Comments by "J Nagarya" (@jnagarya519) on "College Presidents say calling for Jewish genocide is allowed" video.

We get it, Stefanik: Israel can do no wrong.
8
How about the Jew who murdered the 6-year-old Palestinian? We don't hear anything about that; but we still hear about October 7 as excuse for everything thereafter -- about which latter we aren't to criticize. Dead and decomposing infants were found in the Gaza hospital that the IDF forced to be abandoned. But they don't matter because they are Palestinian.
8
@kinggrantking Stefanik's premises are FALSE.
4
@jamessilver6429 Trump and his MAGA dupes.
4
@pjpj2639 Tell it to Netanyahu and his fellow criminal fanatics.
3
@ryanjacobs836 If the PREMISES on which the ARGUMENT is based are false, then the ARGUMENT COLLAPSES.
2
@zxbc1 David is wrong on this one. He is not only buying into the propaganda that Israel is only ever the VICTIM but promulgated that same falsehood. Israel KNEW of the planned Hamas attack FOR A YEAR before it occurred -- but DID NOT PREPARRE for it. But that's Netanyahu's strategy: provoke or allow an attack, then exploit the attack with calculated "hysteria" as excuse to clear more land of non-Jews and annex the cleared land. Hamas is a terrorist organization -- so what explains Netanyahu's support and funding of it? Because BOTH are OPPOSED to the two state solution against the PLO, which is FOR that solution. David is wrong on this one because he ignores and omits basic known facts such as those.
1
It's about freedom of speech when PRO-Israel THUGS DOX -- which is TERRORISM -- Harvard students for exercising their right to protest against Israeli FOREIGN POLICY, which policy EXPRESSLY VIOLATES INTERNATIONAL LAW.
1
Colleges are where every side of controversial issues can be discussed -- see First Amendment. And where Stanik claims to see anti-Semitism against Jews she is ignoring the anti-Semitism against Palestinians. Do you not recall the DOXING of Harvard students by anti-First Amendment pro-Israelis for SIMPLY PROTESTING the actions of Israel against INNOCENT Gazans? Criticism of Israeli foreign policy is not anti-Semitism.
1
What about the pro-Israel "protesters" who weren't on any campus but DOXXED -- that is TERRORISM -- Harvard students who were exercising their right to protest against Israel's actions?
1
LEARN THE HSITORY -- it is NOT a simpleton's "Yes" or "No" question. Israel's President Herzog PUBLICLY said that there is no difference between Hamas and Palestinians -- which is a L-I-E. Netanyahu PUBLICLY DECLARED that Israel's policy in Gaza is COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT -- which was declared a WAR CRIME because it was used by the Nazis against JEWS. I'll believe Jewess Stefanik's "concern" about ALLEGED anti-Semitism when she goes after Trump -- who she SUPPORTS -- who is overtly anti-Semitic: recall his statement that the Neo-Nazis in Charlottesville were "very fine people".
1
@lauralishes1 You're falling for the CON. It is not that simple a question. FOREMOST, BOTH Jews and Palestinians are SEMITES. So against which Semite are YOU the anti-Semite?
1
@koheletsmoger2327 There are victims on BOTH sides. And it was 1,400 Israelis, not 14,000. But so far the killed Palestinians, including women, children, toddlers, and infants, is circa 19,000. LEARN THE HISTORY: since its founding, using the "Bible" they wrote as their "deed," Israel, which calls itself a democratic JEWISH state -- if you aren't Jewish you don't have the same rights -- has been CLEARING THE LAND of those in the region who are NOT Jewish, and then annexing the land to Israel. It is at least as bad in the West Bank, where Jewish settlers kill Palestinians and are not prosecuted by Israel. That's the underlying issue: the far-right -- Herzog and Netanyahu are OPPOSED to the second state solution, which is why NETANYAHU supported and funded HAMAS against the PLO -- because the PLO is FOR a two-state solution, but HAMAS is OPPOSED to it. On BOTH sides there are FANATICS -- Netanyahu's gov't and political party are as fanatical as Hamas. The DIFFERENCE is that Israel has all the modern weapons, but Hamas has the equivalent of rocks and spears. SOME of that is reported WITHING ISRAEL by ISRAELI media. That's where we got the reports that Israel knew about the planned Hamas attack A YEAR AGO but DID NOTHING to prepare for it. Why? Because Israel provokes, or allows such attacks, then exploits them behind the calculated hysteria that is their invocation of the Holocaust. Israel wants all focus to be on October 7 -- and on NOTHING after that date. The world was sympathetic to Israel because of what occurred on that date. But THE WHOLE WORLD IS WATCHING and Israel is LOSING the war. All they are doing is easily predicted: creating MORE terrorists and thus PERPETUATING THE PROBLEM. The ALTERNATIVE is the two state solution.
