Comments by "People Liberator" (@lvjinbin28) on "How Taiwan Will Stop China's Invasion" video.

If you want to say that the Russian army is an invader in Donbass, then the US army is also an invader in Taiwan. You should know the United Nations Charter, right? Some people always have some imbecile and ignorant fantasies, and do not understand the history and mentality of the Chinese people at all. Back then, the CCP went to North Korea and North Vietnam as buffer zone to confront against the U.S. containment, and CCP also fought against the Soviet encirclement in Zhenbao Island, Tibet, India, Xinjiang, and Afghanistan proxy wars. Why do you think If you invade and occupy a territory of China, can you still hope that China will have sobering realization? Aren't you supposed to be the ones have sobering realization?
4
Don’t you know the role of the CCP in the Korean War, the Second Indochina War, the Vietnam War, the Sino-Indian War, the Sino-Soviet War, the Third Indochina War, and the Soviet-Afghanistan War? If even Ukraine is not afraid of Russia's nuclear arsenal, Ukraine has been bombing pro-Russian Donbas separatists for 8 years and is fighting against Russian invaders. Why would China, as a nuclear-armed power, should be afraid of attacking Taiwanese separatists and American and Japanese invaders? Do you think the Chinese are more fragile than the Ukrainians, or that Xi Jinping is more cowardly than Zelensky?
2
@benpurcell4935 China is neutral in the Ukraine crisis because both countries have had good relations with China in the past 30 years, so why should China sanction one of the two?
2
@sonneh86 You used the wrong comparison between China and Taiwan. The comparison should be between Ukraine and Donbas.
2
Because the West naively believes that sovereignty and security are more important than money.
1
@infinitsai If the United States is too weak to engage in a Taiwan war, then the countries in the first island chain will be neutral or pro-China. Otherwise, why do you think the first island chain dares to encircle China?
1
@krishmalhotratalks The CCP was anti-American and anti-Soviet in the 1960s. PLA bombarded Taiwan’s Kinmen for 21 years from 1958 to 1979. CCP attacked India in 1962, 1967, CCP armed Vietcong against US 1964 to 1975, funded all communist revolutions in Asia, Africa and Latin America, intervened in the Macau riots against Portugese in 1966, intervened in the Hong Kong riots against UK in 1967, and even attacked the Soviet Union in 1969. It is difficult to imagine that China will only attack Taiwan, instead of makeing trouble in Ukraine, Israel, Cuba, Korea, Japan at the same time as it did in the 1960s? Of course China will retaliate.
1
The CCP was anti-American and anti-Soviet in the 1960s. PLA bombarded Taiwan’s Kinmen for 21 years from 1958 to 1979. CCP attacked India in 1962, armed Vietcong against US 1964 to 1975, funded communist revolutions in all Asia, Africa and Latin America, intervened in the Macau riots in 1966, intervened in the Hong Kong riots in 1967, and attacked the Soviet Union in 1969. It is difficult to imagine that China will only attack Taiwan, instead of makeing trouble in Ukraine, Israel, Cuba, Korea, Japan at the same time as it did in the 1960s?
1
Although this video is very neutral, but he forgot to mention that China has already broken through the 7nm chip within 3 years from 28nm, so Taiwan's chip shield will be invalid, and the world, including the Taiwan market, will be overwhelmed by cheap Chinese chips in the future.Taiwanese or Westerners judge that chip shields are useful because they are based on the reality that China will never be able to catch up with advanced chip manufacturing processes. But isn’t this the prejudice of different ideology??
