Comments by "Cary Black" (@caryblack5985) on "Erhard Milch to the Rescue! BATTLESTORM STALINGRAD E48" video.

  1. Milch was not Jewish in any interpretation. He had a jewish father but was raised aChristian. He had no ties to the Jewish community and never considered hmself Jewish in any way.. His mother claimed he was illegitimate to hide his ancestry. He was only Jewish by Nazi racial laws but not by any recognized view of his identity. Reply
    4
  2. In 1945 there were many surrenders in the West and many mass surrenders.
    2
  3. Milch was not Jewish in any interpretation. He had a jewish father but was raised aChristian. He had no ties to the Jewish community and never considered hmself Jewish in any way.. His mother claimed he was illegitimate to hide his ancestry. He was only Jewish by Nazi racial laws but not by any recognized view of his identity. Reply
    2
  4. They didsince every plane landed brought back wounded. It wouldn't make sense to flu planes empty and the number of planes that made it due to weather flak and the Red Airforce would not be greater if the planes were loaded with supplies. There was little chance each plane could make atrip more than once s day so the number coming out was probably noy going to change.
    2
  5. Milch was not Jewish in any interpretation. He had a jewish father but was raised aChristian. He had no ties to the Jewish community and never considered hmself Jewish in any way.. His mother claimed he was illegitimate to hide his ancestry. He was only Jewish by Nazi racial laws but not by any recognized view of his identity.
    2
  6. Perhaps perhaps not. Many were near total starvation or sick and the vast majority died within a few months.
    2
  7. Indee even when it is not justified.
    2
  8. Where did you get that information There is no evidence he opposed Hitler. He was prosecuted for war crimes.
    2
  9. Part of their fighting was do to fear of the Soviets and their retaliation for German atrocities.
    2
  10. Milch was not Jewish in any interpretation. He had a jewish father but was raised aChristian. He had no ties to the Jewish community and never considered hmself Jewish in any way.. His mother claimed he was illegitimate to hide his ancestry. He was only Jewish by Nazi racial laws but not by any recognized view of his identity.
    2
  11. Too little too late.
    1
  12. Part of their fighting was do to fear of the Soviets and their retaliation for German atrocities.
    1
  13. The entire southern front in the USSR collapsed and they lost all the territory they had gained in 1942 plus losing the 6th Army and their Italian Hugarian and most of the Romanian armies. See Prit Buttar's trilogy regarding the fighting in the Ukraine.
    1
  14. Have not heard anything to document that.
    1
  15. Milch was competent and Goring was not at that time. Whether it would have changed anything is speculation and not provable.
    1
  16. I said that. The nazi racial ideas are crap. @AlexMilenk 
    1
  17. What is the lie?
    1
  18. Animal feed.
    1