at zelensy great remarks.
    1
  868. Today is for tidying the house
    1
  869. ​ @JackieChan-rk7mc it's not rude
    1
  870. Zelinsky should have said, to the crony questioner, nice suit do they have a men's department
    1
  871. So is he saying the yamanaya and cornered ware were like cousins, and then spread. Amazing.
    1
  872. China.
    1
  873. Babe and gandalf invited him.
    1
  874. We stand on the shoulders of giants, and it's easier to invent a bike, when someone else has invented the wheel.
    1
  875. 😂😂😂😂
    1
  876. Nah
    1
  877. There is no malice in their banter, no its his namem
    1
  878. ​ @WalterWhite-jz7ct prof Dawkins is just saying his opinion,
    1
  879. Vance is the one calling for a apology, zalinsky was the comedy roast King.
    1
  880. Epstein trump, private jet, 🤔
    1
  881. That's not fair, she is clearly left wing. She has traditionally backed labour, and remain. She backed the Iranian women protestors, and opposez trump. She even weighed in on Scottish independence , which I think upset some people, which I think was silly for such a proudly civil movement. It is not the same, to have segregation in terms of race for toilets, for to have separate bathrooms for men and women. There is no sensible safeguarding reason to have separate toilets for white and black people. But it is sensible to have different public toilets for men and women, for all sorts of safeguarding reasons. Maybe there is a argument for unisex in some situations, but not all. Also she does but demand people conform to certain womenhood looks. She like most gender critical people believe a woman can be short, or tall, a secretary or anything, even in the army, but just by having short hair or doing a macho job it does not make you a different gender. Like her famous quote, dress how they like, call themselves what they like, and then she said, a person born a biological male,is still man whether they wear a three piece suit or a flowery 👗 dress. So no, she does not believe in gender stereotypes, I mean she even had a male pen name, and has female characters like Hermione be the heroes. Also the debate she had about the boxers was a complex topic as Richard Dawkins talks.
    1
  882. Why are the nets lower for women in volleyball then,
    1
  883. ​ @LucienCanon what did you think of the German guy in the producers.
    1
  884. Too many Trans rights activists are bullying macho impervious aggressive fellows , who lack feminine compassion.
    1
  885. There are not, look at how the average person is not clever enough to be a doctor, but every country has produced doctors. .
    1
  886. Love this show, hecklefish 😂. Anyway i also love the way human debunks but lets there be a kernel if doubt. But i mean wouldn't a super civilisation know our planet revolves on its axis and change the message to suit those changes. Still the guy who dreamt thatbuo, kudos to his brain.
    1
  887. Agree
    1
  888. Same to you
    1
  889. It's just a a term anyway, you can see whatever you like about him but it doesn't stop him being pretty much an expert on subject that really mean that you can only really call them a scientist. Are you inventing a silly new definition of scientists that also is silly
    1
  890. But it's the.gender idealogy campaigners who gets annoyed and start huge campaigns if southern states ban sex change surgery on young minors, and I don't mean west Virginians there, I mean young people. It's the rich surgeons who are most interested in private parts.
    1
  891. Shame on your spelling
    1
  892. ​ @salvadorromero9712 who are these people who think mocking victims of the Holocaust is funny. I remember watching a documentary on pol pot and was physically shaken by it, genocide is not funny. It's like Stalin killing people was not funny, it was evil, and that poor grandfather who died after being jailed for his rubbish stupid looking sign, that was sad also.
    1
  893. Zelensy made some great jokes.
    1
  894. And his own suit looks like he got it from a tramp.
    1
  895. ​ @dvda9725 but people have been fired for mocking trump, it's such hypocrisy, that red haired lady.
    1
  896. Great show
    1
  897. Good idea, amazing thought. But what if they became mutant.
    1
  898. Like stormy Daniels
    1
  899. Clear trump is compromised, Epstein and Daniels prove that.
    1
  900. Cool show.
    1
  901. ​ @pipinpip the plurality of people in every country on earth have some terf beliefs,
    1
  902. ​​​​​​ @pipinpip in 2020, every party leader was afraid to say what a woman is. Now in 2024, the Tory leader is the leading gc person in the party. Stamer agrees biologico males should not be in women's sports. Even snp leader John Swinney says there are only two genders, the reform party George Galloway and britains leading communist party plus sinn fein, uup and dup, all accept some gc ideas as well, JK Rowling has crushed a boycott v her, and wes streeting, is gc now as well. Scotland the most left wing country in Europe has massive polling against gender idealogy.🎉 As of the prison case. And there have been legal wins, Maya Forrester and the like. P s no way on a million years do I think being trans should be illegal, I think there is a debate about should the state fund operations, but all gc people believe is biological sex exists, we should tolerate and accept trans people, none should be disliked or fired for be trans, but there should be nuanced laws accepting biological sex exists, for women's sports, safe spaces, and accepting biological males whatever they identify, have higher rates of certain types of aggression. Just as all the putrid insults linehan has against him on this comment page, shows.
    1
  903. People just criticize him as he believes biological sex exists. Biological men exist.
    1
  904. And Riley Gaines,
    1
  905. What about the fact care workers get min wage, while talking head media guys get millions. It's slavery. Awful.
    1
  906. Xy and xx chromosome,
    1
  907. I took it, and used to be ill all the time, now I never get ill.
    1
  908. Biological males should be on men's teams.......... ..
    1
  909. Good critique
    1
  910. That's his best ever review.
    1
  911. The Madagascar plan would have killed millions.
    1
  912. I dont think sapolsky is renowned, I think he is unknown, i think more great minds have heard of dr nick riviera of the simpsons.
    1
  913. In what way are any of these, trans phobic, can you explain.
    1
  914. I would prefer he talked to Kenny Dalgleish.
    1
  915. ​​ @monkeybudge but are you saying that Stewart lee really believes in gender idealogy. I mean the cool dude American comedians like Chapelle, Joe Rogan and Colin Quinn don't fall in line with that, people who have stronger critical thinking, and high iqs. And have you heard Norm MacDonald on this issue.
    1
  916. ​​ @monkeybudge Norm MacDonalds brother is a major Canadian journalist, Dan akroyd is the son of a major Canadian political advisor , a lot of comedians.are clever. Look at Rich Hall, very well read. Billy conolly is smart, and old Jasper carrott, Robin Williams was a genius, Weird al yankovic has a IQ on the stratosphere, and Stephen fry is a clever fellow, and Harry Enfield is pretty smart. they do have a capacity for independent thought, that politicians often don't. Politicians are virtually silenced by the media, and by special interests, and to be honest Joe Rogan may have some views many people disagree with, but he can hold a sensible conversation with anyone from mad conspiracy theorists to major businessmen and leading figures. Look at Conan o brien he is the son of a leading medical fellow. And Julia Dreyfuss was from the scions of the Dreyfuss family. And I think Dylan Moran and Tommy tiernan are high IQ also.
    1
  917. ​ @monkeybudge He has a right to a opinion, he may be wrong, but we can't be right all the time, thats why we discuss things.
    1
  918. And Mark Steel and David Baddiel are clever also. Plus Frank Skinner. And Ukraines president must be clever also. To be where he is.
    1
  919. ​​​ @vangroover1903 the betters like Dawkins and Rowling and co, know that biological sex exists the US supreme Court and Congress have just voted to stop this daft belief system having any power. Nobody can defend it without personal abuse, and alice in wonderland codswallop. Trans rights extremism at its worst so links up with orwellian beliefs, presuming the common people to be proles, despite their idealogy lacking intellectual rigour.
    1
  920. ​ @vangroover1903 ps I don't really think anyone is my better, or worse.
    1
  921. What has he said that you define as transphobic, please tell me, I love to learn.
    1
  922. ​ @LURLINE_ well how do you know if he is what you said, transphobic,
    1
  923. The Chinese did not think much of the British empires offer of gifts in their first visit.
    1
  924. 😂😂😂
    1
  925. Because evolution made humans to be judgemental, with the help of God.
    1
  926. ​ @lew6861 a man has a pe,,nis, as he is a man, it's not the other way around.
    1
  927. That was the last century
    1
  928. Nah, it was not his fault.
    1
  929. Yes, I like fairness.
    1
  930. How dare he express opinios contrary to a orwellian idealogy.
    1
  931. This makes me sad to see, but I am happy they won the world cup, as it gives a moment of joy. Hope Brazil next time wins.,
    1
  932. But surely a biological male, will hit harder, and be more robust.
    1
  933. ​ @poppat3238 but you don't go out of your way to make it more dangerous, like they dont tie pianos above the court, with weak string, as that would be dangerous and wrong, don't needlessly make it more dangerous.
    1
  934. Ice hockey win for Canada
    1
  935. She is not hateful, unlike j Edgar Hoover who was racist, who targeted black people, and had some unusual things about him , connected to this issue, and dresses. He used to wear them. So don't act like trans rights extremism is done left wing thing.
    1
  936. Great points
    1
  937. Bull fighting should be condemned,
    1
  938. He never harassed any woman on dating sites, what nonsense. Also a great hill to be on, it's a defensible position, like a super strong castle, whereas his opponents have the intellectual coherence of barricades made of ice cream, which is why they run away from debating, screaming.
    1
  939. It is the name of the series, he is not calling specifically him the most corrupt. I think he is examining many USA pres, failings. Maybe it is a high Google search thing.
    1
  940. ​ @josephsimmons9241 not she is not, she never hurt anyone in two decades. She was just a nice woman.
    1
  941. Surely whistleblowers are good.
    1
  942. You made that comment on two videos on him, why was that.
    1
  943. That mans suit is blue, what a disrespectful choice, where does he think he is, the blue butlers convention.
    1
  944. Put in reconciliation bill for Senate.
    1
  945. Outstanding research
    1
  946. He mentions Zionist financiers, in the same way Hitler went on about Jewish financiers, we know where his bread is buttered.
    1
  947. We can ban the worst books, for kids
    1
  948. But it's ok to not find genocide funny,
    1
  949. Homelessness fell under him.
    1
  950. 😂😂😂😂😂
    1
  951. No, jk Rowling has authority over it.
    1
  952. It's like Winston smith standing up to big brother.
    1
  953. You can disagree with trans rights extremists, Trumpism and be a atheist,
    1
  954. The strongest country in the world totally surrendering
    1
  955. He is six foot five, you must be a giant, who are you Robert Waldow.
    1
  956. It is not fair on the other athletes, if someone has a unfair advantage, and being born male, is a unfair advantage over the assigned at birth female competitors. Biological males are on average, taller, stronger, bigger, tougher, and more aggressive than women, as shown up by how impervious unreasonable and gaslighting aggressive and all mighty trans rights activists are to their opponents.
    1
  957. Biological sex exists, whatever trans rights extremism and it's bullies demand.
    1
  958. When the gender recognition act was proposed, all the media outlets said, it was just about making it easier for people to change sex, it sounded like it was just about on their passports. There was no announcement it was about regarding biological men who identify as women in every case. Very few people truly believe that is so. Sadly the courts will certainly choose the extreme trans activists position that biological males who identify as women are women in every case. Well if you give in to thus demand without any thought about it , its like failing at level one of 1984 the computer game, so say what ever you like law, biological sex still exists. Two plus two is four. Even if the law says it is five, if anything we should wear our rejection of this orwellian descison as a proud badge of pride.
    1
  959. The same people imposing, have the cheek to claim that anybody has expresses the tiniest of questions, is fighting a culture war, this is the most arrogant gaslighting claim that can be.
    1
  960. Would you feel the same way about dankula, if he was a Muslim.
    1
  961. If treasure is defined as rubbish comedian s, he is gold bullions.
    1
  962. hoje é dia de casa arrumada.
    1
  963. It's not the same at all, if we have space s just for women, it's ok to delineate what a woman is. If we don't, what the point in having safe spaces just for women, and most people would agree, it is good for safeguarding, to have certain safe spaces just for women. Whereas most people believe in some kind of a color blind society in terms of race.
    1
  964. Yes it was great.
    1
  965. Neanderthals are brilliant.
    1
  966. To be fair, I don't think they laughed.
    1
  967. But what about people who are offended, do you want to protect your fellow Puerto Ricans, from people who mock them.
    1
  968. Does the journalist, who was wearing the suit, know that there is also a men's department.
    1
  969. I bet Australian aborigines can use commas.
    1
  970. ​ @ScorpionSuerte thab enough, is that some new language you have invented, for us non master race people, what does this word thab, you just used translate to, for us inferiors, please tell me , and why did the soviet's crush the self proclaimed master race so humiliatingly. Sorry is thab, some Aryan god you have invented. Please tell me what a thab is sir.
    1
  971. ​ @ScorpionSuerte thab
    1
  972. ​ @ScorpionSuerte thab,
    1
  973. ​​ @ScorpionSuerte is thab indicative of thab high IQ thab you talk is so much, thab is such a thab thab thab thing to say, thab I am intrigued, thab is so interesting.
    1
  974. ​ @ScorpionSuerte thab thab thab thab, 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂thab, hah ha ha ha ha
    1
  975. ​​ @ScorpionSuerte thab says it all, thab
    1
  976. ​ @ScorpionSuerte apparently thab means bother in the Hmong language, were you speaking Indochinese.
    1
  977. ​ @ScorpionSuerte thab
    1
  978. ​ @ScorpionSuerte to be or not to be, THAB is the question.
    1
  979. ​​​ @ScorpionSuerte learn to spell, and realize your not superior to anybody, racists are vile cruel often ignorant people. And don't be rude to people.
    1
  980. ​ @ScorpionSuerte as in how I noticed your error and have you rattled like a man in a super jet, keep the insults coming, your full of hate, and make errors every time you speak or write. Therefore I must have loads Of friends.
    1
  981. She is anti orwellian hero.
    1
  982. Totally correct .😊
    1
  983. It is not far right to acknowledge biological women exist, and laws should be nuanced enough to acknowledge that.
    1
  984. But you have people of such iqs of all races,
    1
  985. ​​​​​​​​ @markpong5435 but surely it's as there top universities in places. I mean when Germany had the top universities it won that, but as of the war that stopped. I am sure in the medieval and roman era, Italians would have won every novel prize, in the dark ages, the Chinese, in the neolithic, a bunch of Egyptians and iraqis. In the 18th century, Scotland would have won every novel prize there was. Scotland made most of the greatest inventions in history, which would have annoyed a certain nationality to the south, as it was part of the richest empire, booming. And had the best education system there. Ps my Korean car is pretty good. And well done the Basques as well in circumnavigators. Dont let anybody slag off the Basques.
    1
  986. Surely they just need a few afghans in sandles, and the us will have no chance of taking Canada.
    1
  987. It affects hundred percent, and I hardly think sharia would be a preferred option to the LGBT community to mississssipppppi law
    1
  988. Some feminists, like jk Rowling, Elaine miller and Helen Joyce are objeciing.n
    1
  989. What planet is that opinion off
    1
  990. But what about how loads of stats indicate biological males who identify as women, are closer to what biological males who identify as men, do on many stats.
    1
  991. Blue suit wearing man, blue man club disrespectful.
    1
  992. Yes
    1
  993. ​ @timparker4627 the guy is prepared to slam sacred cows, whether it's trans rights, religious extremism, trump or Brexit, the guy has balls of steel.
    1
  994. Yes, but what is wrong with biological males in men's sports, if you say they are so much better, people are jealous.
    1
  995. He should have saved his jokes for elsewhere
    1
  996. ​ @Zippitydoodah007 ,Nobody hates trans people, they just wants the sport to be for biological women. Ps there are so many causes in the world, so instead of campaigning for biologicl men in women's sports, why not campaign for the homeless, there are 500,000 rough sleepers in the USA, or fir peace in the holy land, or how 350 children due of malnutrition a day. Campaign on those issues, not for something nobody wants, or needs.
    1
  997. Religon, trans rights, Trumpism, is there any sacred cow he won't slash.
    1
  998. Yes, loosing allies
    1
  999. Nah, I think Churchill is a hero, and Hitler is the epitome of evil,
    1
  1000. A woman from the Commonwealth of Independent states.
    1
  1001. ​ @pauloicto8252 where did Mr Glenn get his suit, did they have a men's department there.
    1
  1002. Read a book.
    1
  1003. Sacred cows are taking a beating by him.
    1
  1004. Terrifying,
    1
  1005. ​ @johngreenhorn8853 dankula trained his dog to get excited at the mention of gassing victims of the Holocaust, a unpleasant thing to do, that we can forgive him for, but it's nothing to claim makes you Mandela. Linehan is just saying the truth that biological women exist, and orwellian liars punish him for this truth saying.
