Comments by "Marc Joly" (@emjizone) on "The Russian Dude" channel.

  1. 92
  2. 90
  3. 84
  4. 61
  5. 23
  6. 22
  7. 21
  8. 19
  9. 18
  10. 18
  11. 18
  12. 17
  13. 16
  14. 15
  15. 14
  16. 13
  17. 12
  18. 11
  19. 10
  20. 9
  21. 8
  22. 7
  23. 7
  24. 6
  25. 6
  26. 5
  27. 5
  28. 5
  29. 5
  30. 5
  31. 5
  32. 4
  33. 4
  34. 4
  35. 4
  36. 4
  37. 4
  38. 3
  39. 3
  40. 3
  41. 3
  42. 3
  43. 3
  44. 3
  45. 3
  46. 3
  47. 3
  48. 3
  49. 3
  50. 3
  51. 3
  52. 3
  53. 3
  54. 3
  55. 3
  56. 3
  57. 2
  58. 2
  59. 2
  60. 2
  61. 2
  62. 2
  63. 2
  64. 2
  65. 2
  66. 2
  67. 2
  68. 2
  69. 2
  70. 2
  71. 2
  72. 2
  73. 2
  74. 2
  75. 2
  76. 2
  77. 2
  78. 2
  79. 2
  80. 2
  81. 2
  82. 2
  83. 2
  84. 2
  85. 2
  86. 2
  87. 2
  88. 2
  89. 2
  90. 2
  91. 2
  92. 2
  93. 2
  94. 2
  95. 2
  96. 2
  97. 2
  98. 2
  99. 2
  100. 2
  101. 2
  102. 2
  103. 2
  104. 2
  105. 2
  106. 2
  107. 2
  108. 2
  109. 2
  110. 2
  111. 2
  112. 2
  113. 2
  114. 2
  115. 2
  116. 2
  117. 2
  118. 2
  119. 2
  120. 2
  121. 2
  122. 2
  123. 2
  124. 2
  125. 2
  126. 2
  127. 2
  128. 2
  129. 2
  130. 2
  131. 2
  132. 2
  133. 2
  134. 1
  135. 1
  136. 1
  137. 1
  138. 1
  139. 1
  140. 1
  141. 1
  142. 1
  143. 1
  144. 9:34 Putin is making a enormous mistakes here: 1. He still believes that NATO members want Ukraine to join NATO to expand it. Well, no! They aren't against it, if it can bring peace. But they aren't asking for it either, especially if they think it will not bring peace and help mad conquerors' plans. NATO is confident in its capability to defend itself with or without Ukraine , especially against Russia. So NATO members will never push Ukraine to negotiate a spoliation by Russia only to become the direct target of Russia and be responsible for both the security of Ukraine and Russian crimes. Territorial defense is precisely the point of NATO. It's not going to help Russia deny it. Duh. The only motivation for NATO members to see Ukraine joining NATO is to deter any mad bloody conquerors targeting it and to return to sane business in peace that would maximise the profits for all. For this deterrent to be believable, it can't be based on the defeat and political division of its new members. So, if deadly threat don't deter Russia from aggressing neighbors and illegally keeping control of conquered territories (including for example Georgia, Kazakhstan, etc…) there is no incentive for NATO members to include Ukraine: they'd much better form a conventional international defense coalition against В.В.Пу́тин with all the nations threatened by this individual В.В.Пу́тин in particular, without the restrictive rules of NATO membership. This coalition could even include Russians who are fed up to suicide in support of his very personal conquest. 2. He still believes that Ukrainians want to join NATO for reasons other than peace. But there can be no peace with national territory occupied by genocidal madmen! The Ukrainian army come to liberate territory and family members. They aren't going to sacrifice their family members and territory to get a protection they can get without such terrible sacrifice. Strange that В.В.Пу́тин can't understand family bonds, isn't it? Ukrainian wanted to join NATO not to limit their defeat, not because they want more legal constraints, but to prevent illegal invasion and enjoy what is theirs. If it doesn't solve this, if joining NATO doesn't keep hostile armies out of the national territory, there is no reason for joining NATO.
