Comments by "Brad Williams" (@samsabastian5560) on "Ned Kelly - Under Suspicion - Extra History - Part 2" video.

  1. Crowe Man you have no idea have you Crowe. There were no squatters in the Greta during the Kelly outbreak. The police were not corrupt as the Royal Commission found. The only people that were trodden on was Kelly's victims who he abused terribly. Kelly complained about the police who were rightly investigating his stealing of 280 horses.
    3
  2. Super Lets look at the facts. Ned Kelly was found a job by a police sergeant and that sergeant gave him money to get home and go to the job. Ned Kelly did not take up the job, did not pay the money back as he promised, then he turned to a life as a criminal.
    2
  3.  @anarcopablo  Ned Kelly never suffered under the Victoria government or Victoria Police. BUT Kelly's victims suffered from the brutal way they treated them, after stealing the only horse they had.
    2
  4.  @anarcopablo  What I am talking about, is the TRUTH. If you claim the justice system was improper, show us some evidence? In all my comprehensive reading of court records, the Kelly's were let off numerous times, when their relatives gave perjured evidence to get them off. Courts were mostly manned by JP's. Decent men who followed the rule of law 100% of the time. You could not find one instance of a court acting improperly, and I challenge you to find one instance. The Royal Commission into Victoria Police, in 1881, found that the police acted properly regarding Ned Kelly's massive criminal network. Arrested as a teenager for a crime he didn't commit? What the hell are you talking about? He was properly convicted, usually by a jury of 12 men from his area. Present your evidence, Pablo, but you won't come back as you are talking fiction, myths and lies. If you think that what is presented in this video is factual, you have been conned big time.
    2
  5. @Andrew Gray You haven't got a clue what you are talking about. Fictional nonsense.
    2
  6. Lachlan There are no facts in this video at all.
    1
  7.  @jlord9638  Please have another go and write in English next time.
    1
  8. Arrow. So please tell us how the system was stacked against him. He stole more than 280 horses, mainly from poor settlers. Kelly was never pushed as you claim.
    1
  9. b4rbaric Nothing in this video is factual. It's all a load of garbage.
    1
  10. dzanfox Yes, by stealing all the horses he could in the dead of night from poor settlers.
    1
  11. Karoake Koala No research was done to present this fictitious nonsense. Its all made up rubbish.
    1
  12. Babita The only thing Ned Kelly fought against was the police who were trying to bring his criminality under control. There was no class struggle. That is made up BS.
    1
  13. SaintOf TheEarth. So I gather you are referring to the massive lies that Ned Kelly told to justify his extensive criminality?
    1
  14. Noah Wick You must realise that what is in this video is total and complete fiction.
    1
  15. Elucidator Except the TRUE story regarding Ned Kelly reveals that the police were doing the right thing in protecting their communities from the thieving mongrel that Ned Kelly was. Your understanding of Kelly is way out of line with the facts.
    1
  16. Razatron Idiots Are you talking about the Victoria government that granted land to poor settlers on excellent terms, allowing the vast majority of people who took up the land to make a good living without stealing like the Kelly's did?
    1
  17.  @therealjuralumin3416  Ned Kelly is no legend. Only ignorant people consider him a legend. He was in fact a very serious criminal who stole from his poor neighbours, robbed banks, held hostages, murdered police and was a stand over thug. His story is soon be be removed from all schools in Australia.
    1
  18.  @cubiusblockus3973  So where was the injustice to Kelly? There was NONE in fact. Kelly objected to the police who were quite properly trying to rid the community of this thief, hostage taker, bank robber, stand over thug and murderer. the Royal Commission into Victoria police found that the police acted properly regarding Kelly and his family. So again I ask where were the injustices that you refer to?
    1
  19.  @fallowsword  He was a scourge on the entire colony of both Victoria and NSW. The residents were relieved when he was finally captured.
    1
  20.  @gianniskaranikolas3948  Present your evidence of inequality?
    1
  21.  @igneousmoon  He had NO impact and the public were glad to see him gone.
    1
  22.  @doumahamigahila8133  Famous, NO. Known, yes.
    1
  23. Anne Keener Ned Kelly lived the good life as a result of his massive stock stealing enterprise.
    1
  24. Ashleigh Bashleigh HISTORY? If you think this presentation is real, you need a brain transplant.
    1
  25. VoxlKnight Corrupt you say? WHERE? The Royal Commission did not find any corruption. So if you claim there was corruption, show us what you have got?