    1
  1006. Biological women's exists.....
    1
  1007. Dankula made a rubbish act, of training his dog to get excited at the mention of the gassing of victims of the Holocaust, linehan said he did not like that. I think we should forgive dankula for that, as we all do stupid things, but linehan did nothing wrong. Ps I am sure dankula is a good person normally and his friends were to blame for not correcting him.
    1
  1008. You would know
    1
  1009. ​ @UsmanRahman-q3w I got you rattled, I said , you would know, 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅I won.
    1
  1010. It's ok to not support him,
    1
  1011. Yes what would Epstein and Stormy Daniels think of this. How disrespectful to their friend.
    1
  1012. ​ @TheWeb-is-a-Lie don't say mean things.
    1
  1013. Well why are people trying to force biological males into women's sports, when they could be bothering about health insurance companies instead.
    1
  1014. Well if that's so, why are people imposing this unpopular idea on women's sports. Nobody wants it, why not use the emotional capital on this , on opposing inequality. I say anybody who chants and campaigns for biological males to be in women's, sports, should focus on inequality instead.
    1
  1015. Yes, great shows,.
    1
  1016. It was the moops.
    1
  1017. Ehhh, did you know there is a war.
    1
  1018. He is progressive. The communist party,, seth Moulton, Rosie duffield, Joanna cherry, rfk, like Dawkins and Rowling and more all support gc ideas. Indeed even labour pm, Keir Stamer does not support biological men in women's sport.
    1
  1019. You worship money
    1
  1020. The first time I heard anybody say, my truth, and as bill O'Reilly arguing in favor of religious thinking to a atheist, it's ok you have your beliefs, but not ok to demand everybody else accepts your truths, as their truths as well.
    1
  1021. I hope he is not serious, surely expelling people is not a good idea. And he condemns Mexicans entering the usa, if thats bad, how would it be gor egypt to have to cope with more people. Why not let them move to the USA.
    1
  1022. Wow,
    1
  1023. I dont think think the Scottish or British were from scythia, but i think the beaker people, has a lot of dna from those areas, and lots of vikings did as well. As the Vikings had some international not just Scandinavians, but mostly scandi heritage.
    1
  1024. Zelensy is a hero, standing up to a brutal invasion. Vance is a petty opportunist sucking up to a man he forewarned as dangerous In questioner has a suit from a childrens entertainer at a party.
    1
  1025. He did not invade Ukraine.
    1
  1026. I think Dawkins would be very accepting and friendly and understanding of you. He uses preferred pronouns. He does not hate trans people, what is happening is right wingers are paying fake left wingers to say horrible things about other left wingers on this issue, they like to claim, Dawkins hates trans, even though he does not, as it then splits lbg people away from him. Conveniently for the right, they don't tell these people to hate right wingers. These right wingers doing this are just doing tired old special services tactics of divide and rule. Don't hate Dawkins. Dawkins is a ally if you, most people do not have, and never will have gender disphoria, so their belief in biological sex, is as inherent, to them, as you could imagine. Don't push those people into the hate camp, Dawkins would tolerate you in every way with delight, but just acknowledges biological women and men are part of life, it's not hate. Friend.
    1
  1027. How can z disrespect a friend of epstein like this,
    1
  1028. But Hitler allied to the USSR against Poland. And he gave them the Baltic states. And then fought a war, which led them into all of Eastern Europe.
    1
  1029. It shows how rubbish the Nazis were that they lost.
    1
  1030. But surely being born biological male is an advantage in women's sports. Nobody thinks that every man would beat every woman. Nobody has ever said that and don't pretend that's what anybody has ever said. It's pure gas lighting the claim that was being cleaned. What we are saying is babying a biological male in biological women's sports you have an advantage that the biological woman don't have.
    1
  1031. If you stub your foot on a door, just remember, as you had no pity, no pity is there for you either.
    1
  1032. The punchline is the mitch whatsushname line.
    1
  1033. Aerosmith song
    1
  1034. He is still doing well, stating biological sex exists when so many ignore it's reality.
    1
  1035. ​ @akashajones6079 he just tells it like it is, which annoys religious extremists, trans right extremists and all sorts, that's life.
    1
  1036. ​@strangemagic5502 but on that basis, nobody is any nationality, as everyone has ancestors, from all over the place, as everybody mixed, in reality whether you like it or not, and in gods eyes, we are all citizens of the world,
    1
  1037. ​​we have more in common than divides is, we are one human race, you may not like it, but thats just the way it is, and whatever national divides are dreamt up by accidents of history, whatever hatreds are spouted by zealots and extremists, we are one human race, sorry it may sound like a platitude, but like most platitudes, its simply true. End of 😊🎉
    1
  1038. ​​​ Kellbell-z6i well even in your view, gething is the grandson of generations of Welshmen Welsh women. So you are abusing his Welsh ancestors by denying his Welsh heritage. Wales actually likes accepting people into it's nationality, I mean actually if a JFK had a Welsh grandpa, most true Welsh nationalists would shout that from the roof tops, like some do about how abraham lincoln, despite him being mostly English in ancestor, had some welsh links, wales does the same for the tudors, hubert humphrey, and even the much derided hilary clinton, the basques do this as well.
    1
  1039. Unlike Russia, where you are jailed for saying the word war, and prisoners are being released to fight for land thousands of miles from their birth.
    1
  1040. I think campaigning biological males to be in women's sports, is a issue nobody should bother campaigning for, there are far bigger issues,vans it's unpopular.
    1
  1041. Hamburger eating surrender monkeys
    1
  1042. Great point.
    1
  1043. The German far right claimed to be racially superior in the thirties, but in the end they saw defeat with a central Asian guy from the ussr, putting a red flag above the shattered ruins of the reichstag, and the defeated so called master race in 1945. And their leader did to himself the only good thing he ever did. Racism is just dumb.
    1
  1044. He trained his dog to get excited at the mention of the Holocaust, if he was Muslim and did that, people would not have batted a eyelid at him being hauled before the courts, but as he is not, lots of free speech anything goes, extremists, and lots of racist, went crazy.
    1
  1045. Bonespurs
    1
  1046. Being worse at sports does not make you inferior. Fdr was rubbish at sports, but the greatest ever is president.n
    1
  1047. ​ @7n154 as in my experience that is not so. But even then, for most things, I think it's ok for women to choose to be police officers, or such, and there should be qualifications you need to pass. Some women and some men will pass these. But it's not fair to demand that womens sports have biological males in their events, if we have women's sports, it's unfair to have people not born women, in those events, its a unfair competitive advantage. I am not saying no women are good at sports, I am sure the best wnba players, and javelin throwers would beat many men, but I think having men in the women's events is a unfair advantage. You raise interesting questions, but I think the needle can be threaded quite easily to accepting biological differences, and allowing women to have rights as well. Though yes, I think some roles like combat soldiers are more suited to biological males, I can understand there being a argument for some exceptional women passing the tests, to serve in these exceptional fields, and no doubt there are plenty of women who would do better at the navy seals tests, than me at my peak, but yes thats a thing where i hope operational realities are considered highest. Not pure political correctness, I bet hr McMaster would have it right on that.
    1
  1048. ​ @7n154 no I did not, I totally admit, some biological women are bigger, taller and stronger than many men, but being born male is still a unfair advantage. Even if the trans woman finishes 10th, that's still knocking a woman down a place unfairly. It is a unfair advantage, that non transgender women, dont have.
    1
  1049. But can't people just be nice to each other. Not everyone likes jokes like this.
    1
  1050. I think it was geography, as of the mountains, and the distance, and weather, that caused the massive Roman efforts to be defeated, by my ancestors.
    1
  1051. Looks like thev trans rights activists have stopped caring, have they been beaten, or were they all bots.
    1
  1052. Why no tcp in the shops.
    1
  1053. He is cool
    1
  1054. But factually speaking it is not, surely rocks and vegetation are not garbage, i mean he went on holiday there, would anybody do that if it was actual garbage. And it has airports and cars, and baseball teams, even volleyball players, that is not garbage, garbage is not like that.
    1
  1055. Cool
    1
  1056. ​ @tazmanian1033 yes
    1
  1057. ​@jantergibbins85far right trans rights extremists are the worst.
    1
  1058. This is a debate on sex, not race.
    1
  1059. I had to sing fortunate son myself, when the Vietnam clip came on,
    1
  1060. Linehan and Doyle should sue.
    1
  1061. 😮If biological sex does not exist, why am I able to tell which players at Wimbledon are men, and which are women, the only reason some dodgy over defensive pseudo scientists now in their journals, describe biological sex as "more complicated than youuuuuu! Think," in tone belying even they know their agenda is on shaky ground intellectually, is as if a tiny percentage of people on the edges who are intersex, who yes exist, but they want to talk about them to undermine the clear obvious existence of biological sex, so they can muddy the waters of the term, and then shoehorn biological males who identify as women into the category of women. It's just ridiculous. Thank God or the universe for Collin Wright.
    1
  1062. My last comment here, but if that is so, what's the problem with biological males l to identify as women using men's toilets. If there is no problem we could just carry on as the law here say.
    1
  1063. Canada 51, was that their ice hockey score, v their beaten neighbours.
    1
  1064. Agree, it's ok to condemn a idealogy if it denies facts. Monty Python were mocking parts of this idealogy before it even existed. Like in the life of Brian and such, when they had the man wanting to have a baby scene, and mocked the Judean people's front, for them criticising people who agree with them on everything except minor points.
    1
  1065. He should have mentioned the trans rights activist who murdered the lesbian feminist, in his documentary.
    1
  1066. I don't think they were discussing homosexuality here were they.
    1
  1067. But is it right to keep big impactful things like this secret.
    1
  1068. ​ @sarbantz what is a mis gender
    1
  1069. Autism is a super power
    1
  1070. They are not Right wing talking points z they are views many lefties like Dawkins and Rowling support.
    1
  1071. ​ @vangroover1903 class hatred, shameful
    1
  1072. No he is not,
    1
  1073. I think most people were worried, and Russia should not have invaded Ukraine, then it could have protected its allies in Armenia, and Syria, look what is happening now as it is focused on annexing places who don't want to be Russian. Russia should pause its attacks, or stop them, so it can protect their allies from genocide. The Russian invasion of Ukraine is a disaster for Europe, and Russia, as big a mistake as the Iraq War. Though to be honest the bombings by Russia in Syria were terrible, so it would have been better if they had not done that. The whole situation is terrible. Lots of stupid people made a lot of stupid choices.
    1
  1074. Hopefully Russia will stop fighting in Ukraine, and firm a deal with Western powers to stop the genocide in Syria.
    1
  1075. ​ @ScorpionSuerte you spell that, thab, your accuracy is not to be trusted.
    1
  1076. A very decent and well mannered debate. Wikipedia's bigoted gender idealogy extremists should see that you can debate in favour of trans rights with decorum, without demonising your opponents. Well done Andrew Gold on putting the case so well. Gender critical people don't hate trans, we just believe biological sex exists. Also I do think there should be a blanket ban on biological men in women's sports, the trans women can just compete in mens, in makes no difference to their gender. There should be some nuance on women's safe spaces, but a acceptance on gender critical ideas being better, though good to know that Tatchell has his limits. Also I don't think gender identity of someone identifying as the other sex is the same as accepting you are the sex you are. It's obviously completely different and a bit silly to deny that. Also I think the term trans critics, is still a bit unfair, as it ignores the fact gender critical idealogy is focused on biological sex, the trans element of a person is for most issues beside the point.
    1
  1077. It's ok to criticize sacred cows.
    1
  1078. All ethnic minorities agree with the GC position, more so than anybody, and any rational person does.
    1
  1079. Father Ted was great
    1
  1080. I like all three.
    1
  1081. What have you seen that you regard as transphobic. Do you condemn the bullies launching personal attacks on the player called Brooke.
    1
  1082. But whistleblowers are good at times. Like it's good when politicians reveal what their presidents were up to at times.
    1
  1083. It is not fair to call someone a transphobe, for saying biological women exist. It is so offensive and arrogant to say that,
    1
  1084. Most people take the piss out of conspiracy theorists, that does not mean we should ignore obvious reality, that biological sex exists. This just shows he is right to support jk Rowling the voice of reason.
    1
  1085. Whistleblowers are good.
    1
  1086. Clearly there is already a event for biological males.
    1
  1087. But even then but 200 lb male boxer, will have advantages over a 200 lb female boxer.
    1
  1088. ​​ @RobThomson-x8g you mean the people who did nothing about it, as they were concerned about their own hides. Like a person in the comment section here, who did nothing about it. Where was society.
    1
  1089. ​​ @RobThomson-x8g that is exactly why this happened, as the people in society who should have protected those people, did not want to act to protect those children. Just like happened in the Jimmy Saville case. Thank the Lord we had people like JK Rowling and Helen Joyce noticing the potential and actual abused from self id, stamping out it's most extreme elements, if it were not for heroes like JK rowling, campaigning despite orwellian hate campaigns v them, against intact biological males, convicted of the worst crimes against women being put in women's prison cells, then that horrific dystopian act would have still been occurring. These two ladies made sacrifices against a idealogy of great power, if only the people who knew what was going on in Rochdale, but did nothing about it, who then try and blame everyone else for it, had jk rowlings sense of moral goodness. She deserves a nobel prize.
    1
  1090. It is not far right to know and acknowledge that biological women exist.
    1
  1091. The thing is even Peter tatchell usrs the term biological males, i mean as poets said, a rose is a rose is a rose, if it were by any other name, it would still be as sweet smelling etc, you cant pretend something is not so, by banning the word ingsoc orweellian style, as winston smith said, 2 plus 2 is still four no matter how often you put him in room 101. Its not good, its very Orwellian.
    1
  1092. ​ @fromthedumpstertothegrave3689 but if you state biological sex exists, and has consequences then like Kathleen stock, you get a fanatics hate campaign against you. It is good that many are prepared to stand up against the orwellian aspects of gender idealogy.
    1
  1093. ​ @H0otz nobody said that
    1
  1094. Were they not just forced roommates.
    1
  1095. That's a matter of opinion, but most think she is good looking.
    1
  1096. This video was great. Evolutionry biology is cool, thevgreats dawkins, darwin, and all them. Helped. But also archaeology.
    1
  1097. Maybe she shall sue them, after like Maya Forrester, if she is fired for her beliefs, well truths.
    1
  1098. It's ok to change your view, there is more joy in heaven, etc etc.
    1
  1099. It was 49.9 percent, of those who voted.
    1
  1100. That's why his employees trump etc wear the same blue suits, but he does not 🚫.
    1
  1101. The good life
    1
  1102. 😂When the gender recognition act was proposed, all the media outlets said, it was just about making it easier for people to change sex, it sounded like it was just about on their passports. There was no announcement it was about regarding biological men who identify as women in every case. Very few people truly believe that is so. Sadly the courts will certainly choose the extreme trans activists position that biological males who identify as women are women in every case. Well if you give in to thus demand without any thought about it , its like failing at level one of 1984 the computer game, so say what ever you like law, biological sex still exists. Two plus two is four. Even if the law says it is five, if anything we should wear our rejection of this orwellian descison as a proud badge of pride.
    1
  1103. I don't think he ever threw anyone under a bus.
    1
  1104. Nope, it exists to allow people to criticize the elites, the strong and the most powerful. Otherwise do you support Islamic extremists being allowed to say any vile stuff. I mean do you support that,
    1
  1105. Jk rowling and Richard Dawkins are right. Biological women exist.
    1
  1106. Yes, they were bad.
    1
  1107. Yes
    1
  1108. Just put the biological men in the men's teams, simple
    1
  1109. South park, well being mocked in South Park is a badge of real true pride.
    1
  1110. Trump makes people laugh by accident.
    1
  1111. Trans rights activists lack compassion. Biological males have less compassion than biological females.
    1
  1112. Did they even mention COVID.
    1
  1113. She looks pretty,
    1
  1114. Every trans rights activist wishes they were as pretty as her.
    1
  1115. I think he would score you low for that
    1
  1116. He is just saying biological sex exists.
    1
  1117. ​ @Maksie0 what a miserable thing to believe.
    1
  1118. ​ @erroreliminator2.076 neanderthals knew what a woman is, and modern homosapiens.
    1
  1119. But surely it is as they fear the orwellian power of gender idealogy activists.
    1
  1120. But it's unpleasant
    1
  1121. Interesting stuff,
    1
  1122. Rubics cube
    1
  1123. But we do not have women's sports, as of gender identity, it's not about who likes shoes, and who likes cars, it's as biological males have advantages by birth, like Dallas under fifteen boys beat the USA women's team.
