GilbertdeClare0704
Mansur Ashkar
comments
Comments by "GilbertdeClare0704" (@GilbertdeClare0704) on "Germany's Shocking Crisis: Syrian Refugee I Rescued from ISIS Speaks Out @doogri.podcast" video.
17
13
11
6
5
3
@thebottles3153 Could you provide a Source reference for that "Fact" my friend ?
According to Turkish and British sources, from 1190AD right up until 1918, 720 YEARS, this area was known by the ISLAMIST Occupiers as these THREE SANJAKS, of JERUSALEM, - TRIPOLIS, - ANTIOCHI ! NEVER "palst.."
And the common Arabic name for this region was always "Yahuda wa - Samara", not "palest"
The Bedou or Arabs you refer to were also known by the Turks as Arabia or Bedou, as THAT is how they referred to themselves. NEVER with the "palest" prefix, until the 1918 peace negotiations with the BRITISH, who used the term of their League Of Nations MANDATE
Refs. Balfour Declaration. McMahon Letters, Lord Peel's Commission, Ottoman submission re the Vilayets to the Brest-Litovsk Peace Treaty, signed on 3 March 1918
3
@MrSachback Many thanks for your reply. It has deeply saddened me to actually have seen what you describe when I've visited my friends in London, and another up in Blackburn. I once saw that same "active seeking out" with my own eyes when we were just walking past a Saturday "gathering" and my friend hadn't even said anything, just turned away from them, and three of them came after us to give him a load of aggressive crap, which nearly got nasty. It was scary but also SO deeply sad that my friend M has remained anxious for his own safety now, where he HAD once felt safe. When I was younger, I DID have that western attitude that everyone could or would integrate etc, it saddens me that I have grown up and no longer believe that naiive, idealistic, yet disconnected from reality "rose tinted glasses" view.
Thank you for your videos, they are excellent, especially your fatherhood ones😊
2
2
@andreskorge1828 Again, my friend, and this is in good faith, check out what Zuheir Mohsen, a senior member of the pLO said about the very term "Palest"
In his March 1977 interview with Dutch newspaper Trouw, only a few years after Arafat re-adopted the British Mandate descriptive name of “Pal*stine”, Zuheir Mohsen a senior member of the Pal*stine Liberation Organization, declared, "There's no such thing as a separate Palestinian people, there's no difference between Jordanians, Palest**ians, Syrians, Lebanese... the Palest**ian identity exists only for tactical reasons. The creation of a Palest**ian state is a NEW instrument in our ongoing war against the state of Israel and for the purpose of our Arab unity".
Ismael Yaniyeh repeated this as recently as 2023
The KGB had created this "Palest" identity in 1964 through Yasser Arafat, as the Soviet Union was supplying AND advising the p.LO and PfLP
Before 1964, NO Arabs even called themselves Palest**ian because the Holy Land was known by Arabs as Yahuda wa Samara
If you genuinely DO endeavour for Truth, please read widely on this and cross check anything I've said. There is also a website that YT won't let me name, but if you search for "Arabs On Ham***s" you can find endless quotes from the FOUNDERS of those organisations, that confirm all that Mansur Ashkar is saying
2
1
1
@andreskorge1828 OK, my friend, I will take you at your word, that you DO believe in Truth, Justice, and Human Rights.
Your FIRST outright LIE was suggesting "Palest was invaded". It was NOT. Judea and Samaria were invaded by successive Islamist Armies from 638ad onwards, culminating in the Ottoman Islamist armies invading and Colonising the area for over 720 years.
When the Ottoman Empire collapsed with the defeat of Turkey, the INTERNATIONAL League of Nations DELEGATED RESPONSIBILITY, i.e. MANDATED that area of the Levant for RETURN to its rightful OWNERS, the INDIGENOUS PEOPLE.
Ever since the Balfour Declaration, THE INTERNATIONAL LEAGUE OF NATIONS were officially recognising a PRE existing RIGHT, and NOT creating a NEW right, as in the very ACT of formulating Legally Binding Instruments, there WAS a recognition of the cultural historic roots of the J*wish People in that land. It was MORE than just a legal decision, it was BASED in the cultural heritage of the J*wish People.
Within the Articles of the Palestinian Mandate, was Article 2 which is the EXPRESS duty to “safeguard” the rights of all “Non J*wish communities”.
Today, ISRAEL is the ONLY Nation state in that area that IS fully democratic with FULL rights for ALL people, Women's rights, LGBT Rights etc NOT ONE SINGLE Arab country can claim that !
Your LIE = "Palest" was NEVER invaded as "Palest" only existed as a DESCRIPTIVE Term of the MANDATE for only 28 years. NEVER a Nation or Country
1
@thebottles3153 My total respect to you sir, and I apologise if I was in any way strident. I really do, deeply respect you for your openness.
That Pan Arab Nationalist Movement was known as "The Arab Club", later "The Higher Arab Committee", NEVER "Palest....". If you read the minutes of San Remo Conference and later, Lord Peel's meetings with their Leader Amin Al Husseini, the Arabs REFUSED to use the word "Palest..." as they saw it as a Zionist term !
Also enlightening to check out where Husseini got his inspirations from and WHERE he spent WW2 ?
Other than that, what you say tallies with documentation I have ever read, that the HUNDREDS of thousands of Arabs from Egypt, Syria. Lebanon ONLY started coming to Israel between 1930 and 1947 to work for the British, but also having SEEN what the returning Jews (purged BY them from Arab countries) were beginning to achieve regards using modern agricultural and Irrigation techniques. Appearing to magically “make the desert bloom” (Authors like John Steinbeck, Mark Twain had all visited the area and described it as an “undeveloped desert hell hole”.
The area had almost zero tillable land prior to the arrival of the Zionists in the late 1800s. Turks and the very few Arab villagers had clearcut the trees to make charcoal for fires—-which they had been doing this since 700 AD and the Muslim invasions.
This clearcutting meant that the soils were not anchored, and they were washed down the hills during the rainy seasons—-leaving infertile and desolate lands and malarial swamps, that the early Zionists could only recover with many years of back-breaking labour—-J*w*sh farmers labour. They did not hire any other people for that task.
Approx HALF the population of Gaza only came there during those British Mandate times.
1