Comments by "Linda S Steckel" (@Linda43) on "Religious Israelis: Are Messianic Jews still Jewish?" video.

  1. Yes is the answer
    44
  2.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  If he is born Jewish, he remains a Jew. Watch and listen to the first man in the video. I have answered the second part of your post many times. If you want to be Jewish and a part of the Jewish people, then convert to Judaism with a recognized Rabbi.
    16
  3. 💙💙Shavuah Tov to all Am Yisroel wherever you are 💙💙 Chanukah Sameach "A small light can dispel a lot of darkness " Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi
    10
  4. The 10 tribes were carried away by the Assyrians and intermarried with non Jws for generations and were not considered Jews according to Jewish law but still could be welcomed back. In the time of the true Mashiach, they will return and undergo a type of conversion. The Conversos and the Bnei Menashe are examples of this return. Many live in my city
    10
  5.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  There is no contradiction. You just are unable to accept that you can't consider yourself a Jew by wishing it. Shalom Aleichem
    10
  6. 1- Jesus is not the messiah of the Jewish people. 2- A Jew will always remain a Jew because he has a pure soul that connects him to HaShem.
    6
  7. It just happened lol. Email Corey
    4
  8.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  The Southern tribes, known also as the Ten lost Tribes of Israel, were carried off by the Assyrian conquerers.
    4
  9.  @Adrian-vy5vn  Rubbish
    4
  10. If your Mother is Jewish, you are Jewish. That is Jewish law.
    3
  11.  @Centrioless  The Kaaba was a altar in pre Islamic times. The Kotel was the outer wall of the Temple.
    3
  12.  @thelastgeneration1926  Judaism is a ethnoreligon. Only Jewish law and our Rabbis decide who is Jewish. DNA is not relevant. BTW: Ashkenazi Jews have DNA closest to that of Biblical Jews. I can understand your desire to be connected to the Jewish people. We are a unique group.
    3
  13.  @perniciousseizurehellio3438  Millions of Jews have died in the name of JC through the centuries, ie Inquisition and Crusades as a example. Doesn't seem that tranquil at all
    3
  14. Most religious or traditional Israelis don't really make a distinction between the two ( Catholics and other Christian denominations).
    3
  15.  Temporary Account  The sacrifice of Isaac: "Avraham Avenu settled in Beer Sheva" Beer Sheva is in land of Israel. Moshe Rabbenu is the Prophet Moses and it was he that didn't enter the land of Israel. G-d said to him to look at the land of Israel because he would not enter it.
    3
  16.  @dogbert52  A little bit of both I imagine. Massive illiteracy Massive ignorance of the Tanach
    3
  17. Most are disenfranchised youth. There are various people who are trying to help them. Their aims are pure. Sometimes their methodology is off. As Jews, we are obligated to settle the land of Israel and that is what they try to do.
    3
  18. Jews do not accept JC as the Messiah.
    3
  19.  @RudydeGroot  A interesting point but it is the halacha that I mentioned that counts.
    2
  20. We are in our ancestral homeland Israel as the G-d of Israel commanded us and more Jews are arriving. B'H
    2
  21.  @Centrioless  Jews don't worship the Kotel. We pray at the Kotel in the same way we pray at the Tomb of the Patriarchs in Hevron. It represents what is left of the Temple. It is also a national symbol of redemption and the liberation of Jerusalem from Jordanian occupation.
    2
  22.  @Centrioless  Jews pray at the Kotel because of its merit as a holy place. We pray at the Tombs of our prophets because holy people even in death have merit. That is far from idolatry. The issue with Catholicism is the presence of statues. In ancient times they were used in pagans rituals. It is called Avodah Zarah( Strange Worship).
    2
  23. Jewishness doesn't go through surnames.
    2
  24. They are not to be found in your contrived community but in the land of Israel and religious Jewish communities of the world.
    2
  25. You are Jewish if your mother is Jewish. DNA is not a factor.
    2
  26.  @thelastgeneration1926  You really have nothing to worry about dear, you aren't.