    1
  145. ​ @CjrRbt  You are taking us for one-week-old rabbits hoping to become our next master, you bastard. Maybe you think you're the first one to try to dumb down the populace by playing on their ignorance and making them believe that anything medical researchers come up with is meant only to be used to subdue them? But more likely, you are trying to make people believe in something they can't know in order to become caliph instead of the caliph. A classic. Unless you are paid in small social rewards by exploiters of the naive and superstitious, which is not much better. I hope you aren't so desperate that you need to pervert yourself to this point to make "friends". Refusing everything without a thought is obviously as stupid and dangerous as accepting everything without a thought. In both cases, it is the government's position that dictates behavior. This is still slavery, clearly. One really has to be completely brain-dead to believe that opposing is enough to be sure not to do bad shit. Do you really think we don't realise that you are saying people what to do or not to do without explaining seriously why, just like Putin do by now ? If this work, people could trust any other dictator just the same. You really should meditate with you own issue with power and frustrations before it goes as far as the current wars. To compare the refusal to get killed or crippled in helping people to kill with the refusal to try a medical a solution against a pandemic, what an insult to your fellow humans, and to intelligence in general ! Study for real what you are talking about, please. Note I'm not against people who decide for themselves not to obey things, as long as they accept the consequences of possible increase of danger for other people and their reactions. I just can't bear any more romantic, grandiose, all-confusing leaders coming with a simplistic solution for everybody.
    1
  146. 1
  147. 1
  148. 1
  149. 1
  150. 1
  151. 1
  152. 1
  153. 1
  154. 1
  155. 1
  156. 1
  157. 1
  158. 1
  159. 1
  160. 1
  161. 1
  162. 1
  163. 1
  164. 1
  165. 1
  166. 1
  167. 1
  168. 1
  169. 1
  170. 1
  171. 1
  172. 3:51 I don't know for sure what will happen, but this "already did much" pseudo-explanation is completely nut. In general, and even more in case of war, the most important is to deliver the needed hardware according to goals, not according to the diplomatic weather or out of frustration. If a few F-16 more to combine with the existing army give much better chances of successful missions and dramatically reduce the waste of tanks and lives, then this is what must be done. It would be very stupid to brag about helping a lot with no significant effect because one piece is missing. I am not a military expert, but I think that the air supremacy that Ukraine has been praying for since 2014 would have ended the war already, because it would have blinded Russia even more and neutralized its heavy artillery. Well, it seems quite obvious now that the Russian army cannot conquer or even keep occupied land in Ukraine without heavy artillery. Real experts, tell me if I am wrong and why. I am quite sad that Europeans are wimps counting beans and comparing efforts instead of accepting what it means that the Russian government is definitely becoming authoritarian, fanatic, and clearly expansionist with not limit, literally committed to the path of world conquest at all cost and its submission to the whims of one man at all cost. We all have learned History. We know how it goes. We all know that the more we wait the worse it get and the more it costs. Surviving it requires more than half a reaction and half a treatment. Of course, this "no" could be misleading. It could also mean that the U.S. will supply allied countries, which in turn will supply Ukraine, or some other diplomatic ploy to give Russian spies more work.
