Comments by "Sandy Tatham" (@sandytatham3592) on "The CJ Werleman Show" channel.

CJ seems to conveniently forget that the UN recommendation (not mandated) for a plebiscite was proposed on the condition that Pakistan withdraw completely from occupied Jammu & Kashmir. Pakistan never did that.
9
@timcastle1844 : When a Jewish man in Israel says "we all have European passports" it doesn't mean he is speaking for ALL Israeli Jews. The context of the interview is not clear, and he may have been speaking on behalf of his own group, whatever that might be. This is probably more accurate: "CCLEX, an association of global immigration lawyers, estimated in 2019 that about 10 percent of Israelis held more than one passport." Around half of them would have a European passport, and the other half American, Russian and/or other passports. Roughly 75 percent of the country is Jewish, and half of them come from the Middle East and North Africa. Most of the Jews from MENA Arab countries can never return because they were exiled. PS: I don't have any videos on my channel but I'm very clear about who I am if you care to look.
5
@castertroy9129 : I have been there and it was those visits that changed me from being a supporter of Palestinians to standing up for the legitimacy of Israel. I've also seen the thousands of Palestinians who are still held in refugee camps in Jordan TODAY. I have a friend who owns a beautiful property in Gaza who is right now trying to sell it in Dubai so he can move on with his life by resettling his family in a stable Muslim country like Turkey. Palestinians are being used to further the agenda of corrupt Muslim leaders.
3
“A rapid growth of Muslim population”… where? The growing trend is for Muslims to leave Islam, including in India. The Muslim birth rate is also reducing, similar to that of Hindus. In 2015 the birth rate for Muslims in India was 2.6 and for Hindus it was 2.1.
2
@southside-hornbaby5325 : People need to remember that *wars have consequences*. In 1918 the British and Allies defeated the Ottoman Empire which ruled over the Palestine region. I'm happy that the Ottoman Turk Muslims were defeated because I never want to live under Islam and Sharia!!! The Jews were promised a homeland for their support to the British and Allies in the war effort. The liberated Palestinian Arabs were given more than 99% of the land previously ruled by the Ottoman Caliphate. They rule independently in Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, and Jordan. The Jews are still struggling to get less than 1% of the land, enough to give them a viable and secure homeland. Give me a break with your cries of victimhood for the Palestinian Arabs. Millions of people across the world were displaced in the 40s-50s (the Indian sub-continent is a good example). Few of them are still refugees today. It is only the Palestinian Arabs who allow themselves to be used as 'pawns' in a game of lost Arab honour. A large proportion of Arab Muslims accepted Israeli law and live comfortable lives today. The Israelis are not going anywhere.
2
@castertroy9129 : I've also seen how good the lives are for those Arab Muslims who did accept citizenship of Israel. They make up nearly 20% of the population and are doctors, lawyers, politicians, human rights workers, start-up technicians, agricultural experts, etc. They live far better lives than those Palestinians who refused to recognise Israel and who are kept in open-air prisons or camps, with funding from the international community and UNRWA going to their leaders and being used for continual jihad against the Jews.
2
@southside-hornbaby5325 : I understand that losing the Holy Land is a huge shame for the Islamic world. I support those Arab countries which have signed the Abraham Accords and are now normalising ties with Israel through economics, science, trade and friendship.
2
@southside-hornbaby5325 : The Holy Land was invaded and conquered by Caliph Umer in 637-38, and losing it to Israel was a big blow to many Muslims. It will be an even bigger blow to their honour when they lose control of the Temple Mount, which I think is inevitable. Going to war on the side of the Germans in WWI was a fatal mistake. However, after the collapse of the last globally recognised Islamic Caliphate in 1918, there has been relatively little loss. Just something like 0.5% of land which Israel now claims as their viable homeland.
2
@southside-hornbaby5325 : I'm talking about the collapse of the Ottoman Empire in 1918 during World War One. That was a critical turning point for the Middle East. The Arabs got self-determination over a massive 99.00% of the Middle East land area, and the Jews got a tiny homeland centred on Jerusalem.
2
@timcastle1944 : It might say something if it were true🙄. Over HALF of Israeli Jews are from Arab countries that they were "ethnically cleansed" from. Where would they go? Please be critical when listening to people like CJ Werleman.
2
 @l-uk3xm : Very well said, thank you. It's sad that CJ Werleman has to make things up for his Muslim followers.
2
Well said... 🙏
1
@faizanfayaz8978 : It doesn't. But Pakistan's subsequent strategy, to bleed India by a 1000 cuts, makes it very difficult for peace to ever occur in that region.
