Comments by "William Warren" (@wbwarren57) on "Lei's Real Talk" channel.

  1. Lei, this is truly one of your greatest videos! Thank you so much! The eight points that you recite in this video crack the code of Chinese politics completely. This video should be watched by every diplomat in the west, and everyone who thinks that they can deal with Chinain business or politics.
    104
  2. Does china really know what is domestically produced food cost? Considering how prices in China are distorted by government mandate and corruption and the lack of real markets, does china really know how much domestically produced food cost? Also, considering the scale of pollution in China, how fast are they destroying their arable land?
    16
  3. All of these very complicated and subtle moves may convince the CCP that they’re making real progress, but it sounds like to me that what they’re really doing is rearranging the deck chairs on the HMS titanic.
    13
  4. Delightful! Thank you for showing us your Vietnam trip.
    11
  5. Great video! Thank you. Your listing of the four challenges facing the CCP was most encouraging because I’m very doubtful that they can overcome any of them.
    9
  6. Thank you! It is refreshing to hear that American Christians are not the only ones who are willing to force fit current events into ancient prophecies. It’s nice to hear that the Chinese also do the same thing and like the Americans, give it much too much importance.
    7
  7. I think you vastly over estimate the capacity of the CCP to learn. Real learning requires grappling with the facts, even unpleasant facts. I don’t think the CCP has the capacity to do that based on the way that they are structured. Also, I think you underestimate the effect of corruption within the CCP and assign them a much more consistent unified purpose and execution of their plans than they really are capable of. Lastly, I think you underestimate the ability of the west to learn.
    7
  8. Is this really a problem unique to the CCP or a Chinese problem? The CCP sounds a lot like just modern-day emperors. China has had emperors who were foolish stupid and unwise for thousands of years and has suffered under them for many different reasons many different times. Given that long history, is the “special institutional advantage“ of the CCP really any different? If the CCP is replaced with some of their form of government, I wouldn’t be surprised if the same types of behavior which seem to be so indelibly fixed in the Chinese character doesn’t happen again and again and again and again.
    6
  9.  @tedzehnder961  Very true. I just haven't seen the "politician's creed" stated so clearly and succinctly before.
    6
  10. Considering China’s aging demographics, falling birth rates, rising labor costs, overbuilding of real estate and the real estate bubble, over building of high speed rail at the expense of cargo rail, the necessity to build more and more highways, The economic failure of the south to north water transport system, The looming failure of the belt and road initiative, and the fact that companies are leaving China, has the Chinese communist party pushed China into a downward spiral that it will be impossible to stop?
    5
  11. Nice video! Thank you. This really explains a lot to me about what is going on in China now and you are one of the few people who is actually taken on the subject. Congratulations.
    5
  12. Bad assumption! There really is no concept of “ownership“ in China under the CCP. The CCP can move money from any party to any other party. However, it wishes without worrying about the concept of “ownership“. The CCP will decide who needs to suffer and who will be satisfied. The CCP will not collapse because of debt because they can repudiate any debts they want to at any time.
    4
  13. Xi Jinping and the CCP should study what happened in 1989 when the Soviet Union did not roll the tanks in and crush the demonstrators and the revolutionaries in eastern Europe who wanted to escape their rule. If she’s in pain (XiJinping) and the CCP want to survive, they need to crush the mortgage boycotters. I think that is what they are going to plan at these meetings in the summer.
    4
  14. You want the truth about the crash? Forget about it Jake! It’s Chinatown!
    3
  15. I have a better idea for achieving true security for the CCP! Why not create a language that uses tones that the west is not familiar with and instead of using an alphabet uses pictograms which of course the West could never master? In this way the CCP will be able to have a language that no one in the Wes can understand! Once the language is complete, the CCP can force everyone in China to speak it! In this way, the CCP can achieve total security for Chinese communications and computations!
    3
  16.  @drumpfdon760  You might be right. I don’t think so but I agree wholeheartedly that there is one thing that will be accomplished without question: no matter how much suffering and hardship and poverty and persecution the Chinese people have to endure, the CCP and she Jean bing (Xi) will never miss a single meal nor lack for a single luxury.
    3
  17. Question for your live stream: how many Chinese people will the CCP have to kill in order to terrorize the Chinese people into paying their mortgages again and accepting the fact that their houses will not be delivered on time and may never be delivered? Summary execution of mortgage boycotters is the only way that the CCP is going to survive. If the CCP gives in to the mortgage boycotters and actually improve the situation in the real estate market, they will be showing the Chinese people that protesting is worth the risk and the Chinese people will start demanding that they be able to breathe the air in their cities again, drink the water in their cities again, eat the food without dying again, and invest in banks and real estate and the stock market without a constant fear of losing everything overnight.
