General statistics
List of Youtube channels
Youtube commenter search
Distinguished comments
About
Darnit
The Cold War
comments
Comments by "Darnit" (@darnit1944) on "" video.
@doug6500 However, we all know Vietnam instead did not become full on communist, they use communism as a mean to unite the people. They implement mixed economy and not becomes so closed like North Korea, which is absolutely fantastic as they become great business partner for everyone. That's kinda unexpected to be honest.
3
@abandonedchannel281 My country purged communists. Purged so hard that Communism is a slang/insult here. And guess what, it created stability here.
1
@lordbadman9264 Ok, let me explain this. America wins the war, 1973 Paris accords, America left Vietnam because hippies dont like it, finally North attacks South and conquered Saigon. America wins the war, but lost the politics.
1
@originalkk882 I'm blaming the congress for that. But considering how Vietnam has improved, i'll let it pass
1
@wakakabravo7998 Every battle in Vietnam leads to higher Vietnamese casualties. After several battles, the Paris agreement was signed, to cease fire between the two Vietnams and then the US withdrew due to pressure from congress, abandoning any promises to help South Vietnam. But after they left, NVA attacked and conquered Saigon.
1
@wakakabravo7998 I did not say that. I'm saying that the US won the fight or battle, but lost politically. What makes you think that way?
1
@wakakabravo7998 Perhaps it's the bad wording i use. The US won almost all major battle, Paris agreement decides to split Vietnam to 2 like Korea today. But the US left and did not protect South Vietnam, breaking their promise. Then North Vietnam attacked, breaking their ceasefire and agreement and conquered the weakened South Vietnam. I already explained why the US withdrew, dont ask the same questions.
1
@wakakabravo7998 Ah sorry i didnt notice that point earlier. Not only on casualty side, when i said won the war that means they won every battle, whatever what you mean by win. The Paris agreement supposedly is the end. The fact that they managed to keep NVA from taking Saigon is the prove that they win back in 1973. However the US did not stay and immediately leave because the US congress told them to, that way South Vietnam lost when the NVA attacked in 1975.
1
@wakakabravo7998 And let me say this in the easy way. They won in 1973, but left due to pressure from congress, then NVA attacked and conquered Saigon. If the US stayed, they would be able to protect South Vietnam. Got it?
1
@wakakabravo7998 I didnt see why you said they failed even beforeParis accords. The NVA had 2 years to prepare for invading South Vietnam. With remaining US force, they could have repelled NVA invasion. If Korea gets the same treatment as Vietnam, they would also be invaded and conquered by the North in around late 1950s- early 1960s
1
@wakakabravo7998 I know the aftermath. I'm just talking about what really happened. America abandoned their ally and let them get stomped.
1
@wakakabravo7998 I did not, i only said that they won battles but not the war.
1
@wakakabravo7998 "But lost politically"
1
@wakakabravo7998 They won the battles, and abandoned the objective due to political pressure. So that's it, yeah? We have nothing to fight for anymore.
1
How to spot a third world country: 1. Mention their country in a video. 2. Watch the comment section.
1
Oh shut up. You're making your country looks bad. The only thing that sepparates your country is just border and the word "Malaysia and Indonesia" Deep down, you're not so different. Just so you know, people like you is the reason why discrimination exist.
1
You forgot the fact that the US wins Vietnam, and the victory was settled in 1973, Paris accords. Then the US withdrew from Vietnam, the North attacks the weaken South, and conquered it in 1975. The US withdrew due to hippy protests and other opposition in the US mainland. So technically, the US wins the war, but lost politically.
1
@doug6500 Im not trying to say they won. Im saying that the US could have won, Saigon could not have fallen by not leaving South Vietnam alone. South Vietnam with US base would be like Japan or South Korea.
1
Maternal grandfather.
1
And then there's Korea. Both still allies to the Russians and Americans.
1
Good riddance communism, hello stability.
1
@Joshua Джошуа Well that's a risk i'm willing to take. But no need for that now. Communism is already proven ineffective in today's society .
1
@Joshua Джошуа That means more reason to support the persecution. This time with people's support.
1
I opposed and supported that at the same time. Communist purge is important, but accusing innocent people is just wrong
1