Comments by "May L" (@MeiinUK) on "" video.
-
3
-
1
-
@bluesclues132 : Sorry... but in the UK, it is a circular economy. So those who have to pay for school fees, are only doing so, cos it was the previous generation's tax which went round, and some got free education. This is how things work in the UK. China is the same too. You assume, that these people are not using any state money, but they are. And some generation before them had already provided the taxes which went round generation to generation. Even with China's one belt one road initiative.. I think you misunderstand that it is supposed to benefit you. Cos they are not benefitting you.... This is why the entire world is stopping them from doing this. As at the moment, ALL, or MOST of the money... are tied with extortionately HIGH interest rates and returns.... OBOR means, the money which the chinese had earned, are going to be fizzled out of the country. So these people, are going to be even more poorer.. Cos they will and never shall ever see the money, which the people generated. Most countries, do not let their own money released out of the country. No country does this. When there is a trade, it is supposed to come back... It goes out and it comes back.... You think that it is supposed to go out and never comes back ???? You are shaming your own country, a lot. Because you have no understanding of how things work.
1
-
1
-
@斛律金-c4e : After the formation of the "PRC"... and that "ROC" gave up the UN level seats.... "Western" countries have absolutely NO jurisdiction, what-so-ever actually.... in China. What it DOES do... is to check whether the membership of the UN, and its associated laws, and rules are upheld. So far, China has not upheld them, actually.... THIS is the problem. It is BECAUSE of the UN's remits, and clauses, that PRC is doing these kind of work... In the name "of the PRC Government"... But on the other hand, so many do not see the country as having an actual government. Some in government, do not even know their own responsibility either !!! These people... were from previous centuries' actual.... descendents... and lived off grid.. and remote for an awfully long long long time. And it is not part of the original civilisation which made up of China. Or the Middle Kingdom. This is why, so many inside of China, refuses to acknowledge these people, and their actual land AND boundaries, as part of China either ! This is why the clause of these areas classified as "autonomous", because in truth, they DO have a civilisation structure, and an actual "Kingdom" of their own !!!! If they have their own Kingdom, then it means that China is now stealing ! This means, PRC is stealing, under the pressure of the UN memberships.. and most of the members from the West sitting inside the UN meetings.... This is actually quite unacceptable.
1
-
1
-
1
-
@kevinchen7903 : You have to understand a lot of things. A lot of so called "Tribes" or "clans" may live remotely... and some of them, were actually so called "army units", or people who fought for their dynasty in the past generation and settled in that area. It is modern day words to describe them as tribes. What is missing... from then, til the now, is the continous hardwork to keep a civilisation going. Or a society going. In many South America.. Many tribes deliberately "hide" from Western civilisation... But they live the best lives in the Amazon. China's tribes, if they were originally nomadic ones, should be supported.. So that they do not lose any of their so called skillset.. To live with the land. Many of these tribes, can live off the land, for free. Without paying a single penny. Did you know that ? It is now the pressure on the CCP government, to migrate a "thriving community", into an actual urban area.. Some of them cannot cope. They do not even know the concept of money, never mind the concept of interest rates.. Or to even work for someone else, in a white-collar job. There are so so SO many movies, made from the US, above this bridging of gaps... between extremely nomadic life, to that of an advanced society and country. Should it ? Can it ? Really, should it ?? If you look at even cities like HK, so many are sentimental of the past old village life. Of not paying extortionate amount on accommodation costs... So many people screws up the calculations. So a generation is to be blackmailed ? Is this how life is supposed to be ?!!? Wake up. If these tribes or clans can survive... in a rural way. Then they must not be disturbed !!! Capitalism is not for everybody... with it, comes responsibilities too. So many people also misuse money... and it still kills of a population, or a generation.