    3
  18. All hail the leader ship of Xi Jinping and I CCP! This video highlights why we need the genius thinking and long game strategic management of the CCP around the entire world! That way, we won’t have to worry about global warming anymore because a lot of the worlds population will starve!
    3
  19. The thorough corruption of the CCP is a tremendous accomplishment of Wall Street! Yes, Wall Street funneled a lot of money to the CCP,, which has now thoroughly corrupted the CCP. It also resulted in a CCP economy and an infrastructure that is completely unsustainable for China that will collapse. Without a war, the CCP has been thoroughly defeated. That may well be worth trillions of dollars for the future of mankind.
    2
  20. Nice video! Thank you.
    2
  21. The United States NSA says “thank you“ to CCP!!! Chinese made hardware and operating systems will, of course, receives far less scrutiny to find security problems than the hardware and operating systems of the west. This will make them so much easier for the NSA to crack and to plant all kinds of malicious software inside of! Thank you CCP! As the NSA says “all hail the leadership of Xi Jinping and the CCP!“
    2
  22. Nice video! Thank you so much for making these videos. I think that your voice is important and getting the word out about what’s really happening in China and I think it is an important contribution. thank you!
    2
  23. Words alone will no longer suffice. As long as the Chinese Little People are concerned with paying off car loans and mortgages, the CCP will be able to control them with outright lies, empty promises, and false predictions. However, when large numbers of people in the major cities begin to starve, the CCP will need to resort to other measures.
    2
  24. Great video! Thank you. I’m not sure that I agree with the tone of your video that she’s in pain (xi Jinping) may actually be a figure that we could hope would lead the CCP to political reform. However, I do agree with what you say about the CCP: as far as I can tell the CCP views the Chinese people as livestock and treat them as such. I have no doubt that the CCP will butcher as many Chinese people as necessary (Thin the herd) in order to remain in absolute power. Livestock can’t really own property, don’t have any civil rights, and don’t have any human rights. And that is precisely the way that the CCP treats the Chinese people.
    2
  25. Great video! Thank you. Is there some rational reason behind the zero Covid policy of the CCP? Certainly such a policy is not going to succeed or even protect the Chinese people and actually seems in its implementation to be hurting the Chinese people more than anything else.
    2
  26. If Singapore is wise, they will confiscate the money of the CCP defectors and return the bodies of the CCP defectors and their families back to China where they can be turned into dog food at a great profit.
    2
  27. Be very careful what you wish for Lei. The CCP has lured hundreds of millions of Chinese people into big cities which are extremely complicated machines that require in order to work a constant flow of food, water, and electricity, inward, and an unimpeded flow of sewage and garbage outward. If the CCP falls, these machine cities will stop working almost immediately, and the people in them will begin starving and dying of thirst, covered in filth, and surrounded by heaps of garbage paralyzed with fear. As your expert pointed out, the groups that are most likely to remain effective if the CCP falls are the internal security forces that will begin to feed off of the population without restraint of local officials or the central government and they will rape and torture and kill tens of millions of Chinese people to ensure their own survival. If the CCP falls, it will likely take years before any replacement government arises that can restore social order. Be careful what you wish for, Lei.
    2
  28. Nice video! Thank you very much.
    2
  29. For the amusement of the West and for the eventual liberation of the Chinese people: Western media and western government should do everything possible to encourage infighting between factions within the CCP! The more that the CCP parasites fight one another, the closer and faster comes the day that the Chinese people will overthrow them.
    2
  30. Lei? Do you really think the boobs of the CCP are capable of devising complex strategies that will outfox the rest of the world? Please remember that these incredibly subtle deep thinkers of the CCP are the same people who starve tens of millions of people to death, during the great lead forward Who destroyed Chinese culture with the cultural revolution who destroyed the future of China with the one child policy, who oversaw the pollution of the air and water and land and food of all of China in the last 30 or 40 years and who allowed the real estate crisis to develop to a point where it may bring down all of the CCP. Are those the subtle thinkers that you think can devise Deep strategies that will outfox the rest of the world???
    2
  31.  @vincenttay2812  Would it make a difference?