    1
  173. 1
  174. 1
  175. 1
  176. 1
  177. 1
  178. 1
  179. 1
  180. 1
  181. 1
  182. 1
  183. 1
  184. 1
  185. 1
  186. 1
  187. 1
  188. 1
  189. 1
  190. 1
  191. 1
  192. 1
  193. 1
  194. 1
  195. 1
  196. 1
  197. 1
  198. 1
  199. 1
  200. 1
  201. 1
  202. 1
  203. 1
  204. 1
  205. 1
  206. 1
  207. 1
  208. 1
  209. 1
  210. 1
  211. 1
  212. 1
  213. 1
  214. 1
  215. 1
  216. 1
  217. 1
  218. 1
  219. 1
  220. 1
  221. 1
  222. 1
  223. 1
  224. 1
  225. 1
  226. 1
  227. 1
  228. 1
  229. 1
  230. 1
  231. 1
  232. 1
  233. 1
  234. 1
  235. 1
  236. 1
  237. 1
  238. 1
  239. 1
  240. 1
  241. 1
  242. 1
  243. 1
  244. 1
  245. 1
  246. 1
  247. 1
  248. 1
  249. 1
  250. 1
  251. 1
  252. 1
  253. 1
  254. 1
  255. 1
  256. 1
  257. 1
  258. 1
  259. 1
  260. Too bad they waited until they were too afraid of being killed to stop fighting. It's extremely sad that so many people are willing to hurt or kill people they don't know, to help someone steal , as long as they think they can avoid the consequences or benefit from some crumbs of the theft. No kind of decisive morality beyond self-interest. No solidarity between members of the same species. It's amazing how some hide behind the excuse "I had orders", "I just did my job as requested", even if it means scaring, hurting or killing people. But when it's their turn to die, all of a sudden, like magic, they start to think we can make an exception, because it's them, their skin, their life, their ass, so another morality should apply and orders and rules don't matter so much after all. It shows that their mentality is entirely based on the fear of the strongest and that many people deeply lack spiritual autonomy : they don't decide anything about their life, they undergo it. They don't develop any higher moral values of their own, they just follow the beatings and run away from the most imminent threat all their lives, without the ability to truly respect others, to grant forgiveness, to trust, or to rebel against common real threats for the benefit of more people. I insist: perpetual escape from most imminent and obvious threat, not the actual greatest danger in the end. Some even chose to commit suicide instead of improving their lives, too afraid of the responsibilities to face them. Are we farm rabbits ? Are we ?!
    1
  261. 1
  262. 1
  263. 1
  264. 1
  265. 1
  266. 1
  267. 1
  268. 1
  269. 1
  270. 1
  271. 1
  272. 1
  273. 1
  274. 1
  275. 1
  276. 1
  277. 1
  278. 1
  279. 1
  280. 1
  281. 1
  282. 1
  283. 1
  284. 1
  285. 1
  286. 1
  287. 1
  288. 1
  289. 1
  290. 1
  291. 1
  292. 1
  293. 1
  294. I agree, and this is essentially what I hope or ask of everyone: Fight the only war worth fighting, not the one against the passport of servants, but rather the one against their most debilitating fears. Don't bring down nations. Bring down their autocrats ! Here, as a motivation song, the REAL original words of L'internationale from Eugène Pottier (1871) , revolutionary song by excellence, translated in english an Russian: > Debout les damnés de la terre! Debout les forçats de la faim! La raison tonne en son cratère. C'est l'éruption de la faim. Arise, damned of the Earth ! Arise, galley slave in hunger ! Reason thunders in its crater. It's the eruption of hunger. Вставайте, проклятые люди Земли! Вставайте, голодные подневольные работники! Дух грохочет в своем кратере. Это извержение, вызванное голодом. > Du passé faisons table rase. Foule esclave, debout ! debout ! Le monde va changer de base. Nous ne sommes rien, soyons tout ! From the past, let's keep nothing[1]. Slave crowd, stand up ! stand up ! The world is about to change. We are nothing, let's be everything! Давайте оставим прошлое позади.[1] Толпа рабов, поднимайтесь! Поднимайтесь! Мир вот-вот изменит свои основополагающие принципы. Мы - ничто, давайте станем всем! > C'est la lutte finale ! Groupons-nous et, demain, L'Internationale sera le genre humain. (bis) It's the final stand! Let's regroup and, tomorrow, the Internationale will be the (whole) human kind. Это последняя битва! Давайте объединимся, и завтра Интернационалом станет (всем) человеческий вид. > Il n'est pas de sauveur suprême ni Dieu ni César ni tribun. Producteurs, sauvons-nous nous-mêmes. Décrétons le salut commun. There is no supreme savior, neither God nor Caesar nor tribune.[2] Producers, let's save ourselves. Let's decree common salvation. Нет верховного спасителя, нет бога, нет кесаря, нет трибуна.