    2
  27. DNA has become another antisemitic method of delegitimizing our claim to our ancestral homeland Israel. Its a waste of time.
    2
  28.  @thelastgeneration1926  As for "hackling" you, I thought you didn't care one way or another. Apparently you do care.
    2
  29.  @thelastgeneration1926  The land of Israel only retains those truly committed to it. The rest are gently swept away. DNA has nothing to do with this.
    2
  30.  @thelastgeneration1926  The land of Israel belongs to the Jewish people. We are connected to it through our spiritual DNA which is more powerful than science.
    2
  31.  @thelastgeneration1926  I guess words fail you. Well I don't blame you. Your words were as empty as your claims of Jewish ancestry. If you are in Israel, leave. If not, stay where you are. You have no place in the homeland of the Jewish people, Israel.
    2
  32.  @thelastgeneration1926  Only Jewish law and our Rabbis decide who is Jewish. I am Jewish according to Jewish law. You are not. You are a antisemite with pretensions of Jewishness, a wannabe Jew without the soul of a Jew. Sad really.
    2
  33. I doubt your authenticity. You would have said so with pride and joy from the beginning. You are only Jewish if your mother is Jewish. DNA is not relevant. Israel is a country founded on Jewish principles The Law of Return supports the return of all Jews to Israel which is based on said Jewish law. I made Aliyah based on that law. Could you?
    2
  34.  @thelastgeneration1926  Aliyah means going up. Under the Law of Return, those Jews, who are Jewish under Jewish law, fulfill the mitzvah of the return to Zion.
    2
  35. Islam and Christianity come from Judaism. All three are monotheistic religions. The similarities between Judaism and Islam are superficial.
    2
  36.  @vijgenboom2843  And G-d bless you
    2
  37.  Jacob Ezra  Well put. Thanks for replying.
    2
  38. It was interesting
    2
  39.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  Avraham Avenu and Sara Imenu were tasked with creating a new people and spreading monotheism.
    2
  40.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  The return to Zion, the ingathering of the exiles and the reclamation of the land of Israel are all Elohims will.
    2
  41.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  The whole world knows the story of Avraham Avenu and Sara Imenu because they were the parents of all nations. However, they were also instructed by Elohim to found a new people, the Jewish people.
    2
  42.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  NT is not a Jewish document
    2
  43. Who are you to judge anyone?
    2
  44.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  A Jew remains a Jew no matter what. He has a pure soul that connects him to HaShem.
    2
  45. I would speak to a Rabbi about your Jewish ancestry and also discuss the last part of the post too. Don't be angry with your parents. They were only trying to do what they thought best for you. G-d bless and Be'Hatzlacha ( that means to be successful in your life in this case, in Hebrew).
    2
  46. There is only one law concerning Jewishness: if your mother is Jewish then you are Jewish. This also applies to women who convert to Judaism.
    1
  47.  @YehudaLion  It is Rabbinical law that governs the world Jewish community which is the majority. Only Jewish law and our Rabbis decide who is Jewish. You are Jewish if your mother is Jewish. If your father is Jewish, you can claim Jewish ancestry but you still aren't Jewish according to Jewish law. Kararite Jews are not Jewish. Samaritans are considered a branch of Judaism but still must convert in order to be considered Jewish under Jewish law.
    1
  48.  @thedolsez3200  Great. I think I know what they will say though lol
    1
  49.  @snowcrow1178  The return to Zion, the ingathering of the exiles, and the reclamation of the land of Israel are all G-ds will. Zionism is Jewish national self determination in our ancestral homeland. The first example of Zionism was the Exodus from Egypt.
    1
  50.  @Adrian-vy5vn  What does Jewish tradition matter to you? Go wait for the Second Coming. It will be "coming" to a store near you.
    1
  51. Shalom from Judea and Samaria- the heartland of the nation state of the Jewish people, Israel.
    1
  52. @Jacob Portman According to the Jewish tradition, Bnei Ishmael was given a different inheritance.Ishmael and his mother lived in the wilderness of Paran where he supported himself through thievery. His destiny was not to inhabit the land of Israel.