    1
  26. Hewlp! Only to ignorant babboons.
    1
  27.  @GallowglassAxe  Ned Kelly was found a good job by the police and a police sergeant gave him money to get home and to take up the job. He did not pay the money back as he promised and did not take up the job and turned to crime.
    1
  28.  @lazyc0mmander277  Like hell they were. What is presented here is fiction from top to bottom.
    1
  29.  @lazyc0mmander277  NO. What is presented is a load of fiction. Nothing factual at all.
    1
  30.  @extrahistory  In 1860 the Victoria government enacted The Lands Act that took the land back from the squatters. There were some problems with the legislation, but by 1869 the squatters had been defeated, and the settlers had won. Note that was well before the Kelly outbreak. Kelly mainly stole from poor settlers, as there were very few squatters left in that area.
    1
  31. Sad Starfish. If you claim the police were corrupt, show us your evidence. The Royal Commission into Vic police of 1881 found no corruption at all.
    1
  32. CMB505 and I suppose you would say that all criminals are angels?
    1
  33. Finland Ball You do understand that everything in this video is fiction don't you?
    1
  34. Mason Adams Ned Kelly certainly messed up a lot o f lives and families for that matter. When he murdered the 3 police at Stringybark Creek, 9 children were left without their fathers. Ned Kelly certainly messed up a lot of lives, didn't he?
    1
  35.  @mrhalfwit972  Research by professional historians. Newspapers and court records.
    1
  36.  @CommittingSudoku  Your statement is not true. As a teenager, Ned Kelly was charged with robbery under arms. The police gave him money and found him a good job, which he rejected and turned to a criminal life. He had opportunity to reform, which he discarded.
    1
  37. Elegant Pardon me? What about the 280 victims he stole horses from? They are the ones that deserve better, than having to deal with this vindictive, vicious criminal.
    1
  38. weofparadigm WRONG on all counts.
    1
  39. SauceJedi The law was very fair in Victoria. Kelly had many opportunity to turn his life around, and he rejected those opportunities.
    1
  40. rogueshpaladin Ned Kelly was born in Australia and always claimed to be Australian. Police found Ned Kelly a good job when he was 15, but he rejected that job and turned to crime of his own volition. Ned Kelly was never desperate for money, in view of his extensive thieving.
    1
  41. Gremlech Very True. Nothing in this video is true.
    1
  42. vincedelicious Why would you be. It's a load of garbage.
    1
  43. Ballistic Boxer. Tell us why you would respect a man who murdered 3 police officers in cold blood? A man that held up banks and stole the savings of poor settlers. A man who took hostages, men, women and children at gunpoint and threatened them with death. A man who robbed poor settlers of the only work horses they had, effectively sending them bankrupt. Are you a lunatic?
    1
  44. Munch Kin You have been led up the garden path if you claim there were difficulties in Australia. Most people lived quite well on their selections, which were granted to them by a responsive government. Ned Kelly lived the high life, taking a large number of horses from poor settlers.
    1
  45. Max Murphy What a disgrace you are.
    1
  46. Just another gutless Kelly fan, who thrives on BS.
    1
  47. Flavio Chavez Only to the ignorant.
    1
  48. bananian The police paid proper attention to Ned Kelly's criminal enterprise. After all he bragged that he had stolen at least 280 horses.
    1
  49. commandervulkkan Go and see a psychiatrist, you sure need one.
    1
  50. InmdiekidDrugPatrol Murderers do not quality as legends.
    1
  51. Dominic Tee what you have heard and seen here is fiction through and through. Kelly was a serious murdering criminal.
    1
  52. Qardo What a load of fictitious rubbish. In 1860 the government enacted The Lands Act in Victoria that took back all the land from squatters. By 1869 the poor settlers won that battle. You have no idea what you are talking about.
    1
  53. Ilkka Rauitio You mean the system that gave poor settlers land grants on excellent terms?
    1
  54. Classic T.J. Harsh? Very harsh for Ned Kelly's victims. That is for sure.
    1
  55. Reece Red Kelly stole two pigs in Ireland. He took them straight back to market and sold them for money.
    1
  56. Extra Credits. You obviously don't know that there were no squatters left in the Greta, Moyhu, Benalla when Ned Kelly was at the height of his criminal actions in stealing horses. Most of the horses he stole was from poor settlers. You people are a disgrace, and you sure need a lesson in telling the truth.