1
@umerqureshi1606 You still really only look at your own strengths and only look at your opponent's shortcomings, military experience? Don’t you know the role of the CCP in the Korean War, the Second Indochina War, the Vietnam War, the Sino-Indian War, the Sino-Soviet War, the Third Indochina War, and the Soviet-Afghanistan War? tell me which proxy war that CCP lost? When you compare Russia and China, you should know that China's GDP is 10 times that of Russia, and its industrial output is also 10 times, Russia military ranks second today simply because its nuclear arsenal is 30 times that of China. But China will definitely not use nuclear weapons to attack its compatriots. Therefore, considering only conventional war, China has a huge advantage over Russia. Little Emporer Syndrome? Do you think liberal Taiwanese are more aggressive? In the eyes of the Chinese, they are the kind of strawberry soldiers who need parasols for shooting training. According to Harvard data, 93% of Chinese people support the CCP, and the lowest support rate for local governments is at least 70%. The remaining Chinese who are dissatisfied with the CCP is also due to corruption or dictatorship, but even liberal Chinese are nationalists, Isn’t it hard to understand that the tougher the politicians, the more populist support they get? Trump, Erdogan, Modi, Putin, Zelensky, they are tough on enemy countries and cruel to separatism. Look at their polls, At this time, you care about the public opinion of the Chinese people again. Don’t forget that when the CCP locked down 1.3 billion people for 2 weeks, 10 million people in Wuhan for 1 month, and 26 million people in Shanghai for 2 months, such harsh policies will lead to public dissatisfaction and protest. If CCP only attack Taiwanese separatists, why will Chinese be dissatisfied? Are the Ukrainian people dissatisfied with Poroshenko and Zelensky’s attack on Donbas? 1974 Sino-Vietnamese War (which they lost)? You are talking about the Paracel naval battle 1974 between the CCP and South Vietnam, The CCP obviously won. I think You mean CCP lost the Sino-Vietnam War in 1979? The Sino-Vietnamese War in 1979, the Sino-Vietnamese Conflict in 1979-1991, and the Cambodia-Vietnam War in 1978-1989 were all part of the Third Indochina War. If you think the CCP lost this war, it is because you are too ignorant of the history of the Cold War. Within a month, the CCP "demilitarized, de-industrialized, de-agriculturalized, and de-infrastructured" northern Vietnam, and then PLA immediately withdrew all troops to Chinese border to prepare the Soviet troops in Mongolia to move south to Beijing.. Through 12 years of constant border attrition, CCP supported the Khmer Rouge guerrillas in their fight against the Vietnamese occupation. In the end, the CCP regained the disputed border territory and recaptured Johnson South Reef in 1988. The CCP even provided military aid to the Afghan mujahedeen in the Soviet-Afghan War from 1979 to 1989. In the end, Vietnam withdrew from Cambodia and Laos and gave up the unification of French Indochina Federation. the Viet cong visited Chengdu and eased relations with Deng Xiaoping, and the Soviet Union also withdrew from Afghanistan. Since then, the Soviet anti-China encirclement in Vietnam and Afghanistan was broken. Where did the CCP lose strategically? The CCP killed more Viet Cong. Where did the CCP lose tactically? One term for China's tactical thinking about Taiwan is the "Beiping model." That is, the CCP blocked Beijing in Chinese Civil War, which was controlled by the Kuomintang, and then the pro-communist KMT officers in the city easily surrendered. Why? Because there was a "Changchun model" before, the five-month siege resulted in the starvation of 100,000 to 600,000 Chinese civilians in Changchun.Therefore, the People's Liberation Army Navy will only block Taiwan, and then attack the U.S. warships that comes to assist. As long as Taiwan is a democratic regime, the CCP can make a regime-change if Taiwanese is afraid of starvation. Isn't this what the United States does with sanctions against those anti-American democratically elected regimes? This is what the CCP learned from the United States. Unless Taiwan becomes an authoritarian regime like Cuba, North Korea, and Iran, then Taiwan will be able to suppress the struggles of hungry people. But once Taiwan becomes a totalitarian regime and the People's Liberation Army finds that the blockade is useless, the CCP will bomb Taiwan on a large scale, just like Israel did to Gaza today. Why did I say before that the CCP has never lost a proxy war? Because you really underestimated the determination, perseverance and cruelty of the CCP. The CCP was anti-American and anti-Soviet in the 1960s. PLA bombarded Taiwan’s Kinmen for 21 years from 1958 to 1979. CCP attacked India in 1962, armed Vietcong against US 1964 to 1975, funded communist revolutions in all Asia, Africa and Latin America, intervened in the Macau riots in 1966, intervened in the Hong Kong riots in 1967, and attacked the Soviet Union in 1969. For example, the Chinese Communist Party has been supporting the Vietnamese Communist Party for 29 years to fight against France and the United States. The Chinese Communist Party has been supporting the Afghan mujahideen for 10 years to fight against the Soviet Union. Today, the United States is tired of supporting Ukraine for just one year? ? ? How could the CCP only focus on one battlefield? When the CCP is determined to take over Taiwan, it will definitely cause trouble for the United States in Ukraine, Israel, Korea, Japan and Cuba, It depends on who the United States will save first, and how long American public opinion can persist in the war of attrition.