    2
  32. Suggested Video: Why Did Xi Jinping Impose the "3 Red Lines" Policy? As a small-brain, short-term, weak thinking, fundamentally-corrupt bourgeois Westerner, I don't understand why the big-brain, long-game, mystically-powered, genius-thinkers of the CCP suddenly imposed the "3 Red Lines" policy?!? As a small-brain, short-term, weak-thinking, fundamentally corrupt bourgeois Westerner, what I think gave rise to the "3 Read Lines" policy that is now endangering the very existence of the CCP includes: 1. The CCP policy makers did not have adequate accurate information about the real financial situation of the Chinese real estate sector either because they were too lazy to go get or because the CCP had allowed for so much systematic corruption to thrive at all levels of Chinese government and business that the data was impossible to get. 2. If the CCP policy makers DID have the data (even if only a potion of it) then they did little or no analysis about the likely outcomes of imposing the "3 Red Lines" policy and cutting the Chinese real estate sector off from more borrowing that would have allowed them to cover up their precarious financial situation. 3. The CCP policy makers fastened onto the "3 Red Lines" policy to indulge their fascination with policies that look good on a bumper sticker and include a number in the name. 4. The CCP policy makers showed little or no imagination in different approaches to reducing the real estate bubble. For example, they could have quietly worked with the real estate companies to sell off non-core assets and businesses (while these were still attractive to other investors), speed up the completion of their building projects so they could access any escrow funds, and help them to do limited borrowing to refinance/restructure the most urgent debt repayments to avoid a huge loss in international investor confidence. 5. The CCP policy makers in the Xi Jinping faction imposed the "3 Red Lines" policy to embarrass and destroy the rival CCP factions with little or no regard to what the collapse of the Chinese real estate sector would do to endangering China and the CCP as a whole. Please help me understand! As a small-brain, short-term, weak-thinking, fundamentally corrupt bourgeois Westerner I want to bow down and - nay, kneel down and kowtow - to the big-brain, long-game, mystically-powered, genius thinkers of the CCP and surrender totally, abjectly, and apologetically but until I can understand the true genius of the "3 Red Lines" policy, I must admit I am hesitating - and for that I am truly very, very, very sorry and deserving of punishment!
    1
  33. Forcible insemination is the CCP answer! Consistent with their overall treatment of the Chinese people, the CCP should put all Chinese women in concentration camps where they can be inseminated by CCP officials! “Kinder Macht Freight!“. All hail the leader ship of Xi Jinping and the CCP!
    1
  34. Xi Jinping and the CCP are putting on a show? I look forward with great enthusiasm for Xi Jinping and the CCP to show us how they can breathe poison air, drink polluted water, and eat contaminated food! This will be a very wonderful show to see and one that Xi Jinping and the CCP are going to ask the Chinese people to participate in first hand. All hail the leadership of Xi Jinping and the CCP (unless of course you don’t like poisoned air, polluted water, or contaminated food).
    1
  35. Everything the CCP does is genius! Thank you, thank you, thank you! Thank you for explaining to a short term small brain totally corrupt bourgeois idiot Westerner like me how deep and subtle the moves of the CPP actually are! I would never have been able to figure this out myself! Now, could you please explain the deep, subtle strategy behind the one child policy that has ruined Chinese demographics for years to come? I mean, To me, a small brain Westerner, it looks like the CCP is full of stupid corrupt idiots who are constantly trying to enrich themselves at the expense of the Chinese people and who refuse ever to admit that they may have made a mistake. But that’s just me!
    1
  36. I certainly hope that things improve for the Chinese people! They are certainly living under one of the most evil regimes, the CCP right now! However, as I’ve said, before, I am pessimistic that the Chinese people can expect much that is good from the west. The west gets a very good deal right now with the CCP, essentially selling the services of the Chinese people as slaves and allowing for the pollution and degradation of the Chinese environment. The CCP as part of this deal gets plenty of money and power, and the Chinese people get oppression, unfreedom, pollution, sickness, lack of healthcare, bad food, lowered life, expectancy, etc.
    1
  37. Lei, two questions: First, who were the internal security forces most loyal to? Xi Jinping? The national CCP collective leader ship? The local provincial, CCP leader ship? Or to their paychecks and their power and us are willing to work for anyone who pays them more and gives them more power? second question, what is the relationship between the province, leader ship and the central government like? Are the provinces all led by relatively weak leaders who are addicted to the money from the central government? Are there any strong provincial leaders? I think it would be very interesting. If you did a video about the leader ship of the provinces, and whether or not any of the provinces might begin to act more independently, such as not sending the yearly money to the CCP in the national level.