1
You know nothing about the issue; Stefanik, who is a Jew, is playing you like a fiddle -- while at the same time she supports OVERT anti-Semite Trump.
1
So you believe everything you "hear" because a REPUBLICAN says it!? You'll be voting for the ANTI-SEMITIC TRUMP because Stefanik, a Jew, ALSO supports him!?
1
@deenman23 I doubt it happened except perhaps as a challenge to Israeli and SOME Jewish HYPOCRISY: Israel has been colonialist and expansionist since its founding -- despite its word not to be. It has, since its founding, driven anyone not Jewish off their lands, and then annexed the lands to Israel. And if the non-Jews REFUSED to give up their lands, they were killed by means called ETHNIC CLEANSING/GENOCIDE. The world was sympathetic to Israel on October 7. But as it has watched it has become increasingly horrified by Israels total disregard for the very international law it wants imposed on everyone else. Israel is yet again committing mass slaughter of Palestinians, and thereby creating MORE terrorists. Israel is DELIBERATELY creating more of that they CLAIM they are against: TERRORISM. Because it is TERRORISM that is then used as a pretext to drive Palestinians off their lands, and if they won't be driven off then killed off. Stop being a sucker for the Israeli's extremist right-wing propaganda using calculated "hysteria".
1
@oliver_twistor We got her question -- it is a fake defense of Israel to oversimplify the issue in order to prevent criticism of Israel's public declaration of the WAR CRIME of COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT and ETHNIC CLEANSING against the Palestinians -- and not only in Gaza. You'll note she ISN'T asking about the threats against Palestinians and Muslims. It MATTERS that an elderly Jew was killed at a protest -- but IT DOES NOT matter that a JEW murdered a 6-year-old Palestinian boy. So, yes, it is about Israel -- and the calculated hysteria, the propaganda, intended to distract from the slaughter in which Israel is engaged in Gaza.
1
@oliver_twistor It is about Israel, because it is Israel that is about COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT -- a WAR CRIME -- in Gaza. They are about GENOCIDE against anyone in the region who isn't Jewish -- and have been doing the same thing, over and over again, since the founding of Israel: clearing the land of non-Jews, and "annexing" the cleared land. And any criticism of their ACTIONS is met with calculated hysteria about the Holocaust -- which included the use of COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT against the Jews. If it was wrong for the Nazis to do it, then why is it okay for Israel to do it? You need to learn the HISTORY of Israel's ETHNIC CLEANING/GENOCIDE against no-Jewish SEMITES in the region, instead of responding exclusively to one instance of a REPUBLICAN who supports FASIST TRUMP deliberately demanding a "Yes" or "No" to a question which is more complicated than she pretends and than you understand.
1
@moniqueshannon8442 Because it's a setup. Stefanik is Jewish and supports Trump. Trump is an anti-Semite. You won't hear her questioning Trump about his overt anti-Semitism. It's an opportunity to smear Democrats -- and EDUCATION -- while opposing aid to the Jewish president of Ukraine. It's all about separating the Jewish voters from the Democratic Party. The issue of what is happening on college campuses is being distorted -- no one is being "hysterical" about the pro-Israeli protests against Palestinians. No Republican is condemning the pro-Israel DOXXING of Harvard students for protesting Israel's publicly-declared COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT against Gazan Palestinians. No Republican is condemning Israeli President Herzog who publicly asserted that there is no difference between Hamas and Palestinians. Or condemning the discovery of dead and decomposing Palestinian infants found in the ICU in the Gaza hospital that the IDF forced the Palestinians to abandon.