    1
  1124. ​ @Aeson-np8tr that is totally different. We live in a society where most of us say black and white people should be equal, without segregation. We also live in a society where most of us agree women have a right to safe spaces, and sports, as males can pose a safeguarding risk, and are often, bigger and stronger, tougher and more aggressive, on average. That is why we have women's sports. There is no point in having women's sports if you have biological males in the sports.
    1
  1125. She is just saying biological women exist, and laws need nuance accepting that.
    1
  1126. Bill Naher is right.
    1
  1127. Heaven.
    1
  1128. Well done him
    1
  1129. Good grief, she is what is known as a upstander, it's ok in some cases, but in this case it's just ignoring certain important facts.
    1
  1130. I wonder if planet of the apes reminds our brains of inherited fears of homo erectus.
    1
  1131. ​ @stuntman1359 I used to think gop guys were like decent, what about the decent gop guys, who don't like jokes like this, should they vote dem.
    1
  1132. ​ @snuggles03 and the idea a maori is a Nazi for believing biological sex exists, is monstrous. She is not a Nazi,
    1
  1133. Jk rowling is super vanilla, she is good. If you are too weak in your arguments, you will be walked all over, and then used as a door mat, then be hated and blamed for everything also. I know that from experience.
    1
  1134. He has degrees from the most prestigious university in the Western world, is fetted for his answers by the great and the good, the guy knows his stuff, sorry you can't see that. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
    1
  1135. ​ @cattysplat no, 😔, why are so many dankula fans arguing for racism.
    1
  1136. ​ @derianimp he is talking about the aggressive activists, not random trans people, who are just like everyone else, it's the activists who are mean.
    1
  1137. The onion
    1
  1138. As he is a bioloogist,
    1
  1139. Nonsense. Look who criticises trump, it was that bishop in Washington, on day one.
    1
  1140. Why does every racist comment have a gramatic error. There were no denosivens. They were the Denisovans. Also the scots invented far more than the Anglo-Saxons and Germans.
    1
  1141. There aws a volleyball player injured, in such a game.
    1
  1142. Good interview, yes churchill was amazing for standing up to the no,ncies, i meant nazis. I don't know what the tucker Carlson view on foreign policy is. I find is, I mean if a country invaded the USA, would he say USA should fight, or if a strategic ally is invaded. I mean I suppose it's a nice pacifist view, but does that really work, if your the major power. I just don't believe right wingers are really pacifists. As all I hear from tucker is like a aping of Michael Moore, on foreign policy, and I don't believe Palaeo conservatives are really like that.i mean look at orban, his wing have that hingarian expansionist section, though maybe orban opposes that.
    1
  1143. I just think Palaeo conservatives in the end fight more wars than neos, as the world wars show. And Russia shows it as well.
    1
  1144. Someone does not like working class accents in politics,
    1
  1145. Now that's totally unfair, grappling for unconnected things. Why do you have to bring unconnected things into the dispute, to dehumanise Dawkins. It's just not fair. Are you claiming Elvis pressley was a bigot for singing hound dog, or is it bigoted to say one man and his dog, for lower league attendances.
    1
  1146. Now that's totally unfair, grappling for unconnected things. Why do you have to bring unconnected things into the dispute, to dehumanise Dawkins. It's just not fair. Are you claiming Elvis Presley, the great American singer, is a bigot for singing hound dog, i hope not, as Elvis was a marvel. Or the phrase to work like a dog, or crowds at lower tier football matches are we banned from saying one man and his dog.
    1
  1147. Russia has defeated maga usa in the war. Its a shame.
    1
  1148. Dawkins is cool
    1
  1149. Booh, rubbish jokes,
    1
  1150. ​ @nuqwestr be mored nerdy, study elections better, she is up ten million votes on your stats now.
    1
  1151. Maybe his cabinet picks are not random tv guys, maybe they are random as they are kgb and compromised agents.
    1
  1152. Dankula trained his dog to get excited at the mention of gassing victims of the Holocaust, it was nothing to be proud of, comparable, to doing the toilet in the main square, in front of everyone. Yes we can forgive him for it, but it was not good. Meanwhile linehan was cancelled for saying biological sex exists,that two plus two is four. Linehan was treated unfairly.
    1
  1153. Did anyone accuse of him being a.nazi, surely people just said it was sick bad taste joke, that was rude and insensitive, surely nobody said he was a Nazi, the guy just did something many did not like, he should be forgiven, but nobody called him a Nazi.
    1
  1154. I am fitter than ever after taking it.
    1
  1155. 😂
    1
  1156. National lampoon European vacation knocked down Stonehenge as well.
    1
  1157. Yes, did he get it in a bin.
    1
  1158. It's virtually slavery, and I bet their the ones doing the useful jobs, like care workers, unlike billionaire sportsmen and hedge fund managers.
    1
  1159. , biological males have a unfair advantage in women's sports..
    1
  1160. Yes, women's sport should not be just the second class for men.
    1
  1161. I think he just has to accept, he needs to persuade archaeology to change its view, he xant just write a book and expect everyone to agree.
    1
  1162. He was good then, and is even better now,
    1
  1163. There is training drills.
    1
  1164. It's Putin who invaded, what about all the Dead Russians and the Dead Ukrainian daughters.
    1
  1165. Good point.
    1
  1166. Would you agree with him if he was Muslim and did that.
    1
  1167. ❤
    1
  1168. He is not,
    1
  1169. Totally agree
    1
  1170. She, yes, women exist.
    1
  1171. It is steffan Milo or Dan Davis, or that David Reich.
    1
  1172. Are you talking about when dankula trained his dog to get excited at the mention of gassing the victims of the Holocaust, I don't think it's bad for people to say they dislike that he did that, it a free country . I am not a fan of Catherine Tate, does not mean I am a thought police,bas I say I don't like her jokes. Whereas all linehan did was say biological sex exists, which is true.
    1
  1173. But she was forced to accept this.
    1
  1174. Interesting
    1
  1175. But biological men who identify as women, are often quite macho in many ways.
    1
  1176. Yes, it happens.
    1
  1177. I did not know it is a blue suit idiot covention.
    1
  1178. He was tough here,
    1
  1179. This is a different issue
    1
  1180. I don't care the race of my pilot, if you can fly, that's all that counts.
    1
  1181. ​ @ScorpionSuerte well how would you know the rest were not just old school tie, and the like.
    1
  1182. ​​ @ScorpionSuerte coming from a man who spells than, thab, I would not want you anywhere near air traffic control or aircraft controls. You need accuracy for that, and people of all races, but not you in your comments in this comment section, when you spelt than, thab, you would be a danger to flights with that attitude in air traffic control.
    1
  1183. Would you support dankula if he was Muslim
    1
  1184. It's like some level one but if a 1984 computer game.
    1
  1185. Of real man.
    1
  1186. I like to imagine Chandler bing saying that for you. Gives it more power.
    1
  1187. He did not say anything transphobic, can you give a example, huh, I thought not.
    1
  1188. Would you be ok if a Muslim did what dankula did, would you find it funny if a Muslim did that about Jews.
    1
  1189. Use a ai version.
    1
  1190. It would be very surprising if there is a team, with a man who is weakest. Most British women's soccer teams, are on average below average male height even at professional level. And quite far below. So a amateur team would be likely much shorter, otherwise this team would be womens champions league winners every season. I mean even a us school boys team beat the USA women's team, who are the best team on the planet. Dallas under fifteens boys beat them five two. I mean if it was basketball or volleyball it may be different, there are some tall ladies there, but not football.
    1
  1191. Aging, exists, so does biological sex.
    1
  1192. Coming from the land where all the men wear dresses, and win women's sports events, its total hypocrisy.
    1
  1193. But Putin was the guy who invaded,
    1
  1194. Human sacrifice a d cannibalism occurred on every continent, happily rationalism stops it.
    1
  1195. Zelensy had some good repostes to trump. And the douchebag journalist. Also trump is always rubbish and wooden in snl, just like musk.
    1
  1196. Like a carbon copy of Brexit. 🙄
    1
  1197. And one of those one in 10000 won a division one swimming title, shows it is unfair.
    1
  1198. Money worshiper
    1
  1199. Putin invaded Ukraine, and you can't blame them for the Israeli Palestine war, what do you think they should have done, just surrender to Russia and Iran. I mean you can believe that if you wish, but surely they are just following post war policy on Ukraine, and us policy on Israel, it's not their fault Hamas did October the 7th, or that Israel was recognized by the USA decades ago. I mean they are not war mongers, they never invaded anywhere, and looks like Iran and the Palestinians fear trump more which is why they gave up the hostages just before he arrived, before he gave Israel even bigger weapons and the green light to be even tougher. I mean Biden has almost let the taleban and Yemen do what they like, gnd has not been invading them either. I think the only place you have a argument is Israel , but even there if USA did not give Israel weapons, it would probably see some mass invasion the other way around, and horrific expulsions , so it's difficult to say what to do there. The thing I find annoying is Iran and Russia supposedly launched their attacks as they thought Biden is a weakling, when he showed that he was not prepared to just let allies be walked all over. Then when Trump comes to power, threatening a madman tactic, all these horrible dictators say, ok boss, we will free the hostages, and give you what you like sir. Even Yemen, they never attacked Israel, Biden makes the Saudis stop attacking it, and lifts sanctions on Iran, so Iran and Israel decides well that's the time to attack. I mean what's the point, so on that case, internationalism and being nice is not rewarded, only horrible psycho brinkmanship is seen as acceptable by these anti Western powers. But surely the problem with that, is either you always surrender, like trump did in Afghanistan, or you act bellicose and cause a war, like Germany in world war one. I think internationalism is right, but you can't just lay down to invaders surely.
    1
  1200. The fault of the Israeli Palestine war, is two sides who are against eacother, led by two sides with extreme opposite aims, that was not Biden fault, he is a typical pro peace process Dem, who sure supports Israel, but he did not cause oxt 7th, unless you subscribe to the idea Iran felt he was a push over, and then he just gave Israel all the guns it wanted, which any US president since Truman would have done.
    1
  1201. ​ @crowscoyote she is not trying to eliminate anybody, don't use such revolting extremist incendiary language. .
    1
  1202. ​​ @vangroover1903 trans rights activists, the most unpleasant people you will ever meet. What a repulsive horrible thing to say, especially from a idealogy that goes on about that subject every ghoulish way they can.
    1
  1203. ​ @vangroover1903 what a revolting thing to say 😢 shameful awful
    1
  1204. ​ @user-to5lc6sg2l yes, there should be a compromise that allows women's rights and accepts sex exists, but also welcomes trans people.
    1
  1205. ​​ @danyoutube7491 but are they really a oppressed people. There were three roman emperor's who were trans, Eddie izzard has come out as trans and kailyn Jenner. They both have great positions in society. They are not oppressed like victims of the Irish famine, or North Koreans, or victims of wars, or some such, in many ways their lives are good, it's a first world problem, I mean the fact there are formerly respected politicians and newspapers campaigning fir biological males in women's sport, os so first world problem, when your living is easy.
    1
  1206. Witty
    1
  1207. He has received lots of used cars to defend his country from invaders
    1
  1208. It was not Dawkins fault, he is not the police.
    1
  1209. ​​ @Tom-yg9ts if that is so, he is also responsible for all the good stuff. Britain is super wealthy, high life expectancy, nuke super power, which beat Hitler, and invented everything, well done mr Dawkins. And what did you do to stop it.
    1
  1210. Agreed😃
    1
  1211. JD pants
    1
  1212. Hollywood has done some Greek things, 300 and meet the Spartans, also Bill and Ted had a Greek. And wonder woman is based on Greek stuffs.
    1
  1213. ​ @sobbyhasselhoff he just condemned dankula for a rubbish act of training his dog to get excited at the mention of gassing of victims of the Holocaust. I forgive dankula for that, but condemn him for it, just like I condemn Catherine Tate for her rubbish jokes, and some modern art,bas it is rubbish,though some is superb. It's a free country. Whereas linehan is cancelled for saying biological sex exists, which is true. It's like being cancelled for saying Canberra is the capital of Australia.
    1
  1214. But it's trans rights activists who support traditional gender stereotypes, they are the ones trying to claim wrongly there are big differences between black people and white people, to make sex differences seem less important, and who try to take our eyes off inequality and homelessness, with this stuff.
    1
  1215. They are completely different beliefs, 😅😅😅,
    1
  1216. There are more than five idiots in Europe, and every American town. This disqualified your remarks.
    1
  1217. Then why did the USA women's team, the best women's team on earth lose to a Dallas under fifteens team in soccer , and Dallas adult men's team would not even be good enough for aby top soccer league.
    1
  1218. Which one.
    1
  1219. That's good.
    1
  1220. What if he had specificly said jokes aimed at swing states, would that be clever or stupid.
    1
  1221. Interesting show, interesting stuff.
    1
  1222. What next, pokey sticks
    1
  1223. Dawkins knows his stuff.
    1
  1224. 😢
    1
  1225. Every trans rights activist would love to be as pretty as Brooke.
    1
  1226. And the non binary ones, who usually just look like any other woman, play in the women's sports as well.
    1
  1227. I knew he would be that
    1
  1228. NPCs have better grammar than you
    1
  1229. What about hobbits.
    1
  1230. ​ @Choops197 what is a man.
    1
  1231. Hamburger eating surrender monkeys
    1
  1232. He showed some compassion, which is great, but still the term trans critical is a bit of a rude term, ignoring the point of gc. The main fact is peoples sex, not whether they are trans or not.
    1
  1233. Wear the clothes I demand you wear,
    1
  1234. ​ @brianbraeburn4241 wear what I demand. Yep we know Trump would wear a certain kind of suit if Putin asked him to. A kind of suit YouTube would ban me from saying, would you as well if Putin asked you to wear a g suit. I can't spell the other three letters, YouTube would ban my comment.
    1
  1235. USA lose to Russia in war. Breaking news.
    1
  1236. 😂
    1
  1237. I love Seinfeld the sitcom, no surrender to anybody on that,
    1
  1238. But is there a fear Russia will just invade again.
    1
  1239. But what if they only won five votes, then it would not be good for democracy as then they would be the least popular party.
    1
  1240. ​ @arethanow then why do all the non binary xx footballers play in the women's world cup.
    1
  1241. If he is his best friend like he says, he could get him to withdraw from Ukraine. Though really it's just sucking up to him .
    1
  1242. But it is unfair advantage to be born male, in women's sports.
    1
  1243. Be nice
    1
  1244. But Jordan Peterson was sent to a re education centre for it.
    1
  1245. Sorry you can't identify obvious women, it's nothing to be proud about, 😂😂😂
    1
  1246. Stewart Lee is working class, and adam buxton is upper middle class, both are high status individuals. And fine comics. But linehan and gold are class acts, for standing for the truth on this issue. Great blokes. I don't think the elite are class bound, i think its more like 1984, i think Orwell was painting a picture of British intelegica, left and right, of living in a academic bubble, that looks down on the lower less educated, as to be ignored , to be kind of looked down on a bit. I mean in some ways we are hyper egalitarian, but look at this debate, where yrans activists, and elites kind of see average public opinion, as brutish, ignorant and prole, i think the book Orwell was almost like a parody of British elites in some ways, merged with the horrors of soviet communism. Saying that, there are good thinks about British elites, left wing, and upper class, that we need,band even of some aspects of the ussr, like its equality, and space.
    1
  1247. I mean it is jaw dropping how trans activists are so much like the baddies in 1984, it's as Orwell knew how things work in the elite of both the left in Britain and the world, and how the broad british elite worked. This debate is like a level one computer game about 1984, spotting the Orwellian bigots. I mean tra extremism, is so much like it. With some Kafka, and python, and mad hatters tea party the mad hare, Alice in wonderland.
    1
  1248. Homelessness and poverty fell under him.
    1
  1249. Communism in the east was better than Lebensraum, and bankrupt Britain created a NHS, gave up it's immoral empire, and had seventy years and counting of peace.
    1
  1250. But people like JK Rowling don't feel there is a difference between biological males who identify as men, and biological males who identify as women, they often talk of statistics, that indicate and show that there is some foundation to their belief there, that male aggression is biologicals. Indeed in Scotland, one of my relatives friends, was r@ped by the trans butcher, so it's hardly like they are never a threat.
    1
  1251. My feelings matter.
    1
  1252. ​ @AbigailGriffin-l6k but surely that's why we have police, and laws, so that criminals don't hurt people's feelings by killing them or robbing them. I have to say, I think feelings do matter, I think shops who don't care about your feelings should go bust, and customer service matters. Feelings do matter, I mean you may feel I am wrong there, but that's hypocrisy, as you are choosing your views via your feelings. Feelings matter. ps don't ever be a nurse.