1
@benpurcell4935 So why does Xi Jinping want to aid Russia?
1
@benpurcell4935 neutrality is stance, do you want China to send weapons to Russia, or do you want China to sanction Ukraine?
1
@benpurcell4935 is your country neutral?
1
@MagePlue Why did the USA attack the CSA? Why did North Korea attack South Korea? Why did North Vietnam attacked South Vietnam? Why is Ukraine attacking Donbass now? Are you pretending to be stupid, or do you think Chinese people are particularly stupid? Most people in China are more right-wing nationalistic than the CCP, Since you have absolutely nothing to do with China, why do you want to get involved in China's civil war?
1
@kostakatsoulis2922 defending Taiwan? The United Nations and the United States both believe that Taiwan belongs to the PRC, so the US military in Taiwan is an invader, just like the Russian army said they was defending Donbas from being attacked by Ukraine, right? Of course, imperialist aggressors have always had double standards. So how many times and for how long will the US military defend Taiwan? For example, the CCP has defended North Vietnam for 29 years, and the United States has defended South Vietnam for 29 years. But why does the United States not continue to defend it?
1
Why do you think that if NATO intervenes in China's sovereignty issues, China will not fight NATO? Is it because today's NATO is more powerful than the United Nations forces was in 1950?
1
@kostakatsoulis2922 Are you saying that the West is better prepared today and therefore the West will definitely fight better than in 1950? You really should do some basic research. In 1950, the GDP of the USA accounted for 45% of the world's economy as industrial country especially after World War II, while the PRC only accounted for 2% GDP of the world as agricultural countries, especially because China experienced 30 years of civil war. If you only count industrial output value, then the industrial output value of the United States alone is 100 times that of PRC! What about 2023? China's GDP is 70% of that of the United States, its purchasing power parity has surpassed that of the United States much 10 years ago, and its industrial output is even that of the United States, Japan, and Germany combined, what you parepared?
1
You don’t know that the drones on the Ukrainian battlefield are all from China? ? ?
1
If the Taiwanese really want to maintain the status quo, then return to Ma Ying-jeou's 92 consensus route. You can be anti-communist but not anti-China. The CCP can acquiesce in the Republic of China, but it will definitely destroy the Republic of Taiwan. Don't join the US military encirclement, and don't be China's Cuba, Vietnam, Ukraine.
1
In fact, Taiwan was researching nuclear weapons in the 1980s, but was reported to the CIA by pro-American Taiwanese spies. Then Taiwan canceled its nuclear weapons program under pressure from the United States.
1
Don’t you know the role of the CCP in the Korean War, the Second Indochina War, the Vietnam War, the Sino-Indian War, the Sino-Soviet War, the Third Indochina War, and the Soviet-Afghanistan War? In all these anti-Western or anti-Soviet proxy wars, the CCP is always the winner, Because CCP is more determined, smart and cruel than you think.
1
Don’t you know the role of the CCP in the Korean War, the Second Indochina War, the Vietnam War, the Sino-Indian War, the Sino-Soviet War, the Third Indochina War, and the Soviet-Afghanistan War? In all these anti-Western or anti-Soviet proxy wars, the CCP is always the winner, Because CCP is more determined and cruel than you think.
1
The CCP was anti-American and anti-Soviet in the 1960s. PLA bombarded Taiwan’s Kinmen for 21 years from 1958 to 1979. CCP attacked India in 1962, 1967, CCP armed Vietcong against US 1964 to 1975, funded all communist revolutions in Asia, Africa and Latin America, intervened in the Macau riots against Portugese in 1966, intervened in the Hong Kong riots against UK in 1967, and even attacked the Soviet Union in 1969. It is difficult to imagine that China will only attack Taiwan, instead of making trouble in Ukraine, Israel, Cuba, Korea, Japan for US at the same time as it did in the 1960s? Of course China will retaliate.
1
@大家好-d7q 中国民主了，台湾也不会和统，那中国统一党，中国优先党，中国民进党，还是会打台湾。
1
PLAN is the second largest navy in the world in terms of tonnage which stands at 2,400,000 tonnes as of 2022, US navy is 4,635,628 tonnes as of 2023, but China's shipbuilding capacity is 232 times greater than US,
1
China is the world's factory, while Taiwan is just a chip factory. They are completely different comparisons.
1