    1
  57. Zappyguy National legend? Are you completely mad?
    1
  58.  @KuraIthys  You haven't got a clue have you. Ned Kelly was no Robin Hood. He kept all he thieved from the poor and did not even give his mother one penny to get her out of gaol. His sisters lived in poverty all their lives. Kelly was just a very serious murderous criminal.
    1
  59.  @TildaM1994  Ned Kelly is only liked by morons who haven't got enough brains to recognise he was a serious criminal.
    1
  60.  @tangent272  The police were well respected as the Royal Commission found.
    1
  61.  @LunaS043  What a load of rubbish you are talking. Ned Kelly never tried to make an honest living. He was just a serious criminal from a criminal family. There were no wealthy squatters as you claim left in the Greta area when Kelly was stealing horses. His victims were poor settlers. After thieving their only horse, he and his Greta Mob would stand over them and threaten more damage if they had the audacity to report the theft to the police. You have got the story upside down, Dustin.
    1
  62.  @KuraIthys  Ned Kelly NEVER gave one penny to the poor, and he gave nothing to his mother or his sisters when they were dressed in rags. Your understanding of this vicious stand-over-thug and murderous criminal is abysmal.
    1
  63.  @poshboy4749  If you claim the legal system was flawed and corrupt, let's see some evidence. He often robbed the only horse poor settlers had, sending them bankrupt. He didn't care who he robbed from. By the way, there were no squatters left in the Greta region when Kelly was at the height of his horse stealing empire.
    1
  64.  @tangent272  The Royal Commission DID consider the police at the time and found they acted properly regarding Kelly's criminality.
    1
  65.  @tangent272  You haven't got a clue, have you? You have no idea of the facts regarding Kelly.
    1
  66.  @LunaS043  Your understanding of the history of this country is woeful. Ned Kelly was found a job by a police sergeant, and he gave him money to go home and to take up the job. Kelly rejected the job and failed to pay back the money and of his own volition took up a life of crime. What you have stated is a load of fiction.
    1
  67.  @troglodyte4207  Nice to his hostages, was he? Except for the one he shot in the eye and refused him medical attention, and George Metcalf died 2 months later. Nice to the man who challenged him at Faithful Creek Station, when he put the barrel of his revolver into his mouth and threatened to shoot him dead. Nice to the police officer's wife at Jerilderie, when he threatened to shoot dead her three children and then her. Your understanding of Kelly is abysmal. Where are you getting this fictional nonsense from?
    1
  68.  @beriasims1869  The statements taken by police from the hostages, that are still in police custody.
    1
  69.  @coolsceegaming6178  You haven't got a clue, have you? Read the Kelly Gang Unmasked by Ian MacFarlane. You might learn something.
    1
  70.  @coolsceegaming6178  Only 280 horses? That is the number he admitted to. There were probably many more that he did not disclose.
    1
  71.  @Resolance  My information comes from researching records made at the time. Numerous sources, including police records, court records, newspapers, and a myriad of other sources. Also, from books and other research papers written by professional historians, including Dr. Doug Morrissey PhD, and Dr. Stuart Dawson, PhD. Everything I say can be proven by direct evidence. This video follows fiction written by Kelly fans, who dreamt up most of the story. Be informed that ALL government departments, state and federal, are removing Kelly myths from their documentation right now. The Ned Kelly Touring Route, controlled by 7 councils, have already removed most of their myths, with much more work to be done to remove them all. This has occurred as the result of me proving to these government departments that their material is full of myths, lies and fiction. My knowledge is very wide indeed, and I say again, everything I have stated can be proved. Not one thing in this video is factual and could not be proved if they were asked to prove it.
    1
  72. funisfun Keep what up? The myths that is promoted in this video. Not a fact anywhere to be seen.
    1
  73. Riley Graham What is presented here is not history. It's a load of made up rubbish.
    1
  74. Saffana Siddique The Kelly's had plenty of choice. The majority in that area were good, decent Christians who worked hard and despised the Kelly's because of their criminal activities.
    1
  75.  @geneirai  Ned Kelly mostly stole horses from poor settlers, some of them Irish. There were so Squatters left in the Greta area during Kelly's activity with horse stealing. He boasted that he had stolen at least 280 horses.
    1
  76. Drecon84 Where did you dream up that fiction. Ned Kelly with his thieving of poor settlers horses lived the high life.
    1