1
@faizanfayaz8978 : I agree that today's Indian government is handling Kashmir in an atrocious and probably unconstitutional manner. But I also don't see a solution in the near future. What would you recommend? I would love for Gilgit Balstistan, Azad Kashmir and India Kashmir to be reunited and become an autonomous state under India, but that is just my personal dream as it has amazing tourism potential. Independence is hardly viable when Pakistan and China would likely occupy it immediately, and Pakistan is pretty much a failed state.
1
@faizanfayaz8978 : I guess you are right, though there are some activists in Gilgit Baltistan who reject the oppressive rule of Pakistan. J&K did have a reasonable amount of autonomy before Narendra Modi enacted that horrible lock-down and removal of rights. As you say, it's a stalemate. I am impressed that you acknowledge an independent Kashmir wouldn't be able to sustain and defend itself. Not many of my Kashmiri friends can see that.
1
Exactly. They are anticipating many more Jews making Aliyah in the near future.
1
This statement is misleading: "Muslims peacefully coexisted with Jews for centuries in the Middle East". The Jews lived as subjugated second-class 'dhimmis' under Muslim domination, and had to know their place if they wanted peace. But now that they have the Jewish state of Israel, they live as equals under the law with all non-Jews.
1
I’m curious to know, what your evidence is for growth? Iran is no longer a Muslim majority country according to the Gamaan survey of 50,000 Iranians in 2021. Pew Research in 2015 found that 24% of Muslims who move to the West stop believing in Islam. Muslim birth rates are falling everywhere in the world.
1
It seems that Hamas and Fatah also have a lot to answer for.
1
@suzanyassine9422 : I need to see some hard proof of this before I believe it. What we do know for sure is that Hamas use women and children in their warfare instead of evacuating them to an area of safety beforehand.
1
@dallastex4561 : You're welcome to follow the thoughts of Gabor Mate, but I don't. I'm more interested in the facts of what is happening today in Gaza. How Palestinians who live under Hamas authoritarian rule are treated, and what THEY say about it. I have a Palestinian Muslim friend who is right now in Dubai trying to sell his Gaza land so he can move his whole family to Turkey because of Hamas. He wants stability. He no longer wants his family living under a violent jihadi regime which is also corrupt.
1
@dallastex4561 : Here's an account from someone who actually lives in Gaza under Hamas. He has a rather different perspective than Gabor Mate: "I'm a 31 year old Palestinian and have been living in Gaza for all my life. We're so scared right now and we want this to be over but a lot us (secretly, we can't say publicly) actually know Israel is in the right (yes, a lot of us here know Israel is not the one waging war). When we voted for Hamas more than 15 years ago, we thought they would let us have regular elections and turn this area into an amazing, democratic Palestinian land. But they regularly pay us massive money to rally on the streets and to tell the media Israel is the agressor and we badly need the money so we accept. Hamas officials told us that we have to stay in our work buildings when the Israel army warns us to leave before they bomb the buildings, if we don't Hamas will jail our families. We risk not moving in the hope that we don't get hurt so our families don't get jailed. We also get paid to hold fake funerals where we carry 'killed' children on stretchers in the streets (they're just pretending to be dead). What I'm trying to say is that what you see on the media is Hamas making us look like war victims, but really we are victims of Hamas who will do what Hamas says because of our desperation for money. We don't get aid even though apparently most countries say they give aid. We use to live peacefully with the Israeli's before Hamas controlled us and now we rely on Hamas to survive. Some of us have tried to escape to Israel but Hamas will also kill our family if they find out. We pray that one day Hamas will stop using all they money for rockets and terrorists and use its money for us, to build us parks and schools and hospitals and give us food. Right now I pray for the violence to stop."
1
So you ignore the fact that it is the Jewish people who are #indigenous to the Holy Land? The majority of Arabs in Palestine arrived AFTER the British Mandate period began in 1920 and the British and Jews created economic opportunities. The Arabs came flooding in from the surrounding 22 Arab countries. Today we would call them 'economic migrants'.
1
I agree. I'm Australian but I travel in the Middle East. I was in Sinai when that despicable attack happened and all the Egyptians around me celebrated. My first thought on watching this video was how this won't age very well because most of it is nonsense.
1
Except he’s lying. Over half of Israeli Jews are from the Middle East and North Africa. They were refugees who fled their homes and businesses in Arab countries. They were “ethnically cleansed”. Do you expect them to leave Israel? Please think critically. Don’t listen to #grifters.
1
@l-uk3xm : I've heard of other 'Muslim influencers' being offered money, especially the converts from Western countries, so it wouldn't surprise me.
1
It's quite a stretch to compare the treatment of homosexuals in Qatar with the people of Gaza who cleansed their land of Jews then 'elected' the terrorist organisation Hamas.
1
Read how democratic Christian-majority Lebanon was ruined by accepting thousands of Muslim refugees from Syria. It resulted in a civil war. Now it’s a failed state.
1