1
But the WAR CRIME of COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT in pursuit of ETHNIC CLEANSING -- ACTUAL GENOCIDE -- is taboo to speak of when done by Israel to Palestinians because Jews were victims of COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT during WW II. THE WHOLE WORLD IS WATCHING, and Israel is LOSING this war. And let's not pretend you know anything about what occurs on college campuses, or the line between protected speech and over-the-line. Look at the incitements of death threats and violence by your felonious "hero" Trump and how much he's allowed to get away with.
1
@bennuinspace6688 Some will believe any political grandstanding if done by a Republican. Stefanik supports anti-Semitism both against the Palestinians and by supporting anti-Semite Trump.
1
Then you should be criticizing, foremost, Israel President Herzog, who publicly asserted that there is no difference between Hamas and Palestinians. And Netanyahu, who publicly declared Israel's policy is COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT of EVERYONE in Gaza. Only those who are ignorant of the full history on BOTH sides have the luxury or unquestioningly swallowing the Stefanik propaganda. Stefanik, a Jew, pretends to be against anti-Semitism while fully supporting overt anti-Semite Trump. Remember his, "There are very fine people -- on BOTH sides"? -- one side of which were anti-Semites self-identified as NEO-NAZIS. Those are the people Trump praised -- those chanting, "Jews will not replace us!"
1
@TheSongsmythe Except when Israel engages in it against the stateless Semite Palestinians -- then the hate of Muslims (some Palestinians are Christians) erupts, and the dumb-assed fall in line with Israel's propaganda of calculated "hysteria". So the infants found dead and decomposing in the ICU of the Gaza hospital that the IDF forced the Palestinians to abandon DON'T MATTER. ONLY Israel can do no wrong -- after all, they invented the "God" that said what they wanted it to say: that the Jews -- unlike everyone else -- are the "Chosen People".
1
COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT is GENOCIDE. As of October 7, NETANYAHU PUBLICLY DECLARED AND IMPLEMENTED COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT AGAINST GAZA. COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT was declared a WAR CRIME because the Nazis used it AGAINST THE JEWS. Why is ISRAEL EXEMPT from that rule of law? Because IT says so, and BULLSHITS you into believing they are?
1
@Fern00352 Trump directly incites death threats against people he attacks -- and yet dealing with that by gag order is COMPLICATED. But when it comes to dealing with Israel's calculated hysteria and propaganda, it is so very, very simple for the SIMPLETON'S who buy into the Israeli propaganda that they are ALWAYS the VICTIMS. Israel knew of the planned Hamas attack A YEAR AGO, but did NOTHING to prepare for it. That's why IN ISREAL Netanyahu is viewed as part of the PROBLEM: HIS gov't has supported and funded Hamas AGAINST the PLO because BOTH Hams and his gov't OPPOSE the two state solution, whereas the PLO is FOR that solution. those who fall for Israel's propaganda don't know the history, don't understand how Netanyahu's gov't PROVOKES incidents in order to EXPLOIT them by slaughtering MORE Palestinians and grabbing MORE land.
1
No, it doesn't violate the code. Defending Israel's ongoing genocide against the Palestinians is THE NORM.
1
Because the FIRST AMENDMENT protects POLITICAL speech above all other speech. Why are the pro-Israel TERRORISTS who DOXXED Harvard student protesters not being condemned? Because they are carrying out Israel's propaganda IN THE US. And too many Americans don't know the history of Israel vis-a-vis everyone NOT Jewish in the Middle East. And within Israel itself.
1
@postiepaul Did the Republican ask the college presidents about the DOXXING -- which is TERRORISM -- of Harvard student protesters by the pro-Israel gang of non-college individuals? Nah -- and the Republican supports anti-Semite Trump.
