Comments by "Surojeet Chatterjee" (@surojeetchatterjee) on "Anatomy of India’s ALH u0026 changing global dynamics of helicopters" video.

@orkkojit We don't have good Indian mechanical engineers in US UK EU as well, those r all average lot. Also we don't have great electronics engineers. Bcs there is no R&D system in IITs for these 2. Our Mechanical engineers r also working in Information technology in US. 🤷‍♂️🤣 I accept sarkari baboo r pathetic, but we don't have mechanical excellence due to communism & destruction of manufacturing industry & conglomerate building with license raaj from 1970s era.
3
One is 40 years old & other is same quality Russian helicopter just like HAL Dhruv. India lacks good mechanical engineers due to lack of opportunity & lack of industrial culture.
2
@orkkojit Sundar Pichai has a metallurgic engineering degree from IIT Kharagpur. But is CEO in US of an Information technology company of search engine called Google. 🤷‍♂️🤣 That's India & Indian engineers for u. 🤦‍♂️
2
@GhostRillley U need to import certain things where u don't have options & haven't build ur capacity. Its always a mix bag option not one way street. How u will plan ur import & maintain inventory with less complications is upto ur management skills.
2
@GhostRillley Ukraine is most poor corrupted & mismanaged country in Europe. But had enmity with Russia. 🤷‍♂️🤣 Ukraine has caused Russia huge damage being such a pathetic mismanaged & bogus country, just by using those imported or free weapons from NATO countries. 🤷‍♂️ 🥴 Without those tactical weapons like Turkish drones & Himars from US, it would have been piece of cake for Russia. Russia came back strongly after using Iranian kamekaze drones. Meanwhile Israel is being neutral not supplying weapons to Ukraine. Otherwise situation would have been more bad for Russia.
1
@GhostRillley U don't know how modern warfare is evolving. OFB India is still living in WW2 era regarding weapons. 🤣 India doesn't have it's high quality Rifle ammunitions, sniper ammo, rockets launchers ammo, mortar shell & cannon shell, Grenade, ATGMs & Manpads production line.These r the first requirement for self reliance in defense. Then comes other things like Suicide drones, different towed & truck mounted artillery. Multiple MBRL systems, different weight categories of Tanks, the SAM systems,
1
@GhostRillley India OFB had quality & supplied in both the world war. But couldn't keep up the quality after independence due to rogue system, zero research & labour union, particularly become pathetic after late 70s. 🤣 Dhruv is an Utility helicopter but HAL wants to make it a attack helicopter is hilarious. This shows the incompetence that they can't design an attack helicopter after working on Hind Mi35, Mi28 & Seaking helos as maintenance. 🤷‍♂️🤣 can't ever reverse engineer like China. 🤷‍♂️🤣
1
@GhostRillley 75 years is too long time for a giant country like India produce 1 helicopter in every 15 days. Learn to make parts & components first, fuselage making is childs play in this era. Main thing is inside components & mechanism & electronics. If u import cheap Russian parts or makeshift parts of other helicopters, then Dhrub will be ditched on sea. First Learn to make, not assemble things by importing parts. 🤷‍♂️🤦‍♂️🥴🤣
1
@GhostRillley DRDO is a research org not a production line. 🤣 Rest ur Solar industry documents got hacked, these clowns r making ur national security products who started as a dynamite producer in mineral mines. 🤣 just look at China & US & EU what they r capable of. A small country Israel has more productivity than Indian defense companies, even Iran made kamekaze drones doing reverse engineering. 🤣🥴🤦‍♂️ Indian companies r still busy signing contracts & paper works. 🤣 only big talk end result babaji ka thullu. 1.3 billion ppls country but run by jokers for 75 years. Still conglomerate non specialised jokers thriving in industry sector with jack of all trade master of none moto. 🤣 Vegetables sellers can't become defense contractors. Bhujiya sellers can't open hospital. There is something called specialisation. But India lives in another alternative reality. 🤦‍♂️🥴
1
@GhostRillley Even helicopter rocket ammo comes from thales. Can't even make, can't even make diesel engine for naval ships, had to import from Ukraine & GE. 🤦‍♂️🤣
1
@Learningram That I have already mentioned, can't u read? still even with opportunity information technology sector in India, indian engineers r doing foreign companies coolie job instead of innovating Indian apps & games development. Point is both govt, system industry & engineers mentality is in misplaced place, whole country thinks in parallel universe way 🤣, when engineers mentality becomes clerks that country can't build industry. Engineers should be the ppls who will build industry, not businessman conglomerates who r well known good for nothing craps. That's why Indias good & Merchandise sector is in trade deficit for last 75 years.
1
@erenyaeger9407 Yes Russian help, french German British help. Our engineers haven't innovated anything, neither created big industry in different fields from 1980s. That's why India is 5 times smaller economy than China & has Goods Merchandise trade deficit for last 75 years, non stop till today.
1
@tirthachakrabarti5912 ADA is incompetent & HAL doesn't have productivity capacity. Why should we pay them salary for free ?
1
@divyanshverma2296 Drones can transport cargo very easily.
1