[2] Продюсеры, давайте спасем себя. Давайте примем резолюцию о всеобщем спасении. > Pour que le voleur rende gorge, pour tirer l'esprit du cachot, soufflons nous-mêmes notre forge, battons le fer quand qu'il est chaud. To get the thief to spit out what he's swallowed, to get the spirit out of the dungeon, let's blow on our own forge, beat the iron while it's hot. Чтобы вор выплюнул то, что проглотил, чтобы дух вышел из подземелья, давайте сами выковать себе кузницу, давайте бить, пока железо горячо. > C'est la lutte finale ! Groupons-nous, et demain, L'Internationale sera le genre humain. (bis) > L'État comprime et la loi triche, l'impôt saigne le malheureux. Nul devoir ne s'impose au riche, le droit du pauvre est un mot creux. The State pressures and the law cheats, taxes bleed the unfortunate. No duty is imposed on the rich, the poor's right is an empty word. Государство раздавливает людей, закон обманывает, налоги забирают кровь несчастных. У богатых нет обязанностей, права бедных - пустые слова. > C'est assez languir en tutelle. L'Égalité veut d'autres lois. "Pas de droits sans devoirs", dit-elle. Égaux, pas de devoirs sans droits. It's enough to languish in guardianship. Equality wants other laws. "No rights without duties", she says. Equals, no duties without rights. Прошли времена опеки! Равенство требует других законов. "Не бывает прав без обязанностей", - говорит она. В равенстве нет обязанностей без прав. > C'est la lutte finale ! Groupons-nous, et demain, L'Internationale sera le genre humain. (bis) > Hideux dans leur apothéose, les rois de la mine et du rail ont-ils jamais fait autre chose que dévaliser le travail? Hideous in their apotheosis, have the kings of mine and rail ever done anything other than rob work? Отвратительные в своем апофеозе короли шахт и железных дорог. Делали ли они когда-нибудь что-нибудь, кроме кражи трудовых доходов? > Dans les coffres-forts de la banque, ce qu'il a créé s'est fondu. En décrétant qu'on le lui rende, le peuple ne veut que son dû. What it has created has melted away in the bank's vaults. By demanding it back, the people only want their due. То, что он создал, растаяло в хранилищах банка. Требуя этого, люди просто просят то, что им причитается. > C'est la lutte finale ! Groupons-nous, et demain, L'Internationale sera le genre humain. (bis) > Les rois nous saoulaient de fumée. Paix entre nous ! Guerre aux tyrans ! Appliquons la grève aux armées. Crosse en l'air et rompons les rangs. The kings made us drunk with smoke. Peace among us! War on tyrants! Let's apply the strike to the armies. Rifle stock up and break ranks. Короли выкурили нас. Мир между нами! Война против тиранов! Давайте ударим по армиям. Поднимем приклады винтовок и покинем военные парады. > S'ils s'obstinent, ces cannibales, à faire de nous des héros. Ils sauront bientôt que nos balles, sont pour nos propres généraux. If they insist, these cannibals, on making heroes of us, they'll soon know that our bullets are for our own generals. Если они настаивают, эти каннибалы, на том, чтобы сделать из нас героев. Они скоро узнают, что наши пули предназначены для наших собственных генералов. > C'est la lutte finale ! Groupons-nous, et demain, L'Internationale sera le genre humain. (bis) > Ouvriers, paysans, nous sommes le grand parti des travailleurs. La terre n'appartient qu'aux hommes. L'oisif ira loger ailleurs. Workers, farmers, we are the great labor party. The land belongs only to human beings. The idle will live elsewhere. Рабочие, крестьяне, мы - великая рабочая партия. Земля принадлежит только людям. Бездельники будут жить в другом месте. > Combien de nos chairs se repaissent ? Mais si les corbeaux, les vautours un de ces matins disparaissent… Le soleil brillera toujours. How many of them feast on our flesh? But if the crows and vultures disappear one of these mornings... The sun will shine forever. Сколько из них питаются нашей плотью? Но если вороны и стервятники исчезнут одним из этих утр, то... солнце будет светить вечно. > C'est la lutte finale ! Groupons-nous, et demain, L'Internationale sera le genre humain. (bis) --- [1]: "Faire table rase" is the French version of the latin expression "tabula rasa". "Faire table rase" - это французская версия латинского выражения "tabula rasa" https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tabula_rasa. [2]: therefore no V.V.Putin as a Csar. Поэтому нет В.В.Путина в качестве Царя.