    1
  1253. But surely it's just about accepting biological sex exists, we should be nice to trans people, but we should not ignore the glaring reality that biological gender exists.
    1
  1254. That's a lot. I would have zero.
    1
  1255. Andrew Doyle is certainly a good speaker. Whether you agree with him or not, he is a intelligent fellows in the UK.
    1
  1256. I heard a Muslim did the same joke about Jews, do you support him as well
    1
  1257. Meeting stormy Daniels lover boy no less. ​ @LowerYourExpectationsPleb 
    1
  1258. Or Stormy Daniels
    1
  1259. The difference is he never really got famous, he is more famous now, as of his YouTube stuff, which would never ever have got on the BBC,
    1
  1260. Dua lipa
    1
  1261. Why would a scientific paper decide the definition of a word like gender, surely that is decided by language professors and society, or sociology, or even just arbitrary opinion, which in this sense is more a language field, than science. I mean if someone classifies Greenland and Australia continents, in a paper , that's a opinion, not science in itself, if someone classifies gender as different to sex , that again is just a opinion, a choice of definitions, it's not science. It's more tautology than science.
    1
  1262. ​ @colinmatts that's just your opinion, on how things should be categories, it's not a scientific fact, it's a categorisation choice, you and some other people support, many other people see it as a problematic choice, disagree with the logic and lack of logic with that choice. It's really just a matter of opinion.
    1
  1263. ​ @colinmatts it is just a matter of categorisation, it's not a scientific fact, and what is gender based on but biological sex.
    1
  1264. If over eighteen s want to transition, we don't care, all we say is biologigcal sex still exists and has strong consequences.
    1
  1265. Canada won the ice hockey,
    1
  1266. 😂
    1
  1267. I hope so.
    1
  1268. Dawkins is cool.,
    1
  1269. That's hilarious, mayonnaise gender, what if someone said they were ketchup
    1
  1270. Yes, and then there are pseudoscientists he claim to know everything,
    1
  1271. ​ @Cardinal_Hordriss there is a difference between recognition, and defining biological males who identify as women, as as much women, as biological women, which is a huge debate, that was just imposed top down.
    1
  1272. ​ @Cardinal_Hordriss that was a very long essay, and I have not the time to answer all. It's too tiring. But gender critical people do not want to oppress trans people. Dawkins and Rowling are not calling them freaks, they would treat them politely and as human beings,. Like he did to Jan Morris, All they are saying is biological sex exists, and has consequences, and law should therefore be structured with that reality in mind. A biological male who identifies as a female is much a threat to women, as a biological male who identifies as a man. Also I would say be who you want to be, but also accept biological sex exists. I condemn anybody who bullies people for being trans, but gender critical feminists have a problem with trans biological males who identify as women in women's sport as of them being biological males, not as they are trans. Also to be honest I would say the people at the bottom of society in many ways, below trans, in terms of their treatment are the homeless, the severely mentally challenged, the severely disabled, some criminals, some victims of crimes even after the crimes , afghan women, thelidimdide sufferers and the like, i mean look on the bright side. On some things trans are actually quite elite, like there were three trans roman emperors, so let's not pretend you are like pathetic creatures, your not treated like jennifer Lawrence or arnie in their prime, but few of us are. I get called horrible names as well, but I don't twist this into reasons to blame nice people like jk Rowling.
    1
  1273. ​​​ @Cardinal_Hordriss why do trans activists always compare biological men competing in women's sports, to black women competing in women's sports. It's really racism to say that. I mean why do they never say, well if it's ok for young white canadian daughters of the liberal middle class to compete in women's sports, it's ok for big tough biological males to compete. It's as they are racist. Also jk Rowling is a hero, for standing up to Orwellian bullies, who twist her words, . And nobody said those boxers are trans, they say they are intersex, which is very different. Also look af Rachel devine, that's someone with power, who has used it for trans rights activism as well. And I agree most people in power at not at all trans, but it is wrong to ignore the concerns of others, with throwvawayvdismiss
    1
  1274. ​​​I dont hate trans people, if we had a trans pm, I would have no problem, if I had a trans work mate, I would have no problem, if i had a trans kid, or wife or husband , or doctor, i would not mind. By gosh trans are no threats to us whatever per say. What I hate is bullying trans activists calling people names, for saying biological sex exists. I abhor that, as I hate people being condemned for saying inoffensive truth, that people should just get over and accept. When you consider there are guys with no arms and legs, or who are blind and such, who don't go around hating everybody for not agreeing with everything they say, it gets on my nerves that people call Dawkins and Rowling names when they are nice people, just for not agreeing with then, and there are plenty of gangsters, dictators bullies, thugs and skinhead, racists, and bullies fior them to hate, but these bullies pick on jk rowling, for defending biological women, from a nuanced feature of debate. Stop calling people horrible names for not agreeing wholeheartedly with your idealogy, stop being bigots, it's horrible what extreme trans activists say about nice decent left wingers, just for saying biological sex exists and has consequences. Stop calling people bigoted, or ignorant or far right, just as they say biological sex exists. We should love everyone non trans, and trans, but don't call people bigots for saying biological sex exists. Stop it, it's not nice.
    1
  1275. No sane person denied that. The question is the categorization of biological males who identify as women. They are still human beings whether you think they need be defined in the man or woman categories.
    1
  1276. Nobody denies the trans people are human beings, the debate is purely about whether you categorise trans people according to their biological sex, what about the gender they wish to be seen as. But it does not stop them being human beings whatever position you have of which group they should be categorised in, whether that would be man or woman.
    1
  1277. Are you saying people who are not trans are not human beings, are they all human beans.
    1
  1278. But the boomerang is a super intelligent invention, could you dream that up, even my hero Andrew Selkirk, did not do that, surely the rest of the world was so linked, it built off each other, Chinese gun powder and paper, the silk road, Arab scientists and European ones as well. Surely if Australiia had been off the coast of Japan or Spain, it would have got that tech sooner, and has been the same level as the rest of the world. Look at rural parts of Europe and China which were in bronze age poverty to 1900, look at the fact there were aborigine teachers and scientists even in the 19th century. And all the aborigines I have seen on tv were cleverer than a IQ of 60, look at the poverty of st kilda in 1900, which was part of Scotland, probably the most advanced nation on earth in the 19th century.
    1
  1279. Yes, people should stop campaigning for biological males to be in women's sports, something nobody wants, and campaign against inequality instead. There are people freezing in the streets, and some people are dreaming up ways of changing the whole idea of lady sports.
    1
  1280. ​ @Panfila303 by being born a male, you have advantages, men are on average, taller and bigger, that counts a lot in volleyball. Like 6 5 Lauren Jackson s brother is 6 10, and could pick her up with ease in his prime. Geva mentor 6 3, has a brother 6 10 as well. Being born male is a unfair advantage in women's sports. Like even if a person who finishes 20th is found to be taking performance enhancement drugs, it's just as unfair as if the person who finishes first did. And if someone who finishes first in a woman event, turns out to be biological males, it's just as unfair as if someone who finishes 20th turns out to have been born biological males, it's simply a unreasonable advantage in women's sport.
    1
  1281. ​ @MsReasonableperson it's orwellian oppression, and is like a female Winston Smith
    1
  1282. Sounds like conspiracy theories.
    1
  1283. ​ @Abyssal-r8d you can't blame a atheist for Trumpism, or terrorism. Atheists did not do these things.
    1
  1284. Z should have said, which bin did you find your ugly suits,
    1
  1285. Better still, Barry cunliffe.
    1
  1286. Be honest, he won't insult putin
    1
  1287. She looks like blake livesley, ryan Reynolds wife.
    1
  1288. Agree, I mean she is part maori, I don't think Nazis liked them. Whereas the people who voted against her, were mostly white males, the group the Nazis liked.
    1
  1289. Yes, but it's unfair, and ten percent unsafer.
    1
  1290. I never said that, or did not say that, I said it's not fair, and less safe, as biological males are on average bigger and sturdier, and more powerful. ​ @lewy1 
    1
  1291. That's a relief, am a fan of linehan, gold and Buxton. So that's good.
    1
  1292. The good guys won world war 2, that's why we are all alive.
    1
  1293. But what if someone invaded your country, or if you were in need, would you expect anyone to help you.
    1
  1294. I hope Russia stops bombing.
    1
  1295. Too you, bug not to the People.
    1
  1296. You heartless, b
    1
  1297. Nobody else lets him on. Ps all the other comics never minded appearing in right wing newspapers glossy Saturday mags, and most would, and many have written columns for them.
    1
  1298. Because it becomes tired and lame,
    1
  1299. In what way is he not American.
    1
  1300.  @johnrussell3961  I was not condemning Mr Stamer, I was just saying, its a shame she left the party, as most Labour voters, would agree with her on most things, and she certainly is not more aligned to Tory, Reform or Green voters, and even Lib Dems as they are more extreme on the things she opposes than Labour at times. So its a shame, as probably she is as down the road, centre left as can be. She is not extreme on anything, and likely chimes with most 2024 election Labour voters. So its a shame she left. But I suppose really its just a excuse, and really she was very unhappy with the way she was treated by certain other members, for her rather moderate views on a certain other issue. Which to be fair, most Labour policy now chimes with her to a extent. But maybe it shall be fun for her to have 5 years as a rent a mouth independent, and really considering the way she was treated maybe thats her right. And really also it wont harm Labours majority. Maybe she will be able to appears on Question time all the time now, as a indepdent voice,
    1
  1301. The guy has balls of steel, beware sacred cows like trans rights.
    1
  1302. Rosie Duffield
    1
  1303. I love netball, women's netball is great, protect women's sport, as Riley Gaines says. To be fair the aussie netball ladies are amazing, and the crowds are world class for womens sportz outside of tennis.
    1
  1304. She obviously is not, and it's embarrassing if anyone who can't tell that for the person who can't tell that, not for her or anyone else.
    1
  1305. It's not a war, it's sport. Trans activists forget that, as they are so macho and aggressive.
    1
  1306. Einstein and Arnie,
    1
  1307. Half the signers of the declaration of independence were born in Bolton, Lancashire, and the rest were born in Whitby.
    1
  1308. Cool chats 👞
    1
  1309. Whistleblowers are good
    1
  1310. The Nazis were defeated
    1
  1311. Trans rights activists make up hateful remarks as the truth ruins their arguments.
    1
  1312. And to my mind zielinski still won.
    1
  1313. I agree,
    1
  1314. A dam dictator, I love beavers, 🦫. But z is elected surely, he won a free election.
    1
  1315. Jk rowling is best.
    1
  1316. ​ @roboi2241 do racists have a higher life expectancy than Scots.
    1
  1317. But surely it's ok to stand up to this orwellian idealogy, it's like so much like 1984, not objecting to it, lis like failing at level one of a George orwell computer game. Can't you see it.
    1
  1318. I abhor anybody who would attack you for being trans. But please, don't think that gender critical people support those who attack you. We believe biological sex exists and has consequences, that's women's sport should be won by the best biological woman, and that there are debates over safe spaces, and same or opposite sex attraction rights, but as jk said, wear what you want, call yourself what you wants and that's ok. I would have no problem with a trans work colleague or customer, there just humanity.
    1
  1319. As you long as you are respectful, I think their are protected beliefs.
    1
  1320. What a unpleasant remark, so Trumpian, so final, so dismissive, just like the uncaring arrogant nature of extreme gender idealogy.
    1
  1321. Happy days.
    1
  1322. 100, well done.
    1
  1323. ​ @venga3 Dankulas terrible act was training his dog to get excited and happy, when mentioning the gassing of victims of the Holocaust, a very unfunny and strange act. Nothing to be proud of, and anybody who condemned him for that was within their rights. Ps I think dankula should be forgiven for his stupid act, but don't act like what he did was done heroic act, I am sure he has done good stuff for people, and made good jokes in his life, but that stupid thing he did was dumb. Not that any of us are perfect, and to be honest dankulas friends should have told him it was dumb as well. So let's forgive dankula, but also accept linehan has every right to say biological sex exists, like Dawkins says it does.
    1
  1324. But who should decent people vote for, who don't like unpleasant jokes like this.n
    1
  1325. All it says on Putins cards are Pee Pee tape. And he nods at trump, and he submits.
    1
  1326. No, it's a perfectly reasonable thing to say no biological men in women's sports, if it's such a wedge issue why are people trying to impose it against the populations will, surely democracy says no, so the elite, the servants of the people, should say no
    1
  1327. And puberty blockers are restricted in Britain now, as there are felt to be concerns .
    1
  1328. That would be more dangerous
    1
  1329. Delicious
    1
  1330. The advert actually featured Stephen fry and Mark Watson. And a beautiful lady.
    1
  1331. Yes, well done everybody who just said no to this glaringly obvious reality.
    1
  1332. ​ @itsallminor6133 Russia beat America in a war, fdr would be spinning in his grave, total defeat, then again I'm not American.
    1
  1333. Pearl davis is beautiful.
    1
  1334. Never heard one, did you watch this.
    1
  1335. Race realism is rubbish and a lie, they lost world war two, to people they claimed were their inferior. They claim Nepalis gave a IQ in the fifties, which is a tragically comic thing to believe do you think any of these dumb racists commenting here could climb Everest, specially as the first person to ever, the way Sherpa tensing did. 😂😂😂
    1
  1336. That's bullying, she is the female Winston Smith.
    1
  1337. If Lisa nandy had been in power in the the 1970s Martina naveratalola may have lost all her titles to a biological male identifying as a woman, and none of us would have heard of her, it is not right of Nandy to believe these views. Well done Helen Joyce.
    1
  1338. Why are trans rights activists such fans of Adolf, I would think like linehan they should oppose him.
    1
  1339. Men are not biological women, end of.
    1
  1340. In Britain labour did it.
    1
  1341. Omg, a pathetic anti semite, go crawl under a rock ,
    1
  1342. Well why not just play in the category one was born as
    1
  1343. ​ @ScorpionSuerte get a life and read something fun.
    1
  1344. No way, as actually a lot of trans rights extremists are bullies, bullying middle aged women.
    1
  1345. No, it's not jealousy, it's fairness.
    1
  1346. But biological males are born on average taller and bigger. That's a unfair advantage in women's sport. Just imagine someone took a banned drug which made them stronger, that would be unfair, even if they finished first or twentieth. It's still unfair.
    1
  1347. Shows we should always be careful as drivers and pedestrians, I shall take this as a lesson. 😢
    1
  1348. But is it team player, like, to impose this ideology on her and her team mates, and to bully them if they question it.
    1
  1349. But what's about when Kathy Gifford was fired for mocking Trump's family
    1
  1350. You are flippantly ignorant Dawkins points on the existence of biological sex.
    1
  1351. Did you miss spell biologist
    1
  1352. But to some unfunny.
    1
  1353. Because it is unfair to have biological males, in women's sports.
    1
  1354. Because it is unfair to have biological males in women's sports. Keep women's sports best achievements for the best biological women, like karsta lowe, Gabrielle Reece, Lisa Leslie, Ekaterina gamova, Lauren Jackson, etc, it not fair to have their achievements taken by biological males. We can love trans, but we have women's sports,vas biological women exists, not as of gender.
    1
  1355. If this petition does not work, i could easily imagine some of the petioners, going to he extra step, andbsending a strongly worded letter of criticism ro the local newspaper.
    1
  1356. Biological woman exist, yup.
    1
  1357. You need to learn how to make compliments,
    1
  1358. What if the joke by dankula, instead of being about Jewish victims of the Holocaust, would you find it ok if it was about Stalin's victims, or pol pots victims, or that grandfather who was jailed for his amateur harmless sign about the new world order, and died of a heart attack in jail this year, would you laugh at jokes about them, I would never laugh at any of those victims, including the poor grandfather, or Stalin's victims, or the victims of the Holocaust, I remember watching a documentary on pol pot, and I was physically shaking from it, I can't understand why anybody would enjoy mocking victims of the Holocaust, it's horrible.
    1
  1359. ​ @jamesespinosa690 I would not be a fan of his humor, if he mocked pol pot or Stalin's victims either. We all make bad taste jokes, but it's ok to apologize for them in a decent society.
    1
  1360. ​@jacobesterson he was mocking the victims of the Holocaust, as he was talking about, gassing a specific eth ix group, , I will not insert that word, it's such a shocking thing he said, I can't write it. And look at all the pro far right comments on this comment section of people who liked dankula so called joke. There is a guy saying we fought on the wrong side in WW2, a d a other guy giving combat 18 style cryptic messages. I know dankula is not that at all. But loads of his supporters online on this issue, seem to branch out into that. He could condemn them. And it was a insensitive thing to do . He could just have said, sorry if I caused any offense, instead of acting like there is something to be proud about in jokes that mock the victims of the Holocaust.
