Comments by "FrozEnbyWolf150" (@FrozEnbyWolf150) on "Anti-Trans Hysteria Takes Over Alberta" video.
-
8
-
4
-
3
-
2
-
1
-
@nestorpoetus781 You want to talk about bad research? The Singh study that TERFs cite was based on outdated diagnostic criteria from the DSM-3 and 4, which conflated gender expression with gender identity, and mistook gender nonconforming children as having gender dysphoria. It then concluded that since none of these kids grew up to be trans, they must have "detransitioned" and therefore it must be due to peer pressure. It further lost track of more than half the individuals in the study, and concluded they detransitioned as well. It also falsely conflated desistance with transition regret, even though there is zero evidence to support this.
Better studies, like the 2021 meta analysis by Bustos, the 2023 Jedrzejewski study on GCS patients, or the 2021 Turban study on desistance, found the actual regret rate is very low, typically less than 1%. Of those who had detransitioned, which is not the same as regret, more than 80% cited factors like familial pressure, societal stigma, and losing access to healthcare. When these factors are addressed, most go on to resume their transition. It's also not uncommon for nonbinary patients to transition up to a certain point, then stop. When people have detransitioned voluntarily due to actual gender related reasons, they did not regret the experience, and were grateful for the opportunity to safely explore their identity.
1