    1
  295. 1
  296. 1
  297. 1
  298. 1
  299. 1
  300. 1
  301. 1
  302. 1
  303. 1
  304. 1
  305. 1
  306. 1
  307. 1
  308. 16:11 Wouldn't it be more correct to assume that the Russians have already all realized that they have been lied to about almost everything, and have already chosen one of these options a long time ago: - protest and frontal rebellion: they have been neutralized (charged and put in prison, impoverished by administrative and socio-economic exclusion, murdered, sent to die in war by forced mobilization, put on the run abroad...). - silence: they claim to be "apolitical", they know very well but they wait for someone else to decide for them, they refuse to take the responsibility they deserve. - self-hypnosis and alcohol: they suppress the fear and discomfort caused by inconsistencies by constantly forgetting what is wrong (religious trance, personality cult, patriotic rituals, repetition of key sentences or words dictated from above, acrobatic rationalization, nationalistic symbolism exacerbated by plastic works such as "Z" or music, or even fanatical careerism, ritual sacrifice of men by sending them to war, etc); this is especially noticeable in the anger caused by legitimate questions perceived as "provocations". All of this is very human, and very understandable (yet not always acceptable due to consequences) in their situation. I also thought that many Russians did not know, but I changed my mind: they all know very well what is happening but refuse to admit it or refuse to fight it for fear of the consequences, and have done so for a long time. Therefore, it would be stupid and futile to expect the Russians to get out of this unhealthy situation simply by realizing that they have been lied to. But perhaps we can still hope for a renewed awareness of their own power as a people. Obviously, the vast majority of Russian citizens do not believe in this collective power and remain in avoidance. As for the others, they are largely controlled because their permanent anger is so strong that it is easily exploited in order to redirect the attacks towards the enemies of the government rather than against their own enemies including their current government. Continuing to address the Russians as if they did not know may increase their anger but does not fundamentally change the exploitation of that anger. I think it would be much more beneficial to reassure them of their ability to collectively produce political content and enforce it. They would need labor unions, popular self-education workshops, practical workshops to resist tongue-in-cheek, and in the worst case they would need physical defenses against the police: bulletproof vests, tear gas, tasers, flashlights, warning systems to avoid abusive individual arrests without the possibility of collective reaction, training in individual self-defense... Some of them would also need alcohol detox and an psychological support program against mental depression. Finally, I believe that there should be a promise of (at least partial) amnesty for the corrupt who would accept to let go their privileges instead of more mockery and threats of revenge or punitive justice, without which they will cling to the defense of the criminal enterprise Putin&Co at all costs, even if it means sacrificing their own family, just to save their ass. In short, the more I learn about the abused Russians we are talking about, the more I think they are not so much lacking in information (even if it's true) as they are lacking incentive and individual self-worth.