    1
  1361. ​@jacobestersonso is your problem, that you are unhappy people are not allowed to train their dogs to salute Hitler. Is that your problem.
    1
  1362. Put this in a reconciliation bill, then it wont need sixty one senators.
    1
  1363. Yes, he did, he stood up for Mandela.
    1
  1364. Who has the prettiest wife, z, the questioner, the ugliest, so suit wearing does not always work.
    1
  1365. Baby universes,wow, genius.
    1
  1366. But whistleblowers are good.
    1
  1367. Nice speech,
    1
  1368. That's what they said about
    1
  1369. Zelensy won,
    1
  1370. I read a book on him, cool subject.
    1
  1371. And a lot of tra activists do argument like they don't understand your point. Though that may just be a rhetorical trick. Though nothing against autistic people, some are very clever.
    1
  1372. It is a unfair advantage for a person to compete in women's sports, who was born biological male, it's like it's also unfair if people are taking performance enhancement drugs.
    1
  1373. And Alistair Campbell statement, about the horrible fear he has, and well done him for saying he has this fear, that biological males who identify as women, trans women, may be beaten up in men's toilets. Well surely that is admitting that men are more aggressive than women. Why is it a flat out statement that biological males identify as women shouldn't be in men's toilets because men are so aggressive, where is it ok then to put certain biological males in women's toilets, is there a fear then biological woman could be beaten up by these biological males, who identify as women. The stats as far as I am aware, don't indicate that biological males who identify as women become women in every way, the criminal statistics indicate that trans women are closer to what you would call cis men in many crime statistics, than to cis wome. It doesn't change because they identify as a different gender. If you perceive yourself to be a different gender, you are still likely to have statistically the same threats and danger towards women as if you identified as what you were observed at birth as. That's not me being hateful, that's just an observed reality. We should be tolerant and kind to trans people, but just to ignore the fears of those women, to me just seems to be kind of I don't get it, surely you can genuinely tolerant and understanding towards the fears of those women. I don't understand this kind of just ignoring those fears.
    1
  1374. Are you saying older people are not allowed to give their knowledge and experience on this issue., if so why not.
    1
  1375. Your charm school failed you big time.😊
    1
  1376. Biological males should be in men's sports, like has been all my life.
    1
  1377. Yes, agreed
    1
  1378. Some of them got off English free.
    1
  1379. Yes, good lady.
    1
  1380. Cool, man these guys are cool, 😎. How can this be for free.
    1
  1381. 🎉❤In most situations we don't need to care, and can be happy and inclusive, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins is also someone criticized for saying biological sex exists, but was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤ we should oppose bullying of trans people, but it is ok to sensible nuanced laws which accept sex exists.
    1
  1382. As she is pretty
    1
  1383. They don't need your sympathy, homeless people, war victims and victims of crime need our sympathy. These two are riding over the sunset into the big time.
    1
  1384. Nixon lost to North Vietnam, trump lost to Russia.
    1
  1385. Well why on earth is anybody trying to impose this unpopular idea then.
    1
  1386. Cool
    1
  1387. Great discussion, Dawkins is a important voice on this.
    1
  1388. It was a good joke
    1
  1389. Someone more recent in the comments section says they know a pre school kid who had hormones to make them change gender, don't know if it's true, they might be anything.
    1
  1390. Homelessness fell under him. And unemployment.
    1
  1391. It's not hateful to say biological sex exists.....
    1
  1392. It's laughable orwellian rubbish.
    1
  1393. People like JK Rowling, believe that a biological male who has gone through all these procedures, and some of whom are trans but have not gone through these procedures, are still biological males. And there is a case for believing that belief. They believe that male aggression is still male aggression whether that male identifies as a woman or identified as a man, when you understand it from that point of view you become more tolerant of their concerns. We should be nice to trans people but also understand the fears of these women who have these perfectly understandable evolutionarily created fears.
    1
  1394. How dare zelensy not wear a suit, this is disrespectful to stormy Daniels and Epsteins good friend.
    1
  1395. The replies are for the rest of us, it would send any normal person insane to read abuse all the time, very important to ignore that.
    1
  1396. Stop pretending a rubbish joke, needs a literal defence. That's silly. 😅😅😅
    1
  1397. He agrees in a way.
    1
  1398. Well meteors were pretty bad, so the protesters were right there as well. The dinosaurs protesting in favour of the meteor, we're just as badly burned. I bet the crocodiles and birds knew it was bad, so hid, they were the gender critical folk of the time.
    1
  1399. It's amazing how many ethnicities there are in the Caucasian Caspian areas, and they are all in just 7 countries. I love hearing about these societies. I can think of over 20, it's like a mini continent. But I have a question, are some of those ones in Iran, more like Occitians in France, as in virtually French now, or is it more like comparing the french and the Spanish, two different nations. Just asking. I did not even know the groups existed, and I love knowing these kind of things, the Lurs, amazing, hope they all get along and have peace. My fave one is that tiny Georgian one who apparently went to world war one in armour amazing. The Khevsureti.
    1
  1400. If you count groups that cross borders, as three if in different countries it must be like 50 ethnicities at least.
    1
  1401. I would rather simp about Beautiful biological women, like Jennifer Lawrence, and such, and agree with clever good women like Helen Joyce than simp about biological males who.identify as women, and Alice in wonderland gender ideology orwellian theirists and bullying activists that don't stand up to scrutiny.
    1
  1402. Well why comment on this if it's so unimportant, go and cure call all the worlds problem s and al tell people to stop campaigning for biologicl males in women's sports,
    1
  1403. But Russia invaded, and fired missiles at every Ukraine city.
    1
  1404. And i cried at his mention of his wife, 😅
    1
  1405. ​ @ScorpionSuerte everything you say is suspect,vas you spell than, thab, so have low accuracy levels.
    1
  1406. ​​ @ScorpionSuerte no you are slagging off the Spanish, a great people, stop the racism.
    1
  1407. ​ @ScorpionSuerte Spaniards include admixtures of Arabs, indeed the evil ah, the hero of racists, claimed Spaniards were lazy, and William pferdekamp claimed Spain was Africa. The fact you are slagging of the Spanish is such racist hate, that I can see why you are reduced to reading pseudoscience books that no sensible person reads, and thabs fact.
    1
  1408. ❤❤In most situations we don't need to care, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins is also someone criticized for saying biological sex exists, but was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤ we should oppose bullying of trans people, but it is ok to sensible nuanced laws which accept sex exists.
    1
  1409. Hamburger eating surrender monkeys.
    1
  1410. Good point.
    1
  1411. It's not hateful to say biological women exist, or biological males. Any more than it is hateful to say sone people are taller than others.
    1
  1412. It's not right wing or hateful to say biological women exists, and j Edgar Hoover, and three roman emperors, and some Tory mps, were trans or interested in cross dressing, so don't act like being trans is some radical superior expression. Some like that kind of thing, that's ok, be what you want to be, but it does not stop biological sex existing.
    1
  1413. ​ @hamansing787 but it could affect turnout,
    1
  1414. I am a ❄️
    1
  1415. Why are people so obsessed about thus dank fellow. As far as i am aware linehan is not in charge of the British justice system, and has no power over anything that has ever happened to him. A so has dank apologised, and have you apologized to the jews who died in the Holocaust, who he mocked by training his dog to get excited at the mention of gassing them. A weird and strange thing to do. So when is your apology. What if a Islamic extremist did what Dank did, would you see him as a hero if he did that., I hope not. What has happened to people today, they just seem to be self important people who demand they be allowed to do whatever they want without any idea of decorum. Horrible bullies insulting JK Rowling for saying biological sex exists, and other unpleasant people proclaiming they should be allowed to make horrible jokes about the victims of the Holocaust, purely dehumanising and laughing at them, and then being upset for years when sensible people tell them they were wrong. I think we need more decorum, we should be condemning religious extremists, far right extremists and trans rights extremists to account, they are all different sides of the same coin, and it is good when the establishment condemn these movements., and limit their hateful ideaologies and lies. JK Rowling is right on just about everything. Make her President.
    1
  1416. The thing about all the Dankula fans, is the fact they are still griping about what Linehan said 10 years ago, which had no influence over anything. Then these hypocrits claim Dankula should be allowed to say whatever he likes, with no decorum at all. Can you see the hypocricy here, they still have their knickers in a twist over something Linehan said 10 year ago, which was probably just a brilliant joke by Linehan, but think Dankula should be allowed to mock the victims of the most horrible crime in human history. No Dankula did not decide to mock a powerful political leader, or celebrity or the perptrators of the crime, he mocked the poor innocent victims, (Which he spent a good amount of time training his dog to do) and these Dankula fans, dont condemn Dankula they condemn Linehan, just as Linehan makes jokes people actually find funny, PS I know most extreme trans activists are just far right people pretending to be trans activists. PS, are you wanting me to apologise to Dankula as well, and you, Coz I aint going to,
    1
  1417. ​ @venga3 are they really pro free speech, 💬.
    1
  1418. There different issues,
    1
  1419. ​ @RadioBirdman-u1r so does that mean all your views are like anti vaxxer views, and therefore does that mean orwellian Bigots should try and cancel your if you express any view on anything.
    1
  1420. What about Harrogate.
    1
  1421. ❤❤In most situations we don't need to care, and can be happy and inclusive, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins is also someone criticized for saying biological sex exists, but was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤ we should oppose bullying of trans people, but it is ok to sensible nuanced laws which accept sex exists.
    1
  1422. But if sex and gender are different what is the argument that biological males who identify as women, compete in womens sports.
    1
  1423. ​ @shemdig well why are people trying to campaign for biological men competing in women's sport,
    1
  1424. Most people who believe biological sex exists, absolutely accept that there are people who are trans who want to identify as the opposite gender, that is just a reasonable debate about how this affects other things. We should be nice to trans people, but we can still debate the nuances of how a society functions where we know that biological males pose, safeguarding threats to biological females,
    1
  1425. Your plumbers opinion is relevant, and if he was fired for protected opinions, that would be wrong as well.
    1
  1426. Surely you understand there is a war on, and he does this to show affinity with the troops. I mean loads of leaders wear different clothes to meet the presidents, look at Saudi, etc. And why should anyone show respect to a friend of Epstein anyway, why is that.
    1
  1427. Who is he attacking, gi e a example.
    1
  1428. No , she is saying there are real differences..
    1
  1429. So why not just have the biological males in the men's tournaments then, surely you would have no problem with that,vas you say that's ok. Trans women in the men's comps.
    1
  1430. If anything Scotland has the highest polling against this.
    1
  1431. Rubbish
    1
  1432. Lots of working class people don't like swearing, look at the methodists and evangelicals, I mean I swear but must remember to hold my tongue in some places. Good manners are just as much working class as any other class, indeed some middle and upper class folk swear.
    1
  1433. You don't have to go back to the 1960, 2010, is far enough even 2016, biological males in women's sports is so recent, South Park had a episode mocking the idea,
    1
  1434. Also, yes Phelps has physical advantages over the average man, but it's not as those men are women. The difference is there already is a event for biological men, so trans women can compete in those sports. There is no reason why they should not. If a biological man s physical advantages over women', is as they are men, they can compete in mens sports. It's like we have weight categories for boxing, so we don't let heavier men compete is lighter categories. We want to see the fastest man in the world , and also the fastest woman, not the fastest man and then a fastest women event including biologigcal man who identify refas women and therefore have physical advantages that should have put them in the mens event. 😆😆😊
    1
  1435. ​ @LoreEclectic nah, I think biologicl women have different stats on personality traits, to biological males who identify as women. Like on crime and all sorts of things.
    1
  1436. I agree, it is racist, trans rights activists always compare trans women to ethnic minorities, with ethnic minorities being othered, never to the group they are in, or their relatives or wives,
    1
  1437. I am sure pre feminists as well warned about toxic males, any sensible woman knows men and women have traits which must be factored into laws.
    1
  1438. Lots of left wingers oppose this, the British communists, for eg. Keir Stamer, Alex salmond, the US green party vp, Seth Moulton.
    1
  1439. Because only 40000 years separate them, and all were hunter gatherers, till 10,000 years ago.
    1
  1440. ​​​​​​​ @CarlLo-mein-k3i all the evidence indicates that racists usually have low iqs, while anti racism people like Oppenheimer or Dawkins or such like have high iqs. Have you ever talked to people from various races, there is no way in a million years that IQs are substantially different for different races. I have lived a long time, and talked to people of different races, and there is not one , that to me stands out as all are mostly super intelligent, and there is not one that stands out as particularly stupid. I think IQs are remarkably similar worldwide, other than educational systems. Ps bringing in the chip on your shoulder rubbish, does not wash with me, it's just boring and the fact that the huge chip on your shoulder poor me stuff you trot out is your main obsession indicates that. Just talk to people of different races, and you will find your theory on IQ has no semblance in day to day reality. You can believe there were colonial injustices, and historical effects, without believing that certain groups need to be classed as evil. I don't think white people or East Asians are evil, but do realise, that history has effects on some places being richer or poorer. All you have to do is talk to people of other races, and it's clear. Also in the modern globalized world most advances are by globally sourced egg heads in top universities. A d you misunderstood what the word equality means, like in 1984, when ingsoc try to ban the word, and make it mean the same as same. It does not mean that, it means respecting all as equal citizens in certain situations, with certain caveats like law, or some such. Which most would want for them self. If you talk to people of different races, you will see there is not the huge difference you want to believe in. It's not me being politically correct, it's just what I have experienced in life, your theory that different races have naturally different levels of IQ, does not hold up to every day experience, and life. The reason most clever people dont agree with you, is the opposite of what you believed was proven to be true, by reality.
    1
  1441. Cool Okinawa fact.
    1
  1442. If you speak out against biological males in women's sports, there is always a cruel aggressive impervious hate campaign against you, I hope this is not you part of it.
    1
  1443. The racialists claim Nepal has a IQ in the fifties, which is utterly impossible, how did Sherpa tensing climb Everest, with no path, when other very clever people from across the world had failed before him. How come there were Gurkha parachute regiments, landing behind enemy lines in WW2, and defeating the so called master race soldiers. Huh so called master race, they said, just like the guy in Highlander.
    1
  1444. ​ @ScorpionSuerte is thab so, 😂😂😂😂, sorry you don't dare put the word that, after what you did last time.
    1
  1445. But it does not have to be compulsory, and sometimes it's just bullying. I mean how come trump never mocked the guys he did as interviewed by, he was charming with them, that's how people should be.
    1
  1446. In what way has he gone nuts, surely whatever is the case, he is right on saying biological sex exists. 😊
    1
  1447. ​ @jonnygibs77 are you saying you see the end of 1984 where Winston adheres to big brother, under the pressure of it's Jack boot, as a happy ending. As I don't, I think the irrational idealogy of gender idealogy will be beaten as the people and cleverest folk will not allow it's utter nonsense elements.
    1
  1448. It is like a episode of assasins creed, in a way.
    1
  1449. You clearly don't understand the situation, it's not a business meeting, it's a war leader v a appeaser.
    1
  1450. Reason and rationality will win.
    1
  1451. I was followed by a road rager why, I have no idea, on a road in Yorkshire, where I don't live, I was driving, and saw the car behind was right up behind, and both young men had a angry expression. I slowed and stopped at a lay by, they did also, then started again, making sure it was just enough to make them start after the next flow of traffic, then luckily I saw a lay by just for one car, before a strong corner, I managed to stop there, they could not as they were in a flow of traffic, then I started and went down a other road on my journey, and even went round a big roundabout a few times, to make sure they were not behind. I lost them.
    1
  1452. I am sorry to hear that. Let's hope things can be safe for you. Down with any bullying against you . I know most gender critical people would agree with me, that we can accept biological sex exists, have some limitations in sport, and some safe spaces, but be welcoming and inclusive to trans people as well, for instance Dawkins was pals with Jan Morris years before this debate, so most gender critical people are completely ok with trans people, other than some minor legal nuances. Have a good day, best wishes to you.
    1
  1453. When the gender recognition act was proposed, all the media outlets said, it was just about making it easier for people to change sex, it sounded like it was just about on their passports. There was no announcement it was about regarding biological men who identify as women in every case. Very few people truly believe that is so. Sadly the courts will certainly choose the extreme trans activists position that biological males who identify as women are women in every case. Well if you give in to thus demand without any thought about it , its like failing at level one of 1984 the computer game, so say what ever you like law, biological sex still exists. Two plus two is four. Even if the law says it is five, if anything we should wear our rejection of this orwellian descison as a proud badge of pride.
