Comments by "Vladimir Bogorad" (@vlbogorad) on "Forbes Breaking News"
channel.
-
33
-
3
-
3
-
2
-
Mr. Elon Musk, I've got a better idea on Crimea. Please, don't ignore, I have been a lawyer for 40 years, the last twenty years a California attorney. I present the proposal in two languages.
There is a way out of the impasse in Crimea, if bias is discarded. Crimea should belong to both countries. Crimea has never been part of an independent Russian state as it exists today. Crimea belonged to the people inhabiting Russia and Ukraine, when these territories were part of the USSR, and when they were part of the Russian Empire. The current state border between Ukraine and Crimea is the same injustice as if such a border were between Russia and Crimea. In international law, there is the concept of condominium (condominium) - an entity over which two states exercise sovereignty and possession. For example, Pheasant Island, owned by France and Spain, under the Treaty of the Pyrenees in 1659, after the Thirty Years' War. Russia cannot afford to be in international isolation for thirty years. It must move towards a compromise. The whole world sees that Crimea was not rightfully annexed, and this curse cannot hang over Russia forever. Firstly, Crimea was annexed on the basis of an illegal referendum in one region. In the Constitution of every country, including Russia and Ukraine, it is written that the separation of any territory is possible only by popular vote. The whole country. Otherwise, if each region could choose the country to which it would like to join, not a single state would have survived. Ask Putin, if tomorrow they vote on Sakhalin to surrender to Japan, will they let him go? The way he let go of Chechnya. .Secondly, Crimea was annexed in violation of the 1994 Budapest Memorandum, which Russia signed and under which it pledged to respect the territorial integrity of Ukraine in exchange for renunciation of nuclear weapons. In Russia, lackeys on all channels repeat that Russia should not comply with this document, because it has not been ratified by Russia. Lies. The absence of ratification does not exempt Russia from fulfilling its obligations. Article 15 of the Federal Law of the Russian Federation "On International Treaties" dated July 15, 1995 states that ratification is required if it is provided for by the international treaty itself. However, the Budapest Memorandum, according to its text, does not require ratification. On the contrary, at the end of this document it is clearly stated that it comes into force immediately after signing.
Vladimir Bogorad, Esq.
Из тупика по Крыму есть выход, если отбросить предвзятость. Крым должен принадлежать обеим странам. Крым никогда не был частью независимого российского государства в том виде, в каком оно существует сейчас. Крым принадлежал людям населяющим Россию и Украину, когда эти территории входили в состав СССР, и когда они входили в состав Российской империи. Нынешняя государственная граница между Украиной и Крымом - такая же несправедливость, как если бы такая граница проходила между Россией и Крымом. В международном праве есть понятие condominium (кондоминиум) - образование, над которым осуществляют суверенитет и владение два государства. Например, Pheasant Island, которым владеют Франция и Испания, по Пиренейскому договору 1659 года, после тридцатилетней войны. Россия не может позволить себе находиться тридцать лет в международной изоляции. Надо двигаться к компромиссу. Весь мир видит, что Крым присоединили не по праву, и это проклятие не может висеть над Россией вечно. Во-первых, Крым присоединили на основе незаконного референдума в одном регионе. В Конституции каждой страны, включая Россию и Украину, записано, что отделение любой территории возможно только всенародным голосованием. Всей страны. Иначе, если бы каждый регион мог выбирать страну, к которой хотел бы примкнуть, ни одно государство не устояло бы. Спросите Путина, если завтра на Сахалине проголосуют отдаться Японии, отпустит? Так, как он отпустил Чечню. Во-вторых, Крым присоединили в нарушение Будапештского Меморандума 1994 г., который Россия подписала и по которому обязалась соблюдать территориальную целостность Украины в обмен на отказ от ядерного оружия. В России холуи на всех каналах повторяют, что этот документ Россия не должна выполнять, потому что он Россией не ратифицирован. Враньё. Отсутствие ратификации не освобождает Россию от выполнения её обязательства. В статье 15 федерального Закона РФ «О международных договорах» от 15 июля 1995 г. сказано, что ратификация требуется, если она предусмотрена самим международным договором. Однако Будапештский Меморандум, по его тексту, не требует ратификации. Наоборот, в конце этого документа ясно сказано, что он вступает в силу сразу после подписания.
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
Vladimir Bogorad, Former Assistant Minister of Justice of Russia
Putin says he is afraid of NATO missiles on his borders. But NATO has been at these borders for a long time from Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, NATO members. It's not actually about NATO. NATO is just a pretext for expansion against neighbors. To take over Ukraine. Shame on Carlson. He pressed his lips to the boots of the new Hitler. Does he know that, like in the 30s in Germany, thousands of people are in the new Gulag for calling for peace? Does he know that, like in the 30s in Germany, Putin shoots and poisons his critics, not only in his own country, but also abroad? Does he know that, like in the 30s in Germany, Putin closed all media that did not praise him? Does he know that, like in the 30s in Germany, Putin declared all the best writers and publicists in Russia enemies, how many minds he squeezed out of Russia? Does he know that, just like in the 30s in Germany, in Russia books are burned, performances and concerts of any performers who do not support the war are banned. Does he know that, like in the 30s in Germany, Putin raped the constitution in order to be elected to a fifth term? Does he know that, like in the 30s in Germany, Putin turned his parliament into a herd of sheep obedient to his will. Does he know that Putin is hiding from his impoverished people everything he earns from selling oil in order to build rockets and create new weapons of death? Does Carson know that Putin ruined hundreds of thousands of young lives in this war for his idiotic ambitions? Do you know how many people he has made miserable in life?
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1
-
1