Comments by "Yerris" (@yerri5567) on "" video.
-
7
-
7
-
7
-
5
-
5
-
4
-
4
-
@墙内人-o4p "Typical modern Chinese thought"?
For what? For using economic principles to answer a question?
"Are you suggesting Uyghurs are undeveloped...just need to be assimilated or wiped out"
Yes. Not only Uyghurs, but China as a whole is undeveloped. In terms of GDP, Xinjiang is indeed undeveloped.
And also, what country doesnt want its people to assimilate? Name one country that doesnt. Nothing wrong with assimilating. Assimilating doesnt mean you cant practise your own culture. It just means youre able to fully function within the country and accepted socially.
"I tell you, the tribes in Amazon are going very well, and tribes in middle east are also going very well, but other civilized people in middle east aren't going very well, just because lack of democracy"
How do you know the tribes in the Amazon and Middle East are doing very well? Have you been? Have you read about it? You seem so confident. Link me your source of knowledge.
Democracy is a Greek ideology. So as far as I know, tribes dont have democracy. Tribes are inherently authoritarian led by a chieftain, which is usually the most powerful or an elder.
"Terrorism among Uyghurs, who defines it, the CCP?"
I said independence movements/terrorism, not just terrorism. But who defines it? Theres a standard definition what terrorism is. Pretty much any organisation that uses unlawful violence or unlawful threat of violence for political agendas.
Now, name me one country that supports an independence movement within their own country. Name me one country thats happy to give away their own sovereign territory because a small group of people wants it.
"but in communists eye, Uyghurs should not have the right to express their dissatisfaction"
You are too self-centred. Its not just Uyghurs. ANYONE with subversive thoughts inside the country is subjected to the rule of law. Thats Chinas law whether anyone likes it or not. When youre in country X, youre subjected to country Xs laws.
"why those "terrorism" only occurred after 9.11, it means CCP hardened their iron fist on that region, with an excuse of America's war on terror"
Maybe 9/11 encouraged and empowered more extremist to act upon their beliefs?
"if you keep these idea, I'll not argue with you anymore. because it means you are fifty cent, or CCP member, or from those country heavily relied on China's aid"
Everyone is able to express their opinion. If you think Im a 50c, a CCP member, or from a country that relies on Chinas aid, then you must be funded by the CIA for having your own opinions against China. Sounds ridiculous doesnt it?
Also, someone linked me the truth on what really happens within these vocational centres.
Take a look, its better than bloodshed:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=91FFyinPK3M
4
-
3
-
@墙内人-o4p If you keep saying Im a 50c due to my "explanation" then I will also continue to say youre funded by the CIA because of your "explanation".
"I know very well about those camps, because I came from XJ, I know what's going on there"
Just because someone is from a certain area doesnt mean they know whats going on behind those centres. I could say I come from Nevada, does that mean I know whats going on in Area 51?
"about low, if they broke some low, they were in jail, or sentenced to death, not putted in those camps"
From my understanding, these vocational training centre is not for those who broke the law, its for those that have been in contact with those that have radicalised views.
"if you interested about democracy among some tribal people, you can investigate yourself"
Im not interested in tribal people. Im interested in how you knew about the isolated tribes social hierarchy. You still didnt answer my question.
'How do you know the tribes in the Amazon and Middle East are doing very well? Have you been? Have you read about it? You seem so confident. Link me your source of knowledge'
"about "Terrorism" after 9.11, you just copied it from CCP's propaganda, also confirms you a a fifty cent"
I used my brain tyvm. I also said "maybe". By saying "confirm" when you have nothing to confirm, confirms you are stubborn and have irrational thinking.
"about assimilation? who said to you they can practice their own culture? even before fully assimilation CCP don't allow people to practice their own culture, even don't allow they teach their children in their own language....about assimilation in fascistic way, if you still defend CCP's policy, it means you are one of them.
If they cant practise their own culture then how come Uyghurs can wear their traditional clothing? How come Uyghur dance is publicised everywhere?
And about suppressing language. Its sad, but this is practised everywhere across the world. But I get it. In order to integrate everyone to be on the same page as everyone else in the country, a standard language is needed. But just because they dont teach it at school doesnt mean they cant speak it.
They dont teach native American Indian language in the US too. Do you have something to say about that?
"you said name one country, for example UK, if there is enough Scottish voted for independence, UK will let them"
Try again. Scotland is already a country. United Kingdom is a pact between the 4 countries to work together as one. England, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales are all in their own right their very own countries. Remember, compare apples with apples, not with oranges.
3
-
@墙内人-o4p UK unitary system like China? UK was originally 4 separate tiny countries that agreed to united as to work as one. Since when was China made up of many countries that voted to unify as one?
AND UK is democratically voted in. If they democratically voted in, that gives grounds for them to democratically vote out. Can you really not see the difference?
"you agree they don't broke any low, and you agree they should be held in those camps, it prove you are CCP's "agent" (just working for CCP for money or willingly, if you are not comment for money I assume you are one of Chinese descendants in Nevada who admires CCP's Rule in China)
Proves Im a CCP agent? Im commenting to correct you. I have interest in correcting people. What worldly "agent" am I part of now?
I didnt a "agree". I said "from my understanding". I could be wrong. And Im open for correction. I also didnt "agree" with anything regarding those camps. I said those vocational training centres are a better solution that bloodshed.
Now, you havent answered my question yet. Terrorist/independence movements in any country is unacceptable. How do you suggest a country tackle this issue?
"I said there are some people at 70s, why they keep those people in those camps, just for contacting with some problematic person??"
I didnt respond to that because I dont have to answer to everything. If you want to know, then ask CCP. Its unwise to make bias comments without knowing both sides of the story. I could be that he was brainwashed by extremist.
"and I ask you if there are millions of terrorist, how could they hold XJ so firmly."
No one said there were millions of terrorist in Xinjiang. No one can even confirm that these centres can hold 1 million people. Only speculations.
If you watched the video I linked, you would understand the impact on what these extremist have affected the minds of the "victims".
"at that time if you wan't you answer you came visit"
Sure. Do link me when thats uploaded.
3
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1