    1
  1454. Just stop using the terrible toxic language.
    1
  1455. Well why are people trying to impose putting biological males who identify as women, in women's safe spaces and women's sports.
    1
  1456. It is not hateful or transphobic to observe that biological sex exists. It's the most obvious reality there is.
    1
  1457. Or compete in biology male events, it doesn't change your gender, if you believe in gender ideology definitions.
    1
  1458. He should have said, sit on this pearl clutches. He was like they fonz, they were like fools. .
    1
  1459. And then claim anybody who questions the most extreme elements, is fighting a hateful culture war. It's so upsetting when they gaslighting Ike this.
    1
  1460. It's still an unfair advantage to be born male in women's sports. It would be like someone on steroids finishing fiftieth with less training and pushing down a place some one else, it's still unfair.
    1
  1461. Men are not women.
    1
  1462. Yep, he should mind his own.
    1
  1463. ​ @TheWeb-is-a-Lie some conservatives are nice people, and don't like racist jokes. I like those ones, they are great people.i this k they helped make America great, I don't think racist jokes did.
    1
  1464. Dankula was unknown, and made a rubbish joke, what would you say if a Muslim fundamentalist did what he did, would you be one of those useful idiots saying let people say what they like.
    1
  1465. ​​​ @mrcaboosevg6089 it's that kind of mealy mouthed weakness that let the grooming gangs, and extremists to proliferate. Your weak politically correct anything goes attitudes is the type of thing we should not accept. Our police should take note of clear red flags like that, and it is appalling that politically correct attitudes like yours, pussy footing around the issues allow our people to be at risk, as if pure woke political correctness.. don't care what you say, we should never have allowed the guys who committed the nice and Berlin massacres to have proliferated. We should have never allowed those events to have occurred, down with extremism, the red flags that come up time and time and time again from those extremists must be seen as red flags and must be seen as reasons to jail these extremists. if we had jailed the nice and the Berlin terrorist beforehand then those terrorist attacks would never have occurred. And you talk about free speech and of privileges of people's rights etc, the red flags were obvious. The police and the army should have acted on the obvious red flags earlier.
    1
  1466. ​​ @mrcaboosevg6089 I am still here, where is your answer, so are you saying you would allow Islamic extremists to mock british victims of terror attacks, and not put those individuals on watch list, and be prosecuted, is t that what causes ninety percent of terror attacks, just letting the extremists do and say horrible stuff. On the other hand, many terrorist attacks have been foiled as sensible people realized red flags like that must be noted.
    1
  1467. I hope Russia stops fighting in Ukraine, and helps with the west promote a peace here.
    1
  1468. Should Kathy Griffin was fired for her joke, critical of trump.
    1
  1469. What if a Islamic fundamentaliamst did it, would you support the joke and person who did it then.
    1
  1470. What if they are like spanners, multi size ones
    1
  1471. I don't like this schadenfreude, specially when the so called far left people are virtually of the same beliefs as the so called right wing people. Mel Gibson and James woods, both had their houses burnt down, and they are not remotely left wing.
    1
  1472. Is this a joke
    1
  1473. He does not think you should not be allowed to change gender, he said he has great respect for Jan Morris, he does not hate trans people. And I am sure, like me, he would abhor anybody who beat someone up for being trans. I don't think he ever said trans is cosplay, he believes gender disphoria exists. He has expressed compassion for people who have it, he does not hate trans people. Please don't miss state what people say, and don't blame him for what horrible people do, , the horrible people who beat people up for being trans, are the horrible people, don't excuse their horrible behavior by blaming Richard Dawkins.
    1
  1474. Putin invadef Ukraine, surely trump should tell his murderous friend to withdraw, if he loves him so much.
    1
  1475. So people don't like how he opposes biological males in women's toilets, and opposes sex change operations on miners, yes there are people who opposes him for that, well those people should examine their views and criticize themselves first.
    1
  1476. His supporters tactical voting, was too cleverly by half.
    1
  1477. Are there dankula fans who laughed at his so called joke mocking the gassing of Jewish Holocaust victims, who also are not fans of Israel, hey you surprise me.
    1
  1478. Could they be connected to thoe Scottish bronze age spheres.
    1
  1479. It would be good if the great Russian and Ukrainian people can make peace, by ousting Putin.
    1
  1480. ​ @calumlambert is there really such a thing as a female brain and a male brain. Surely if there is, why do stats for trans women on many things, have a closer comparison to biological males than to biological females. Surely all it is, is some biological males perceived themselves to be women, and yes some will have more feminine traits than most other biological males, but equally some biological males who perceive they are women, actually have much less feminity than that. As shown by the trans rights protests a week ago, where many were holding aggressive banners with dehumanizing threatening terms towards what they dismissively call terfs. I am not sure from my experiences that the fact someone perceived themselves to be the gender of the opposite sex, makes them have a women's brain, because in my experience they usually seem more masculine in persona before transition than feminine, and a lot of stats involving male female safeguarding indicate that as well.
    1
  1481. Do you laugh if Muslims did this joke.
    1
  1482. Yes Russua stop invading and withdraw
    1
  1483. Oh 🫨 shock, he annoys trump supporters and trans rights activists by telling it like it is, how dreadful. Ps I am being ironic. He's a rebel with a cause.
    1
  1484. Yes, that was a bit silly.
    1
  1485. I say, there is more joy in heaven for one sinner converted, than a thousand angels praying. Not that he is a sinner, he is a angel, but come on, be happy he has come round to rational view.
    1
  1486. Pearl is a very pretty lady, live the fact she played volleyball, very beautiful tall women in that. Kerp it for biological women only like Pearl.
    1
  1487. It's like witnesseing the fall of Rome.
    1
  1488. Are you calling trump that
    1
  1489. Totally 💯
    1
  1490. IQ depends on many things, look at Massachusetts, a far higher IQ than most European countries, whereas most of the USA, is below them, look at most racists, most are very stupid. Weird al yankovic IQ is way above average USA or even Europe IQ, and no IQ test has ever found any group anywhere near his IQ, surely the IQ differences found are tiny, and probably caused by economics, really. Clever people have iqs in the 130 range, or 150, no race or nationality is anywhere near that. So iq differences are at most tiny and uncertain. And populations have wide variance. IQ is not racial, it's educational.
    1
  1491. ​ @AngrySahraoui they can make a toothbrush. Look at the famous Ghanaian stools, that West Africans king who was richest in history, West Africa had metal industries before Jesus. Gas masks and refrigerated trucks were invented by black people. Have you heard of Mark Dean who invented the IBM PC monitor, and the traffic light. I find most white racists speak like junkies. What about all the doctors who are black, and all the white racists, who are not clever enough to be.
    1
  1492. ​ @AngrySahraoui what about the benin bronzes of the 18th century, they are far more complicated than a toothbrush,
    1
  1493. Look at the carved wooden doors of oliwe of use
    1
  1494. ​ @AngrySahraoui look at the masquerade masks of West Africa, far more complex than a toothbrush.
    1
  1495. Look up the story of Abram petrovich Gannibal.
    1
  1496. ​ @AngrySahraoui I don't know what translation device you are using, but those words don't go together in a sensible sentence, it's gobbledegook.
    1
  1497. ​ @AngrySahraoui horse, elephant, didgeredoo, small hands, kangaroo, kalazaboo, what wango, peoplexing smagaroo😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
    1
  1498. 👍
    1
  1499. Most people just spend their time discussing the exact tactical position of a specific player in the premiership football match, I mean I like football, but this is a better more important interest, the many of the things people use their time on.
    1
  1500. Amen to that
    1
  1501. Like how many refused to play whites only South Africa, it was a noble act.
    1
  1502. No
    1
  1503. Helen Joyce and Kathleen stock and jk Rowling agree with him and the labour mp for Canterbury, nine of them are fad right.
    1
  1504. Let freedom roarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr. He can say what he likes, it's a free country.
    1
  1505. ​​ @LOwens-xf8yo so are you saying that if someone likes pink, or dolls, that means they are female, and even if they were born male, that they should be treated as a female. I have been getting told by many trans rights activists that nobody is gendered as female, just as they like pink or dolls, but are you saying they do, and get medicalized with puberty blockers, even before school, so it does happen after all. In how big numbers, is it hundreds a year in the USA, like some guys said on Joe Rogan.
    1
  1506. ​I agree, I like decent Republicans, the bullying ones, are just mean.  @Bluedd125 
    1
  1507. Say the people who got Kathy Griffin fired for a joke.
    1
  1508. ​ @jasonwhite6463 and one of them won a NCAA swimming championship. That's huge odds, for such a tiny percentage to win, showing being biological males is a unfair advantage in women's sports.
    1
  1509. ​​ @sculpt-media this is insane, I bet it has had a affect, it's so crazy, it's like a miracle of Harris. How did anybody on the trump team get a job, who appointed this guy. Just think, whoever appointed this comedian got paid money, while anybody with half a brain cell would know not to appoint anybody like this.
    1
  1510. Thanks for the compliments
    1
  1511. I thonk the vids are being demoetized as things are being said that show up facts, msm dont reveal. Its not because of violence, thats a lame excuse. Their facts that right wing media won't mention either, its not wokeness.
    1
  1512. ​​​​ @operationgoldfish8331 biological sex exists, two plus two is four, you can't hold back that truth, I don't know, somehow Orwellianism will be defeated, something will defeat it, the spirit of man, the truth, orwellian gender idealogy just won't win. You may consider gender critical views crime think, and condemn me for not doing duck speak, you may be considered doubleplusgood for your condemnation of me wright, on your five minutes of hate against him, But the spirit of truth wins, jk Rowling is right. P.s one of the people you suggested as a source said that jk Rowling should be arrested, under Scotttish hate crime law, something the authorities said would not happen, you should not be paying more attention to people who support Orwellianism positions like jailing people for saying things that do not go along with gender idealogy, you should find moderates, to tell me about. JK Rowling is good, and Richard Dawkins. Biological women exists. Ps I won't last ok up any sources you suggest, as one of the people you suggested tried to claim the horrible murder of a trans teen, which was a horrible thing to occur,nwas to some extent jk Rowling and other gc peoples fault,which one as a bullying orwellian method of trying to silence others. It's this hatefulness from trans rights activists that they must reduce.
    1
  1513. I say it would be better for a non USA world alliance.
    1
  1514. Scotland invented penicillin, I hope you accept that anti Scottish people are not allowed to use penicillin, watch tv or use telephones, MRI scanners, or hypodermic syringes, or even money from the bank of england which a scot invented. Whatever polluted urban dystopia you live in as well, accept she opposes pollution.
    1
  1515. Yes😂
    1
  1516. Actually they are racist, as they always compare biological males in women's sports competing, to black or Chinese women competing, as if they think Chinese and black women, are somehow not women, which is crazy racist thinking.
    1
  1517. Nah,
    1
  1518. Yes, but only for believing in biology, and his good jokes. ......
    1
  1519. Amen
    1
  1520. And he killed bin laden.
    1
  1521. Be supports Kettering Town.
    1
  1522. Don't drag Britain into this mess
    1
  1523. Fighting has no place in football, any sane person would run away from football hooligans. Football hooligans are neanderthals whatever club they support, ruining a beautiful game, I don't care if they support my team, or somebody else's, football hooligans are just football hooligans and should be banned from every stadium, and from being near any stadium. Football is just a game, any neanderthals whoever they support, linked to looking for trouble and fighting, should be barred from even being near a football crowd. And those who keep away from such trouble are right, it's just a game, kicking a ball about.
    1
  1524. The thing about trans rights campaigners is they seem to value far right racist tropes,.whereas Gandhi and Mandela opposed racism.
    1
  1525. It was important to fight against this orwellian idealogy that there were politicians, and celebrities to fight back. JK Rowling and Richard Dawkins, Ricky gervais, were too big to cancel, the small fry like the odd dance director or social worker were successfully cancelled by orwellian Bigots on this issue, but linehan was in between, more a back room staff guy who most people of that ilk were successfully cancelled, but as he appeared on camera every so often, he was able to use this, and ironically he has become more famous for opposing this orwellian ideai than the comedy circuit he has been banned from. His voice is important in fighting this obviously hateful orwellian idealogy. I am not saying he is perfect, but he is a bit of a dark angel on this issue, really annoys the trans rights bully wing. Love to trans people, but the gender deology fanatics is so bad, even their moderates campaign for jailing people who don't agree with them. I m am their main sportsperson in Britain said JK Rowling should be arrested, that's mad extreme.
    1
  1526. 67 percent of yougov poll brits blame trump, only 7 percent blame the great z.
    1
  1527. Well tell schools to stop teaching under tens lessons, where all these issues are framed in the anti jk Rowling mindset.
    1
  1528. Good health to you, would you say biological males should be allowed in biologigcal women's sports, if they identify as women.
    1
  1529. This lady has a good manner.
    1
  1530. Seriously, it's not filled with garbage, surely your misunderstanding.
    1
  1531. So just have the biological male who identify as a woman, with the men's team, on your argument, nobody would object.
    1
  1532. Etc, what sort of far right extremists use just laughiiby vague terms.
    1
  1533. The etc people are a branch of Christianity. And they are not pleased at you asking them to emigrate.
    1
  1534. Very good, but is there a fear the Brandenburg tests only gets used for white supremacists, rightly we did not see it used regarding bin laden terrorists, they were all put in gitmo. Otherwise Doyle is brilliant, great stuff from him. There might be a argument for some kind of re-establish decorum, fining the costume guy, but I can't defend people being jailed, or especially if the law was never really debated, and is just a radical interpretation of the law, I mean at least if we now where we stand that's bad enough, but laws being radically reinterpreted is not on is awful.
    1
  1535. Your the first to mention that word, 😂😂😂😂
    1
  1536. Kaspersky did that for a while as well, it's stupid, as they can get us customers back another year. I have it on a old laptop again, as I bypass it. It should be illegal though.
    1
  1537. But you can not like a joke, in free speech, otherwise my knock knock jokes would make me the worlds leading comedy star.
    1
  1538. Gold 🥇 won, that's why he is called gold.
    1
  1539. I don't think Dawkins has anything against adults choosing to do what they want to. Remember he has much respect for Jan Morris. But we do need nuanced laws, tolerating and accepting trans people, but accepting for safeguarding that biological sex exists, for sports, dating, and women's safe spaces. Also there are reasnoble debates about puberty blockers, and transitioning for non adults, and Dawkins accepts that, he is actually the moderate living caring centrist moderate view, neither hateful and nasty far right, or biological denying trans rights extremists. He has it just right.
    1
  1540. She was forced to, both ways.
    1
  1541. Congress, should pass a act.
    1
  1542. What about mermaids.
    1
  1543. ​ @7n154 most cis men would be ok, with a trans woman in the team. Why on earth would anybody have a problem with that, and should we give in to such attitudes, or do we only listen to men complaining on this issue. That would be unfair.
    1
  1544. By losing wars,
    1
  1545. Trans rights activists, oh such inclusion language, not.
    1
  1546. He also built the channel tunnel, defeated the Germans in world war two, invented the NHS, penicillin, the internet, killed bin laden , and lowered homelessness.
    1
  1547. Didn't the guy throw a egg at him, a lot of people said it was a man standing up for himself.
    1
  1548. Race science is nonsense, look at all the dumb people everywhere, and the clever people everywhere.
    1
  1549. It probably lost some votes.
    1
  1550. ​ @mattboyer3385 they ran a add in Pennsylvania on this all day long
    1
  1551. Buffoons
    1
  1552. But everybody does in passionate debate.
    1
  1553. ​ @brettjohnson536 like tennent who is a nice guy, said something I think he is ashamed of, he made a speech, and said kemi badenoch should just, and he said a word quite unpleasant. Some interpreted it as various things. I think he has learned his lesson, but it just goes to say we all say things that can be misinterpreted as more extreme than may have been meant. You could say, we are all a bit daft at times.
    1
  1554. If guys like him are not standing up to this, trans rights extremists bring in their Orwellianism at full pace, well done jk Rowling, and co for standing up to this stuff. If you don't it's like failing at a 1984 computer game, before level one, I mean if you can't stand up to this, what would you stand up to.
    1
  1555. Man, good word.
    1
  1556. But how can I see which entrants in a grand slam tennis tournament are biological women and which are males, just by looking at them.
    1
  1557. Actually the Dana rivers case involved three murders, so great as Robson is, he should really apologize, and add that to his documentary.
    1
  1558. She is ok with trans, just has nuances issues there.
    1
  1559. It's anti Marxism as well.
    1
  1560. Seinfeld is still great. No it was not overated.
    1
  1561. ​ tz7813 I don't think John Smith was a thorn, any more than Gordon Brown.
