Comments by "John Walsh" (@johnwalsh4857) on "Putin Does Not Think Russia is Winning" video.

  1. as I said earlier, the Russians cannot seem to maintain a large offensive like they carried out with 100K men and 900 tanks in Kharkov oblast. which started in July 19, 2023. within a week it already bogged down and stopped, mainly due to its logistics cannot hammered by Storm Shadows , HMARs JDAMs. Cluster bombs, as I said before, the Russians offensive is far from their rail head and have to truck in their supplies to their units unfortunately the area have a few good roads, its mainy open field intersped by hills and forests. and the Ukrainians heavilly mined the open fields. the Russians lost a lot of trucks and trains at their rail heads got blasted. the Russians several days ago tried to improve the situatikon by railing it lots of trucks but obviously this failed probably got destroyed in their trains by Ukr missle and JDAM strikes. So the Ukrs tried to contain the offnesive which they knew was going to happen by doing JDAM and missle strikes on their logistics but it was too few and failed. So the when the Russians attacked, the Ukrs were in prepared entrenchments and the Russians were attacking uphill since the Ukrs were in high ground. While the Russians lost a lot they were still able to inflict heavy losses on the Ukrs but the Ukrs retreated and the Russians tore a 8 kilometer hole in the Ukr lines however due to poor logistics the Russians were not able to exploit the hole which the Ukrs quickly plugged. and the Ukrs have been counterattacking pushing the Russians back and here the Russian are on the defensive with low supplies. However the Russians are kept alive with heavy air and artllery support slowing down the Ukrainians. Interesting the motive of the Russian offensive in Kharkov oblast, seeing the Russian high command still does not have a grasp on the limitations of their logistics along tranpostation of their supplies which suck bad and the Ukrs strategy on concentrating on their logisics for missle and JDAM strikes. and the Russians probably either thought the Ukrs have most of their reserves focused on taking the South and little reserves in the area or the Russians are trying to distract the Ukrs from dealing a death blow to their defenses in the South. Now Its interesting if the Russians actually have viable reserves to counteract the Ukr push in the South. if the Ukrs manage to breakthru Russian lines in the south and they dont have much reserves then the Russians are toast and you will see a collapse of the Russian southern defense lines.
    1
  2. Igor Girkin got shut up since the Russian MOD and probably Putin himself got sick and tired of his realism and yah while Igor gerkin is a ahole mass murdering fanatic war criminal who should fall out of a window, he is a realist at his core and tells it as it is. Russia is losing this war, and they dont want any Russian mil blogger tellng them the truth.
    1