Comments by "Sandy Tatham" (@sandytatham3592) on "Interview with Jamal al Durrah: "To this day, the perpetrators were not held accountable”" video.

What do Muslims say about those people who've investigated this tragedy and concluded that the Israelis could NOT have shot Muhammed? "That the physical evidence of the shooting was in all ways inconsistent with shots coming from the IDF outpost" (from The Atlantic article of June 2003). It causes me to ask why was Abu Akleh's body also buried so quickly without a full investigation?
6
Faith Eternal : We live in a physical dimension which calls for evidence in order to know who should be "held accountable". Religious dogma does not cut it with me, sorry.
2
@pjq420 : Thousands of years of archaeological and historical evidence show that the Jewish people are intrinsically connected to that land. In 1920, after the collapse of the Ottoman Caliphate, the League of Nations (today's United Nations) laid the political foundation for the creation of the 22 Arab League States and one Jewish State of Israel. As set out in the San Remo Agreement, the Jews were recognised as the indigenous people of Israel (historic Palestine) and all non-Jews living there at that time were to be accorded equal rights. Today those Israeli Arabs, whose families accepted the State of Israel, participate in all walks of life including in government, law, education, health, technology and security. If God has gifted the land of Israel to the Jews then that's a bonus for them, but international law is not based upon promises by God.
2
@PeleRana-pp6zc : The so-called Palestinians are being used as #pawns in the Arab Muslim game of hate for Jewish people. They should wake up and ask to be resettled in another country.
1
@shaynelahmed6323 I wouldn’t be so sure of that. As with ISIS in the last decade, the barbaric behaviour of Hamas jihadis on October 7 will probably see an increase in the trend towards Muslims leaving Islam. Their eyes are being opened to the extremes of Islam and its founder. The whole world also sees that if Israel 🇮🇱 doesn’t stop Hamas, this behaviour will spread to Europe snd the US. Islam has problems. And the ‘Palestinians’ are being used as #pawns in the Islamic ☪️ hate for Jews.
1
We do see the horrible situation that the so-called Palestinians are in. They are being used as #pawns in the Arab Muslim game of hate for Jews. They should wake up and ask to be resettled in another country.
1
@erwi2836 : Over two million Arab Muslims live as FREE citizens of the Jewish state of Israel TODAY. They are from families which chose to accept life in the Jewish state in 1948. They have #equal rights with Jews and other minorities such as Arab Christians, Druze, Circassians, etc, and they have #freedom of religion. Israel should extend sovereignty over all of their ancestral Jewish land, from the Jordan River to the sea, and then give 'residence status' to the so-called Palestinians who choose to remain in their homes. That way they have to abide by the law. They don't get national voting rights but they do get access to education, health, and all the benefits of living in a developed country like Israel. And they vote for their own civil leadership, like mayors and town councils. Around 190,000 East Jerusalem Arabs already live with 'residence status' in Israel and they don't seem to want to leave.
1
It seems there is NO evidence that is consistent with the IDF being responsible for the death of the young man Muhammad al Durrah, yet people keep putting forward theories which are not supported by facts. #Conspiracy The Palestinian Authority will not allow Israel to conduct a joint investigation into the tragic death of the Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh so that, to me, also seems suspicious.
1
@saywhatuwanttosay : We live in a physical dimension which calls for evidence in order to know who should be "held accountable". Religious dogma does not cut it with me, sorry.
1
@pjq420 : So evidence means nothing to you? What about the idea of "innocent until proven guilty"? Let's see if the Palestinian Authority will allow an independent investigation into the tragic death of Shireen Abu Akleh. They were quick to bury her body so a key piece of evidence is already missing. It looks similar to the tragic death of Muhammad al Durrah...🙄
1
@saywhatuwanttosay : I'm not religious. I look at evidence and I have no idea what point you are trying to make. It seems there is NO evidence that is consistent with the IDF being responsible for the death of the young man Muhammad al Durrah, yet people keep putting forward theories which are not supported by facts. #ConspiracyTheory The Palestinian Authority will not allow Israel to conduct a joint investigation into the tragic death of the Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh so that, to me, also seems suspicious. The Jews were recognised in 1920 by the League of Nations (today's United Nations) as being the indigenous people of 'historic Palestine'. All Arabs who are HOSTILE to the State of Israel should be resettled in a third country, preferably one which has similar cultural values, ie. one of the 22 Arab states.
1
@saywhatuwanttosay : So you don't even acknowledge history and the indigenous people of a place? I guess that's why they say that Islam is NOT compatible with modernity. You are welcome to stay in the 7th century...🙏
1
@gilabola4642 : Maybe there was a possibility that the IDF could have shot the boy, but then the new evidence was investigated and people now know the truth. It doesn't matter much though because Israel is not going away. It's only getting stronger. And Islam is losing power.
1