    1
  309. 1
  310. 1
  311. 1
  312. 1
  313. 1
  314. 1
  315. 1
  316. 1
  317. 1
  318. 1
  319. 1
  320. 1
  321. 1
  322. 1
  323. 1
  324. 1
  325. 1
  326. 1
  327. 1
  328. 1
  329. 1
  330. 1
  331. 1
  332. 1
  333. 1
  334. 1
  335. 1
  336. 1
  337. 1
  338. 1
  339. 1
  340. 1
  341. 1
  342. 1
  343. 1
  344. 1
  345. 1
  346. 1
  347. 1
  348. 1
  349. 1
  350. 1
  351. 1
  352. 1
  353. 1
  354. 1
  355. 1
  356. 1
  357. 1
  358. 1
  359. 1
  360. 1
  361. 1
  362. 1
  363. 1
  364. 1
  365. 1
  366. 1
  367. 1
  368. 1
  369. 1
  370. 1
  371. 1
  372. 1
  373. 1
  374. 1
  375. 1
  376. 1
  377. 1
  378. 1
  379. 1
  380. 1
  381. 1
  382. 1
  383. 1
  384. 1
  385. 1
  386. 1
  387. 1
  388. 1
  389. 1
  390. 1
  391. 1
  392. 1
  393. 1
  394. 1
  395. 1
  396. 1
  397. 1
  398. 1
  399. 1
  400. 1
  401. 1
  402. 1
  403. 1
  404. 1
  405. 1
  406. 1
  407. 1
  408. 1
  409. 1
  410. 1
  411. 1
  412. 1
  413. 1
  414. 1
  415. 1
  416. 1
  417. 1
  418. 1
  419. 1
  420. 1
  421. 1
  422. 1
  423. 1
  424. 1
  425. 1
  426. 1
  427. 1
  428. 1
  429. 1
  430. 1
  431. 1
  432. 1
  433. 1
  434. 1
  435. 1
  436. 1
  437. 1
  438. 1
  439. 1
  440. 1
  441. 1
  442. 1
  443. 1
  444. 1
  445. 1
  446. 1
  447. 5:30 Since the crackpots in the Kremlin decided to hate them for life anyways, Westerners are finally realizing that the more they wait for the evil to calm down the worse it will become , just like the relation with Hitler. Blue helmets in Ukraine in 2014, at a time when Putin was still denying that he was behind the killings in Ukraine, would have prevented Putin's plan from the outset and thus saved several hundred thousand lives. Today, it's terribly late to intervene, but later still would be much worse anyways. Until now, Westerners naively believed that Russia would eventually choose peace and the respect of its own sayings and treaties out of obvious self-interest. This hope has been systematically destroyed by Russia, especially since 2021-2022. This came as a shock, and all that was improvised at the time were nothing but emergency measures to temporise in order to: 1. Get informed in spite of smoke screens and lies. 2. Understand what's going on and why reason doesn't work in that case, and quadruple-check it. 3. Accept (which is the hardest and takes the longest) what is happening and what it implies if we let it happen. Now that Europe has woken up, mourned its sweet dreams of automatic peace by operation of universal reason, mourned the hope that the situation would resolve itself, and consulted all its members, it is slowly but surely beginning to warm up to the idea of actively solving the problem once and for all by its own means, including the most brutal methods if necessary, before it gets any worse. Europeans simply refuse the domination of any new empire on the continent, simply refuse to be turned into enemies of the Russian people by some silly neo-Czar, and refuse to live under constant menace. Debates and patience are nearly over. Fed up is fed up. Even if, from the outside, it looks like nothing has changed yet, minds are massively synchronizing around the idea of getting rid of the mafia jerks. We are on the eve of a breaking point.
    1
  448. 1
  449. 1
  450. 1
  451. 1
  452. 1
  453. 1
  454. 1
  455. 1
  456. 1
  457. 1
  458. 1
  459. 1
  460. 1
  461. 1
  462. 1
  463. 1
  464. 1
  465. 1
  466. 1
  467. 1
  468. 1
  469. 1
  470. 1