Comments by "The Outhwaite3" (@theouthwaite3385) on "New Atheist Gad Saad DISMANTLED By Palestinian Analyst and Rabbi" video.

the problem is islam, katie. read the charter of hamas
1
@bikeserv what does the charter of hamas say they want to do to the jews?
1
@bikeserv there is only one charter written in 1988. there has been no revision according to hamas themselves. what does it say?
1
@bikeserv that is incorrect. the 2017 document did not replace the charter, according to hamas themselves. what does it say they want to do to the jews in the charter?
1
@bikeserv from the bbc- The new document, which Hamas says does not replace the charter, accepts the establishment of a Palestinian state within territories occupied by Israel in 1967 as a stage towards the "liberation" of all of historic Palestine west of the River Jordan."
1
@ correct. the 2017 document did not replace the charter. what does the charter say they want to do to the jews?
1
@bikeserv thats not an answer to my question. what does it say?
1
@ correct. and it did not replace the original charter, per hamas themselves. so what does it say?
1
@ i have asked you what the charter says they want to do to the jews 7 times but you have not answered.
1
@ if you answered the question, you would know that is not true, hence the reason for the question. for starters- 'israel will exist and will continue to exist until islam will obliterate it"
1
@ article 7. what do the rocks and trees say?
1
@ not an answer- article 7 says they want to unalive the jews. summarized, as YT wont allow the actual wording. do you know where that part comes from?
1
@bikeserv i'll answer. its from a hadith. islam as a reason for what hamas is doing is all over their charter, in their own words. its not my opinion. they say god wants them to unalive the jews and thats exactly what they did. it was the biggest unaliving of the jews since ww2, according to them, because god wants them to do this. but ms halper thinks thats not a problem.
1
@ katie halper says this has nothing to do with islam, yet hamas says it does
1
@ there is no 'revised' charter. there is only one, according to hamas. and it contains 1400 year old religious verses calling for them to unalive the jews. hamas says this is about religion. katie halper does not. katie halper is wrong.
1
@ islam is all over the 2017 document as well, btw.
1
@bikeserv its not a charter and ive read it and islam is all over the 2017 document.
1
@bikeserv it is not a charter according to hamas. it is a slightly less openly genocidal document than the charter. but even if it were a new charter, it still gives islam as a reason for its actions- a belief system riddled with anti semitism and calls for violence against the jews and other people- which katie halper seems to think is not a problem.
1
@ i have read it. my post was in response to the video where katie halper claims this conflict is not religious. hamas does not agree with her. what 'conversation' are you talking about?
1
@bikeserv its not a revised charter, according to hamas themselves. what does article 15 have to do with the point?
1
@bikeserv read it. my point is that islam is all over both the charter and the 2017 document, the former citing religious texts calling for the unaliving of the jews. unfortunately you dont get to edit texts, as they are considered to be from god. meaning, that is, in fact, what they believe. i also dont believe 10 7, the biggest unlaiving in a single day of these people since the holocaust . was a coincidence. yes, religion is at the source of this conflict, according to hamas themselves
1
@ the organization cites religious texts that calls repeatedly for the unaliving of the jews. then they do it.
1
@bikeserv netanyahu said they were trying to fool the world by appearing to soften their image. he was obviously correct on this point.
1
@ do you think its more logical that they really did soften their stance, but then committed the oct 7th attacks, or that they never actually softened their stance and they meant what they said when they said they wanted to unalive the jews ?
1
@bikeserv you choose to post or choose not to post. we have Israel living next to a group of people who believe they have a religious duty to unalive them and will be rewarded for it. how do you propose they deal with those people?
1
@ thats not an answer to anything i've posted . do you think hamas softened their stance given what they did october 7th? (which was the largest unaliving of the jews since ww2)
1
@bikeserv what do you want to know?
1
@ kid deaths before oct 7th? yes
1
@bikeserv how many killed by israel or hamas?
1
@bikeserv west bank or gaza?
1
@bikeserv The proportion of Palestinian women and children being killed in the Israel-Hamas war appears to have declined sharply, an Associated Press analysis of Gaza’s Hamas-run health ministry data, which cannot be verified, has found. This trend coincides both with Israel’s changing battlefield tactics and contradicts the Hamas-run ministry’s own public statements. The trend is significant because the death rate for women and children is the best available proxy for civilian casualties in the conflict. In October, when the war began following Hamas’s October 7 onslaught, it was above 60 percent. In April, it was below 40%. Yet the shift went unnoticed for months by the United Nations and much of the media, and the Gazan health ministry has made no effort to set the record straight. Israel faces heavy international criticism over the level of reported civilian casualties in Gaza and questions about whether it has done enough to prevent them in an eight-month-long war that shows no sign of ending. Jerusalem vehemently denies the charges, saying it is taking unprecedented measures to reduce civilian casualties, and that the combatant-to-civilian ratio is relatively low even according to the unverified figures issued by Hamas-run authorities. The figures make no distinction between civilians and combatants, and include Gazans killed by hundreds of misfired Palestinian rockets that landed inside the Strip. The AP analysis highlights facts that have been overlooked and could help inform the public debate, said Gabriel Epstein, a research assistant at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy who has also studied the Health Ministry data.
1
@bikeserv what do you mean?
1
@bikeserv An estimated 5,500 children have been killed in the Gaza Strip since October 7, according to Gaza’s government media office, amid widespread airstrikes by the Israeli military. Hundreds more are reported missing and may be trapped under the rubble. Since October 7, one child in Gaza has been killed every 10 minutes on average according to human rights watch
1
@ depends on the source. HRW says 5500 in 2023
1
@bikeserv The IDF estimates that 9,000 terrorists were killed so far. The Hamas-run Gaza Ministry of Health claims 23,000 Palestinians were killed, the Ministry doesn’t differentiate between actual civilians and combatants merely posing, or civilians killed by Hamas themselves. The ratio is a staggering 1.5:1, the lowest casualty rate ever recorded in history. The UN estimates the global average to be an astonishing 9:1
1
@bikeserv 38 according to save the children international
1
@bikeserv i believe hamas figures dont distinguish between combatants and civilians
1
@bikeserv as i posted above, the civilian death toll for this conflict is unprecedented. if you are determining moral superiority based on death toll, the Germans would be the 'good' guys in ww2
1
@bikeserv we dont know the actual numbers?
1
@bikeserv i used to think retaliating created new combatants, but i dont now. one example- in 2005 israel forcibly pulled every jewish person out of gaza and left the palestians to do as they wished with the land. it didnt go so well. i'll post more below in case yt deletes.
1
@bikeserv you understand that the islam teaches that any land once occupied by islam belongs to islam forever even if its conquered by other people? this is why they have never accepted a two state solution.
1
@bikeserv why did israel blockade gaza?
1
@bikeserv thats not an answer. after israel left gaza (egypt didnt want gaza back), the Palestinians elected a group that has in its charter the unaliving of the jews. hamas then launched thousands of rockets into gaza. then israel blockaded gaza. of course if you launch rockets into another country, they might blockade you.
1
interesting. who built the temple mount?
1
anti muslim bigotry? example please?
1