Comments by "People Liberator" (@lvjinbin28) on "Germany is increasing its military presence in the Indo-Pacific region | DW News" video.
-
3
-
3
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
@akahment China follows UNCLOS, it's you guys opposed WWII order and UNCLOS.
Sino-Japanese Peace Treaty
Article 2
It is recognized under Treaty of Peace with Japan signed at San Francisco, Japan has renounced all right, title and claim to Taiwan and Penghu as well as Spratly Islands and Paracel Islands.
like Greece was the winner after the Balkan War, WWI, and WWII, so Greece can control 97% of the islands and EEZ in the Aegean Sea, but Turkey can only control 3% of the islands in the Aegean Sea, but Greece has not violated UNCLOS because Greece owns all islands, if Turkey wants to change the post-war order, win the next world war.
West and Soviet let ROC, Not American Philippines or French Vietnam to control SCS after Japan left 1946, coz Southeast Asians and colonial troops surrendered to Japs in 1942, but KMT/CCP resisted fascist until 1945, PRC inherited same claim from ROC after 1949, that's why both Beijing and Taiwan claims same islands in South China Sea today.
Beijing claims all the islands within the 9-dash line, and Taiwan claims all the islands within the 11-dash line. Beijing and Taiwan have never claimed the entire South China Sea. The South China Sea has never been China's internal waters. The Philippines, Vietnam, and Malaysia have also drawn a large dotted line, but they only claim the islands within the dotted line. No country regards the ocean within the dotted line as its internal waters, so no countries really disrespect UNCLOS, the only dispute is who owns those islands. Don't you understand this?
Just like the United States claims many islands in the Pacific, but not the entire Pacific is the United States' internal waters, so Chinese merchant ships can sail in the Pacific at will, but once Chinese warships approach the EEZ of Hawaii and Guam, the United States will be angry! If China wants to challenge the US sovereignty over Guam, it is challenging the post-war order of the Spanish-American War. China used to tacitly acknowledge that Guam belonged to the United States. If China no longer recognizes it now on the grounds that Guam is too far away from the United States, then who do you think is the provocateur?
And the US warships are approaching the islands claimed and controlled by China, which is a challenge to the World War II order, because it was the United States that gave the warships to the Chinese in 1946, allowing the ROC navy to control South China Sea.
I wonder why USA doesn't oppose Taiwan's 11dashline claim? Of course it is based on the geopolitical factors of Cold War 2.0, not on so-called morality!
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
@AlphaHorst Are you playing dumb? Beijing and Taiwan have never claimed that the South China Sea is internal waters, Beijing only claims islands within the 9-dash line, Taiwan only claims islands within the 11-dash line, the South China Sea is so huge, merchant ships have always been able to sail freely, but why are warships coming to China's periphery? Are you playing dumb? United States has never claimed that the Pacific Ocean is an internal water, so Chinese merchant ships can sail freely, but can Chinese warships enter the EEZ of Guam? The Taiwan Strait is very narrow, at least China's EEZ, then merchant ships have always been free to sail, but what are your warships coming? Are you playing dumb? The English Channel is international waters, but if your United Kingdom warship just passed through the Taiwan Strait, and then the Chinese warship also passed through the English Channel, don't you know the political implications? Since you want the freedom of navigation of warships, why don't you go to Madagascar and choose only the waters around China? Don't play dumb, so China will go to the Aleutian Islands and around Alaska for free navigation, and then the Gulf of Mexico.
1
-
Sino-Japanese Peace Treaty
Article 2
It is recognized under Treaty of Peace with Japan signed at San Francisco, Japan has renounced all right, title and claim to Taiwan and Penghu as well as Spratly Islands and Paracel Islands.
Beijing and Taiwan respects UNCLOS, or they will claim whole water as internal water not just islands, anyways, Win WWII to rewrite WWII order,
also remember, In 1958, CCP issued declaration defining territorial waters which encompassed Spratly and Paracel Islands. Vietcong's PM, Pham Van Dong, sent a diplomatic note to Zhou Enlai, stating Vietcong respects this decision, but Le Duan changed after reunification, caused 1979-1991 war.
Vietnamese will learn lesson in Fourth Indochina War
1
-
1
-
@AwesomeJoe007 Does the United Nations support Philippines? nope, UN spokesman supports the code of conduct in the South China Sea.
Then has the United States signed to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea? Never.
When ROC navy used American warships to land on Taiping island, Thitu island, Triton island, Woody island in 1946, where was UNCLOS? where was rejection? why only opposed now? why doesn't oppose Taiwan today's 11dashline?
When PLA killed 100+ South Vietnam soldiers and retook Paracel Islands in 1974, Where was UNCLOS and SEATO?
When PLA killed 100,000+ Viet Cong soldiers, militiamen 1979-1991, PLA navy killed 64 Viet Cong soldiers and retook Johnson South Reef Spratly in 1988, Where was Soviet navy and condemnation from both West Soviet, and UNCLOS?
Such arbitration tribunal, have no right to decide sovereign rights, even they have now then China can just quit UNCLOS, like USA has been ignoring UNCLOS forever.
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1