    1
  53. @ Jacob Portman: The story of Ishmael is found in the first book of the Torah. If you can't find it. I will help. Why did you change the order of your posts?
    1
  54. @Jacob Portman The story of Jacob also starts in the first book of the Torah.
    1
  55. @ Jacob Portman: The children of Avraham Avenu were Ishmael and Isaac from Hagar and Sara. After Sara's death, Avraham Avenu married again and had other children. He also sent them away as they were not the inheritors either( Ishmael)
    1
  56. @Jacob Portman The Tanach includes the Torah and other books. You are ignorant.
    1
  57. Elohim gave the land of Israel to the descendants of Isaac.
    1
  58. @Jacob Portman No more games. The history of Israel is found in the Torah. You are obviously unfamiliar with the Torah. I suggest you start reading
    1
  59. @Jacob Portman If you are so familiar then look up these verse yourself. I don't think you can.
    1
  60. Avraham Avenu was to be a father of all nations. However, Avraham Avenu was also tasked with the creation of a new people, the Jewish people. The inheritor was Isaac. That is why Ishmael was sent away. He was hostile to his brother and demanded a double inheritance.
    1
  61. @Jacob Portman Yes. Cherry picking from the Torah is unhelpful. You should read the whole chapter.
    1
  62.  Shani Isreal  Inserting yourself into a conversation so is rude.
    1
  63. @Jacob Portman Not when you read it in Hebrew.
    1
  64. @Jacob Portman The simple meaning does not change and it must be read in context, not picked through to suit a argument or a opinion. There are ways to study the Torah properly.
    1
  65. Jacob Portman has left the building. 😁
    1
  66.  @urvanhroboatos8044  The Catholic church needs a complete overhaul. Lol.
    1
  67.  @urvanhroboatos8044  Poor me? What do I care about Popes and Cardinals or the history of the Catholic church.
    1
  68.  @urvanhroboatos8044  Again I don't care about it.
    1
  69.  @helloitsnate7890  She isn't primitive. Most Orthodox Jews don't recognize the different branches of Judaism( Conservative, etc) much less accept them. In Israel the use of the word primitive is very offensive.
    1
  70. Only Jewish law and our Rabbis decide who is Jewish.
    1
  71. It is his laws that we are carrying out and one of those laws is you are Jewish through your mother.
    1
  72.  @dogbert52  Yes. The community of Hebrew Israelites 🙄
    1
  73. You don't recognize Rabbinical authority as you are not Jewish. So it would be useless to point out anything to you. The World Jewish community recognizes Rabbinical authority and its accepts it authority. Pretending to be Jewish is just that pretending.
    1
  74.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  Our Rabbinim are emissaries of Elohim. He has given them the wisdom to advise and decide.
    1
  75.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  It hardly matter what you think as you have no real understanding of Judaism.
    1
  76.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  Again, the Rabbis are the emissaries of Elohim and the interpreters of the Torah and its laws. It has been this way since the Sages of Israel. You can misinterpret as you like but eventually you will see your errors
    1
  77.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  They don't have to be in order to be Rabbis. Levites and Cohenim served in the Temple.
    1
  78.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  Do you own research then. Start by reading a book like The History of the Jews by Martin Gilbert. Then run your mouth.
    1
  79.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  Then stay ignorant.
    1
  80. @ Zechariah Yudah Israel: In the Torah, it is written that Judah married the daughter of a certain Caananite. Not that she was a Caananite. The word Caananite being a appellation for a merchant.
    1
  81. Rabbi Schneerson represented a very specific group of" Hasidic Jews" and not all of Orthodox Jews. Not a particularly good example.
    1
  82.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  In the Jewish tradition, Ruth was the first convert and therefore, her descendants are Jews.
    1
  83.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  Not so. Converts to Judaism are considered Jews in every way. As a matter of fact, it is a sin to remind them of their past. So precious are they, that their feelings are protected.