1
-
@stefanosong9314 : The reason about Uyghurs, is that, when ROC took over China, it wanted to recognise the part that was genuinely Chinese. That is Han's China. There are maps out there which states "China proper" in English. It is the extension of the "Manchuria, Mongolia, and various other regions".. that PRC defined.. and I do not even know when CCP took control and was the status quo party to run the country. Cos that was not actually accepted and acknowledged by everybody.... And now, so called CCP acting as if they are the only single party of the entire country, acting part like a government department, and part like a... political party.. I do not know which.. It is like, those who have memberships... are learning on the job ??? So therefore, those regions... were actually part of their own civilisation, and does not belong to China. So as you can see... it is memberships of a group... they call themselves "CCP"... and by right of Western media's supports.. and those Western government's supports... Managed to actually bully those regions, and areas... Some of those regions, were actual mongolians, or descendents, or a mixed racial civilisation... If you read the history books, then you would know who these people are.
It is this ignorant generation, and the so called "burn the books, revolution"... managed to bulldoze over those regions as well... One day, if those regions has arms... and guns... China will not be so funny doing what they are doing. Just one day... If Tibet also, is no longer.. "religious" and piety... and they held guns as well. Things shall change.
1
-
1
-
@nickg1895 : This is not true. A lot of land are owned by families.. and those families, earned them from previous generation of working for... and paid taxes and rent to the imperial dynasties... So this is legitimate, and it belongs to them. If and when it is finished, and of no use, then the government can take it back. But nobody can force these families to give it up... It is the pressure of so called "UN laws" and various other laws, that is overriding this fundamental part of Chinese history and heritage !!! So stoppit !!!! So many families are made homeless... even in HK. Some families go as far back as the Ming dynasties.. they worked their lands off already... and should be able to earn money wherever they wish to do so.. and bring back home the bacon !!! A lot of families can live off rural land without paying anything to the country. Did you not know this ?? Some people wants to make money, and use land to borrow against the bank and then give back... I think you do not know China that much... It is not what you think and assume. And some so called "media" are just BSing on issues that they have no understanding of.... In fact, Taiwan has taken away a lot of factual evidences.. and kept it under lock and key, just to prove this fact. And now, more and more people are putting forward, legitimate items to prove legitimacies.. and the history of China.. and none of this "I say, you say" and argue business...
1
-
@nickg1895 : Where ? In Pingyao ??? I do not know who or what is CCP... To me, the Hans chinese culture is gone.... Lineage, legitimacies, Confuscianism.... I feel that, CCP is like, another layer, embedded within the Hans system... and they just behave in that atypical Mongolian way. I can conquer and take as I like. Some people say, for the sake of the country, or that collective consciousness... or that communal ideas... But I mean... Do you have links ? This is so BAD.
You need to read wiki about the city. It seems like, they want to preserve it, do they not ? IT is a city of 50k people. (Isn't this small by china's standard ? This is smaller than the city I live in.) Apparently it dates as far back as the Qin dynasty... and it seems like a historical town. It is trying to preserve itself...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pingyao
To me, it is important that, they preserve the people who lives there...
"12,132 residents held local hukous and 36,399 were from other parts of China."
1
-
It is time that these countries are independent and hold their own budget, and their own government. This is not China's issue any more. It is with sadness that, the fights and conflicts in the Northern part of the country, had caused heartaches for centuries and centuries and centuries... to see dying citizens.. to see families breaking up... to see poverty, even though those families had been helping the imperial dynasty rise.. only to be cheated out of their past honor. Humiliated, and betrayed. THIS is not the history that I want to see. THIS is NOT the reputation, and the history that one wants to see about their heritage. There is ZERO honor about that... ZERO moral value.
When the Nationalists won back the country, it should have STAYED THAT WAY !!!! All the CCP members and party members keep saying sweet talks, but do ZERO actions..."Oh, my Taiwanese comrades" etc etc etc... BS.... If you did wanted and treated them as comrades, then you should have stepped DOWN. And went with their policies !!!!!! Not fight them, and created your own !!! And damaged what loyalties most people threw their lives, and their sons and daughters's lives, and their next generation to sacrifice for the state... Only to be taken, sorry, STOLEN... by you. Trash. Absolute trash.