    1
  1562. Zelensy was the comedy genius here, mocked trumps mannerisms, and ridiculed Vance.
    1
  1563. Zelensy was being disrespectful to democrat party voters, in not putting his hands in faeces, and wiping them on trumps wig, and vances beard.
    1
  1564. Yes, some of the old navvies, were short, bug mighty,
    1
  1565. Ancestors can include a uncle who did not reproduce. or a neanderthal etc.
    1
  1566. But was it fair of the college to impose this on the athletes,
    1
  1567. The guy cooper shoe horns the word Zionists and bribes into the politics of world war two, i mean come on, of course we know Hitler would do that if he was writing a book on the war today. It's cringeworthy. Well done Roberts for putting this fool in his place. And Hitler made speeches about the Jewish financiers, what a pathetic historian cooper is to use terms like financiers. Sickening.
    1
  1568. But he had a right to state his points, surely.
    1
  1569. ​ @Wilso387 trump was slagging off every previous us president, all z was doing, was stating corrective points, which if he had not he would be a bit of a doormat . Trump skags off Biden and Obama, but never putin. and trusting Putin, why, ?
    1
  1570. He was always a articulate fellow, very good commumicator, clever guy. He helped make snp more popular, i suppose Charles Kennedy was good like him as well at that. He had a good life, and experienced a lot. His speeches were fun as well. I wonder what shall happen to alba now.
    1
  1571. Scotland has the highest polling against this. According to a unherd poll.
    1
  1572. I just have to say, pure genius you're right,
    1
  1573. Only 50, but a division one swimmy champ won, that's like 10 ,000 to one
    1
  1574. But surely accepting your gender is the same as your sex, is a world of difference,from identifying as a different gender, to that sex. It's not atv all the same.
    1
  1575. London is amazing.
    1
  1576. 😂
    1
  1577. Yes it's a shame.
    1
  1578. You are absolutely correct,
    1
  1579. Z wife is attractive, it cause jealousy.
    1
  1580. Nobody hates trans people, they just wants the sport to be for biological women. Ps there are so many causes in the world, so instead of campaigning for biologicl men in women's sports, why not campaign for the homeless, there are 500,000 rough sleepers in the USA, or fir peace in the holy land, or how 350 children due of malnutrition a day. Campaign on those issues, not for something nobody wants, or needs.
    1
  1581. The Olympics does not have coed sport teams does it, there is only men's and women's volleyball. And it is not fair that anyone who raised a objection to biological males in women's sports, is the victim of a horrible hate campaign. Like your allegations are beginning to look like.
    1
  1582. It's like a giant worse Rhyl
    1
  1583. So what
    1
  1584. Zelinsky is the real man, he said how it is, he spoke truth to power. And where is Trump spending Valentine's Day, with musk, a 200 grand horse face, or Putin
    1
  1585. The great leader
    1
  1586. I agree that gender critical beliefs span the political spectrum, .
    1
  1587. Finland did it
    1
  1588. Bone spurs
    1
  1589. There was a election, and the centre right voters split, that's how labour got in. We have a electoral system where they now rule for five years, unless their mps change their mind. It's just the way the British system is. The people who don't like that, can behave the way everyone else did before, and try and win the next election. Would pr, be a better system. Or is Britain better off with the current strong system.
    1
  1590. ​ @crowscoyote she is a rational lovely person.
    1
  1591. Linehan is right that Hitler was a bad man.
    1
  1592. A higher life expectancy than the the USA, lower crime, and less gun massacres.
    1
  1593. ​​ @taliawtf6944 Us murder rate, is much more than UK. There are like a 648 people killed this year in mass shootings, in the USA . Which is the same as all the murders in the UK this year. The 10 biggest us mass shootings add up to all the murders in Scotland this century. 43000 people died of gun violence in the USA last year. More than all the murders in Scotland in its entire history. More than all the murders in the UK in stamers lifetime. Even the richest US State has a lower life expectancy than the lowest part of socialist France. The USA has the highest alien abduction rates in the world, and highest 🐻 bear on human kill total, also Bigfoot deaths are higher in the USA, abd your food rules let Americans eat silly stuff, get real, socialism is strong, it makes you manly, and powerful.
    1
  1594. Long live socialism.
    1
  1595. I think he shall cause 5000 Puerto Ricans to vote Harris in every state. And 2000 more latinos and it hurts Trump's momentum, but that may not be enough for Harris, as she is maybe level on popular vote, which is behind in electoral college. And it hurt what had been a successful spectacle.
    1
  1596. ​​ @candidbowyer4625 but that would result in horrific life ending injuries for the feather weights, that would be horrible beyond belief. It is a good thing we have good people protecting the weak from the bullies and strong.
    1
  1597. I bought some, as of the documentary here.
    1
  1598. You worship money.
    1
  1599. 😂😂
    1
  1600. Glenn found his suit at the bottom of a bin.
    1
  1601. Linehan has been cancelled, he is unable to do his musical, and the activists tried to ban Chapelle,there were giant protests trying to get him fired, but he like jk Rowling was too big to sack. It's more social workers and dance directors without fame who are fired on this issue , but people like jk help get them to sue the orwellian Bigots who sacked them.
    1
  1602. And surely in terms of free speech laws, Mr trump surely wants South Africa to have the same free speech laws as Britain has. I said how we protect ethnic minorities.
    1
  1603. Does that mean YouTube just use it as a excuse to take all the cash for themselves💰
    1
  1604. That is a utterly intolerant remark, judging people by their looks is bad enough, but to think you can say if someone is bad just as of their looks, is very intolerant.
    1
  1605. ​ @monstrosity8855 but it's ok to say you don't like these jokes, salt if the earth, decent folk don't.
    1
  1606. ​So you accept it's ok, to find rubbish jokes unfunny. That's brilliant, thanks, you have learned what freedom is.
    1
  1607. A H killed gay people, clearly linehan and gold would oppose that, of course ah and co were the bad guys. Gender critical people just want sensible policies, not evil stuff.
    1
  1608. But I thought most people say the Nazis were not Christians, they were like hyper nihilistic.
    1
  1609. There should be interesting facts.
    1
  1610. It is not versus on gender, as they are more or less in agreement on that topic.
    1
  1611. She does not at all in the slightest. She looks like a normal, pretty, young female. If you can't tell that, your prob.
    1
  1612. No, it's that biological males have a unfair unique advantage compared to biological women.
    1
  1613. They are still able to do most of those jobs in some form, if they choose , maybe certain combat roles are more suited to males, unless you are Diana, but being a biological male in women's sports is a unfair advantage.
    1
  1614. But on loads of stats, biological males, whether cis or trans, are equally as much a safeguarding threat to society and women as each other. Remember that debate where a trans woman threatened to punch Ben Shapiro for not agreeing with gender idealogy. I have never seen a biological woman do that in a debate.
    1
  1615. I been to windsor
    1
  1616. Needs to go in budget reconciliation bill to pass the Senate, am I right there. Just do it please, and then this issue will be sorted and reality will have been accepted, just so it. Well do the two Dems .
    1
  1617. Is that all it took,
    1
  1618. Russia invaded Ukraine. They were the invaders
    1
  1619. ​ @michaelfern4079 he just does not submit to sacred cows. Apologies.
    1
  1620. ​ @michaelfern4079 trans rights, racism, Trumpism, the world's religions, big and small, Brexit, and on Trump's inauguration day, he slams them in every truthful way,
    1
  1621. I don't think so.
    1
  1622. He was criticized for it. I think that's enough.
    1
  1623. That's not true, if people say something untrue about me I am offended, if it's true, I come to terms with it.
    1
  1624. That did not happen. Don't make things up. And it would not have changed anything anyway, biological sex still exists, whatever happens.
    1
  1625. I don't think that is a fair remark
    1
  1626. ​ @lisanidog8178 I think it is mean if someone says a woman looks like a man, but in some extreme intersex cases it's maybe ok to debate sport allowances of who competes. But even then, yes, people should be respectful, and not call people mean names. I mean biology sex is obvious in the main, but like all words, biscuits and cakes example, harder at the edges. But a kind, but sensible and pro fairness answer is required. ,
    1
  1627. There is a strong chance labour won't call an election till after weird al yankovic is inaugurated as president in 2029.
    1
  1628. Trump says silly things, so it's ok to disagree with him. Dawkins is cool, though to be fair well done trump on stating there are only two genders today.
    1
  1629. Poor English
    1
  1630. In what way is he anti trans.
    1
  1631. ​@schweiztony5728 if JK Rowling compared trans people to city ports, she would be called a hateful bigot, when her views are moderate sensible and centrist.
    1
  1632. ​@schweiztony5728jk Rowling and Richard Dawkins are right.
    1
  1633. Just look it up, read his biography
    1
  1634. But still leaves out of Africa as key.
    1
  1635. Absolute rubbish, you, me and all humans, were evolved off lystrosaurus, not dinosaurs. I do agree though that gender critical liberal socialism is the height of rational thought, after billions of years of evolution. 🧬
    1
  1636. 😂😂😂😂
    1
  1637. But what about Thomas Sowell, surely he proves you wrong. Most racist people are not very intelligent, look at all their spelling errors.
    1
  1638. The great name and hero Pele can be remembered as
    1
  1639. ​​​ @FABRlCE and most of the racists, here can't spell, don't use full stops, and must never have talked to anybody of a other race, for more than a minute, they are not race realists, they are race fantasists.
    1
  1640. ​​​​​​​ @ScorpionSuerte i did see Aled Jones in London once, but he was a adult by then, he counts as a choir singer, but why are you referencing those singers, what's your interest in them, is that you are saying the Welsh are great at singing as of genetics, if so, Shirley bassey and tom Jones, yes, that shows it's cultural as well, as both have heritage as well from outside Wales.😊 congratulations scoropin for your keen interest in the subject t if Welsh singers. Ps if there were any unpleasant connotations in your remarks, it shows the repulsiveness and sordid lowest of the low way, that racists normally are, normally racists are the worst in everything, in what is going through their minds and everything, unpleasantness, and low iqs. But I am sure you were only referencing that the Welsh are famed as great singers. Also you spell than, thab, which is not a sign you understand accuracy, so please never be a air traffic controller, or pilot, please leave that to people of all races, who have greater accuracy abilities, you unpleasant individual.
    1
  1641. ​ @hanswurst2765 it is about biological sex , as there are people who would rather womens sport is just for biological women.
    1
  1642. Which is why gender critical feminists support safeguarding rules, in terms of men, whatever those biological men's gende identity.
    1
  1643. Define anti trans.
    1
  1644. How can he be a enemy of Europe, HE IS EUROPE.
    1
  1645. Its a tool.
    1
  1646. Who are you referring to
    1
  1647. Id rather go out and chat to people,, of all races, and have a full life, than read a boring book like that, .i hope THAB people can do that.
    1
  1648. Thab sounds a boring book.
    1
  1649. ​ @ScorpionSuerte you stop pretending you have friends, and stop pretending you can read books.
    1
  1650. You mean a hero to millions that will never surrender to a corrupt larger power.
    1
  1651. No, she is not, she is a nice woman.
    1
  1652. Yes, a nice woman.
    1
  1653. What has he said that you considered hatred or prejudice.
    1
  1654. ​ @tatata1543 can you tell me, or is that just a remark
    1
  1655. ​​ @TheBlackDogChronicles how do you know, it's not you who are affected by that affect lt. or the guy who invented it.
    1
  1656. It's terrible , some Wikipedia editors are vandals.
    1
  1657. ​​​​ @andrewjones-productions yes, his father is Welsh, and Vaughan is Welsh name, he has also lived in Wales most of his life, if we barred people from office, as some of their ancestors were born from outside Wales, I think there would be few people who could be politicians in Wales and certainly eastern Wales, I think it's ok to condemn him for his policies, but people being racist about him, is awful, and i dont think most people in Wales or the uk, would support that kind of racism. The amount of aggressive hateful vitriol about his ethnicity on this comment page is shocking, and very unrepresentative of most people. I have never met anybody who holds the racist beliefs shared by so many hateful people on this comment page. And certainly no one. Also I better say ps I won't read any replies, as people as hateful as what you are seeing here, are not somebody I choose to speak to, and my life is much better for it.
    1
  1658. Totally agree.
    1
  1659. The law is ass
    1
  1660. He personally caught Saddam with his own hands, and killed bin laden when he was a green beret.
    1
  1661. He killed bin laden with his fists, in a fight, when he was oaratrooped in, I remember. In his last punch, he said to Osama, and this is for the twin towers, then dramatic music played, and was helicoptered out.
    1
  1662. She is a biological woman, they are like virtually half the population. And she is a pretty,, volleyball type🥰, tall , blond and attractive to most men.
    1
  1663. I like the un,
    1
  1664. She looks like a pretty, young, biological woman.
    1
  1665. There is no way iqs are.drastically different, if you ever met people of other races you will know they are pretty much similar in IQ. The range is probably a difference of ten at most, except for some cultural causations, like if a country has a national education system, with higher education for all its bounds to have higher average iqs, than one without. The differences in IQ are negligible, unlike voting for right wing and populist parties, which is often something done by people of much lower IQ, especially when you remember IQ is only significant when you get to 120 or 140, or down to 80, and no nationality or race , taking out cultural bias, of IQ tests is truly on either of any end of that spectrum.
    1
  1666. Some people like jokes like this, some don't,bits not compulsory to like certain jokes, can't we skip this stuff. And concentrate on good stuff.
    1
  1667. I hope they are not too tough on immigration. But yes I cannot see why they can't stop these boats, it does not make much sense to me, surely it would be easy enough.. what I found amazing, is it spending money on a Salem seekers in Britain is supposedly part of the foreign aid budget, when really it is just spending a lot of money on hotels in Britain.
    1
  1668. That's not a very nice thing to say. 😊
    1
  1669. ​​​​ @Marcusml333 so are you defending what linehan says, there, and how he says it. Or am I wrong there. Or are you insulting Linehan, I'm confused. As he would consider what he says is calling a spade a spade.
    1
  1670. Whistleblowers are a godsend
    1
  1671. ​ @morisan42 is it nothing
    1
  1672. Good morning, great point.
    1
  1673. And ironically the most sensible left wingers, like jk Rowling are the standard bearers of gender critical views, the only left wingers who are not gender critical can not argue their point, as their argument is so weak, so they need very unbritish, very undemocratic methods to impose their ideology.
    1
  1674. But pearl clutches made the US great, anything goes crudeness, is a sign of the moral decline of America, et Al fall of Rome.
    1
  1675. Hesgeth lost the war to Russia, by sheer force of his own personality, backi g down.
    1
  1676. You may sometimes
    1
  1677. He wears baseball cap
    1
  1678. Ant and dec, 🐜 and dec are great. Love their shows.
    1
  1679. Yes, biological sex exists, it is not far right to accept that completely obvious glaringly reality.
    1
  1680. Zero
    1
  1681. No
    1
  1682. ​​ @WELVAS. Right wing Conspiracy theorists are just stupid, they did big even know the votes take two weeks to count in some places. It's like the onion sketch about the conspiracy theorist who claims NASA was involved in the moon landing. Well yes, they did it. Too stupid to do the proper research. 😂😂😂😂😂
    1
  1683. 5099 men have beaten the womens hundred meters record, on that basis no woman would ever win a medal again.
    1
  1684. Dawkins is a gender critical lib Dem.
    1
  1685. But what about us allies , surely it shall lose all its alliances, if this stays.
    1
  1686. Dankula trained his dog to get excited at the mention of gassing the victims of the Holocaust. It was a strange thing to do, yes we can forgive him for that, but it was perfectly reasonable to criticize him for it, and really his friends should have criticized him, just like if I did the toilet in the town square, true friends would say I don't do it. Which is why I have never done that.
    1
  1687. Maybe the red flag flying above Berlin in 1945 above the defeated ruins of the so called master race, planted by a central Asian, in the army of what the far right called sub humans, shows racists are always wrong.
    1
  1688. One million years BC.
    1
  1689. ​ @yaoming-j6g it's not equality, biological males have advantages in women's sports from being born biological males, which biological females dont have, it's why we have women's sports.
    1
  1690. I had a dream of top gear, after watching this, this guy was not in my dream.
    1
  1691. Let's hope Russia stops fighting in Ukraine, so it can help with the west force a peace deal between the syrians.
    1
  1692. Not in the slightest, and if you can't tell what a biological l woman looks like, that's more fool you.
    1
  1693. ​ @MrRailjunkie that is unfair and toxic to say. The truth is gender critical people think we should be Nice to trans people, but acknowledge biological sex exists. It is highly toxic to call people bigots and fascist just as they don't absolutely agree with your line. It is not fascist to like Robert Winston, accept biological sex exists.