    1
  84.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  In the Jewish tradition, Jesus is not the Messiah.
    1
  85.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  Ruth's conversion was based on her willingness to follow the customs of her mother in law. This happened before Rabbinical law. Now the process is more formal.
    1
  86.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  You are Jewish if your mother is Jewish( whether she was born Jewish or converted to Judaism). It cannot be any clearer. Ruth adopted the customs of her Jewish mother in law. In that time period, that was enough.
    1
  87.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  You are chasing your tail instead of reading the posts. Educate yourself with actual books, not your own thoughts
    1
  88.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  Not in the Jewish tradition, read the Book of Ruth which is found in the Tanach
    1
  89. Don't confuse your contrived religious beliefs with authentic Judaism.
    1
  90.  @thelastgeneration1926  There are hundreds of antisemitic channels on yt. Yours is just one more, useless and irrelevant.
    1
  91.  @thelastgeneration1926  Judaism is the basis of Islam and Christianity. Moses received the Torah from Sinai and passed it on to Joshua. Joshua to the Elders, the Elders to the Prophets, the Prophets to the Men of the Great Assembly and they have passed down to the Sages and then to the Rabbis.
    1
  92.  @thelastgeneration1926  I have seen your channel. Please continue on that way. You are your own worst advertisement. BTW: JC is not mentioned in the Tanach
    1
  93. You can only be Jewish according to Jewish law if your mother is a Jew, whether she was born Jewish or converted
    1
  94.  Starhopper  If your mother converts to Judaism, then you are Jewish.. I revised my post Better.
    1
  95.  @vijgenboom2843  You might want to read about him on the website My Jewish Learning
    1
  96.  @vijgenboom2843  The world Jewish community goes according to Rabbinical authority. You are only Jewish if your mother is Jewish.
    1
  97. Interesting. Email Corey
    1
  98.  @Adrian-vy5vn  You are Jewish if your mother is Jewish or a convent to Judaism.
    1
  99.  @thelastgeneration1926  Judaism is a ethnoreligon. That is how the Jewish world describes itself.
    1
  100. If your mother is Jewish then you are Jewish
    1
  101. The true Mashiach is here. The Jewish people are returning from their final exile( Rome) to the land of Israel. The future is clear and can't be judged by mans puny knowledge and understanding which is reflected in your posts.
    1
  102.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  That is the difference between reading the Torah in Hebrew and reading it in English.
    1
  103.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  In the Jewish tradition, he is a ordinary person.
    1
  104.  @vitoria3658  A Jew remains a Jew no matter what. The road back might be hard though
    1
  105.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  These are the sons of Noah. They came before Ishmael.
    1
  106.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  The Book of Genesis is the first book of the Torah.
    1
  107.  @zechariahyudahisrael9695  The sons of Noah were the beginning of the civilization of mankind ie: how they were distributed on the earth. Color is not the issue.
    1
  108.  @machinegun2282  You need to improve your reading comp
    1
  109.  Temporary Account  Avraham Avenu entered the land of Israel when he bought the Tomb of the Patriarchs from the Hittites after Sara Imenus death. All the Patriarchs and Matriarchs, except for Rachel Imenu, are buried there. According to the Jewish tradition, Adam and Eve are also buried there. You are thinking of Moshe Rabbenu.
    1
  110.  @GigiAbbi-cu9qn  🙄
    1
  111. Only Jewish law and our Rabbis decide who is Jewish. Jewishness is passed through the mother, even if she is a convert. How do we feel? We don't worry.
    1
  112. A Jew always remains a Jew in Jewish law
    1
  113. A Jew remains a Jew but the practice of another religion distances him from his people Israel.
    1
  114. Judaism is a ethnoreligon
    1
  115.  @Whatever4867  Avraham Avenu was the father of all nations. He was the first Jew according to the Jewish tradition.
    1
  116.  @sog777-z8m  Judaism is the religion from which Christianity and Islam evolved. Each has its own distinct characteristics. Vive Le' Difference
    1