    1
  38.  @donnydrumpf9563  I’m not surprised that you laugh so much! Truly, the CCP as a government is a joke! A very, very bad joke on the Chinese people who suffer under it, and he will continue to suffer under it until they exterminate every member of the government! For the sake of the Chinese people I hope this happen soon
    1
  39. I hope you are right, that she didn’t ping (Xi) is a “one trick pony“ who can do no better than to try and reuse a strategy of melted down.(Mao)
    1
  40. All hail the leadership of Xi Jinping and the CCP! No other nation in history has ever managed to so severely damage its demographics - a problem that China will suffer for the next 20 years or so at least - like the big-brain, long-game, deep-strategy, subtle-tactics, genius-level thinkers of the CCP! As a small-brain, short-term, ham-handed, clumsily-transparent, utterly corrupt bourgeois, moron-level thinker of the West, I, of course, will never grasp how great the CCP has made China's demographics! Truly, we small-brain, short-term, ham-handed, clumsily-transparent, utterly-corrupt bourgeois, moron-level thinkers of the West should just surrender now and line up (with the rest of the Chinese livestock people) to have our organs harvested for the exclusive benefit of the god-like CCP members! All hail the leadership of Xi Jinping and the CCP!
    1
  41.  @J_X999  Not trying to convince the CCP.
    1
  42.  @J_X999  Mostly expressing my anger that the Chinese people are stuck with the CCP and are the victims of their bad policies and apparent inability to learn from their mistakes such as realizing that the lockdowns are stupid and ineffective and changing their policies appropriately.
    1
  43.  @EquipoNitro1  True. It is discouraging that Western analyst seem to want to forget that the CCP isn't a democratically elected government, but a criminal organization that has killed 10s of millions in the past 75 years and will kill 10s of millions again if needed to stay in power.
    1
  44. The lockdowns are working! The lockdowns are working! The lockdowns are working! Soon China will be free of the greatest scourge that has ever victimized, the CCP and Xi Jinping!
    1
  45.  @canicetang8837  thank you, I think your answer is very thoughtful and very good. However I think that the fact that China is divided into provinces which are relatively independently governed under the overall leader ship of the CCP plays a major role in leading to the current situation where each province has been competing to industrialize itself as much as possible in order to make itself as rich as possible and to accomplish the goals of the central CCP with the net result that there’s been a huge amount of damage done to the arable land in China that probably cannot at this point be undone. Another area that I’m very interested in is the impact that so much urbanization is having on the quality of freshwater sources all over China. When it comes to air quality, you can affect that fairly quickly by stopping the cars and turning off the coal fired power plants, but water pollution takes decades to reverse as does the contamination of arable land. It would be interesting to know what the real trend lines are in China at this point with respect to water pollution and arable land contamination to get a feel for how rapidly things are going to deteriorate unless the CCP can make a major course change. Given the widespread corruption in the CCP I am not very hopeful that it will be able to save China from an even darker future.
    1
  46.  @sjv9147s  3 times - once on vacation and twice on life-changing visits. Of course my opinions on China may be wrong and, for the sake of the Chinese people, I sincerely hope they are but the more I learn about the CCP the less hopeful I am. That being said, I look forward with interest, curiosity, and a sincere desire to learn to see what tactic you will employ next to discredit my opinions.
    1
  47.  @randacnam7321  The question I have is as China's manufacturing revenue declines, will the Chinese people starve when the CCP can no longer buy large amounts of food abroad?
    1
  48. War with mortgage boycotters instead of war with America! Instead of starting a war with America (an external war) Xi Jinping could start a war on mortgage boycotters (And internal war) which would then lead to a new round of killing his enemies in the CCP in the name of ending corruption. An internal war would serve Xi Jinping‘s interest much better than an external war. Besides, the net result of a war on mortgage boycotters would be to restore faith in the real estate sector and to improve the finances of the provinces.
    1
  49. Have you forgotten the “red card“? When Mao faced opposition he created the “red guard“ to destroy it. Today, a much improved version of the “red guard“ is called “zero covid“. Unlike the “red guard“ of the past, the “zero Covid“ policy is much more controllable, much easier to direct i against specific enemies, and far easier to either accelerate or stop all together whenever needed. In the past, the average Chinese people did not matter to the CCP and they let millions of them die. Today the average Chinese people still do not matter to the CCP and they will be allowed to die in the millions or tens of millions as necessary in order to preserve the CCP. To think otherwise is very naive.
    1
  50. Xi is a WOMAN! Vlad is a MAN! Xi is a WOMAN! Vlad is a MAN! Xi is a WOMAN! Vlad is a MAN! A MAN takes what is his (Ukraine). Someone who can't take what is theirs (Taiwan) is a WOMAN. Does the CCP really want to be led by a WEAK, TREMBLING, WOMAN for 5 more years?
    1