1
-
1
-
Yang: I also want to share my perception too. I am also Hans chinese. (I presume that I am Hans, since I can count my family tree for at least 3 generation in HK, and then before that, it was supposed to be Dong Guan.) I was the first of my generation to be born (safe) in the UK, but I have been back to HK every year, as often as I could, to worship the graves of my ancestors. If it was not for the social media generation, I would not have gotten a much much deeper insight of China. Of who, of when, and of which... Who did what, and when. I now appreciate why so many people in HK supported the Nationalists. I do. I also think that Hans chinese should be supported too. I also do think that... those who had homes, and had heritages, should go back and rebuild their homes, and their heritages.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqemIQiheJI
THIS... this is a tv documentary, made from HK... about the previous descendents of the Hans, or those families during imperial rules. Those two clans.. that is their family-tree and their legacy. At least they did not cheat, nor lie, and nor bullied their way through.. Each generation is recorded. I hope that, the government, would also be like the British government, which is to find their own people, and rebuild back their own heritages... and live onwards. If you read the comments on that link.. so many moved abroad.. Is it not time to rebuild ? And to reunite and clean the old graves ?? Japan and South Korea managed well. Their rival families, never rival, but they merge, in order for another generation to survive. Why and how can this not be so in China ? So yes, there can be Manchurian/Mongol.. and then also Hans... So why do Hans not merge with Hans now. And Mongolians merge with Mongols ?? Those 56 tribes, in English , people assume that they are tribes. But in reality, in plain English, they are an entire family tree of people. This is why they are called a "clan". Even the Queen of England, married her second cousins. So why, do some countries do not do that ?? They should. When Harry married Megan... America rejoiced. Because she is also the grand daughter of a Lord. She is now welcomed home. I hope to see... in this village... Their previous mongolian rich relative, to save this town. This is what I hope for this town. I wish that, they would see and find their family... and live in more prosperous times. Not from the State... But from their families...
1
-
@nosignal7156 : They are not "languages" than they are uneducated to pronounce the words properly, meanwhile, their other extended families could speak better and so forth, and these are maybe just kind of... dispelled.. from their family-tree or something. Gengkis Khan was quite powerful, and created a lot of armies, or so called units that fought for the country, and they were given land. But if people followed Hans culture... and like most other countries and dynasties... If only this happened... Then it meant that, each family will not die out. Cos somewhere along the line, is an extended family.. that can help you out. This was how a long of things were done before... Before the "communist" declared that, everything belongs to the state, and robbed other families of their riches, and even went as far as to kill them. I wondered.. whether... some of these "kids"... knew that, they could have killed, one of their own ancestors ? I wondered if they knew this. Or could have known this ???
"Mother, who lived in those areas ??"
"Son, that could have been your ancestors... your great great great grand father's cousin, twice removed."
(Thunder. Lightening!)
1
-
1
-
1
-
@nosignal7156 : First of all, you do not know that, the "West" carries the weight of the Mongolian Empire as well ? The "Hans chinese" or the so called "Middle Kingdom" is where all the Hans chinese congregated. The rest, were from the Mongolian Empire, which the PRC formed and tried to "integrate". By now.. I am guessing that, there are no more Hans chinese left in the country already. Some of the descendents of the Mongols, have gotten their own tribal land. And as for the finances, do you not know that, it is the hardworking slaves of the Hans chinese from the East Coast, who props up these tribes ??? Talk about favouritisms... ethnic tribes can do as they wish, and can prosper as they wish. They can have as many children as they wish. They can get subsidises from the government. Meanwhile, the remaining so called "capitalists" from the East Coast... including Hong Kong.. has to work very hard to make ends meet. Have to pay taxes, have to create a lot of things, to make things work and to go round... Even so many American companies, actually just trade and support China. If China did not join the WTO... The country would still be a nomadic tribe. Tell me, how could the country, grew from the Qing dynasty's of 300 million, to the current 1.7 billion ? Who has been not counting the figures correctly ????
To think I used to donate a lot of money as well.. to Sichuan.. I wish I never did. They live off grid and was in a sustainable tribe. The government should not try to integrate them into any capitalistic model. It is not sustainable !!! 1.7 BILLION !!!!!
1