Comments by "Sandy Tatham" (@sandytatham3592) on "BREAKING: New Plan Underway To Resettle Palestinians in the Gaza Strip (With Hebrew Subtitles)" video.

This show made me so happy!!! I absolutely support Gazans being given the CHOICE to leave. It's inhumane to keep them in a war zone. It's also inhumane to have perpetuated their refugee status for generations, as leverage against Israel. I don't want corrupt Egyptian border police making money from smuggling people illegally into Sinai, as happens now. I stand with Israel... 🙏✡💙
64
@everythingandmore5537 : Why would Israel let hostile people back in their country after they sided with the attacking Arab armies in 1948? Two million Arab Muslims are Israeli citizens TODAY because their families accepted life in a Jewish state. They were probably reluctant to do so, but you don't always get a choice in these things. The majority of Arab Israelis don't want to leave Israel.
2
Wasn't Egypt one of the main Arab countries which caused this #displacement in the first place? Egypt gets plenty of foreign funding, and many Gazans have extended families in Egypt and would want to return there.
1
What is being proposed is giving the people of Gaza the CHOICE to leave. At the moment they can leave by paying corrupt Egyptian border police a lot of money.
1
Well said...🙏
1
@LegallySound-n3b : The vast majority of 'displaced' Arabs took the side of the attacking Arab armies. That has to be factored in. Who would give hostile people the chance to return and wreak havoc? Israel already has around 20% Arab Muslim citizens. Any more would be very dangerous for civil unrest.
1
@LegallySound-n3b : You do realise that around 100 million people were #displaced in the last 110 years due to new countries being formed and the current occupants not "fitting" in with their rulers? The biggest examples are the partition of India in 1947 with up to 18 million people changing countries, and the enforced population exchange of 1.5 million Greeks and Turks in 1924 when Turkiye was founded. Do they still whine about their displacement today? Why are these Arabs, who REJECTED the 1947 Palestine partition plan, being treated with kid gloves for over 75 years? Why are they the only group in the world who have their own UN organisation to keep them as perpetual refugees? Why do they receive more funding per head than any other genuine refugee group? You can cry for them if you like, but I'm more of a "tough love" person. They should move on and accept their lot, like all those other millions did.
1
The Nazi ideology is not equivalent to Islam, which has is based on a book that Muslims believe is the actual word of their God. The good news is that Muslims are leaving Islam so that helps.
1
Israel only ever supplied about 9% of the water. There are desalinations plants in Gaza that Hamas has not maintained as they prefer to spend money on tunnels. Gazans have to be held accountable for the problems that they created by supporting their terror jihadist government. They don't want "self-determination" for the people of Gaza. Hamas wants to restore the Islamic Caliphate and remove ALL the Jews from historic Palestine.
1
@everythingandmore5537 : I wouldn't put too much faith in UN Resolutions, or Resolutions from its precursor the League of Nations. Israel still has the right to all the land from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea because the Arabs REJECTED the 181 Partition Resolution of 1947. The San Remo Resolution of 1920 "laid down the Jewish legal right to settle anywhere in western Palestine, a 10,000 square-miles area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea. On July 24, 1922, fifty-one member countries – the entire League of Nations – unanimously affirmed the historical connection of the Jewish people with Palestine as their grounds for reconstituting their national home in that country." Where else in the world is it deemed a good thing to let hostile people, or those who sided with the attacking Arab armies, back into their new country? Today around two million Israeli citizens are Arabs who are from those families which accepted life in a Jewish state in 1948. The displaced Arabs should long ago have been resettled in the neighbouring Arab countries, but we all know that the Arab League prohibited this in order to USE the people as weapons against Israel. It's time that stopped. Let the so-called Palestinians CHOOSE to leave. Support giving them the choice to live as full citizens somewhere else.
1
@jshepherd2893 : Well said...🙏
1
@everythingandmore5537 : UN General Assembly Resolution 194, paragraph 11 states: Resolves that the refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date..." Has any Arab in Palestine pledged to "live at peace" with Israel? Did the Arab nations agree to this? Read more here if you're interested: https://elderofziyon.blogspot.com/2021/12/no-there-is-no-right-to-return-for.html
1
@FontaineDerby : What exactly is the "ethnic" group of the Gaza people?
1
So you are against Gazans being given the CHOICE to leave? Keeping people in a war zone, or as perpetual refugees for generations to come is a good thing by you? That's inhumane.
1