Comments by "Taxtro" (@MrCmon113) on "Best Film on Newton's Third Law. Ever." video.

  1. Willoughby Krenzteinburg You obviously have no idea how we operate in physics. When you work on more complex problems, mathematics is your guide, not your intuition. You don't have to justify these things to your brain, you just have to stay consistent. I very much doubt you have a good rationalization for quantum physics. Indeed a great physicist said that if you think you had understood it, you don't. I don't necessarily agree with him there, but there are multiple ways to rationalize quantum mechanics, not one way of understanding. And those have no impact on your APPLICATION of quantum mechanics. That is what it comes down to. Whether you can APPLY your knowledge. The universe is counter intuitive at the very small and very fast.
    5
  2. Willoughby Krenzteinburg Again: There is a difference between knowing laws of physics and having them rationalized in your mind. When it comes to cosmology almost noone has a rationalization for the mathematical models, yet they work just fine.
    4
  3. Willoughby Krenzteinburg Me? You are constantly talking down to us, unwilling to even explain yourself. I've put effort into explaining the matter to you. You lack basic rules of engagement.
    4
  4. +Willoughby Krenzteinburg You don't need to rationalize any of it in order to work with it.
    1
  5. Willoughby Krenzteinburg No, it's knowing how to throw the ball, but not having a rationalization for why it flies the way it does.
    1
  6. Willoughby Krenzteinburg Yes and I explained how that is.
    1
  7. Willoughby Krenzteinburg Where is your problem? You are talking with two people, who practice physics every day and all you do is claim over and over again, that one needs to have justified laws in his mind, in order to apply them. That's simply not true. I think I was clear enough. When you have problems understanding me, just ask. What is your rationalization of quantum physics? I can tell you another one, which is just as valid. You are utterly disconnected from the reality in science and engineering.
    1