1
@09BiGDylan Have YOU EARD the ACTUAL talk? Or are you a sucker for Republican extremism? What about the pro-Israel DOXXING of Harvard students simply because the Harvard students were protesting against Israeli FOREIGN POLICY that VIOLATES INTERNATIONAL LAW?
1
@KH_FYM Stefanik, a Republican, is distorting and exploiting the situation for all its worth to her. She also supports OVERTLY anti-Semitic Trump. So she isn't opposed to anti-Semitism -- it's something she can EXPLOIT for political purposes. It's just a game to her, and an opportunity to smear education and alleged "liberals". And, more to the point, attack and suppress views of which she disapproves, just like a good little Nazi. She's the female Gym Jordan. And to think that people actually fall for it!
1
She is wrong because she is denying equal protection of the laws to everyone but the Jews whose votes she is seeking.
1
She is "anti"-Semitic in this instance -- she is Jewish. But she also supports Trump, who is OVERTLY anti-Semitic. "There were fine people -- on BOTH sides!" -- Trump. One of those sides were the anti-Semites carrying torches and chanting: "Jews will not replace us!"
1
@noamkoren7390 Calling for genocide is not the same as committing genocide. But look at Israel by that same measure: Israeli President Herzog publicly asserted that there is no difference between Hamas and Palestinians -- which includes ALL Palestinians including toddlers and infants. Israel's Netanyahu declared as official Israeli gov't policy COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT against the Palestinians -- ALL of them -- in Gaza. COLLECTIVE PUNISHMENT was declared a WAR CRIME because it was used by the Nazis against the JEWS. What makes it okay for Jews -- and no one else -- to commit war crimes?
1
@noamkoren7390 No: you have Stefanik, a Jew, who supports ANTISEMITE Trump, MAKING ACCUSATIONS without a shred of EVIDENCE. Aren you STILL ignorant of the fact that HATE SPEECH is STANDARD for Republicans. And that Republicans REJECT the ide of "hate speech" when THEY want to do it. No, illiterate jackass, I don't "skip over" anything -- I leave it to the suckers for Israeli propaganda against the facts to "skip over" the fact that -- as example -- Israel KNEW about the planned Hamas attack FOR A YEAR BEFORE IT HAPPENED, but did NOTHING to PREPARE for it. Instead Israel ALLOWED IT TO HAPPEN so they'd have a pretext to invade Gaza and kill more Palestinians. They've been doing the same thing over and over and over again since their founding; and every time you fools fall for their blaming of their VICTIMS.
1
@noamkoren7390 Israel is the SOURCE of not only the problem, but also of the "argument" and the PROPAGANDA you are repeating AGAINST freedom of speech WITHIN THE UNITED STATES. In the US were operate according to the RULE OF LAW, not against foreign anti-democratic propaganda that attacks US rule of law. Stefanik is a fraud -- her purpose is to defend the GENOCIDE against the SEMITE Palestinians. The rest of the world is not BULLSHITTED by your repetition of the HATE ALWAYS being aimed at Muslims and, in this instance, Palestinians, generated by the extremist right-wing Israeli gov't. THE WHOLE WORLD IS WATCHING, and Israel is LOSING this war. All it has succeeded in doing is creating MORE terrorists and anti-Semitism -- the OPPOSITE of what it CLAIMS to want.
1
Anti-Muslim/Palestinian propaganda in the US is also a "dark day". Learn the history so you can see through the propaganda.
1
@pjpj2639 ISRAEL doesn't want the world to hear that. And its propaganda based on calculated "hysteria" has been successful in the short term. But the WHOLE WROLD IS WATCHING and seeing the HORROR being inflicted by Israel for what it is and Israel is LOSING the war. Israel does the same thing again and again and again: PROVOKES violent response, seeks REVENGE, and by that means creates more terrorists. And throughout makes excuses as if it is the ONLY victim of those repetitions. The WORLD is seeing through it this time.
1
Backing Israel's genocide against the Palestinians is the NORM.
1