    1
  1694. Great song
    1
  1695. There is room for sensible nuances, not zealotry.
    1
  1696. Richard herring is a famous UK comedian, good on most stuff, but not on this, still a great comic though.
    1
  1697. Did you miss spell biologist.
    1
  1698. The Nazis were the worst
    1
  1699. Dankula trained his dog to get excited at the mention of the Holocaust, a strange thing to do which we can forgive him for, but dankula should not be proud of that. Just like Catherine Tate is not funny, and some modern art is crap, we can condemn dankula. S linehan did not jail dankula, a judge did, linehan has no power over the Justice system, and dankula just went to jail, as he refused to pay a fine, that could be paid off by his backers. Dankula should be forgiven, but ashamed of his rubbish act, just like a man who poos in the street should be. Linehan should be proud he stated the truth that biological sex exists, and him being cancelled is like someone being cancelled for knowing two plus two is four. ,
    1
  1700. Yes, and even more so, observed is a better word.
    1
  1701. Dawkins agrees they exists, he just thinks the word women should be for biological women. I mean we all exist, but that does not change the reality that biological sex exists.
    1
  1702. ​​​​​​​ @mrvenom88 but surely every death is a tragedy, we should not be excusing horrible events on the altar of ultra individualusm. For a group who claims trans people are marginalized, and go on about suicides, and all that, your side seem as callous as the Russian guy in Rocky, but it is a very aggressive macho unpleasant movement. Which is why it lost, and good thing that it lost so massively also.
    1
  1703. ​ @mrvenom88 that is a typical toxic trans rights view. Not caring about the lives of boxers, in a way reminiscent of the baddy in the rocky movies, as what matters more is a religious style obsession of supporting gender identity over biological reality. it's why most people see self id idealogy as uncaring and unpersuasive.
    1
  1704. Is that why you are doing now.
    1
  1705. Landed, on rhe moon, i would love Ferrell and walsh to debate this. 😅 Would be great debate.
    1
  1706. That is the definition of cancelling. He has been cancelled for saying biological sex exists, like being cancelled for saying Canberra is the capital of Australia.
    1
  1707. Oh, the orwellian hate campaign against anyone who disagrees with biological males in women's sports.
    1
  1708. Are you saying trump losing the war, means he is not a man.
    1
  1709. Caspian report should do a video on the cultures of the Caspian. Or did I miss it. Wasn't a Harry potter, book Astrakhan named for there. 😊 By the great Jk Rowling. 😊😊😊😊
    1
  1710. . Why are all depictions of Neanderthals so different, some make them look like chimpanzees, and some make them look like tough looking moderns. I think they would have just looked like modern people, but different in some way, but they could have learned modern languages, and such.
    1
  1711. He won, his repostes were superb.
    1
  1712. It's called a noble protest against bureaucratic madness.
    1
  1713. It is a big let down,
    1
  1714. Working class hero, a good man.
    1
  1715. Kathy Griffin anybody
    1
  1716. Human beings are not plants, so talking of that is beside the point.
    1
  1717. The Russian army sent all its poorest, weakest people to die in the war.
    1
  1718. At looking like a red faced drunk.
    1
  1719. Jk Rowling and Dawkins abhor people bullying trans people, but in terms of the debate on trans rights, the bullying is just v gender criticals.
    1
  1720. Rowling and gold and Dawkins would abhor anybody being bullied or beaten up for being trans. But in the debate on trans rights, definitely it's just macho slogans hate, and orwellianism and gas lighting from trans activists, v effete intellectual respectful tone writing, tip toe careful language gender critical people, who always say they respect trans people and oppose bullying v them. And the Dana Rivers case, and others are indicative of the aggressive nature of extreme trans rights activists, while Dawkins sitting at a desk saying he has compassion and understanding for jan Morris, is indicative of the GC side.hebis not effete, but gc women are. Indeed most mainstream trans rights campaigners believe people should be arrested, or fired or cancelled for expressing gender critical views, believing in a policy of fear, making people scared to be gc, which gc people do not believe in vice versa.
    1
  1721. But surely we need nuance, we need to accept biological sex exists, and the whole idea of feminine is based on biological women in existence. Surely safeguarding and fairness is still required.
    1
  1722. ​​​ @lucuslopez6866 but in reality it is not at all bigoted to accept the glaring reality that biological sex exists. The only reason why we say such a status as a woman exists, is because there are biological woman and biological men. The concept did not just crop out of thin air or a 19th century thinkers political arguments. The only reason why some biological males believe they are woman is because there were biological woman in the first place for them to believe they are the same as. Even if you believe that trans women are women then you still have to acknowledge that there is such a thing that is distinct from trans women which is biological woman. Just like a rose is still a rose still as sweet still as beautiful even if it were not called a rose. Biological woman still exist distinct from trans women even if you have a terminological sleight of hand like claiming trans women are women. The whole reason we have safeguarding laws to protect women is because of the existence of biological women and the existence and urges of biological males. It is in no sense bigoted to accept that those safeguarding rules still have to exist even if you have a orwellian terminological sleight of hand like claiming trans women are women. It is not right wing or bigoted to accept the glaring reality that biological woman and biological sex exists, it is socially just and coherent to have laws that protect biological woman and understands the reality that there is such a thing as biological sex so we must protect biological woman, and the rights of biological woman, and it has also good for biological males because it's accepting the reality and accepting the truth of the world is always better than living in living in an understanding that is absolutely faulty. And by absolutely faulty I mean pretending that biological woman don't exist as a separate category from trans woman. Please do not be intolerant and do not be orwellian, please be more understanding that there are people with different beliefs to you and different understandings of how the world works. It is not bigoted to accept the glaring reality that biological women are clearly in some important and highly noticeable and identifiable and glaring and effectual sense a distinct category from trans women, indeed if we have laws we should and must accept the reality of biological women existing ❤❤❤..
    1
  1723. ​ @EmmaLaBunn We do have a society that has safeguarding rules, and rightfully so. We are a post-racial society, so rightly we do not have Asian people's toilets, black people's toilets, and white people's toilets. But we do it set the importance of biological sex gender in human relationships. Should we have toilets for women and toilets for men. We could decide that we don't but we do because of safeguarding rules. Biological sex is something with regarded as important, and no wonder when you see the statistics of threats of men towards women, but rightly we do not see your race background as important in that regards. The intelligent centrist position, is to accept biological sex exists.
    1
  1724. Like most places, but it was not a litoral statement. You don't need to defend jokes with facts. That's worse than the joke.
    1
  1725. Winston is right, the masses can rebel.
    1
  1726. I think after the unfunny racism surely.
    1
  1727. But what about the melting glaciers, and recent us hurricanes.
    1
  1728. ​​ @hayleylongster4698 which did you read, and according to experts the glacierscare melting, look at thd polar ice cap.
    1
  1729. ​ @hayleylongster4698 what about the polar ice cap.
    1
  1730. Commodo dragons are different
    1
  1731. She is a winner, don't be mean.
    1
  1732. He is obsessed with protecting women, it's the ones trying to put biological males in women's sports and safe spaces who are obsessed with trans b
    1
  1733. ​ @alexy8520 some words are censored by YouTube
    1
  1734. He has not condemned intersex people, and he has not critique androgynous people, look at some of his guests on his show, some were quite so. Not that there is anything wrong with that. And if bits are so unimportant why do gender idealogy fanatics go crazy if some Southern us state debates banning operations on them, for kids, when just related to gender identity, it's gender idealogy people who are more obsessed with this issue than gender critical people, we are not the ones campaigning for puberty blockers for kids and such.
    1
  1735. Man so true
    1
  1736. I hope people take that attitude to you,
    1
  1737. Dankulas terrible act was training his dog to get excited and happy, when mentioning the gassing of victims of the Holocaust, a very unfunny and strange act. Nothing to be proud of, and anybody who condemned him for that was within their rights. Ps I think dankula should be forgiven for his stupid act, but don't act like what he did was done heroic act, I am sure he has done good stuff for people, and made good jokes in his life, but that stupid thing he did was dumb. Not that any of us are perfect, and to be honest dankulas friends should have told him it was dumb as well. Biological sex exists whether dankula fans or extreme trans activists and far right activists accept it or not. Ps linehan never had any judicial power in Scotland so it is of no importance what he said on the matter.
    1
  1738. Why are trans activists so malicious, you never would have heard MLK say something like that's.
    1
  1739. The insults against linehan, and lack of argument from his critics, is just laughable,
    1
  1740. Less than fifty, but one of them, won a NCAA event, think how lucky that is, if it's fair. Biological women and men exist, to deny this reality is counter factual pseudo science. ,
    1
  1741. Anybody who opposes the Orwellian agenda gets personal attacks.
    1
  1742. ​ @deathmetalmusicals6759 I am not saying anything like that, it's not for me to decide the law on who uses women's toilets. Just like I would never dare criticise a woman for saying biological sex exists. But there was an attempt to cancel her and she was fired from university for her opinions. The attempt to stifle her and censor her may have failed, but only because she stood up to the oppression. As I say it is not for me to decide the law, on who uses women's toilets.
    1
  1743. ​​​ @N6TH9N John Oliver is an embarrassment on this issue, he once said puberty blockers are reversible, and did it in his typical aggressive shouting manner, when how could that even possibly be true, it makes no sense whatsoever. Once he claimed on the Stephen Colbert show that the English fourth division is a amateur league, when they are paid five times the average wage, just as he could not be bothered explaining the facts, and he is always acting like if he were a wimpy coward, when talking about himself in self depreciating ways, when he would be nowhere near where he is if that were true. For some unknown reason him and John Stewart have decided to support trans women in women's sports, and to me bring the English fourth division is amateur, for the sake of a argument, style logic to this debate. No matter how loud John Oliver shouts at the top of his voice, this year's at the end of his tether, that biological males have no advantage over biological women in sports, even though the male record is ahead of the female record in every sport I know of, it does not make it so, and injecting the biological males with chemicals to make them specifically weaker, at a specific rate to make them just less muscular enough to compete with less muscular women, I mean that's just like using drugs to compete really. And in all honesty anyway, if you were born a biological male, you are on average for a little bit taller than if you had been born a biological female, so even from the app that you're getting the advantage of being born a biological male, so that's an unfair advantage in sport over people who had been born biological females. If you had a 6-ft man who then competed as a 6-ft woman, if he had been born a woman then on average he would have been 5 ft 8, so he has the advantage of being taller, then a 5 foot 10 woman. When is he had been born a woman he would have been shorter. And there would likely be over advantages as well. When is people are so desperate for biological males to be competing in women's sports, when there is already a biological male section to compete in, well why don't these people campaigning for that, just concentrate on some more important thing like ending wars and curing poverty. And they can leave the rest of us have biological men's sports for biological men and biological woman sports for biological woman.
    1
  1744. But the majority of Europeans are dark haired .
    1
  1745. These guys are clever, it is like the clever verson of that not the mary Whitehouse experince thing. Anyway they are clever. Good stuff.
    1
  1746. This is like something Oswald would do.
    1
  1747. Women of all races oppose this
    1
  1748. Good thinking, Stamer is great
    1
  1749. Not as funny as knock knock whose there, jokes.
    1
  1750. Even Spanish socialist party have voted out this.
    1
  1751. That bit of Glencoe, is also in HIghlander, i remember it on my journeys there.
    1
  1752. Should everyone remember in fifty years time, that you were unforgiving about Linehan. Like if you drop a cup, or fall walking up a step, say, well remember, he never forgave linehan, so we should always emphasize no pity for you. Of course not. And you have never written a beloved sitcom.
    1
  1753. If the Catholics and the protestants in Northern Ireland can forgive and forget in northern Ireland, how can't you.
    1
  1754. Just remember, next time you drop a cup, or fall walking up some steps, everybody is saying, well we have no pity for taipa, as he never forgave great sitcom writers, linehan, and taipa never wrote a great sitcom. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
    1
  1755. ​ @taipaleenmakips sorry, we have not replaced all the saints day, and national holidays, commemorating dankula, as if he is the most important person in humanity ever. And I am sorry even the leaders of Hungary and Iran and Russia forgot to have massive crowds in their capitals squares, as days of prayer apologising to dankula, and also apologies from all the eastern worlds religous leaders for not finding his poor taste so called joke funny, and do the people of Lanarkshire have to apologise as well for not voting for him, , oh yes i was being ironic there.
    1
  1756. USA defeated by Rus. A d surely Russia was the invader
    1
  1757. One billion subscribers. Though yes, people suffer worse than him, but happy he is doing so well,
    1
  1758. What a condescending trans rights activists remark, emotional perception, sounds like a word dreamt up by the university of mansplaining.
    1
  1759. ​ @KillaG3590 are you gaslighting, you do know there were no trans athletes in sports of a gender they were not born as till the Tokyo games, 2020, and then there was just one, and there was a lot of shocked comments. this is a radical new thing, that most people in most countries are quite opposed to. Even in the USA and UK, even Canada.
    1
  1760. ​ @KillaG3590 biological males unfairly winning women's sporting events,which is a unfair thing. The whole reason for women's sports,bis so biological women have sports.
    1
  1761. Although its sad to admit this, i think the most attractive ancient images of women, are these minoan ones, plus some from i think its indonesian, Cambodian or Indian temples, its like they were done by 1990s lads mags computer designers, to attract young men, most ancient images are just more sedate, which is also great and respectful . Not that there is anything wrong with the people who made the very attractive ones, well done them. Its all human experience, and a major part of our story.
    1
  1762. But is t being born biological male, a unfair advantage, when competing in women's sports.
    1
  1763. Seinfeld is the best
    1
  1764. Oooooooooh
    1
  1765. Fascinating fact.
    1
  1766. ​ @sarbantz nobody has mis gendered Brooke, she is a wonderful soul I agree, for standing up to this orwellian idealogy, but everybody knows Brooke is a biological woman, so nobody has mis gendered her, though I agree she is amazing, if that is what you are saying.
    1
  1767. ​ @sarbantz Brooke and those who support her, are amazing souls, for standing up to this Orwellian command.
    1
  1768. Or just not have biological males in women's sport.
    1
  1769. I hope Russia stops fighting in Ukraine, and allies with the west in creating a peace deal here, between Syrian minorities and the majority.
    1
  1770. What is a misgender,...............
    1
  1771. Is it's so unimportant, don't talk about it then.
    1
  1772. The only people who dislike linehan, are people who don't like him for saying biological males should not necessarily be using women's toilets, I am sorry if you have a problem about him, but he is perfectly entitled to say that only women should be using women's toilets, maybe you disagree, but I think he is right to defend his position. Yes some people are annoyed with him for that, but it's a process, and most decent good law abiding British people feel he is right.
    1
  1773. And they slag off all prior presidents. During the meet.
    1
  1774. Why can't trans women play.on men's teams then.
    1
  1775. Would you respect him more if he was a pal of Epstein.
    1
  1776. I like water, 💦
    1
  1777. Surely if would have been braver to say trump lost the election.
    1
  1778. Good point
    1
  1779. But biological males are on average stronger, which is why the nets are lower for women'.
    1
  1780. ♥️🇬🇧🇪🇺In most situations we don't need to bother either way, and we absolutely should accept trans people in those situations in inclusive nice ways, but in some like women's safe spaces, and women's sports, it is unfair and has dangers to not acknowledge biological sex exists. Dawkins is also someone criticized for saying biological sex exists, but was friends with Jan Morris before most of his ignorant haters were born, he does NOT hate trans people, he has a intelligent nuanced view on the issue, supporting tolerance, within the confines, of accepting biological sex exists, not a puritan idealogical zealotry, of putting trans rights extremism above every human experience. The overbearing bullying arrogant aggressive mansplaining impervious macho nature of most extreme trans rights activists is indicative of sex differences, and why we need some recognition in laws and safeguarding that biological women exist, it's just glaring reality. Like me I can tell which people are men and which are women, evolution made that useful adaption for us. Love to all, ❤❤ we should oppose bullying of trans people, but it is ok to sensible nuanced laws which accept sex exists.
    1
  1781. ​ @SalettaRocks Well that's mighty fine to know, then we are in agreement.
    1
  1782. That's the country north of the Gulf of Mexico.
    1
  1783. Most men would hate living in a men's only world, it would be a distopian nightmare.
    1
  1784. Biological males are taller and stronger and tougher, of course that is a advantage, and I love women's sports.
    1
  1785. It's just a word
    1
  1786. Totally agree, can still identify as a woman, it don't affect gender.
    1